It is important to have an understanding of what can go wrong with a business loan. The focus of this article is on two situations that will have the most severe financial consequences. A loan disapproval at an early point in the application process is not included here because it is not likely to have the immediate financial consequences of the examples provided below. Business owners should be prepared in advance for these problematic circumstances so that they can develop contingency plans.
RECALL OF A COMMERCIAL LOAN
Recall provisions allow the lender to call the loan (forcing the borrower to repay early) prior to the expiration of the loan. This issue is not of concern to commercial borrowers whose business loan does not contain provisions permitting the lender to recall the loan. However many traditional commercial lenders routinely place recall clauses in their loan agreements. The conditions which can trigger a recall will vary but will commonly include periodic review of financials and credit history by the lender. Under these circumstances if agreed levels of income and credit standards are not met, then the bank will typically notify the commercial borrower that they must pay off the loan within a 30-90 day period.
When confronted with a recall notification, commercial borrowers will have little recourse other than to seek refinancing from another lender. In seeking alternative sources of commercial financing, prudent borrowers will eliminate potential lenders who will impose similar recall provisions in new financing. To avoid the recall situation in the first place, commercial borrowers would be wise to consider only commercial loans which will not have recall terms. For commercial borrowers who currently have recall provisions in their commercial financing agreement but have not yet received a recall of their loan, it will be equally wise to consider refinancing their business loan before such a recall occurs so that refinancing is accomplished according to the commercial borrower's timetable and not that of the current commercial lender.
COMMERCIAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL COSTS AND RESULTS
The commercial appraisal process is lengthy, expensive and relatively uncontrollable in terms of results. In many cases one of the unknowns is how much the appraisal will cost. Unfortunately commercial mortgage appraisal costs can be unpredictable and will approach what many borrowers view to be excessive for specialized commercial properties such as assisted living facilities. Appraisals for a stated income loan will usually be more costly because the lender is primarily depending on credit scores and a sound appraisal to support the loan. These appraisal situations will cost more for commercial properties in rural areas because qualified appraisers may not be available locally. The timetable for completing an appraisal is another potential source of problems, and until the appraiser is selected and commits to a schedule, the completion date is not likely to be known with any degree of accuracy (and this can result in a longer processing period for the loan).
Even though cost and schedule are critical issues, an even bigger issue is the appraisal value that is provided by the appraisal. For example, I have seen instances in which a commercial borrower thought their property was worth $500,000 but the commercial appraiser selected by the lender produced an appraisal with a value of $285,000. While this is not a routine outcome, it is certainly not unusual to receive an appraisal that produces a value that is less than the commercial borrower expects. A similar (but avoidable) problem occurs when a commercial appraisal is not accepted by the lender because the appraiser did not provide an appraisal meeting basic guidelines. For example, a key element of a commercial appraisal is the valuation based on analysis of income. If an appraiser chooses to submit an appraisal based only on comparable sales data even though the lender stipulated in the engagement letter that an income appraisal is required, then the lender will not accept the appraisal (and is likely to refuse even a modified report from the appraiser when they violate such a basic appraisal requirement).
It is important to have an understanding of how the appraiser will be asked to determine value as well as to realize that there might be significant assets which will not even be included in the value. Items such as equipment and furniture are frequently excluded, especially in commercial real estate loans. For businesses such as funeral homes and assisted living facilities, it is very common for the overall business value to be much higher than the real estate value. But an appraisal based on the real estate value will nevertheless exclude the excess business value from the commercial real estate value.
What contingency plans are advisable for the appraisal process? First, be prepared for the appraisal to be more expensive than initially expected and ensure that funds are available to cover this possibility. Second, be prepared for the appraisal to take longer than expected. If buying a business property, the buyer should discuss this possibility in advance with the seller. If refinancing, the owner should not make plans for spending funds until the appraisal has been finalized and the lender indicates their readiness to close the loan. Third, consider in advance what action to take if the appraisal produces a lower value than expected. Fourth, decide if an additional appraisal is warranted (this possibility needs to be considered especially for the situation in which the appraisal is not accepted by the lender).
The purpose of this article was to focus on business loan problems with immediate financial consequences. There are a multitude of other serious commercial loan problems which borrowers should have a similar awareness of in order to avoid unnecessary complications. Commercial borrowers should visit http://aexcommercialfinancing.com and http://steve.bush.googlepages.com/home for an overview of strategies for avoiding commercial financing problems.
Copyright 2005-2006 AEX Commercial Financing Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Upside down on my car loan, Just moved to the US ...
By: rlatts | 19-05-2008
Upside down on my car loan, Just moved to the US and brought my Canadian car with me....can't refinance the loan in the US because my credit is non-exsistant (new to the credit world, in the US) Anyone have any ideas on how I might be able to get around this? Anyone gone through something similar?
I have no money for market research
By: Tom Hicks | 18-05-2008
I am trying to get a business loan for a start up company and i need to find statistics on how many canoes are sold annualy? I have 0 money for market research.
Personal Loan and Auto Loan
By: mushi521 | 08-04-2008
What's the difference between an auto loan and a personal loan?Can I take a personal loan to pay for a car? Is that better or worse than taking an auto loan?
Follow up to an original question posted in Jan/2008.
