 |
Mismanagement At The New York Times
Author: Geoff Gannon  | Posted: 24-04-2006 | Comments: 0 | Views: 214 | Rating: (50)  (?) 
The New York Times Company (NYT) isn't just reporting the news - it's making the news. At yesterday's annual meeting, shareholders withheld 28% of their votes for the four directors elected by holders of the company's common stock. Nine other directors are elected by holders of the Class B shares, effectively granting control of the company to a group holding less than a 1% economic interest in the business.
Most of the large newspaper companies have not done a great job of earning the best returns for their shareholders. Some of these companies overdid acquisitions. The New York Times Company illustrates the danger of adding to the empire - you dilute the crown jewel.
In 1993, the company bought The Boston Globe. Unfortunately, this is exactly the kind of paper that will be hurt by online news sources. Second-tier major city dailies are not in a strong position, because they try to be all things to all people.
A newspaper can thrive by dominating a specific niche. That niche can be geographical or topical. Community newspapers can thrive, because they still have no real competition. The news they report is unique. It is very important to a very small group of people.
A company that owns clusters of these papers in wealthy suburbs will do fine. By reporting on local schools, sports, and events these publications set themselves apart from all other news sources. They have a mini-monopoly both on the news they provide and on the ads they run.
There are places in states like New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Pennsylvannia where advertisers benefit from targeting specific communities, because the demographics of the next town over are not nearly as attractive. A lot of this has to do with public schools. I don't see that system changing anytime soon. So, I imagine these properties will fare much better than big city newspapers.
The New York Times Company has one great asset - its brand. The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal each have a very valuable national brand. People all over the country have been exposed to them through other media outlets. The value isn't really in the size of the circulation. If you think of the entire country as their potential market, their circulations are tiny (the news business is very fragmented).
A few years ago, it would have been crazy to think of the entire country as a potential market for these publications. But, I don't think that's the case today. These papers could earn a lot of money online. Of course, they have to figure out how to earn money online.
Long-term, I don't like the idea of expensive online subscriptions. It looks like a great idea now, but it could limit future ad revenue. Becoming a dominant online news destination would prove extraordinarily profitable. Unfortunately, no one is going to capture more than a tiny sliver of the online news market by charging a lot of money for their content.
It isn't just an issue of people not wanting to pay. It's also an issue of exclusivity. The less exclusive an online news source is the more often it will be cited. People who don't visit your site are far less likely to reference it. Just as importantly, no writer wants to exclude any part of his own readership. So, many writers simply won't cite a subscription service.
Some online writers do reference subscription services. Knowing how strongly people react to being excluded, I think writers who cite paid services are absolutely nuts. Even if it isn't consciously acknowledged, readers will enjoy your site less if it points out something they can't have.
Both The New York Times Company and Dow Jones (DJ) went the route of buying an established online destination. I'm always skeptical of these kind of me too acquisitions. These businesses did need to go online, but they needed to do it in their own way. The acquisitions will probably work out better than I thought they would. But, I still think the real value is in the brand.
Is the New York Times Company cheap? It's close. If you agree with me about the potential for a real national news brand, the stock looks cheap. Otherwise, it looks about fairly priced.
Newspapers have been beaten down a lot recently, but they were so well-loved to begin with that they aren't at the kind of levels that guarantee market beating returns regardless of how well they're run. That's happened in other businesses. You could extract more cash from a dying business than the stock was selling for. That isn't the case here. The stock is currently priced as if it were a continuing (albeit mature) business.
If the New York Times is truly a dying business, it isn't worth the current price. But, if there is real value in the brand, it's a bargain right now.
I'm not confident in the decision making at this company, because I've seen how capital was misallocated in the past. Many of these questionable investments were small relative to the value of the core franchise. But, that doesn't excuse the lack of focus and the lack of a true owner oriented culture.
The favorable economics inherent to the business are no excuse either. There are very profitable companies out there that aren't nearly as profitable as they could be. For instance, Campbell Soup (CPB) consistently earns good returns on capital; but, I haven't seen any evidence that those returns were the result of skillful capital allocation. I think much the same is true at the New York Times Company. A great franchise helps cover-up less than optimal uses of capital - and the Times' management has benefited from inheriting a great franchise.
