Please let me know if you have any suggestions to help curb a barking problem when we are not home. Our 2 year-old Shepherd/Chow mix rarely barks when we are home, but when we leave her in her nice pen outdoors when we are gone she yips and barks. We have tried stuffed animals and kong toy with food inside. Do we need to get a bark collar? Any other suggestions or info on the collars would be appreciated.
Thank you,
Beth Nordstrom
Dear Beth:
First, I would try to figure out what is causing the dog to bark. It may be nothing more than nuisance barking. In which case, a bark collar would work best.
But I'd first rule out all other factors, such as:
- A neighbor's kid who may be taunting your dog.
- Lack of exercise/stimulation.
- Throwing a toy outside of the pen and then barking in an attempt to "make it come back"
- Any number of other factors that could be eliminated before dropping $100 on a bark collar.
I don't know what type of exercise regimen you've got your dog on now, but it probably wouldn't hurt to buy a bicycle and start taking your dog for long runs. (It's good for you, too!)
As for which bark collars to use... the ones that I've had the most success with are the Tri-Tronics Bark Limiter. I've tried the cheap yellow ones they sell at the pet stores and have found them to be poorly engineered, consistently over or under-correcting your dog, and resetting themselves too quickly.
The citronella collars are largely a joke. The get clogged and jam frequently. The citronella runs out. Plus, I'm not crazy about spraying the stuff in your dog's eyes.
That's all for now, folks!
Adam
Related Articles
How To Stop Fence Jumping
By: Adam Katz | 09/05/2006 | Pets
Basically, the dog needs to associate a negative experience with jumping up on the fence. But, this negative experience must have three things going for it. First, the negative must happen right as he is jumping up on the fence.
Leaving A Puppy Loose In The House
By: Adam Katz | 10/07/2006 | Automotive
Hi Adam, I purchased your book, and have made huge progress with my 6 month chocolate puppy (Kava). (To read about the book she's referring to please see http://www.dogproblems.com/newvideos.htm) Kava is a good dog, very smart, and basically obedient.
Can't Get Motivational Correction With Pinch Collar
By: Adam Katz | 15/07/2006 | Automotive
Judy writes: "I have a 6 month old Great Dane that I bought a pinch collar to stop bad habits (nipping, jumping up). This worked great for about one week but now it is very difficult to give a 'motivational' correction.
Do you Make These Mistakes When Walking your Dog?
By: Lisa Nobles | 22/01/2008 | Pets
Learn a few tips for getting your dog to walk better. Stop being taken for a walk and start being the walker!
Boundary And Perimeter Training For A Wandering Collie
By: Adam Katz | 17/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam: Hello! I only bought your book a few days ago but have read it cover to cover and reread certain things all the time. (To read about the book she's talking about, please take a look at http://www.dogproblems.com/newvideos.
Are You An Animal Lover
By: John Savage | 28/08/2006 | Pets
Some people seem to run a zoo from their home, but other people have nothing to do with animals.
Teaching Your Dog To Walk On A Leash Properly
By: Lisa Nobles | 31/01/2008 | Pets
If you've ever been to the dog park and watched some owners walk their dogs, it's hard to determine who is walking who. To make your walk times enjoyable for both you, as the owner and your dog, proper leash walking is imperative. And now you don't have to just...
How Peanut became a "good dog"
By: Rachel Phillips | 29/04/2006 | Pets
Sit Stay Fetch Customer Review
I had a problem. An 8 year old son with a fatal attraction to an unruly 4 month old pup. Only two solutions came to mind. Break my sons heart, or train the dog. I voted for train the dog. Ha Ha. The laugh was on me. I started where I always start when I want to learn, I bought books, and lots of them. Before you waste one more dime on any dog training books or classes please read this article.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Funny(big) feet stuffed pigs
By: Tammara | 25-08-2008
I am looking for funny feet pigs... I own a bbq restaurant. I would like to get them personalized to sell to customers
My mom is leaving her lab mix for me to babysit ...
By: sandy | 25-08-2008
My mom is leaving her lab mix for me to babysit for 3 weeks and our cell phones will not reach. I'm looking for a dog toy or several toys he can play with during her absense that has her voice. He has seperation anxiety and has to hear her voice. Her last trip he went 3 days w/o pooping and only constant chewing of rawhide bones and no water until I called her and put her on speaker on my cell phone. I am DESPERATE for some kind of toys she can leave messages on for him that when he picks it up he will "hear momma" HELP ME :O)
Childrens vitamins, safe for nursing dogs?
By: Margaret Cummings | 25-08-2008
Is it safe to give my nursing Jack Russel Terrier 1/2 of a childrens chewable vitamin a day to supplement her diet and help her cope with the stress of 5 puppies?
Harness
By: syreta | 25-08-2008
I have two Yorkies. Can anyone suggest a good source for a harness for them. I currently have Puppia harnesses but their hair mats under their chest so I am searching for a harness that doesn't have as much coverage.
