Film Adaptations Of Books - Do They Work?
The books versus films controversy has been around for a long time. Some wish to discuss the relative merits of each as mediums in their own right and make claims and allegations about which form of story-telling is superior. The other side of the debate looks at the difference between a book and a film-adaptation of that book. Here I'd like to discuss a little about the latter idea and its relevance in contemporary cinema.
Although books have been adapted to film numerous times over the years it is now happening more often than ever. This is largely due to the possibilities that computer animation has allowed for and perhaps this, in itself, is something worthy of note in the discussion. Were it not for the possibility to turn a novel into a computer-generated blockbuster would we still be seeing so many book to film adaptations? It seems unlikely given how heavily these adaptations tend to feature special effects created through computers.
However, this in itself does not give us good cause to see film adaptations of books as something bad. So, what else is it that critics of these adaptations see as problematic? The answer is fairly simple: changes to the original story.
Books can take us many hours to read, but the film version of a book can only last two or three hours at the most. It is therefore inevitable that parts of a book are cut out of the story in order produce a film. Take The Lord of the Rings for example. The film version entirely removes the character of Tom Bombadil and the story that goes with it.
Critics see this as tarnishing the original story. Of particular relevance is the experience of those who see the film but who have never read the book - are they missing out, in some important sense, on the story of the original work and are they being misinformed?
The debate has now received further complication as graphic novels are being used more and more frequently as the basis for films. 300, The Spirit, and the new film The Watchmen are all adaptations of graphic novels. However, do these adaptations differ from those of standard novels?
All these questions are worth considering more closely before judgements are passed. There is certainly a degree to which these adaptations are successful, but they may also be damaging to literature. These issues will be examined further in future articles, but for now give the debate some serious thought, you may find that you surprise yourself with your conclusions.
(ArticlesBase SC #785799)
Article Tags:
books
,Book Reviews
,cheap textbooks
,book price comparison
,online book search engine
,gauchotexts
How to protect a book with plastic foil
How to protect a book with plastic foil / Wie man ein Buch mit Plastikfolie einbindet This video shows you how to very quickly bind a book using a protective plastic foil/film. All credits go to my mother ;-) She can bind 3 books in 5 minutes or so using this method. For this presentation she does it very slowly. In my opinion the "conventional methods" are far too complicated and difficult and only drive you to madness, so I uploaded this Video. I will not answer any questions about the proces (02:21)
How to Roll a Cigar in the Book Bunching Technique
Learn all about the Book Bunching technique of cigar rolling as filmed at the La Aurora factory in the Dominican Republic. (01:09)
Weekend Extra: Cheap Filmmaking
Do you love Indy Mogul, but lack the equipment to actually make your own movies? Well, lack no more! Alan K. will help you jump start your Hollywood career for under $250. That's less than the price of books for one semester at film school. (02:12)
Backyard FX 27: Ninja Swords and Flying Ninja Star
If you could ask a ninja one thing, what would it be? Well, if you asked about swords and ninja stars, then Ninja Erik Beck has your answers. If you asked about the thousands of years of dynamic history within the ninja legend, then go read a book yo (05:35)
How to Play Quidditch
In this watchmojo video learn everything you need to know about the most popular sport in the wizarding world: Quidditch. (02:55)
The old saying goes “don’t judge a book by its cover”. Whilst this has come to mean a lot more in today’s society metaphorically than literally, we still use the statement in reference to books too. Many people swear by this adage, but obviously not everyone - why else would book covers be so important in garnering public attention?
The Majority of Us Will Buy at Least a Few Books in our Lifetime, and a Great Many of Us Will Accumulate Something of our Own Personal Library. However, Why is it That We Like to Buy Books When We Can Often Just as Easily Borrow Them From a Library?
I have been in a position to take Sherry's advice and also put it to use in to my daily eating routine and discovered that all the digestive as well as stomach troubles had been soon starting to subside.