If I were confident about the way this company will be run and the way capital will be allocated, I'd be buying shares right now. There's real value and real opportunity in this franchise. But, I'm not sure there's the will to do what needs to be done.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/advice-articles/mismanagement-at-the-new-york-times-24156.html
About the Author:Geoff Gannon writes a daily value investing blog and produces a twice weekly (half hour) value investing podcast at Gannon on Investing
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
Mismanagement at the New York Times?
By: Geoff Gannon | 21/04/2006 | Non-Fiction
A value investor discusses the recent vote of no confidence by major shareholders and asks whether the New York Times company is now a bargain.
An Analysis Of Journal Communications (JRN)
By: Geoff Gannon | 07/02/2006 | Finance
Journal Communications (JRN) is comprised of seven essentially separate businesses: The Milwaukee Sentinel, Community Newspapers, Television Stations, Radio Stations, Telecommunications, Printing Services, and Direct Marketing.
How to Avoid Investment Scams
By: Joel Arberman | 17/04/2006 | Investing
Investment scams are occuring very frequently. It is important that investors validate and verify everything they are told to reduce the chances of being defrauded.
Dollar Cost Averaging: a Great Strategy for the New Investor
By: Tricia | 09/01/2007 | Investing
What is dollar cost averaging? It's a long, complicated sounding phrase for a very easy investment plan, that is sure to make you money in the long run. Learn how to put together your own dollar cost averaging strategy and why it's ideal start for the new investor.
Investing in the Stock Market: How to get Started
By: Braydon Mccarville | 22/02/2006 | Finance
Learn how to become a more knowledgeable investor. This article shows you the basics of how and where to get started when evaluating a stock.
Misconception of Stock Market and Shares
By: Ponn Nac | 23/06/2008 | Investing
Quite surprising that till now alot of people still do not know the basic meaning and the difference between the ''Stock Market And Shares'' while some people believe that this above forms of transactions belongs to the eminent/aristocratic class of people in the society. Even till this modern times yet some people are still lacking behind of multiple opportunities in the Stocks market, Shares, Equity, Bonds, Futures, and other financial/security form of transactions.
Investing Wisdom From the Princess and the Pea
By: Gary Wollin | 01/07/2008 | Investing
You must do extensive due diligence when you are going to select a financial advisor. Once you have made the selection, give your advisor enough time to settle in and don't be looking over his shoulder every moment. Don't second guess every move. Even the best advisors lose money once in a while. Nobody's perfect.
Investing Wisdom From Children’s Stories – the Dog and the Meat
By: Gary Wollin | 01/07/2008 | Investing
Don't exchange a good long-term investment strategy for short-term fads. Don't get greedy. Don't do stupid things. If it seems too good to be true (and honest) it's not.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Interview
By: karula | 03-09-2007
Which are the hardest questions during an interview?
What is private sectors
By: bhawya | 02-09-2007
what is private sectors
Fiscal and Monetary policies
By: jess_i | 29-08-2007
What is the difference (if they are comparable at all) between Fiscal and monetary policy?
Just got a prepaid visa card
By: samp | 26-08-2007
I just got a readydebit prepaid visa card. The fees seem low, do you think it is a good deal? I've seen a few others, but this one seems to be lower cost when i think about how i'll actually use the card. it's $10 to get the card, then $5 a month, plus a fee for atm withdrawals. Paying for an account might seem crazy, but compared to what banks are charging for overdraft fees, it might work out to cost less. Anyway, i'm curious, what do you think - good deal or not? the website is readydebit.com.
What is a delta ?
By: summerof69 | 26-08-2007
Best way of earning income in the modern age?
By: guy_david | 24-08-2007
What are the best ways of earning steady income in the modern age?
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Advice Articles
Tips for Natural Hair Treatments
By: Kim Snyder | 21/08/2008
Beautiful and healthy hair truly comes from with. By eating well, drinking plenty of water, getting enough sleep all help your hair. As well as staying away from drinking too much and smoking because it all shows up in our hair. Only women can blame having a really bad day on our hair. Sorry guys it doesn’t sound quite right to hear from you that you are having a “bad hair day”. Women say it all the time.
