How Collaboration is Different From Consulting
Indeed they are different; Most widely accepted definition of a consultant is an expert or a professional in a specific field and has a wide knowledge of the subject matter and one who provides advice in that field.
So by definition a consultant has very limited execution responsibility. However commercialization of the 'Consulting Industry' and intense competition has led to a situation where firms promise to own or share responsibility of execution. But in reality, they primarily role is to advise so things fall through the cracks as the engagement proceeds.
Due to their envious position as subject matter experts, consultants usually have an upper hand in their relationship with clients. Many times, this biased relationship is not very conducive for building trust and confidence between both the parties.
"The test of a good consultant is not whether he or she has generated a unique insight, but whether the insight can be applied to produce positive results. Consultants can't just be smart; they have to be capable of delivering a business outcome" - The Economist
That is why consultants are usually criticized for the following:
- Theorizing problems and making them difficult to comprehend
- Heavy usage of Jargon!
- Force problems into a 'methodology' they know
- Attempt to make projects bigger or longer than they need to be
- Produce an elaborate dossier called 'Project Report' that reiterates the problem
Not all consultants have such deficiencies, but it is very prevalent.
'Collaboration' on the other hand is a recursive process where two or more people or organizations work together intersection of common goals - for example, an intellectual endeavor that is creative in nature -by sharing knowledge, learning and building consensus. Collaboration does not require directive leadership and can sometimes bring better results through decentralization and egalitarianism.
Traditionally, collaboration is widely popular among authors, academicians & researchers. These are fields where two or more experts with diverse and varied experience work together to towards a common goal. So 'execution & result orientation' is at the heart of collaboration. And unlike consulting, there is no role to just 'advise' and not own execution.
Good collaboration has the following elements:
1) Tactical - Where one tells other teams members specifically what to do in his/her areas of expertise
2) Tacit - Where one trains other members on how to handle issues/situations beyond technical stuff
3) Co-delivery - Where one dirties his/her hands and work together with the team
4) Partnership - Where one recognizes that they are not experts in all disciplines. Hence he/she partners with other experts in the team
There is no need to emphasis which one is better when it comes to 'change management'. Collaborative style of change management is several notches above consultative style.
Known in short as Neil, Nilakantasrinivasan helps individuals and organizations to improve their performance, profitability and processes.
He is an expert in Operations Management, Customer Experience & Project Management.
Neil's approach is not to prescribe any 'methodology'. Instead he uses his experience with Hoshin Kanri, Balance Scorecard, LEAN, TQM, Six Sigma, Triz, Theory of Constraints, Knowledge Management, industrial engineering methods, ISO, PCMM, etc to deliver a composite solution that will resolve the pain points and improve profitability, productivity & process.
Fore more information check out http://www.collaborat.com
Questions and Answers
Article Tags:
canopus business management group
,six sigma
,six sigma training
,one on one coaching
,business transformation
,customer experience
,strategic planning
Traditionally Human Resource is viewed primarily as an administrative function. But things are not the same in the current environment. While the administration of these activities is still important to business, HR Management is not seen as helpful in delivering upon business strategy. The HR Head is increasingly required to act as both strategist and steward, who orchestrates day-to-day HR operations and participates in overall business strategy.
Customer Interactions happens at each touchpoint of your business channels. A research by a leading institution has concluded that such interactions are key factors in improving customer experience and bridging the gap between brand promise and customer expectations.
Strategy is a key element to any organization or individual's success. Traditionally, Small & Medium Businesses have been deprived of a good strategic document.
Would you visit a doctor who prescribes mass medication? No, Period. Many times we need personal attention and specific guidance.
Business Plan writing is not about filling templates. It is about strategizing on how an idea is going to be executed and sustained. Such an important task can be given to someone else who puts together a document for a fee. This article focuses on educating business leaders and entrepreneurs about what goes into business plans and providing them useful tips. The framework used for writing a business plan that the author recommends is based on popular 'Hoshin Kanri' methodology of strategy deplo
If you want your business plan to deliver results for you, then you have to get involved in creating your plan. Writing a business plan has been discussed in detail in a series of two articles titled 'Essential Business Plan for Start-ups - Individual Hoshin Plan'. But even before starting to writing a business plan, there are a few things which one should have completed. In this article, let me share with you those which are basic and needs to be surely considered.
Find out the best advice on the way to apply Balanced Scorecard system in various companies. Find out more on Balanced Scorecard advantages in this article.
The current economic climate of China is growing at a rapid pace. China is even predicted too become the top manufacturer in the near future! China currently provides imported products to a majority of nations in the world today. One of these countries is Australia. In Australia, the wholesale business industry is a big success and many businessmen are looking for ways to make sure they improve their trading relationship with China.
The most important thing to consider whenever creating business in south America is always to defeat the language barrier and a superb technique to do this if you are willing to know would be to master Spanish language as well as Portuguese.
The Latin America market is among the swiftest widening in the world that's the reason why it is an excellent spot to build organizations or purchase shares from countries in this region. The location has great macroeconomic principles and along with sound political weather, it is quite the spot for traders to put their money in.
TV distributors are extremely getting more intense with the promotional plans and methods they utilize to get clients. You need to give credit to many of these sellers as most of these techniques call for big amounts of money and creativity to draw in attention to their items and frequently, even poach prospective clients from their rivals.
The essence of this article is to all ways of life. But its very pertinent to many professions, more particularly to Project Management as there are multiple stakeholders.
Business Plan writing is not about filling templates. It is about strategizing on how an idea is going to be executed and sustained. Such an important task can be given to someone else who puts together a document for a fee. This article focuses on educating business leaders and entrepreneurs about what goes into business plans and providing them useful tips.
The stress is always on improving how projects are managed. Often Process Management, one of the important pre-requisites for project management is missed from the list. This article highlights the need for good processes so that projects can be delivered flawlessly.
Business Plan writing is not about filling templates. It is about strategizing on how an idea is going to be executed and sustained. Such an important task can be given to someone else who puts together a document for a fee. This article focuses on educating business leaders and entrepreneurs about what goes into business plans and providing them useful tips. The framework used for writing a business plan that the author recommends is based on popular 'Hoshin Kanri' methodology of strategy deplo
If you want your business plan to deliver results for you, then you have to get involved in creating your plan. Writing a business plan has been discussed in detail in a series of two articles titled 'Essential Business Plan for Start-ups - Individual Hoshin Plan'. But even before starting to writing a business plan, there are a few things which one should have completed. In this article, let me share with you those which are basic and needs to be surely considered.
Discuss this Article
