Free Online Articles Directory
20.11.2008 Sign In Register Hello Guest
Email:
Password:
Remember Me 
forgot your password?


Composition and the Rule of Thirds: Rules are Made to be Broken

Author: Andrew Goodall Author Ranking Silver | Posted: 08-06-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 139 | Rating:  (66) Article Popularity - Blue (?) Got a Question? Ask.
Sign Up Now!
Composition in photography can be a difficult subject to teach to others. This is because composition can be a deeply personal thing. What appeals to me may not appeal to you.

However, many photographers, beginners in particular, are not happy with the way their photos look. But often they can't quite put their finger on why.

There are plenty of rules and guidelines to help you with composition. Possibly the best known is the Rule Of Thirds. This rule suggests your composition should be divided into a nine-part grid, by running two lines horizontally (a third from the top and a third from the bottom) and two lines vertically (a third from the left and a third from the right). According to the rule, large objects (trees, buildings etc) should be placed on these lines, and small objects are most effective if positioned where the lines intersect.

Photos composed around these guidelines have a balanced look. Objects seem to appear exactly where your eye expects to find them. So when you build a composition around the Rule Of Thirds, your photo satisfies the viewer's natural sense of proportion.

Some people have an innate sense of visual balance. They have a natural flair for creative composition that does not need to be guided by rules. However, if you were to examine their photos, you would be sure to find that most of their photos fitted the rule perfectly - even if they were not aware of it.

If you are a beginner in photography and still struggling with composition, the Rule Of Thirds is an excellent place to start. I recommend to every beginner to learn it, practice it, get so familiar with it that you start to apply it without even thinking. Then, once you are truly comfortable with the Rule Of Thirds - ignore it about half the time.

Recently a man walked into my gallery, and before I even said hello I heard him telling his friends: "You see, this is a good photo because it fits the rule of thirds. This is a bad photo because the kangaroo is right in the middle. This sunset is no good because the horizon is too low when it should be here, a third of the way up..."

This man was obviously an ardent devotee of the Rule Of Thirds. For him, anything that stepped outside the boundaries of the rule was automatically a bad photo. But is composition really so simplistic? Of course not.

The real world is not nearly so neatly organised as the Rule Of Thirds. More importantly, being creative means finding your own way to express the character of a subject, which may not always require a traditional approach.

I can give you two very simple examples from my own collection. One of my outback photos has a very detailed foreground, and some tall bushes in the background. I have positioned the horizon right through the centre of the photo. If I raised it higher, I would have lost the foreground. If I dropped it lower, the tops of the bushes would be cut off. In this case, the composition was influenced by the circumstances.

The other example is a sunset photo. The sky in this photo is truly spectacular. I dropped the horizon very low so the colours of the sky fill the frame. If the horizon had been set a third of the way up, that would mean one third of the picture was black. Not only would this be wasted space that did nothing for the photo, it would also diminish the impact of the sky.

Choosing to ignore the Rule Of Thirds is not the same thing as not being aware of it. In each case when taking a photo I would consider the Rule Of Thirds, and judge whether its application will make my picture better, or worse. If I choose to ignore it, it is a deliberate method of adding impact to the composition, possibly by drawing attention to a particular feature like the sky in my sunset photo.

So, back to my earlier statement. If you are struggling with composition, the Rule Of Thirds may be the best thing you ever learn. Not because you should use it for every photo (you shouldn't) but because you should have the judgement to know when to use it and when to ignore it. That way, when you choose to compose your photo differently, it is not just a clumsy mistake, but a creative choice to improve the impact of the photo. Once you cross that threshold, your photography will become a true expression of your artistic eye.
Rate this Article: Current: 5 / 5 stars - 1 vote(s).

