The television show American Idol is making headlines in the mainstream media as well as celebrity gossip magazines such as Star Magazine and In Touch Weekly concerning a grassroots online campaign for viewers to tune in and vote for the worst candidate who happens to be contestant Sanjaya Malakar.
All over the media people are weighing in with their opinions. Internet message boards and forums have been abuzz with both outrage and support of the campaign started by website Vote for the Worst to vote only for the worst candidate in the karaoke like contest. According to the website owners they began the site to shed light on what they felt was hypocrisy in the amateur talent contest which seems to push those with less than stellar talent along while those with true singing talent get pushed to the wayside.
In defense of American Idol, it seems that the creators of Vote for the Worst seem to forget that the entertainment industry is after all a business. While viewers may become endeared to certain contestants there is a certain indescribable quality necessary in order to become a successful pop artist. While fans defied the practical Simon Cowell and voted for Taylor Hicks, even his fan base the Soul Patrol has not been able to boost his less than great record sales.
In truth the judges of American Idol along with the producers are looking to find someone who is more than a great singer. The person chosen has to have a specific kind of personality, has to be able to command attention to them and dare I say it should be easy on the eyes as well. The idea at the onset is to give a record contract to whoever might be the winner, and that person should be able to sell records.
The reality is that some of the biggest selling artists of today do not necessarily have the greatest singing voices. Yet, singers like Britney Spears, Janet Jackson, Madonna and Jennifer Lopez are able to fill stadiums for concerts and sell millions and millions of copies of their records. It is the responsibility of the judges and producers to find the total package, and angry fans like the creators of Vote for the Worst have an idealistic view of how the contest itself should work.
While most people love singers in this years contest like Melinda Doolittle and Lakisha Jones we all understand that contestants like Jordin Sparks and Blake Lewis would probably make a better idol in terms of sales. Requesting that the people behind American Idol choose people on talent alone would be demanding that the record company contractually bound to bank on a winner whose album would not necessarily result in any significant record sales.
In the likelihood that Sanjaya Malakar should win what happens to American Idol? Sites like Vote for the Worst have done their job; they can pack up and go home. Malakar, a national punch line has to be signed by J Records, the company started by former Arista head Clive Davis. Those that were quick to rush to the phones are unlikely to pay fifteen dollars to listen to an album the lackluster singer has recorded or pay ninety nine cents to download anything produced by him either. To add insult to injury a singer really deserving of the contract is out of luck, and everyone wins, right? Vote for the worst if you dare.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
How many people cast votes for Season Four ...
By: Thom | 01-10-2008
How many people cast votes for Season Four American Idol and by what percentages ddi the winner win by?
Mark Balas of dancing with the stars split up with ...
By: Robert | 30-09-2008
Mark Balas of dancing with the stars split up with Sabrina? and if so who is he dating now?
Song choice on dancing with the stars. Who picks song couples dance to?
By: rags56 | 27-09-2008
Dancing with the Stars Would like to know if the couple or the show picks the song they dance to.
How do you get on the show trading spouses
By: cookster | 21-09-2008
how do you get on the show trading spouses
Simon, a tie breaker??
By: sarah | 19-09-2008
americanidol.com
Why would they give Simon Cowel the power to break a tie? Yes, he is usually right but if he had the final word, we never would have known Clay Aiken and he definitely would have sent David Cook packing early. What a loss that would have been to a country who needs to watch these young people's talent being developed and improved and to feel a hand in their success. I don't think any judge should be given that power. Find another way to break a tie.
What's Devyn Puett up to these days?
By: GreatAuntCayce | 11-09-2008
What's Devyn Puett up to these days?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Art and Entertainment Articles
10 Questions To Ask A Potential Band Member
By: David Hooper | 12/10/2008
It's like a job interview, but so much more. A band member isn't just doing a job-they are joining your creative family. You want to be sure of their technical ability, and you also want to be sure they will blend with the rest of the band. Success for your...
Nature Photography: How Far are You Prepared to Go for a Photo?
By: Andrew Goodall | 11/10/2008
Good nature photography is not just about technology. It is about having the knowledge and skills to produce a great photo and going to the extra effort to make it happen.
