The Ohio schools board has drafted a framework that will set teacher guidelines to be used when teaching controversial topics in the classroom. The proposal is not a lesson plan, but rather an optional template that guides teachers to enable students to form judgments by critically analyzing all sides of a controversial subject.
The Ohio schools board has requested their Achievement Committee review the draft and make recommendations on its final structure. Some Ohio schools districts already use templates that are similar to the draft guidelines, so it is not something new for all Ohio schools.
A statement within the draft states: "The goals of discussions of controversial issues are for students to have a better understanding of the issue and form a reasoned judgment that is based upon a critical analysis of the facts and arguments and is open to revision as conditions change."
The draft sent to the committee by the Ohio schools board was released in early September 2006. It provides sample rules for teachers to give to students before a classroom debate begins on a controversial topic. It also identifies the student skills required in the Ohio schools' standards that need to be addressed during such discussions. The template will help teachers target these specific student reasoning skills, which can be applied to all controversial subjects when discussed within the classroom setting. The intent is to provide students with content that is rich and challenging, as well as allowing such classroom discussions without legal opposition.
Since the release of the proposed guidelines, however, opposition already is growing. Patricia Princehouse, a teacher at the Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, believes such guidelines will allow religion-based challenges to the subject of evolution with teachers using the guidelines as a cover to teach creationism.
She noted, as an example, that the term "critical analysis" already was used in an Ohio schools lesson plan that encouraged students to seek evidence for and against evolution. The Ohio schools board eliminated that lesson plan and the state science standard to which it corresponded in February 2006. The Ohio schools board, however, has asked its Achievement Committee to determine whether the deleted curriculum should be replaced.
Princehouse further noted that committee members might add more specific anti-evolution wording to the proposed template, but Committee Co-Chairman Jim Craig stated that no such proposal has been made. The guidelines are for all controversial subjects, not just evolution. Such topics include but are not limited to global warming, immigration, evolution and the national debt. The template will support teaching all controversial subjects.
Craig also stated that he wants a draft upon which both sides can agree. He said he does not wish the committee to recommend final guidelines to the board, if a compromised final draft cannot be reached.
Related Articles
Ohio Schools Closing the Gap for Students with Disabilities
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/06/2006 | Education
The Ohio Schools are redefining their Special Education program and closing the gap in the achievement of students with disabilities. The Ohio schools believe that achievement gaps are not the same as ability gaps, and the education system is responsible for ensuring that high achievement is an attainable goal for all students.
Some Student Artists in the Ohio Schools Will Apprentice This Summer
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/06/2006 | Education
With all the education budget cuts during the past decade and a renewed focus on reading and mathematics, the arts have seen many cutbacks and even programs eliminated. Though educators recognize that the arts is an important subject for graduating well-rounded students, the new government requirements do not leave any time or money to underwrite the programs needed.
Six Teachers From Spain to Teach in the Ohio Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 22/08/2006 | Tutoring
Susan Tave Zelman, superintendent of public instruction for the Ohio schools, welcomed six visiting teachers from Spain, who will be teaching in the Ohio schools this coming school year.
Ohio Schools Question Perfect Attendance Reports of Internet Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 11/10/2006 | K-12 Education
The Ohio schools have had state-funded, online charter schools for a few years. Students do their work over the Internet from their homes or other sites. They can work anytime but must log 920 hours per year for perfect attendance.
Criminal Background Checks for Ohio Schools’ Bus Drivers in Question
By: Patricia Hawke | 08/02/2007 | K-12 Education
Last month, Columbus, Ohio, police arrested an individual who drives bus for one of the Ohio schools in Columbus. The driver was charged with possession of cocaine and further investigation found the individual had three previous convictions for driving under the influence.
Indian Jewish CONVERTS are not Menashe!
By: David Ben-ariel | 24/09/2005 | Religion
Are NOT Menashe
Comment:
The vast majority of all those INDIAN descendants of JEWISH
CONVERTS are not ethnic descendants of Menashe ben Yosef and do
not fulfill.
Aging Baby Boomers Need and Demand One-call Home Care Services
By: FranNet LLC | 06/12/2007 | Entrepreneurship
Local franchise owners capitalize on a hot business trend: offer full spectrum of home care services to seniors who want to stay independent.
Single-gender Schools Becoming an Option in Ohio Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 30/08/2007 | Education
In the olden days, boys and girls received very different educations. They were segregated from each other, and pursued learning that was predetermined as “appropriate” for their sex.
Latest Advertising Articles
Are You Looking For A More Affective Way To Advertise?
