Given her background on cars as an auto insurance director, Lauren Woods finds the world of cars to be constantly changing.
A General Motors Corp. executive intimated to a federal judge Tuesday that vehicle carbon emission reductions ordered by California and ten other states would require the average fuel economy standards for cars and the lightest category of trucks of 43.7 miles per gallon.
"The standards we've had to make changes to in the past are incremental," said Alan Weverstad, executive director of GM's environment and energy unit. Lowering carbon emissions as much as the states want will involve "fuel economy requirements that are just unbelievably extreme," he said.
The testimony of the auto executive came as a federal trial got under way in which auto manufacturers are exerting efforts block some states from adopting new standards aimed at decreasing emissions of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide that is intimately linked to climate change.
The automakers dispute that decreasing carbon would require enhancement of fuel economy because carbon emissions are proportional to the amount of gasoline burned. Automakers added that fuel economy is solely under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Department of Transportation. This is mandated by the 1975 federal law.
The states, on the other hand, argue that they can regulate carbon emissions as a tailpipe pollutant under another federal law called the Clean Air Act. The Vermont case is, by far, the first in a series expected to be heard nationwide as the auto industry tries to reduce carbon limits. The case is also the first since the Supreme Court ruled that carbon emissions can be regulated under the Clean Air Act. The said jurisprudence was promulgated last week.
Only the Vermont rules are put at issue in the case before U.S. District Judge William Sessions III. But Charles Territo, a spokesman for the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, said that whatever its outcome, the case is seen as a bellwether for others around the country.
Weverstad said that under questioning, GM had conducted an engineering study called a "maximum technology scenario," in which it hypothetically said that 89 percent of the cars that it would be selling in the coming nine years and 81 percent of the trucks would be transformed to gas-electric hybrids. However, even with such an approach, the automaker still could not meet the new carbon standards. As a foreseen aftermath, it would be wasting $25 billion or more on the effort.
Matthew Pawa, a lawyer for the environmental groups, sought through questioning to point out that the industry predicted technological and economic calamity when the Clean Air Act was passed in 1970, when the law requiring fuel economy standards passed five years later and when other regulations were taking effect. The matter is not as easy as enhancing BBK cold air intake.
"This is the same old saw of pessimism that we've heard from the auto industry time and again," said Christopher Kilian, the director of the Conservation Law Foundation's Vermont office.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A




Aggressive Cost Cuts Help Toyota to Profit - Dai-ichi Securities
By: Patrick Ferguson | 15/11/2009Dai-ichi Securities: - Japanese car giants finally see profit after intensive cuts backs and cost cutting schemes.
Carreg.co.uk are looking to but personalised number plates too
By: DALPR | 15/11/2009Carreg.co.uk are looking to purchase rare and cherished number plates
The Death of the SUV
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009A few years ago, I purchased a sport utility vehicle. I wanted something that was going to elevate me off the ground. Besides this, I thought that the commercials were really catchy. I pictured myself driving over rugged terrain and along sandy beaches, spraying out a neat sheat of surf...
Driver Jean Behra
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009Victory in motor sports is dependent on three factors: the skill and daring of the driver, the endurance of the vehicle and the patronage of Lady Luck. All three must work together to bring the driver from starter to champion finish. While any one factor may overwork to compensate for...
Race Car Driver Alberto Ascari
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009Alberto Ascari was literally born into the Grand Prix. He entered this world on July 13, 1918 in Milan, Italy. His father was Antonio Ascari, the Italian racing star of the Grand Prix during the 1920's. Antonio also owned a Fiat dealership in Milan. As a child Alberto met the...
Eugenio Castellotti - Italian Ace
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009Unlike many racecar drivers, Eugenio Castellotti was a member of a wealthy family. He was born on October 10, 1930 in Lodi, Italy. Although he was able to buy a Ferrari when he was just twenty, he didn't begin his racing career until two years later. Eugenio was a socialite...
Get the Most Stylish Tourmaster Jett 2 Jacket Silver
By: Jeammy Pickle | 15/11/2009Tourmaster Jett 2 Jacket: Drive in the Rain Apparel Rain washes away pain. Rain symbolizes the close of drought. Rain intends cleansing. Adults, similar children, passion to walk in the rain, to dance in the rain, and even drive motorcycles in the rain. Professional and amateur motorcyclists yearn for rain during...
Classic Cars and the Pleasure of Owning One
By: Norma Holt | 14/11/2009Until I started writing about them it was a subject that had never really crossed my mind. But what a wealth of pleasure they bring to those who are lucky enough to own and drive a classic car. They may be seen in rallies driving up the highway of any...
Audi Changes Diesel Perception
By: Lauren Woods | 25/07/2007 | AutomotiveAudi’s success at the 24 Hours of Le Mans with its diesel powered racecar is changing the way people view diesel engines. New generation of diesel powerplants are much cleaner and less noisy than its predecessors as exhibited by Audi’s R10.
Ferrari Ready to Do Battle
By: Lauren Woods | 21/07/2007 | AutomotiveFerrari is prepared going into the European Grand Prix this weekend. Raikkonen is looking for a hat trick while Massa is looking for a good qualifying session.
Schumacher Confident of Toyota’s Resurgence
By: Lauren Woods | 17/07/2007 | AutomotiveRalf Schumacher is confident of his team’s resurgence after their performance at the past two races. Toyota is currently sixth and is looking to overtake third place BMW Sauber before the end of the season.
Peugeot Introduces Its First Suv
By: Lauren Woods | 14/07/2007 | AutomotiveFrench carmaker Peugeot introduced its first SUV in the form of the Peugeot 4007. The 4007 is the result between the collaboration between Peugeot and Mitsubishi.
Subaru Updates Outback Wagon
By: Lauren Woods | 12/07/2007 | AutomotiveThe Subaru Outback was redesigned by the Japanese automaker for the 2008 model year. It was refined in terms of exterior and interiors styling.
Volkswagen Fahrenheit Gli Coming in 2008
By: Lauren Woods | 11/07/2007 | AutomotiveVolkswagen will introduce a new Fahrenheit for the 2008 model year. The Fahrenheit is aimed to attract performance enthusiasts.
Saturn Vue Receives Praise
By: Lauren Woods | 07/07/2007 | AutomotiveThe redesigned Saturn Vue is one of the newest additions to the brand’s lineup. The crossover SUV has been praised both in magazines and online.
General Motors Expects Film to Boost Sale
By: Lauren Woods | 04/07/2007 | AutomotiveDue to the appearance of four General Motors vehicles on a film the automaker is hoping that this will result to increased sales. The Chevy Camaro, Pontiac Solstice, GMC Topkick and Hummer H2 are featured on the film Transformers.