Odd Approach to Performance Appraisals

| Posted: 20-09-2007 | Comments: 0 | Views: 7 | Rating: (51)

(?)

An article entitled "Big-Picture Performance Appraisal" by Paul Falcone was published in the August edition of HR Magazine.

Mr. Falcone is apparently a best-selling author and I guess he's well respected in the human resource field...

...but, I was taken aback by what he was proposing in this article about how to look at deciding on an individual's overall rating. He suggests that you go back to the old-school bell-curve concept.

He argues that each unit in the business should first rate itself on a 1 to 5 scale, with a 1 representing significantly under performing, a 3 performing at a 100% level, and a 5 representing significantly over performing. Let's say a given unit like sales rates its overall performance a 4.2, Falcone says that the overall average total score of all employees in the unit should also equal 4.2. That means if you rate some people over 4.2, you need to make sure others are rated below that number.

I guess the logic is that these two numbers only make sense if they are equal. This is bass ackwards to me--you're supposed to get overall performance from the bottom up not from the top down when it comes to rating an individual. In my mind, this doesn't reflect the actual performance of the individual.

If an individual's overall score is artificially restricted to their business unit's overall score, how is this fair to the individual? More importantly, how can management look at people in the same position across the company and do an accurate comparative analysis?

Another strange point in this article is that Falcone suggests every business unit and everyone should be striving to be rated a 5 overall! If a 3 is considered a 100% performance level, it would seem to me that most people would be striving to be that "A" employee or "A" business unit. Sure, it is possible that some employees sometimes perform above expectations, but rarely should the performance standards be set so that the employee consistently exceeds expectations for all performance measures.

If employees are rated 4's and 5's then they are not being challenged enough. I coach my clients to set the performance standards for each performance measure in a way that asks the employee to stretch even to be rated a 3. If an employee is consistently rated 4's and 5's, how to they get challenged to get to their next level?

Falcone also fixates on the overall score as the number to focus on when filling out the appraisal. Here's another area where I disagree with his thinking. Best practices says you look at each performance measure on its own and score it based on the performance standards for that measure.

At the end of the process an overall score is calculated using the weighted scores of each measure. I suggest you take that one step further...

...instead of showing the overall number on the 1 to 5 scale, you convert it to a %. Why do this?

Well, it's natural for everyone to want to be rated a 5 instead of a 3 since a 3 is half-way down the scale giving it a connotation of an "average" rating when in fact a 3 represents a 100%, or "A", performer .

By setting the right performance measures for each position and for each employee and rating them on these measures, you will be aligning your human capital to maximize your organization's performance. Don't back in to numbers set at the top. That's the only way you are really going to know how your employees are performing so you can use those results for organizational development, succession planning, and other human-capital related actions.

Rate this Article:

Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).

Article Tags: Performance Appraisal, Employee Appraisal, Employee Review, 9-box Graph, Employee Peformance, Human Capital Metrics

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/business-articles/odd-approach-to-performance-appraisals-217391.html

Print article

Send to friend

Publish this Article

Author feedback

About the Author:

Mike is an internationally recognized expert at helping employers meet their business objectives by teaching them how to get the right people into the right seat on their bus. Most employers face continuing challenges in hiring, developing and retaining their best employees. Mike guides his clients through this maze. To experience how this is done, sign up for a free job analysis survey for one of your open positions at www.eSessments.com.

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Add new Comment

Assessment & Development Centers in Employee Selection & Development
By: Graham Tyler | 18/10/2007 | Non-Fiction

15 Performance Management Practices That Encourage Positive Performance
By: Barbara Brown, PhD | 16/09/2008 | Management

Basics of Conducting Performance Reviews
By: David Waters | 02/10/2007 | Human Resources

Purpose of Performance Appraisal-how and Why it is an Important and Effective for Any Orgaization
By: Arshia Imran | 18/09/2008 | Management

What Makes a Good Performance Appraisal?
By: Robin Chandler | 12/12/2005 | Business
Business Articles, learn about busines - An organization created with the objective of making a profit from the sale of goods or services.

Testing the effectiveness of Performance Appraisals
By: Verena Veneeva | 10/07/2006 | Human Resources

Performance Evaluation Made Simple
By: Wally Bock | 02/11/2006 | Affiliate Programs
Affiliate related Articles, Affiliate programs allow Web sites who provide links to your site to receive payments or reciprocal advertising in exchange for promoting your Web site.

Feedback - Your People Need It
By: Paul Phillips | 01/12/2007 | Management

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Q&A Powered by:

Latest Business Articles

A Review of the Zippi Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
Zippi is a California based business that began in 2006. The goal of Zippi is to reinvent the art of selling and buying used treasures. They are combining their own business process with cell phone technology and creating a lucrative business for any person wishing to take advantage of their...

A Review of the Zija International Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
There are many online income producing opportunities available. One of the simplest ways to make money on the internet is to sell someone else's products. There are two very common ways to do this. There are affiliate programs where you set up a website and install links to the product...

A Review of the ZibyCom Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
ZibyCom is an excellent solution to providing the education that people need to be successful in today's world of technology. You can even make money by being a distributor of this excellent solution and take advantage of the many tools available to you if you decide to start your...

A Review of the Zavita Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
Health products keep advancing with new discoveries and recipes. The world as we know it still holds many secrets that are being tapped and introduced as healthy alternatives for active lifestyles. Zavita, a home business opportunity, is one of the company's tapping the natural resources of our world. Zavita...

A Review of the Yves Rocher Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
Yves Rocher is a company which sells all natural, botanical beauty products, including lotions, shampoos, skin care items, and cosmetics. The company has markets throughout Europe and North America and serves over 90 countries. Yves Rocher is a known to be a reputable company, as they have been in business...

A Review of the YTB (Your Travel Business) Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
YTB (Your Travel Business) is a business that lets you know just that, it's a business that you will have to work and work hard. They are not afraid to let you know that. But they are also willing to teach you and be your mentor, to help you reach...

A Review of the Youngevity Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
As one generation comes of age, the one before it starts worrying about things like the ravages of age and issues concerning poor health! There are plenty of people who are concerned about their health as they get older, and this is definitely one field that many different entrepreneurs...

A Review of the Young Living Essential Oils Income Opportunity
By: Brian Garvin | 11/10/2008
Young Living Essential Oils is a company which produces, markets, and sells natural products that focus on beauty and well-being. The company is the largest of its kind when it comes to essential oils. Founded by Gary Young, the company offers an opportunity for individuals to become distributors. The company...

More from Michael Beek

The Real Cost of Hiring Average Performers
By: Michael Beek | 21/10/2007 | Business
Employers make it a point to profess that they hire only the 'best', but in reality, that doesn't happen. This article show you in black-and-white just why it's really important, even critical, that employers need to make 'hiring the best' more than lip service. You will see just how much in real dollars it costs you when you hire less than the best. The article not only points out the problem, but offers you a way to overcome it.

Four Steps That Brings your Company's Mission Statement to Life
By: Michael Beek | 11/09/2007 | Business
Most companies publish a mission statement to let the world know what they are striving for as a company. That's important, but, as important is what the company does to make sure all of their employees are focused on bring the mission statement to life. This article lays out a four-step program to help employers align their employees performance with the company's mission statement.

Article Categories

Article Marketing

Article Notepad

Stop Duplicate Content

Term Papers

Need Help?

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (0.36, 16)

Odd Approach to Performance Appraisals

Article Comments

Related Articles

Got a Question? Ask.

Latest Business Articles

More from Michael Beek

Need Help?

Site Links

Webmasters

Business Info

Sign up for our email newsletter