Investing In China: Arbitrating Your Disputes

| Posted: 29-11-2006 | Comments: 0 | Views: 114 | Rating: (57)

(?)

Arbitration is the most popular commercial dispute resolution method in China. An arbitration agreement, whether before or after a dispute arises, is a necessary prerequisite to any form of arbitration. If this option is chosen it is best to include a carefully drafted arbitration clause in the contract, because a sloppily drafted clause might end up in the People's Courts – first to decide whether or not it is binding, and if it is not, to decide the underlying dispute.

Foreign Arbitration

Arbitration between domestic parties must be held in China. Since Foreign Invested Enterprises (even if wholly foreign-owned), are considered to be Chinese companies because they are established under Chinese law, a dispute between FIEs or between an FIE and a domestically invested Chinese company is considered a domestic dispute and thus must be arbitrated in China (probably not including Hong Kong – current law is unclear on this point). If you put a foreign abritration clause into a contract between your FIE and another Chinese domestic entity, not only will any foreign arbitral award be unenforceable in China, but also the entire clause will be considered unenforceable and thus the People's Courts will have jurisdiction over any dispute.

Foreign parties often prefer to arbitrate abroad. Hong Kong has a good reputation with both Chinese and foreign investors and is probably the best compromise, but other alternatives include the the Singapore International Arbitration Centre, the International Chamber of Commerce, the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce, and the London Court of International Arbitration.

The China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission (CIETAC)

CIETAC is the most commonly used aritration organization in China, at least for foreign investors. It is affiliated with the Chinese government, with headquarters in Beijing and sub-commissions in Shenzhen and Shanghai. Officially it is the busiest arbitral organization in the world, but this is largely due to the fact that it often deals with matters that would be sent to court in other countries.

CIETAC has endured withering criticism from foreign investors charging lack of neutrality and other sins, and it has responded by introducing some important recent reforms designed to harmonize it with international standards. The panel of approved CIETAC arbitrators now includes over 250 arbitrators who are either of foreign nationality or from Hong Kong, Macau or Taiwan. Many of these arbitrators are ‘old China hands', quite experienced in China and well-versed in their fields.

CIETAC was designed for speed and convenience, and like the People's Courts it relies more on documentary evidence than witness testimony. Although reforms have brought an increasing emphasis on cross-examination of witnesses, it is still noticeably influenced by China's tradionally non-adversarial, inquisitorial justice system . Nevertheless the parties temselves have significant freedom to agree on the presentation of evidence.

Members of foreign law firms are generally allowed to represent parties in CIETAC Arbitration, and arbitration may be conducted in Chinese, English, or another language. In practice, however, it is difficult to convnce a Chinese party to agree to arbitrate in any language except Chinese.

Awards – Foreign-related arbitral awards, whether issued by CIETAC or another Chinese arbitration organization, are considered final and thus the substance of the ruling cannot be challenged in Chinese courts - challenge is limited to narrow bases such as formal defects or fundamental procedural irregularities (corruption, bias, etc.).

As is the case in any form of nonconsensual dispute resolution in China, expect difficulties in enforcement.

Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards

China is signatory to the New York Conventionon, which requires recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards (with certain exceptions such as major procedural irregularities). Again, enforcement in China is difficult in practice. Encouragingly, however, refusal to enforce a foreign arbitral award by a lower court requires confirmation by the Supreme People's Court in order to be effective. But enforcement is not the end of the road - local protectionism may make actual execution of the award difficult, especially when tracing and seizure of assets is involved.

Hong Kong and Macau arbitral awards are enforceable in mainland China under bilateral arrangements, and these arrangements are broadly similar to the terms of the New York Convention.

Rate this Article:

Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).

Article Tags: China, Invest, Law, Arbitration, Dispute Resolution, WOFE

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/affiliate-programs-articles/investing-in-china-arbitrating-your-disputes-75979.html

Print article

Send to friend

Publish this Article

Author feedback

About the Author:

David Carnes is licensed to practice law in California. He speaks and reads Mandarin Chinese and has several years experience working with Chinese law firms and Sino-American joint ventures. His website is called China Legal Bulletin.

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means to drive traffic to your website and promote yourself and your business. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Add new Comment

Investing In China: Tax Incentives
By: David Carnes | 13/10/2006 | Affiliate Programs
The People's Republic of China offers a variety of tax breaks and financial incentives to encourage inbound investment.

Investing In China: Proposed Labor Contract Law
By: David Carnes | 13/10/2006 | Affiliate Programs
If you are considering setting up a company in the People's Republic of China (the "PRC") you should be aware that Chinese law is more protective of employees than the laws of many western nations, particularly the United States.

Invest In China - Establishing A Business Presence
By: David Carnes | 13/10/2006 | Business
Three primary investment forms are commonly used by foreign companies to establish a permanent presence in China—the Sino-foreign Joint Venture, the Wholly Foreign Owned Enterprise, and the Representative Office.

Invest In China: Dealing With Labor Unions And The Communist Party
By: David Carnes | 28/11/2006 | Business
Labor Unions If the employees request the establishment of a labor union, the employer must assent and offer assistance.

Investing In China: Hiring, Firing And Labor Law
By: David Carnes | 14/10/2006 | Affiliate Programs
One of China's major attractions for foreign investors is its low labor costs.

Insolvency And Corparate Bankruptcy In China
By: David Carnes | 01/12/2006 | Business
Insolvency China's insolvency regime is still developing.