Fun is a Fantasy
By: Bradley Darville | 11/10/2008
Most of us can easily remember our childhood years when having fun was seemingly all that mattered and our innocent minds dared to dream and imagine what seemed at the time to be the impossible.
Stunning Weddings and Bridal Gowns
By: Christa Kowalczyk | 11/10/2008
Brides and grooms of today come up with wedding themes to make their big day more personal, unique and extraordinary. And as more and more women are attracted to non traditional bridal gowns, the over-all figure of the bride as well as the wedding setting are considered in selecting the...
Picture It! 18 Ideas For Your Custom Photo Reproduction
By: Michael DeVries | 11/10/2008
You want to decorate with something personal, but just can't find it. It may be as close as your photo collection whether it's in Grandma's old photo album or on a modern digital photo system.
You can order a custom artistic photo reproduction and have a one-of-a-kind creation as a focal...
Why the Wii is so Popular?
By: Musa Aykac | 11/10/2008
With the generation of consoles now permanently competing against each other, the Nintendo Wii looks as though it is storming full speed ahead.
14 Johnny Carson Quotes to Commemorate the Birthday of a TV Legend
By: Noel Jameson | 10/10/2008
Few ever achieve the fame and adoration that Johnny Carson achieved. Was it luck? Talent? Personality? It was probably a mixture of all of these things and more. Let's celebrate the years we spent with Johnny, and reflect on his one-of-a-kind wit and charm, with these fourteen Johnny Carson quotes.
Taurus - Characteristics of Those Born Under Taurus Zodiac Sign
By: Ronald Pearce | 10/10/2008
Find out the typical characteristics and traits of the Taurus and other zodiac signs.
More from Lisa James
Sanjaya Malakar Is Saving American Idol
By: Lisa James | 13/04/2007 | Art and Entertainment
The television show American Idols is no doubt a ratings blockbuster, however, after being on the air for six years, a show can start to show some wear and tear. Though not suffering from declining ratings, the crop of fresh talent this year does not seem to have the same...
Vote For The Worst Changing American Idol Forever
By: Lisa James | 13/04/2007 | Art and Entertainment
Anyone familiar with American Idol and that is just about anyone who is not living underneath a rock is familiar with the staying power of Sanjaya Malakar. The seventeen year old has become famous for his ability to stay in the talent contest although he possesses the weakest singing voice,...
Vote For the Worst Changes American Idol Forever
By: Lisa James | 12/04/2007 | Art and Entertainment
American Idol contestant Sanjaya Malaker continues to perform every week for his chance to become the next American Idol due in large part to the Vote for the Worst campaign. Even if he does not win, Idol will be changed forever.
American Idol, Vote for the Worst If You Dare
By: Lisa James | 09/04/2007 | Art and Entertainment
To many the Vote for the Worst Campaign may seem like fun. If the campaign prevails the there may be irrevocable harm to the American Idol franchise.
Sanjaya Malakar Rescues American Idol Ratings
By: Lisa James | 09/04/2007 | Art and Entertainment
Sanjaya Malakar is famous for becoming one of the worst finalists in American Idol history. However, the mediocre crooner is garnering the show huge rating and people are voting in record numbers. Sanjaya Malaker is saving this season of American Idol.
Three Reasons To Hate Hollywood
By: Lisa James | 02/04/2007 | Advice
There are many reasons to glance through the pages of popular celebrity weekly magazines such as Star Magazine and In Touch and become envious at the lives of celebrities. The truth is that fame is often elusive for those who seek it and often fleeting for those that do. We...
Real Hollywood Awards
By: Lisa James | 02/04/2007 | Art and Entertainment
Celebrity gossip magazines such as Star Magazine and the National Enquirer give their readers information on every single facet of celebrity life. Readers look forward to the feature spreads at the myriad of awards show covered by these popular magazines. However, the categories never change. We all have our favorite...
American Idol Do Not Vote for the Worst
By: Lisa James | 27/03/2007 | Art and Entertainment
There is a new grassroots campaign trying to persuade people to vote for the worst contestant on American Idol. Before viewers follow this call to arms they should look at the motivation of the people telling them to do so, and the possible end of American Idol as we know it.
Art and Entertainment 
