Eighty percent of car buyers are using the Internet to research cars and used car prices. For vehicle research, the Internet's great! For vehicle prices, the Internet sucks! It sucks because the prices do not reflect reality for the buyer or the seller. Web sites that place values on vehicles have created more confusion than ever.
"My car's worth $25,800." "I looked up used car prices on the web and my vehicle's worth twenty grand." I hear quotes like these everyday. I wish, for the customer's sake, that the values are real. By "real" I mean a viable number according to market value.
As hard as it is to accept, even for me as a dealer, what we think a car is worth, and what it's actually worth according to "market value" is often drastically different.
To find a vehicle's value the context must first be discussed. What's context?
Context includes, but is not limited to:
1) Vehicle condition: mileage, maintenance, 1-owner...etc
2) Desirability: new model, special editions, just plain cool...
3) Seasonality: plow trucks, convertibles, 4-wheel drive...etc
4) The Economy: factory incentives, gas prices, hybrids, SUVs
5) Location: Beverly Hills versus the Bronx
Now, each of the above context variables could easily have several sub categories. For example...
Vehicle condition is extremely relative. One person may think there vehicle is perfect, someone else states it needs $1000 worth of work.
Desirability is also relative. A bunch of very cool bells and whistles may not add any value, or it may add $1000's.
Seasonality is relative. A convertible in the summer has more value than one during a Chicago winter. A plow truck in June will have significantly less value than in November in the northeast.
Economic recessions, exorbitant gas prices, combined with manufacturer incentives can shift new and used car prices all over the map.
Location has a major effect on used car prices. A convertible in California is worth more than one located in Canada.
To summarize, context funnels down to market value. Web sites such as Edmunds, NADA, and Kelley have drastically missed this mark, creating a host misinformation. To be fair, these are great research sites, but they can not be the final say on price.
Stating that a vehicle is worth a certain amount of money based on a web site's data does not take the above factors into account. It's a value based on misinformation.
These web sites have created an aura of trust when in actuality, the values are mythical. The market is the real indicator of vehicle worth-for better or worse.
What should one do? Buyers and sellers would be wise to follow the market. Check out autotrader.com, cars.com, and/or *ebaymotors.com and watch what vehicles are being advertised and sold for. While these sites are not the final word either, they're much more accurate than web sites leaning heavily on opinion and averages.
Note: eBay used car pricing is generally wholesale. In other words, it would not be accurate to compare a wholesale-priced eBay car (which may need a significant amount of reconditioning) to a retail-priced vehicle in showroom and/or perfect working condition.
In the end, and this come straight from industry expert, Barry Roth, "Take the highest price and the lowest price you find on the Internet and throw them out. The remaining numbers in the middle is where one should wade. But don't forget value. Price is one thing-value is the real key to a great car"
For more on used car values visit www.medwayimports.com/
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
- Cars for Sale – Buy New & Used Cars – Repossessed Cars on Sale
- Finding Cheap Used Cars at Affordable Prices
- Cars - Used Cars - Best Deals On Repossessed Used Cars
- Cheap Used Cars at Wholesale Prices
- Why You Should Use A Quality Car Cover To Protect Your Car From Damage
- How to Buy a Used Car Using an Auto Broker
- Can you Afford a Car - With Car Loans Being So Affordable, you Bet you Can!
- What is the Use of Old Cars?




The Death of the SUV
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009A few years ago, I purchased a sport utility vehicle. I wanted something that was going to elevate me off the ground. Besides this, I thought that the commercials were really catchy. I pictured myself driving over rugged terrain and along sandy beaches, spraying out a neat sheat of surf...
Driver Jean Behra
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009Victory in motor sports is dependent on three factors: the skill and daring of the driver, the endurance of the vehicle and the patronage of Lady Luck. All three must work together to bring the driver from starter to champion finish. While any one factor may overwork to compensate for...
Race Car Driver Alberto Ascari
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009Alberto Ascari was literally born into the Grand Prix. He entered this world on July 13, 1918 in Milan, Italy. His father was Antonio Ascari, the Italian racing star of the Grand Prix during the 1920's. Antonio also owned a Fiat dealership in Milan. As a child Alberto met the...
