A Disaster in Brand Research – New Coke

Posted: Mar 14, 2011 |Comments: 0 | Views: 141 |

One of the most famous marketing disasters in history was the invention and implementation of New Coke by Coca-Cola.  This 1980s cola mistake has become synonymous with awful business decisions.  If a business strategist ever has a decision or idea likened to New Coke, they should probably start packing up their office and polishing their resume because a pink slip is fast approaching.  While most people are aware of New Coke and its effects, not everybody knows why Coca-Cola made the decision that it did.  While it proved to be a horrible decision, there was some (surprising) reason behind the company's decision.

Contrary to popular belief, Coca-Cola did not just switch their recipe on a whim.  There were a number of valid reasons that contributed to the decision.  Brand market research and dwindling market share in the face of competition were the prominent two.  With regards to competition, Pepsi-Cola and its sweeter taste were stealing a great amount of Coca-Cola's market share.  Coke was actually losing the overall battle in markets, relying on their advantage in restaurants and vending machines to maintain a narrow overall edge of Pepsi.  Blind taste tests and effective advertising campaigns that highlighted these tests were showing that consumers actually preferred the taste of Pepsi over Coke.  This was especially true amongst younger soda drinkers.  Coke feared that as their advantage with older consumers continued to age, they would lose even greater market share in the coming years.  As such, they made the decision that everything in the company was up for review, including the formula for their product.  When Coke made the decision to tinker with their formula, the market research actually supported the decision.  A series of blind taste tests showed that the public actually preferred the taste of new Coke (which tasted more like Pepsi than the original formula).  This was tested thoroughly and the results were statistically conclusive.

With these results known, how could New Coke fail so miserably?  Coke's biggest blunder was likely rolling out a full replacement.  Instead of adding a new coach product line, they replaced their previous product completely.  They greatly underestimated the brand loyalty of their current consumers, many of whom were outraged at losing the soft drink they preferred.  While a random sample of drinkers showed that people preferred the newer (somewhat sweeter) taste, Coke neglected to recognize why their current consumers drank coke instead of Pepsi.  They also put too much emphasis on the taste research and not enough on the brand research.  Brand loyalty is a very real thing.  Some consumers are going to be resistant to any change to their favorite products no matter what the market research tells the producing company.

Luckily, Coke stayed flexible and recognized their mistake instead of compounding it.  They re-introduced their old formula as "Coca-Cola Classic" and combined it with better marketing and some savvy partnerships with restaurants and market chains.  New Coke remained, but was eventually phased out over the next seven years.  While Pepsi still owns a large share of the market, Coke's market share is actually higher today than it was prior to the New Coke implementation.

Questions and Answers

Ask
200 Characters left
Rate this Article
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 0 vote(s)
    Feedback
    Print
    Re-Publish
    Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/advertising-articles/a-disaster-in-brand-research-new-coke-4405387.html

    Article Tags:

    market research

    ,

    brand research

    ,

    new coke

    Blair Matthews

    When The Coca-Cola Company changed their formula in 1985 they thought they were making a decision that would be welcomed with open arms. What followed was a public outcry that brought the company to its knees and an American icon was restored to its former glory.

    By: Blair Matthewsl Marketingl Dec 02, 2008 lViews: 6,367 lComments: 1

    Conjoint analysis is one of the most popular quantitative methods in Marketing Research. The popularity of Conjoint Analysis is well deserved. Conjoint Analysis has in many cases replaced concept testing because it is more effective.

    By: Michael Pettyl Marketingl Mar 24, 2010

    A long time ago in a galaxy far away, products were responsible for the fate of the company .When a company noticed that its sales were not increasing, it would come to one conclusion: its product was starting to fail. Now things have changed .Companies don’t blame the product, they blame the brand. This article will give some examples of the biggest brand failures of all the time where big brands despite spending millions of dollars in conducting market research and understanding consumer be

    By: harpreet bajwal Marketingl Oct 12, 2009 lViews: 706

    If you have started up an online business or company and are only offering a few things for sale, then you may not think it is value focusing on brand management for your business. You may believe that all of the effort and time you put into that would certainly be better placed somewhere else. However, branding your business effectively is probably the best ways to promote yourself online and you can simply run to provide a better brand if you are clear in your thinking.

    By: Linda Brodiel Internet> Internet Marketingl Mar 20, 2012

    The global cola and beverage industry is a massive one and the two top dogs, Coke and Pepsi, continue to battle it out for market share. Who is the leader when it comes to taste, effective advertising, and public opinion?

    By: Charlie Winwoodl Food and Beveragel Aug 04, 2011

    70 Percent of businessesfail in their first year of trading. Most fail as a result of poor or NO advertising strategy. Global Brands spend over $25Billion on advertising on the average, most of the budget spent on TV and outdoor advertising. This article will give you pointers on advertising on a tight budget

    By: kenneth bensonl Advertisingl May 23, 2012

    Many businesses advertise with flyers and getting them into the hands of the general public is of great importance. If the delivery people make a stuff-up in any way, it reflects badly on the company. The company will be blamed if those flyers are left to blow around the streets.

    By: John Kiml Advertisingl May 21, 2012

    Research has showed that global enterprises are quickly taking center stage in order to effectively promote their products and services.

    By: Juan Cardeansl Advertisingl May 21, 2012
    Hendrik Behrens

    Advertising today is like the weather. Everyone talks about advertising, but few entrepreneurs do enough about it to change or improve it. When you ask what the "big deal" is with advertising, that's an excellent question, because no matter how you want to view it there is one proven fact which is true of business owners and entrepreneurs worldwide... In today's recessionary spiral, every good entrepreneur wants to do more with less.

    By: Hendrik Behrensl Advertisingl May 19, 2012

    A pinback button may look very small but has a lot of significance attached to it. You may be wondering what is there in a button but a close look tells us that each button has their own unique story behind it. Every button is unique and distinct. Think of it as a small portable billboard carrying your message!

    By: Jyotsna Ramanil Advertisingl May 19, 2012

    Parallel parking is becoming one of the lost arts. Once a common aspect of any driving test, the ability to parallel park is going the way of the dodo. This is not unrelated to the also dwindling number of parking slots on the sides of streets.

    By: felixchesterfiedll Automotive> Carsl Feb 27, 2012

    Hard hats are necessary safety equipment for most construction sites. It is no longer just a good idea to protect the head; it is now a requirement (primarily due to liability issues) for the employees of most companies.

    By: felixchesterfiedll Home Improvement> Tools and Equipmentl Feb 27, 2012

    Age 30 to 39 is a transitional period for men. We have moved past the invincibility of our 20s, but are not yet facing the mid-life mortality that our 40s will bring. Injuries take longer to heal than they once did, but the risk for chronic illnesses is only slightly higher than it was in years prior.

    By: felixchesterfiedll Health> Men's Healthl Feb 27, 2012

    As a political hot button topic, talk of socialized medicine is frequent the twenty-four hour news networks these days. However, despite this prominence, I am often surprised how much of the general public does not understand what it is (and what it is not).

    By: felixchesterfiedll Health> Medicinel Feb 27, 2012

    The Ivy League is a name that is held in the highest of esteems when it comes to secondary education. They represent a large percentage of the most prestigious, most selective, and even most expensive schools in the United States.

    By: felixchesterfiedll Education> College and Universityl Feb 27, 2012

    Discuss this Article

    Author Box
    Articles Categories
    All Categories
    Quantcast