By: hickory22 | 07-04-2008
It has been 3 months now and I found out the people whom we lent money to for their bussiness have full time jobs with different employers and never filed bankruptcy. We can not afford to hire an attorney at the present time. I have contacted them both by phone 3 times but they hang up on me. Now they say they will sue me for harrassment if I continue to call. Even though it was a business loan, and they're working elsewhere, they still can pay us something, right? These people have turned out to be very mean. I just want justice. Please advice if poss.Thanks!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Personal business loan
By: hickory22 | 16-01-2008
We loaned a person $75K for a business loan and he states he's going bankrupt now, which we will probably never see any of the money. At present, he hasn't filed, what can be done to get our money back? I don't want to contact him if I don't have to.
Can i apply for a payday loan even if im on ...
By: darren | 16-08-2007
can i apply for a payday loan even if im on benefits. if not is there anyone who will give me a loan even if i on benefits
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Advice Articles
Set of My Likings Dated 30.08.08
By: Dalip Singh Wasan | 29/08/2008
We should try to examine each even in life and we should observe each person and then we should decide what we had been liking and what we had been disliking and then we should try to make it sure that we should save ourselves from events which we do not like.
How To Achieve Peak Performance
By: Kevin Sinclair | 29/08/2008
Do you often find it difficult to finish your work at home or at office on time , in spite of those long hours you spent behind organizational training? Don't fret, below I have listed the top 7 tips to help you elevate your performance.
Why Latino Leadership Is A Necessity?
By: Ranju Kumar | 29/08/2008
Leadership is a lifelong learning endeavor that requires following your dreams and making them come true. It involves "giving" to help others. It includes: Coaching, Directing, Delegating and Collaborating with others for a productive outcome.
How to be Liked More
By: Ross G | 27/08/2008
Often when we go about day to day activities, we’re our own worst enemy when it comes to how other people perceive us. A lot of the time the desire to be liked or wanted comes second to our established character traits and idiosyncrasies - the very things that turn other people away!
Wake Up Every Morning Full Of Energy
By: Hans Thorn | 27/08/2008
Imagine yourself wakening up every morning full of energy and ready for the challenges of the day. Would you not like this scenario? Discover how you can accomplish this.
Porn Can be Found by Computer Forensics, Even if You Delete it and Format Hard Drive!
By: Valeri Tkatchenko | 27/08/2008
Porn can easily be found on your hard drive by Computer Forensics no matter how hard you try to get rid of porn these guys will still find it because it will always be there ... It can see you lose your job,family and even go to prison...
Speed Reading: Using A Pointer
By: Matt Chang | 27/08/2008
Another tip you can put to immediate use to improve your speed reading.
Achieving Higher Levels of Spirituality in Psychic Development
By: Rose Ann Schwab | 26/08/2008
“How do we reach higher levels of spirituality?” This is the question that I am asked most in my practice.
More from Stephen Bush
Business Opportunity Investment And Business Loan Finance
By: Stephen Bush | 17/10/2007 | Business
Buying a business opportunity is likely to be an extremely challenging task when arranging the business loan. This is largely due to the usual lack of commercial property as collateral for the business financing to buy a business opportunity. When buying a business that does not include commercial real estate,...
Business Finance Working Capital Loan - Credit Card Processing
By: Stephen Bush | 13/10/2007 | Management
Credit card processing is often one of the most overlooked working capital business loan issues for a business owner. An effective credit card processing program can eliminate many credit card factoring difficulties by implementing appropriate business finance and business cash advance cost-reduction alternatives.
Credit card processing improvements can achieve dual working...
Sba Loan For Business Finance And Commercial Real Estate Mortgage
By: Stephen Bush | 01/10/2007 | Real Estate
Finalizing a Small Business Administration loan (SBA loan) and refinancing an SBA loan can frequently be among the most difficult commercial mortgage and business financing circumstances for a business finance or business real estate borrower. There are successful business loan strategies for both loan situations.
Are SBA Real Estate Mortgage Loan...
Business Financing Advice - Commercial Lenders To Avoid
By: Stephen Bush | 16/03/2007 | Management
This business financing strategy article will describe the importance of avoiding "problem commercial lenders". The article will NOT name specific lenders to avoid, but key examples will be provided to illustrate why prudent commercial borrowers should be prepared to avoid a wide variety of existing commercial lenders in their search...
Commercial Loans - How Long Should They Take?
By: Stephen Bush | 16/01/2007 | Finance
One of the most misunderstood aspects about commercial loans is how long they take to arrange. There are some types of commercial loans which can be obtained in just a few days while other business loans are likely to take up to 60 days or more.
The primary example of commercial...
Business Loan Strategies - Why Do Some Banks Say "Yes" When They Mean "No"?
By: Stephen Bush | 21/12/2006 | Management
Many banks are so conscious of their reputation in the local community that they don't want to be known for refusing business loan requests by respected community residents. One alternative that many of these banks have adopted is the art of never saying "no" in such commercial financing situations. What...
Small Business Loan Trade-offs - Choosing The Best Rate
By: Stephen Bush | 19/11/2006 | Advice
Most small business borrowers are understandably confused by all of the different interest rates for commercial loans.
Commercial Hard Money Loans - Three Business Scenarios
By: Stephen Bush | 05/11/2006 | Business
The primary rationale for a business considering a commercial hard money loan is that traditional commercial financing options are not viable.
Self Improvement 