Eugenio Castellotti - Italian Ace
By: Brenda Williams | 15/11/2009Unlike many racecar drivers, Eugenio Castellotti was a member of a wealthy family. He was born on October 10, 1930 in Lodi, Italy. Although he was able to buy a Ferrari when he was just twenty, he didn't begin his racing career until two years later. Eugenio was a socialite...
Get the Most Stylish Tourmaster Jett 2 Jacket Silver
By: Jeammy Pickle | 15/11/2009Tourmaster Jett 2 Jacket: Drive in the Rain Apparel Rain washes away pain. Rain symbolizes the close of drought. Rain intends cleansing. Adults, similar children, passion to walk in the rain, to dance in the rain, and even drive motorcycles in the rain. Professional and amateur motorcyclists yearn for rain during...
Classic Cars and the Pleasure of Owning One
By: Norma Holt | 14/11/2009Until I started writing about them it was a subject that had never really crossed my mind. But what a wealth of pleasure they bring to those who are lucky enough to own and drive a classic car. They may be seen in rallies driving up the highway of any...
Chrysler automotive parts and services
By: chryslerparts4sale | 14/11/2009Welcome to the chryslerparts4sale one stop shop. Here you can buy with confidence from us, knowing you have the most excellent quality Chrysler parts with the best warranty protection at wholesale discount prices!
History of police vehicles
By: caryfank | 14/11/2009Police vehicles are provided to the police persons for many uses. Police vehicles are very important for then so that they can complete there duties and reach to the desired location in time.
Car Maintenance: Will it Really Help Gas Mileage?
By: Theodore Olson | 07/08/2008 | CarsAs gas prices continue to rise, the auto industry is touting the benefits of car maintenance. While maintaining one’s car is indeed important, does it really save gas?
Auto Repair Estimates And Car Repair Prices - The Real Information To Avoid Car Repair Scams
By: Theodore Olson | 13/06/2007 | AutomotiveWorrying whether or not you were overcharged for your car repair is an awful feeling. There's tons of advice on how to avoid getting ripped-off, but few discuss the actual car repair prices. We really need to look at the charges on a car repair estimate or auto repair invoice...
Nada Used Car Prices, Edmunds Used Car Prices, And Kelly Blue Book Used Car Prices - Whose Prices Are Right?
By: Theodore Olson | 13/06/2007 | AutomotiveThe Internet has been touted as the greatest resource for the used car buyer. Prospective buyers can find trade-in, private party, and retail values in a heartbeat. The question to consider, however, is what Internet source is right? The three major sites: NADA, Edmunds, and Kelly Blue Book are clamoring...
Ask A Mechanic: Wading Through The Mess Of Car Repair Prices And Auto Repair Estimates
By: Theodore Olson | 22/04/2007 | AutomotiveIf you were handed an estimate to replace a water pump on your car, would you know if the price was fair? Could you trust the price? How about for a tie rod end, mass air flow sensor, or an evaporative emissions sensor? Most of us don't know what these...
Used Car Pricing: The Insanity Of Used Car Prices!
By: Theodore Olson | 20/01/2007 | AutomotiveUsed car prices are elusive, despite numerous attempts to harness them. We've all heard of Retail, Private Party and Trade-in values. But do these "help" in determining a vehicle's real value? When we turn to the web for prices, it gets even more elusive. One web site places a retail...
Used Car Prices: Myths And Facts About Web-Based Used Car Values
By: Theodore Olson | 09/01/2007 | AutomotiveEighty percent of car buyers are using the Internet to research cars and used car prices. For vehicle research, the Internet's great! For vehicle prices, the Internet sucks! It sucks because the prices do not reflect reality for the buyer or the seller. Web sites that place values on vehicles...
Car Repair Prices: There Are No Honest Mechanics!
By: Theodore Olson | 09/11/2006 | AutomotiveI enjoy reading the tips and suggestions on finding an honest or good mechanic. These can be found on various government and consumer websites, and in a variety of auto repair articles.