Why Bond Grows Bitter?
By: Dr. Pratima Jagadeesh | 21/08/2008
All about make and break of relationships. If enough precautions are taken not to break it, naturally you have made it.
Set of My Likings Dated 21.08.08
By: Dalip Singh Wasan | 20/08/2008
Every one of us must try to understand and enlist one's likings so that we could understand what other likes and we shall be improving on our conduct with others.;
Hypnotic Writing, Does It Work?
By: A. Thomas Perhacs | 20/08/2008
Have you ever wondered if Hypnotic Writing or influencing others through the written word worked? In this thought provoking article, you'll be shown some examples of how Hypnotic Writing works.
Can You be Friends If They Think You Are Faking Your Illness?
By: Lisa Copen | 20/08/2008
Living with a chronic invisible illness can be difficult, but having those you care about the most doubt your disease can be even more disheartening. Can you still be friends?
The Power of Taking Responsibility
By: Gregory McGuire | 20/08/2008
Let me just ask you a question: Do you believe
that you could take action in the next 2 weeks that
would make your life significantly worse?
How to Rid yourself of Destructive Jealousy
By: Katlyn | 20/08/2008
Most everyone experiences jealousy at some point in their life, but jealousy for some, can get out of control. It becomes a toxin to themselves and adversely affects their relationships. It's important to assess your jealous feelings and learn how to deal with them.
Making Friends
By: carol stanley | 20/08/2008
Good friends are what life is about. There are many places to meet them...As we age the process has more challenges.
More from Geoff Gannon
Mueller Water Products
By: Geoff Gannon | 13/04/2007 | Finance
Some smart investors see value in Mueller Water Products (MWA). They're probably right; but, Mueller isn't the kind of situation that jumps out at me as a clear bargain I can understand. However, there is something peculiar about this situation that makes it worth writing about. (Note: The information in...
Topps To Be Acquired By Eisner And Others
By: Geoff Gannon | 19/03/2007 | Finance
On March 6, 2007, Topps (TOPP) announced it agreed to be acquired for $9.75 per share in cash in a transaction valued at $385.4 million. The maker of trading cards and confections (Ring Pop, Push Pop, Bazooka gum, etc.) will be acquired by the Tornante Company and Madison Dearborn Partners....
Traffic At Utube.com Surges 440%
By: Geoff Gannon | 25/10/2006 | Communication
Traffic at uTube.com recently jumped more than 440%. The website is operated by Universal Tube & Rollform Equipment Corporation a company that "specializes in buying and selling used tube mills, used pipe mills and used rollforming machines".
Friendly's CEO Resigns; Largest Shareholder Requests Seats
By: Geoff Gannon | 05/10/2006 | Advice
On September 28th, Friendly Ice Cream Corp. (FRN), announced CEO John L. Cutter had resigned. It was not immediately clear whether Mr. Cutter had been forced out.
I mention the possibility that Mr.
An Analysis Of Lenox (LNX)
By: Geoff Gannon | 03/10/2006 | Advice
Below is a letter from Mr. John L. Morgan, beneficial owner of approximately 7% of Lenox (LNX), to Ms. Susan E. Engel, Chairwoman and CEO of Lenox.
The Human Index
By: Geoff Gannon | 03/10/2006 | Advice
As the Dow approaches a new all-time high (the record close was 11,722.98), now would be a good time to take a break from the financial news found on your televisions, in your newspapers, (and yes) even on your computers.
An Analysis Of Nintendo (NTDOY)
By: Geoff Gannon | 17/09/2006 | Advice
Even before last week's announcement from Sony (SNE), it seemed nearly certain that company's dominance in the PlayStation 2 generation of video game consoles would give way to a much more level playing field for the PS3 generation.
Sony Delays Playstation 3
By: Geoff Gannon | 13/09/2006 | Advice
As a result of problems related to the mass production of a key component of its Blu-ray DVD player, Sony (SNE) will delay the European launch of its next generation video game console, the PlayStation 3 (PS3).
|
|
Self Improvement 