Fine haired dog
By: dmkusy | 25-08-2008
I have a 14 month old small sheepdog (we think he may be a Polish Lowland). He has long fine hair that matts daily. What products are available to help noth dematting and preventing matts. Also. is it OK to cutthe hair away from his eyes - I have heard that you should not do this with some dogs.
I would like to find a car seat for a large my ...
By: mattie | 25-08-2008
I would like to find a car seat for a large my rotti and caine corso, rotti weighing 69 lbs and caine corso at 43lbs
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Automotive Articles
Customized Chrome Rims: Facts of a Worth the Money Rim
By: David H. Urmann | 05/09/2008
There are factors to consider when purchasing chrome rims for customization enhancement. Although getting the popular brands and types can assure you the best quality, there are things you can do t maintain your chrome rims.
When purchasing chrome rims for customization enhancement, the lug pattern of an automobile, width and...
The Honda Civic
By: Brenda Williams | 05/09/2008
The Honda Civic has been one of the more popular models from Honda over the past couple of decades, so much that you still see the original version on the roadway. Because some of the original models of the Honda Civic are still being driven today it is a testament...
Water4Gas - The New Way to Travel
By: Ynavica William | 05/09/2008
What is Water4gas? There has been a lot of interpretation on it and some has taken to believe it or reject it as a scam that is designed to take advantage on those unhappy with the hike in fuel price. The question now is, is it really something that will...
LED Car Tail Lights - Why Are They So Popular?
By: Matthew A. Barr | 04/09/2008
We live in highly industrialized world today. Our cities, and even the towns, are equipped with too much lighting system that you sometimes wonder where those lights came from. Well, most of the lights you see (especially the ones at night) come from your vehicles. Because automobiles are a common...
Working With Blown Automotive Fuses
By: Jayesh Bagde | 04/09/2008
Repairing blown automotive fuses requires substantial knowledge about its placement and how it works.
Automobile fuses come in a type of glass formation. It is cylindrical in shape while the ends are stainless steel and made of glass at the center. Others are made of plastic. It also has links acting...
Things to Know When Buying From an Auto Outlet
By: Jayesh Bagde | 04/09/2008
Auto outlets can help narrow down your options when it comes to the car you need.
An auto outlet is an establishment that sells old and new cars. Some even offer automotive services and car accessories. Choosing the best auto outlet can allow you to acquire the most suitable car for...
Car Kits: Choosing the Right One
By: Jayesh Bagde | 04/09/2008
Car kits come in different varieties. Choosing the car kits with the devices most useful for your needs requires careful research.
Most Car Kits have hands-free mobile phones with voice activated speaker phones, Bluetooth/earphones and cradles/holders, along with mounts and other body kits. Here are some of the most popular car...
Best Radar Detectors
By: Al Turnet | 04/09/2008
Are you looking for a radar detector and don't want to get ripped off? I've compiled a list of what I consider to be the best radar detectors for each price point.
If you're looking to spend just a little, you should check out one of the radar detectors that are...
More from Adam Katz
When Is Dog Reliable Off Leash
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam: My name is Diane and I have a German Shepherd named Ajax. I have watched your video over and over again on having your dog come every time you call him. I have done all you have said (believe me, I'm a fan of yours now).
What Dog Breed I Recommend To My Friends
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
To recommend a good dog breed to someone, you need to know two things: 1. You must have an in-depth and personal experience with many different breeds. And more specifically, you must have multiple experiences with each breed.
What You Need To Know When Picking A Puppy
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
This was a last minute e-mail I sent to a friend in California, who contacted me only a few hours befote she was leaving to pick a puppy from a breeder she's been researching.
Should There Be A Primary Dog Trainer In Your Household
By: Adam Katz | 22/07/2006 | Automotive
Hi, My name is Greg Williams and I just received your book and videos yesterday. I've read almost all of the book and watched all the videos. [To read about the book and videos that he's referring to, please take a look at http://www.dogproblems.
Dog Barks Continuously While Owners Eat
By: Adam Katz | 20/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Mr. Katz, I have a two year-old female Boxer named Amber and a six year-old female St. Bernard named Crystal. My question is regarding the Boxer, Amber.
Training Around Distractions
By: Adam Katz | 20/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam: I have eventually received your book and cassettes. The post office apologized for the delay caused by a petrol shortage over here. Your book was worth waiting for and I hope to action some of your advice.
German Shepherd Whines When Left In Kennel
By: Adam Katz | 19/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Mr. Katz: I have a 6 month old German Shepherd named Thor. Having read your book, I applied your techniques to him and he responded very quickly, to my surprise! He is quite good at a sit-stay and down-stay now, which is very, very useful.
How To Let Your Dog Enjoy Family Time
By: Adam Katz | 19/07/2006 | Automotive
Dear Adam, I adopted a 1 year-old female dog about a year ago. I have 2 cats who grew up with dogs and like dogs.
Automotive 