By: Kristi Ambrose | 27/08/2008
Although posting to groups is a good thing to do, it also can take up a lot of your precious time. So, then what? Well there are actual people that will do this for you!. They allow you to automatically post your ads on these groups, which saves you incredible amounts of time.
A Website Can Be An Asset Or A Flop Depending Upon How You Prepare
By: Robert Schumacher | 26/08/2008
A business website is not a silver bullet that will automatically wake up your business and propel you to new heights.
Best Practices for Transporting Trade Show Displays
By: Amy Nutt | 23/08/2008
Transporting your tradeshow display doesn't involve rocket science, but it isn't something you want to skimp on either. It does take a bit of planning and coordination. Why do you need to be so careful?
Different Ways of Customizing Trade Show Displays
By: Amy Nutt | 23/08/2008
Your trade show display is going to make you or break you. It is that one thing that customers seem to see once. If your display looks good, then the customer will move onto what type of products you're selling.
Mascots and the Olympics
By: Amy Nutt | 23/08/2008
The first Olympic mascot was introduced in 1972 at the Munich games. These mascots have become a very important element of the Olympics. It is an image that is unique and very popular because it materializes the spirit of the Olympics, promotes the history, and communicates the overall concept.
Innovative Ways of Attracting More Visitors to Your Trade Show Booth
By: Amy Nutt | 22/08/2008
When operating a trade show booth, you have to do things that will make customers want to look at what you have. That requires you to be very creative, though. If you're not creative, then you're going to be doing the same exact things that everyone else is doing.
Fall Is The Perfect Time To Clean Blips Off Your Marketing Slate
By: Robert Schumacher | 21/08/2008
Marketing blips keep poppiing up in advertising programs of small businesses. These blips throw up roadblocks and put a ceiling on revenue growth while limiting the effects of advertising. Erase them now.
During Shaky Tmes, Be Careful What You Cut
By: Robert Schumacher | 19/08/2008
When the going get rough, small business owners and managers correctly cut expenses. Advertising should not be one of those cuts. A shaky economy offers an ideal opportunity for the small business to gain market share if they hang in and continue to advertise.
More from Patricia Hawke
Boston Schools Train Their Own Teachers
By: Patricia Hawke | 16/10/2007 | Real Estate
All schools need talented, motivated and inspiring teachers. Without them, students would be hard-pressed to meet the ever-changing standards set forth by local, state, and federal education officials. For those who wish to work in the classrooms of Boston Schools, support and training awaits.
All types of teachers must have appropriate,...
Baltimore Schools Set Performance Goals
By: Patricia Hawke | 16/10/2007 | Education
All school systems should have goals. These goals must be attainable, however. While these centers of learning must know where they headed and how they are going to get there, it seems that they are becoming more and more unreasonable in their expectations. Perhaps they should be classified more as...
Low Teacher Pay Scales At Arizona Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 16/10/2007 | Tutoring
Teachers in Arizona Schools are Paid Less
Teachers in Arizona schools are compensated based on their level of education, qualifications and teaching experience. But is that truly fair pay? The comparatively low pay scales for teachers in Arizona schools are leading to a serious under valuation of teachers, the backbone of...
Atlanta Schools Experiment With Single-Gender Campuses
By: Patricia Hawke | 16/10/2007 | Education
There are many studies that both support and denounce the practice of single-gender schools. For many years, colleges and universities were all divided based on gender. Throughout history, boys were able to receive formal schooling, while girls were expected to remain at home and learn both the domestic arts as...
New York City Schools Include Charters
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/09/2007 | Education
There have been many instances over the past 20 years or so where people have been so unhappy about the schools that they have decided to step up and do something about it. In response to this discontent, charter schools have been formed. For many New York City Schools families,...
Public Versus Private New Orleans Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/09/2007 | Education
Ever wonder what to do with school choice? For families who have ample amounts of money and can afford any school, the decision about what school to send the kids to may seem simple. After all, most people believe that private is best. Other parents may not be able to...
Minneapolis Public Schools Lose Students To Charter Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/09/2007 | Education
Students are Fleeing Minneapolis Schools
Minneapolis schools are being faced with the prospect of empty school buildings as more and more students flee the system to charter schools in the district. Minneapolis schools' enrollment figures have plummeted to just 36,000 this year - that's almost half its capacity of 50,000...
Milwaukee Public Schools Say Hello To Life Without Cell Phones
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/09/2007 | Education
Cell Phone Ban in Milwaukee Public Schools
It's hard to imagine a world without cell phones. Next to the Internet it's probably the single most important invention that has affected the maximum number of lives around the globe. People run entire businesses through their stylish gizmo fitted cell phones...
Advertising 