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/art-and-entertainment-articles/composition-and-the-rule-of-thirds-rules-are-made-to-be-broken-442518.html

Print this Article Print article   Email to a Friend Send to friend   Publish this Article on your Website Publish this Article   Send Author Feedback Author feedback  
Andrew GoodallAbout the Author:

After 20 years as a professional nature photographer, Andrew Goodall has turned his attention to writing and teaching. Thousands of beginners have learned the art and skills of good photography with Andrew's ebook "Photography In Plain English." Check it out at http://www.naturesimage.com.au

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means to drive traffic to your website and promote yourself and your business. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Comment on this article Comment on this article
Your Name
Your Email:
Comment Body
Enter Validation Code: Captcha


Related Articles

Photography Composition: the Rule of Thirds
By: Andrew Goodall | 09/05/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Composition is essential to good photography, but many new photographers don't know where to start. This simple explanation of the Rule Of Thirds is a great starting point for any beginner.

Photography for Beginners: Knowing When to Break the Rules
By: Andrew Goodall | 11/09/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Good photography is a challenging field that can be made easier by learning some essential rules of technique and composition. A good photographer learns the rules; a great photographer knows when to break them.

Learning Photography? Don't Forget Your Camera
By: Andrew Goodall | 21/03/2008 | Art & Entertainment
A warning for new photographers that many ebooks and courses on photography are about using computer software, not about taking better photos.

Composition in Wildlife Photography - Simple Tips for Beginners
By: Andrew Goodall | 23/06/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Composition in wildlife photography poses a double challenge - all the complexity of balanced composition, plus a subject that has no interest in having its photo taken! Here are some tips to help you get started.

Wildlife Photography: the Secret is in the Eyes
By: Andrew Goodall | 08/07/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Wildlife photography can be one of the most challenging fields of photography, and one of the most rewarding. Beginners should remember one thing above all when trying to master wildlife photography: it's all in the eyes.

Composition in Wildlife Photography: the Best Position for Your Subject
By: Andrew Goodall | 11/08/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Beginners in wildlife photography all eventually come up against this question: "Where do I position my subject - left, right, or in the middle?" These guidelines may help you find a balance that suits you.

Landscape Photography: Straight Lines in a Composition
By: Andrew Goodall | 28/09/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Composition in photography is a purely creative process, so it is hard to teach. There are some guidelines to help make the learning curve easier. One is the use of straight lines to add shape and impact to your composition.

Great Waterfall Photos: Five Simple Tips
By: Andrew Goodall | 18/06/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Waterfall photography is easy to enjoy, but it is also easy to get wrong through simple mistakes. Here are five simple tips anyone can try to help improve your waterfall photos.

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Frequently Asked Questions

How to take lunar photographs with digital camera ...
By: PAQI | 23-10-2008
How to take lunar photographs with digital camera and telescope

Is this a scam?
By: Shelly | 23-10-2008
Has anybody ever heard of Timeshare Consolidators or First American Transfer Group out of Dallas, TX? I have googled them several times and cannot find anyone doing business under that name that does timeshare title transfers.

Digi Camera Help
By: Dawn | 22-10-2008
What is the best way to email family pics from your nikon s550

Lucky dog photography, from a photo which said
By: Beewellxyz | 22-10-2008
lucky dog photography, from a photo which said "(c) lucky dog 2008"

1830's or Flag HISTORY BUFFS welcome
By: The Ladybug | 21-10-2008
Where can I find a photo of a mississippi flag flying above us flag from around 1833?

CLS Photo in MN Is there one? If so do they have ...
By: gboysmama | 21-10-2008
CLS Photo in MN Is there one?  If so do they have a website?

Q&A Powered by:
Powered by Yedda 

Latest Art and Entertainment Articles

Leicester Ice Skating – Kids Guide
By: Abhinav Sidana | 20/11/2008
Leicester ice skating rink is definitely one of the venues where you can spend some great time with your kids. Those parents who already know how to skate and have brought their kids to an ice skating rink probably know how to deal wit their kids.

Get Close to One Another
By: Tom Cruse | 20/11/2008
The most effective way to communicate with individuals, staying far away or the people you do not visit frequently, is to chat with them over the internet.

