 |
Tired of Gandhi
Author: C. Read  | Posted: 09-04-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 11 | Rating: (50)  (?) 
In political theatre certain names are used to provide cachet, gravitas, or moral resolve. My favorites happen to be war – mongering, pro – capitalist, largely dead white European males. How banal. In the post – modern, populist, ‘I – feel – your – pain’ (please let me increase taxes and spend more because I love you) socialism, no name gets used and abused more than Gandhi. It is frankly annoying and tiring. Gandhi was anything but great.
Churchill called the careworn defender of Indian self – sufficiency a ‘half - naked fakir’. Harsh but not far off the mark. Gandhi’s recipe for India was one of immoderate nonsense. It took the Indians 50 years to cast off the shackles of Gandhian isolationism and communalism. Now India, in process of integrating itself into the global supply chain of extended trade, is finally lifting hundreds of millions out of poverty, and assuming a middle power (or larger) regional role.
No thanks to Gandhi.
I have two problems with the bald, femininely built prophet. First his message and set of policies were anti – capitalist; anti – modern; and anti – progressive. Second, the Gandhian ‘model’ repudiates reality and merges mysticism and emotionalism, into a replacement for reality and practicality. Churchill was not too far wrong is his assessment but having said that, it is obvious that India would have attained independence post – World War Two. In fact it was a precondition of Indian support against Hitlerism. In any event the costs to the British of their Indian colony had by the 1920’s, outstripped profits. It was the burden of empire and the real consquential costs of controlling India, that made Indian independence inevitable. The terms of economic and political trade had turned. Expenses, political opinion, and mundane reality made Indian independence inevitable – Gandhi or no Gandhi.
Gandhi’s importance rested upon his non – violent approach to political change and self – rule. He advocated the complete rejection of all things British and western, through pacifist, non – engagement means. Gandhi’s great fortune was that he did this in a British protectorate, not a Russian, Japanese, French, Italian or Japanese colony. He would have simply been shot.
So what of Gandhi’s great plan?
According to Gandhi’s 1909 book (and his subsequent 40 year career), ‘Hind Swaraj’, Indian self – rule would repudiate western civilization and embrace ‘the village.’ British imports – law, medicine, transport, education, capital, schools, hospitals, and police – would be substituted by Indian communalism. Gandhi wanted the complete physical, mental and moral emancipation of India, from all British artifacts, including technology, the media and even advanced agricultural production.
It was to say the least, a program of Medieval proportions.
Gandhi advocated village self – sufficiency. This of course ensures poverty. Gandhi, trained in England and South Africa as a lawyer, was totally ignorant about economics, and how and why civilizations develop. Gandhi’s Marxism was untainted by the concerns of modernity. In his mystical world – view Indians would use the hand – loom to spin their own textiles’; use human labor and sharp sticks to develop their fields for agricultural output; and live in simple communal organizations untouched by western methods and devilish ideas around modernity and wealth creation.
In this dream Islam became an ally. The millions of Hindu’s slaughtered by Muslims over 1000 years (100 million or more?), made no impact on the Indian prophet. Saint Gandhi was supposedly a moralist and Hindu reformer, dedicated to modesty, chastity, restraint and temperance. But in his zeal to oust the British, attain power, implement ‘Satyagraha’ (truth – force) and achieve primitive communism, the Muslims – historically the destroyers of Hindu civilization – were conscripted. A rather strange alliance to say the least.
Indeed emboldened by Gandhi, Muslims in the early 1920’s rioted, attacked Hindu and non – Muslim sites, and in good Islamic fashion murdered 10,000 – 20,000 innocents. A poignant question is why the British did not deal with Gandhi and his leadership cadre at that point and destroy Gandhi’s movement? Maybe Gandhi’s support was too deep, the message too resonant, or the consequences too grave. In any event it was a mistake not to shut down Gandhian Marxism in the early 1920’s.
Gandhi’s legacy was to constrain, if not cripple Indian development. His embrace of Islam and ignorance of its violent nature directly led to firstly Islamic demands (within his Indian congress movement) and then in 1947 – 48, to a bloody civil war upon independence, in which at least 2 million died. Islam proved itself no friend or follower of Gandhian pacifism. His disavowal of modernity led to Indian communalism and prideful, superstitions beliefs in an ‘Indian – way’. This retarded Indian political and economic development by two generations.