Abu Lahab said unto the Prophet Muhammad: ‘May you perish, is this why you have summoned all of us here?’ Then, the Prophet threatened him with the chastisement in the Hereafter. However, he said, ‘If what my brother’s son says is true, then I shall ransom myself from it with my wealth and sons!’
Has anybody qualified for Kaplan or Princeton Review? I'm thinking about teaching a class or two--I took a Princeton Review class for the GMAT and it really helped. Is this a well brought-up job? What are the upsides/downsides? I am a Master Teacher for the San Jose Kaplan center, and it is a fabulous job. Aside from all..
GH fan spoilers read and review? Jax restrains Michael after he comes perilously close to harming Carly. Carly is forced to agree with Jax's assertion just about Michael's living arrangements. A shaken Michael apologizes to Morgan for his behavior before sneaking out. Jason warns Jax that Michael is not safe living next to Sonny on Monday, June 22. Morgan gets..
Favorite Music Review? What/Who is your favorite music review? Where do you find artists/CD reviews that you trust? Any websites, blogs, magazines and papers are appreciated. Please let me know about the genre of music your treatise is about. If its rock (any kind) thats perfect, and do not forget a link! Thanks a great deal! ..
Being able to write for magazines or newspapers or any other well read document is a skill. Being able to write almost everyone learns throughout their life but being a writer as such is a different task altogether. When you write for print media, whether it be online media, a newspaper or a magazine you need to ensure that whatever it is you are offering is quality stuff.
This is a review for the dark fantasy book Trials of the Bloodstone
Gone Away is building momentum, was recently picked up by a major publisher and was accepted in several school libraries. I believe it will become the next time-tested classic fantasy tale, universally adored and mentioned in the same breath as The Wizard of Oz, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and The Lord of The Rings.
When reading a book we often form our own ideas about what is said in the text. In fact, we constantly, and always, form our own ideas about what is said. However, sometimes the ideas which we form are expected on the author’s part and sometimes they are not. This is where the debate over authorial intention begins.
Most of Us Enjoy Reading a Range of Literature. a Little Variety Helps to Keep Things More Interesting so We Often Mix our Reading Between Fiction, Fact, and Poetry. However, One Thing We Don’t Often Give Much Time For, Perhaps Even Less Than Poetry, is Plays.
The Majority of Us Will Buy at Least a Few Books in our Lifetime, and a Great Many of Us Will Accumulate Something of our Own Personal Library. However, Why is it That We Like to Buy Books When We Can Often Just as Easily Borrow Them From a Library?
Since the World Turned Digital Many Things Have Changed. Music Went From Being Stored on Records to Cd, Film From Vhs to Dvd, and Now Television Has Gone From Analogue to Digital Signal. Books, Too, are Beginning to Succumb to the Effects of Technological Progress, not Least in the Form of Kindle and Its Ilk – Portable Digital Book Devices Which Store Downloaded Books Inside Them.
Books have been translated for hundreds of years now, but in today’s global market translation is becoming ever more common. Whilst at one time it was chiefly works of religious significance which saw widespread translation, today it is common for any book which is expected to reach fairly high sales to be translated into other languages.
Books vary in length tremendously. A novel can be anything from a couple of hundred pages to many thousands, or even longer if the author so desired. Smaller works are sometimes referred to as novellas, and the smallest of all are called short stories. The distinction between these smaller types of book and those which are longer is a strange thing but has some uses including helping to categorise texts so that people can more easily find something which they wish to read.
The old saying goes “don’t judge a book by its cover”. Whilst this has come to mean a lot more in today’s society metaphorically than literally, we still use the statement in reference to books too. Many people swear by this adage, but obviously not everyone - why else would book covers be so important in garnering public attention?
Although now seen primarily as a philosopher, Nietzsche was also a man of extraordinary literary ability and passion for creativity and the arts. Not so long ago he wasnt even accepted by philosophy on the whole as a philosopher at all, but in the last two or three decades this has slowly changed and today Nietzsche is one of Europes most famous philosophers
1