Judy writes:
"I have a 6 month old Great Dane that I bought a pinch collar to stop bad habits (nipping, jumping up). This worked great for about one week but now it is very difficult to give a 'motivational' correction. It's almost like she's gotten used to the collar and doesn't respond to it anymore. This is especially the case when she is on the couch. Sometimes she bites at this time (not hard, but it's very annoying), and it is impossible to give her a 'motivational' correction. Any advice?"
Dear Judy:
Here's a blurb from an article I wrote on how to use the pinch collar:
Basics of the Pinch Collar
The pinch collar is designed to replicate the way the mother would correct her pups in a litter. Or similarly, how the Alpha dog in a pack would correct the subordinate dogs... that is, by giving a "nip" on the neck.
The prong collar (also frequently called the pinch collar) is made of a series of prongs that link together.
Most pinch collars are designed pretty much the same: There is a safety ring which rides next to the dog's neck and a "D" shaped ring that you hook your leash to. Some pinch collar manufacturers have developed "quick release" mechanisms which may work somewhat differently.
A Safe Fit For the Pinch Collar:
In order to properly size and fit the collar, you must do the following:
1. Understand that size and fit are two different issues. The size is determined by the SIZE of the prong... not the diameter. Sizes usually come in small, medium and large. For dogs up to 40 pounds, a small prong usually works best as you'll get more "pinch to the inch." Dogs 40 to 80 pounds will usually need a medium or sometimes a large size prong.
2. The fit of the collar is determined by adding or subtracting prongs to change the diameter. Simply break the collar open at one of the looser prongs in the middle of the collar and pop off one or more of the individual prongs.
3. Properly fitted, you should only be able to fit approximately 1/2 finger space between the tip of the prong and the skin of the dog's neck. Trust me, you won't be doing your dog any favor if it's too loose and you have to give 10 times the number of corrections and it's rubbing and chafing her neck because YOU weren't using it correctly. Make sure it's a snug fit... 1/2 finger space!!!
Don't Teach Your Dog To Be Collar-Smart!
If you put the pinch collar on your dog immediately before training, she'll become COLLAR-SMART! She'll respond like a complete angel when the collar is on but like a real devil when the collar is off. So, just like the Alpha dog who always has the ability to correct the subordinate dogs (with her mouth)... so must you! In other words, leave the pinch collar and a tab (1 foot leash or longer) on your dog ANY TIME YOU'RE INTERACTING WITH HER. You'll know when she's proofed when you can call me up and bet me $100 because you're so confident that your dog is responding with 100% reliability. If you take the pinch collar off sooner, you're running the risk of making her collar-smart!
Specific to answering your question, usually when people tell me this the culprit is one of the following reasons:
- The pinch collar is too loose, and they need to take another link out. In such cases, you should only be able to put 1/2 a finger space between the prong and the skin of the dog's neck. Sometimes even less.
- When giving the correction, the handler isn't using slack, but is instead mistakenly pulling the leash tight-to-tighter. It needs to be loose-to-tight-to-loose, in a sharp, snapping tug motion.
- If, after trying all of the above, you're currently using a medium sized prong collar, I'd suggest going up to the large. Or vice versa.
Sometimes a different sized prong works better on different dogs. However, this is usually a non-issue, as the culprit is HOW the collar is used (see above.)
That's all for now, folks!
Adam
Related Articles
How To Stop Fence Jumping
By: Adam Katz | 09/05/2006 | Pets
Basically, the dog needs to associate a negative experience with jumping up on the fence. But, this negative experience must have three things going for it. First, the negative must happen right as he is jumping up on the fence.
Dog Barks When Left Alone
By: Adam Katz | 10/07/2006 | Automotive
Please let me know if you have any suggestions to help curb a barking problem when we are not home. Our 2 year-old Shepherd/Chow mix rarely barks when we are home, but when we leave her in her nice pen outdoors when we are gone she yips and barks.
Three Things You Can Do To Fix Car Sickness
By: Adam Katz | 15/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam: Thank you so much for your tip on how to get my dog to come to me. After only a day of training he now comes right away no matter where I am. I am definitely the Alpha Dog around here. I do have another problem. He always gets car sick.
Do you Make These Mistakes When Walking your Dog?
By: Lisa Nobles | 22/01/2008 | Pets
Learn a few tips for getting your dog to walk better. Stop being taken for a walk and start being the walker!
Leaving A Puppy Loose In The House
By: Adam Katz | 10/07/2006 | Automotive
Hi Adam, I purchased your book, and have made huge progress with my 6 month chocolate puppy (Kava). (To read about the book she's referring to please see http://www.dogproblems.com/newvideos.htm) Kava is a good dog, very smart, and basically obedient.
Boundary And Perimeter Training For A Wandering Collie
By: Adam Katz | 17/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam: Hello! I only bought your book a few days ago but have read it cover to cover and reread certain things all the time. (To read about the book she's talking about, please take a look at http://www.dogproblems.com/newvideos.
Are You An Animal Lover
By: John Savage | 28/08/2006 | Pets
Some people seem to run a zoo from their home, but other people have nothing to do with animals.
Teaching Your Dog To Walk On A Leash Properly
By: Lisa Nobles | 31/01/2008 | Pets
If you've ever been to the dog park and watched some owners walk their dogs, it's hard to determine who is walking who. To make your walk times enjoyable for both you, as the owner and your dog, proper leash walking is imperative. And now you don't have to just...
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Flea treatment overdose?
By: Pam | 05-07-2008
Can a 10 lb. dog overdose on a flea treatment with the active ingredient being pyrethrins?