Gandhi was thus a myth, more than he was a man. His mystical utopianism was no more coherent or relevant than the tired Marxist dogma of Mao, Castro or Chavez. The myth of village communalism, a rejection of modernity and racist contempt for European methods, has only very recently been cast off. Indian independence was inevitable. Fifty years of destructive socialism was not. For that disaster Indians can thank their saintly prophet, Mr. Gandhi.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/business-articles/tired-of-gandhi-382043.html
About the Author:Where is Gandhi’s Marxism now in ndia? Only his embrace of Islam is only that is left of him.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
What is sexy swagger
By: shyone | 27-07-2008
what is sexy swagger
Adultery In Islam
By: Woman In Love With A Married Pakistani Man | 23-07-2008
I met a man several months ago. He is Pakistani and I am American. I came to find out today he was married the week before we met. He married via telephone to a woman in Pakistan via an arranged marriage. So in all aspects he has committed adultery. He has said he doesn't know or love this woman and has considered suicide to avoid a life of imprisonment. What options are there if he wants out? What could happen if his family were to find out? Do I need to be concerned for my safety?
Islam is a state of becoming NOT a state of being
By: Asaf Razaq | 20-07-2008
Islam is a state of becoming NOT a state of being
What does this saying mean: "Islam is a state of ...
By: Asaf Razaq | 20-07-2008
What does this saying mean: "Islam is a state of becoming NOT a state of being"
What to do Islamic funeral My Imam died in a car ...
By: kateesquilts | 19-07-2008
what to do Islamic funeral
My Imam died in a car accident on Friday....I am going to sit with his wife and I am a new convert...what do I do? Say? bring food?
In the 1970's and 1980's there was a Dr. King who ...
By: John G. Carswell | 18-07-2008
In the 1970's and 1980's there was a Dr. King who ran seminars on racism in America. What was his first name?
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Business Articles
Getting to Know More About Microsoft Business Software
By: Bei M. | 21/08/2008
There is no denying that currently, Microsoft Corporation is the world's biggest and most popular developer, designer, and maker of the most reliable computer programs and applications. Since its launch and the initial introduction of its first software, the company has never left the focus and minds of computer owners....
Develop a Better Business Model Faster by Analyzing Past Performance as Though These Were New Tests
By: Donald Mitchell | 21/08/2008
Past successes and failures show clues concerning opportunities and hurdles for creating superior business models. Learn from those experiences.
Secret Wholesale List Suppliers: Exposed!
By: Joaquin Reveron | 20/08/2008
You have a business. You need a wholesale list source to expand your product line and surely for possibilities of profiting more from the acquirement of wholesale products from such suppliers. Precisely, one of the easiest ways to get a source contact list of distributors and wholesalers is by hitting...
Wholesale Video Games: Extreme Infamous Tactics!
By: Joaquin Reveron | 20/08/2008
Let say that you have a successful wholesale video games accessory and your back up is your affiliated company that offers DVDs. Pay attention, this is one of the tools many of us on the top use to beat many competitors, make competitors paralyzed and not even make them think...
6 Reasons to Start a Drop Ship Baby Gift Ecommerce Business
By: Stuart Sherm | 20/08/2008
Starting any Ecommerce business is a daunting task, but here are some ideas where you can make money, have virtually no overhead and never leave your home. What you need is to join a great drop ship gift program.
Essentially you are aware that when you buy certain gifts online they...
Why Not to Start a Wholesale Video Games Business!
By: Joaquin Reveron | 20/08/2008
Many people tell you how lovely it is to start a home business, how magnificent it really of having more time with their family, kids, friends and plainly and enjoying what life has to offer with the extra time from a home office. It is true, it is fascinating,...
Do You Really Need a Job or Feel Maximum Incommodity?
By: Joaquin Reveron | 20/08/2008
Noting that many of our culture and society dislikes incommodity, incommodity according to most dictionaries is defined as inconvenient. Generally incommodity is logically and truly defined as something that causes that causes difficulty, trouble, or lack of ease. Society is indeed correct when it comes to its definition, however, you...
Top 10 List of Wholesale Business Tools For Success
By: Joaquin Reveron | 20/08/2008
What tools to succeed with an online business? Before you start with the list of wholesale business tools that you will need for starting your business online, know what kind of business you are getting into. Before thinking of the list of wholesale materials that you should get, one of...
|
|
Business 