Invest In China: Equity Markets
By: David Carnes | 18/10/2006 | Business
China's economy may be growing at the rate of almost 10% a year but its domestic capital markets are in a dismal state, forcing the private sector to disproportionate reliance on foreign investment for capital (particularly hard currency).

All About Real Estate Agents
By: Dave Jarvis | 23/05/2007 | Real Estate
Real Estate Agents..... Who Are They... Real estate agents are professionals instrumental in connecting the buyer with the seller. Additionally, many real estate agents manage rentals wherein they introduce tenants to landlords and oversee the maintenance of the property on behalf of the landlords. In most areas real estate agents are required to be...

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a signed median agreement be withdrawn i have ...
By: tim | 11-11-2008
can a signed median agreement be withdrawn i have a mdiation for a federal court that was signed. Can it be withdrawn?

Sentencings for armed robberies in illinois
By: osobear23 | 11-11-2008
sentencings for armed robberies in illinois

Is a blood alcohol test accurate if it is taken 5 ...
By: cdkjak | 11-11-2008
is a blood alcohol test accurate if it is taken 5-6 hours after the person died

In the state of illinois, if my driver;s license ...
By: dashiag | 11-11-2008
In the state of illinois, if my driver;s license is suspended, what is the process that i have to complete to get them back?

Where can I reach him on weekends?
By: stevie0728 | 11-11-2008
sydney e. unger, mamaroneck,ny

Does my employer have to notify me if they hire a ...
By: Diane | 10-11-2008
does my employer have to notify me if they hire a registered sex offender?

Q&A Powered by:

Latest Affiliate Programs Articles

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: is Your Product Targeted Enough?
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
There some factors that you will have to consider when you are looking for good affiliate product to promote to your customers. One of the key questions that you will have to ask yourself is whether the affiliate product that you are promoting is targeted enough. Why do you need to ask yourself this question?

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: Checking the Sales Conversions of the Merchant Website
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
Are you convinced to buying the products after you have read through the sales letter? This is a very important question that you will have to ask yourself when you are looking for affiliate products to promote. Why the merchant’s website sale conversion is so important to your business?

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: is the Commission and Incentive Attractive for You?
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
Understanding the affiliate program that you are promoting is a very important step as you will want to know the benefits that you can get from the Affiliate program. One of the things that you will want to know is the commission and the incentive that the merchant is offering. There are 2 questions that you will have to ask yourself.

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: Checking the Payout Schedule and Limit
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
When you are doing your affiliate marketing business, you will be spending a lot of your time and effort to promote the affiliate product. You will be expected to be rewarded with the commission from the merchant. It is thus important for you to know the payment system that the merchant has in paying their affiliates.

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: Checking the Merchant’s Term of Service
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
There are many things that you will have to consider when you are choosing the affiliate program that you want to join. It is important that you join a good affiliate program so that you will not be taken advantaged by the merchant. One of the things that you will have to check is the merchant’s term of service.

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: Checking the Merchant’s Support and Contact
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
It is true that you do not have to do any customer supports if the customer purchased the product from the merchant and the merchant should be in charge of giving the support. You will be thinking that your role is to just continue referring customers to the merchant’s website so that you will be credited with the commission if the customer purchases the product. Do you know that your business will be affected by the responsiveness of the merchant’s customer support?

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: Do You Want a Long Term Business?
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
Before you even started your business, you will have to decide on the kind of business that you want to have. If you are not clear, you will not know the things that you will have to do to start your business. So what are the things that you need to know if you want to start your own long term business?

Affiliate Marketing Survival Skill: Checking the Quality of the Affiliate Products
By: Zack Lim | 22/11/2008
There are many affiliates who are only interested in earning quick money and they will just promote any products hoping that the customers will buy. It is true that one of your business goals is to earn money but it is also important that you make your customer happy. One of the things that you will need to do is to check the quality of the affiliate products that you are promoting to your customer. Why is it important?

More from David Carnes

Insolvency And Corparate Bankruptcy In China
By: David Carnes | 01/12/2006 | Business
Insolvency China's insolvency regime is still developing.

What Is 'crazy' Anyway? The Abuse Of Psychiatric Power
By: David Carnes | 23/10/2006 | Advice
A lot of people's definition of "insane" seems to be "not being what I want you to be and refusing to think what I tell you to think". When you are a small child your parents are your gods, and they know it.

Submit Your Website's Url To Chinese Search Engines
By: David Carnes | 21/10/2006 | Communication
It is certainly true that the Internet is dominated by the Englsih language - it has been estimated that 75% of all Internet pages worldwide are written in English. But surprise, surprise, the world's No.

Investing In China: Chinese Banks
By: David Carnes | 16/10/2006 | Business
China's banking sector has traditionally served as a party-controlled feeding trough for its inefficient, unprofitable state-owned enterprises (SOEs), most of which were technically insolvent.

Investing China: China 101 For Smes
By: David Carnes | 15/10/2006 | Affiliate Programs
Many small and medium sized enterprises in western countries are caught between the proverbial "rock and a hard place".

Investing In China: The "china Fallacy"?
By: David Carnes | 14/10/2006 | Business
China has long been an entrepreneur's daydream - "If I could sell one pair of underwear each to a billion Chinese...".

Article Categories

Need Help?

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (1.17, 17)

Investing In China: Arbitrating Your Disputes

Article Comments

Related Articles

Got a Question? Ask.

Latest Affiliate Programs Articles

More from David Carnes

Need Help?

Site Links

Webmasters

Business Info

Sign up for our email newsletter