The Best Flirting Tips and Dating Tips to Try
By: lucy watson | 20/11/2008
Love is everywhere. In fact, flirting tips and dating tips are there to help you out in your dating dilemmas and problems. If you are still single and have not found the perfect person yet, try online dating. Some people have tried it and confessed that it has worked for them. They have met the person they want to share the rest of their life with and found them on the internet. Amazing isn’t it? Back then, people frequented bars and disco clubs because they are looking for dates and partners. B

Online Dating Tips That Work
By: lucy watson | 20/11/2008
Want to know the best online dating tips? You may not be satisfied with the dates that you are expecting but there are a lot of dating tips that you can get on the internet. You may wear yourself out in parties, bars and clubs just to spot a date but there is another practical way of doing so without the hassle. Dating online is one of the most popular ways of meeting other people that you may like or be in a relationship with. Most of the time, those who have internet connection in their houses

What Goes Into Building Sound Stages
By: Deborah Yonatan | 20/11/2008
Most people simply turn on their TV sets, watch their shows and are completely oblivious to what a sound stage is. Of course, everyone knows what a stage is but most people couldn't tell you what differentiates a sound stage from any other type of stage.

Undertaking Commercial Film Production on a Shoestring Budget
By: Deborah Yonatan | 20/11/2008
Who hasn't heard of the Blair Witch Project? Or maybe you have heard of another movie called The Rocky Horror Picture Show? Or what about The Texas Chain Saw Massacre? So, what do all of these wildly successful movies have in common? The simple answer to that question, is that they were all made on a shoe string budget.

Tips on Beginning a Career in Production Design
By: Deborah Yonatan | 20/11/2008
Attaining a successful career in film production design can seem like a far fetched dream but the fact is, that for many people it is a dream that becomes reality. So, what is it that separates the people who actually achieve their dream of a career in production design and those that don't?

Tips for Mastering the Art of Commercial Film Production
By: Deborah Yonatan | 20/11/2008
What is it that separates a good film from a bad film? In fact, it is difficult to put your finger on any one item but in the end a good film is one that people will want to watch and a bad film is one that they don't.

More from Andrew Goodall

Nature Photography That Sells: Five Essential Tips
By: Andrew Goodall | 09/11/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Digital cameras make it easy for anybody to produce 'good' nature photography. These days, 'good' is not good enough; if you want to make a living, your photograph must be a step above the average. Here are five tips for some truly disintive nature photos.

Wildlife Photography: Natural Light for Great Wildlife Photos
By: Andrew Goodall | 06/11/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Wildlife photography calls on a variety of camera skills, but all the technique in the world means nothing if your photo is badly lit. Here are some tips on capturing the best light for your wildlife photos.

Digital Photography: Aperture Priority and Shutter Priority Modes
By: Andrew Goodall | 04/11/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Aperture and shutter speed are great creative tools for photography - once you know how to use them. In modern cameras, this is much easier thanks to Aperture Priority and Shutter Priority modes.

Digital Photography: Breathe New Life Into Your Old Film Photos
By: Andrew Goodall | 27/10/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Digital photography is definitely the way of the future, but that does not mean your old film photography should be forgotten. Revisit the great photos of your past and rediscover some forgotten gems.

Turn Your Digital Photography Into a 2009 Calendar
By: Andrew Goodall | 15/10/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Your digital photos don't belong on a computer screen - they should be shared and enjoyed with friends and family! A 2009 calendar is a great idea for turning your digital photos into a unique personal gift.

Nature Photography: How Far are You Prepared to Go for a Photo?
By: Andrew Goodall | 11/10/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Good nature photography is not just about technology. It is about having the knowledge and skills to produce a great photo and going to the extra effort to make it happen.

Wildlife Photography: Capturing Images With Character
By: Andrew Goodall | 04/10/2008 | Art & Entertainment
Wildlife photography is easy to enjoy, but hard to to get your shots just right. Great wildlife images are not the product of high-tech equipment. They are about patience, timing, and knowing how to capture the character of your subject.

Polarising Filters: Why You Should Have One (and Know How to Use It)
By: Andrew Goodall | 01/10/2008 | Art & Entertainment
There are plenty of filters on the market to enhance your photography, but a polariser is one you should consider. Here are a few uses, plus a few of the drawbacks to look out for.

Article Categories





Give Feedback

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below