Self cleaning dog brush
By: olivia | 04-07-2008
a sceen on tv..a the name of a self cleaning dog and cat brush for 19.95. You get 2 brushes
Puppy on Heat
By: MM | 04-07-2008
At what age does a puppy go on heat?
Raccoon Needs Help
By: animal lover | 03-07-2008
My pet raccoon needs a veterinarian now! I can't find one willing to treat him. He is 9 years old and lives indoors. We live in DuPage County, IL but will travel for help.
I want a deaf dog, but.....
By: Nes | 02-07-2008
So I went to the animal shelter along with my girlfriend today and this 10 month old mixed Pitbull really caught our attention. The dog is gorgeous and very friendly. We just fell in love with her the minute we saw her, but as we were reading her description we read that she is deaf. I really don't care about that but i am worried that if we bring her to our home and if she gets out of the house one day, she may get hurt by a car or something/someone else, since she can't hear anything approaching her. My girlfriend and I really want her, but we are just worried about her safety...we also got a chance to walk her and I obviously couldn't call her over. The only way she comes to us is when she looks at us and we sign her to walk over to us. Should I be worried about her impairment and how can I train her??
Looking for name of a dog/clip
By: horsjumper | 02-07-2008
I saw a clip of a dog (cattle dog) who a farrier (blacksmith) took in, and the dog became famous for his tricks and doing what his master says. He's traveled the world, been on Ellen, Oprah etc. His name is something to do with horseshoeing I believe
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Automotive Articles
Steps to Increase Your Fuel Economy
By: Stephen Long | 08/07/2008
With gas and oil prices continuing to soar there are many people looking for ways to increase fuel economy. There are some simple tips that can save you hundreds of dollars at the pump.
Green Fuels - the Facts
By: Mervyn Rees | 08/07/2008
Have you heard about cars that run on peanut oil? Well when Rudolph Diesel invented his engine the ones we now run on what has become known as 'diesel' (Named after him) he ran his on peanut oil.
Help the Environment by not Using Gas in Your Car - Use Water Instead!
By: Steven De Gracia | 08/07/2008
Help The Environment By Not Using Gas In Your Car - Use Water Instead!
How Can You Remove a Dent From a Motorcycle Tank ?
By: Steven Magill | 08/07/2008
Some motorcycle gas tanks are double skinned. It's a bit like having a tank inside a tank. This kind of gas tank makes it difficult to remove the dent from the inside as you will be applying pressure to the inside metal skin, and not the outside metal skin where the dent actually is.
How to Make Your Motorcycle Rust Free and Look Showroom Quality!
By: Markus Skupeika | 07/07/2008
Everybody wants their bike to be great both in respect to look and riding condition. Almost all pro-bikers take the extra initiative to keep their bike in great condition. However, in case of regular users, a lot of them hardly find some time to take care of their bikes. They...
How to Clean a Bicycle Completely?
By: Markus Skupeika | 07/07/2008
Keeping a bike clean and rust free for a long time is not a very tough and time taking job if you have the right equipments and if you know how to clean a bike properly. If you are a first time bike cleaner, do not worry, it is as...
How do You Fight With Bike Rust?
By: Markus Skupeika | 07/07/2008
What do you do when you pull the rear brake lever to stop your bike and it does not work at all? I know what you are thinking - there might be something wrong in the pads or lever and break just failed. This is a very common occurrence. However,...
Keep Your Car in Good Condition Even if You Are Not Using It
By: Markus Skupeika | 07/07/2008
Rising fuel costs has become a big headache for car or motorcycle owners all over the world. And with rising fuel price, bicycles are back in fashion. There are lots of reports that people are going back to bicycles to move between short distances. In some cases people are sharing...
More from Adam Katz
When Is Dog Reliable Off Leash
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam: My name is Diane and I have a German Shepherd named Ajax. I have watched your video over and over again on having your dog come every time you call him. I have done all you have said (believe me, I'm a fan of yours now).
What Dog Breed I Recommend To My Friends
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
To recommend a good dog breed to someone, you need to know two things: 1. You must have an in-depth and personal experience with many different breeds. And more specifically, you must have multiple experiences with each breed.
What You Need To Know When Picking A Puppy
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
This was a last minute e-mail I sent to a friend in California, who contacted me only a few hours befote she was leaving to pick a puppy from a breeder she's been researching.
Should There Be A Primary Dog Trainer In Your Household
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
Hi, My name is Greg Williams and I just received your book and videos yesterday. I've read almost all of the book and watched all the videos. [To read about the book and videos that he's referring to, please take a look at http://www.dogproblems.
Dog Barks Continuously While Owners Eat
By: Adam Katz | 20/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Mr. Katz, I have a two year-old female Boxer named Amber and a six year-old female St. Bernard named Crystal. My question is regarding the Boxer, Amber.
Training Around Distractions
By: Adam Katz | 20/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam: I have eventually received your book and cassettes. The post office apologized for the delay caused by a petrol shortage over here. Your book was worth waiting for and I hope to action some of your advice.
German Shepherd Whines When Left In Kennel
By: Adam Katz | 19/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Mr. Katz: I have a 6 month old German Shepherd named Thor. Having read your book, I applied your techniques to him and he responded very quickly, to my surprise! He is quite good at a sit-stay and down-stay now, which is very, very useful.
How To Let Your Dog Enjoy Family Time
By: Adam Katz | 19/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam, I adopted a 1 year-old female dog about a year ago. I have 2 cats who grew up with dogs and like dogs.
Automotive 
