Open Biopsy Better for Diagnosing Mesothelioma Subtype

Posted: Nov 21, 2011 |

Open surgical biopsy – called thoracotomy – appears to be the best way to get an accurate diagnosis of mesothelioma subtype.

Mesothelioma is a fast-growing malignancy caused by asbestos exposure.  Epithelial mesothelioma is the most common subtype, followed by sarcomatoid and biphasic.  Determining which subtype a patient has is an important prognostic indicator and can help guide doctors in making treatment decisions. But mesothelioma itself is notoriously difficult to diagnose, and determining subtype can be equally tricky.

To help determine the most accurate diagnostic method, a group of Australian scientists evaluated the records of 83 patients who underwent a surgical procedure called extrapleural pneumonectomy (EPP) for mesothelioma between 1994 and 2009. A panel of pathologists reviewed the specimens collected during EPP and compared their subtypes with each patient's initial subtype diagnosis.

Prior to their surgeries, the patients had undergone different methods to try to determine which mesothelioma subtype they had:  81% of patients underwent thoracoscopy, a minimally invasive procedure that uses a special type of endoscope for visualization; 11% had biopsies done with the guidance of computed tomography (CT); 7% had the open thoracotomy procedure and 1% had another type of diagnostic procedure.

The researchers found that, overall, one in five patients were given an inaccurate diagnosis of their mesothelioma subtype.  Of the different methods used, biopsy by thoracotomy achieved accurate diagnoses in 83% of cases, compared with thoracoscopy (74%) and computed tomography-guided procedure (44%). 

The epithelial subtype was diagnosed correctly in 82% of cases, but the 19 patients with the biphasic type were only diagnosed correctly 26% of the time. There were no sarcomatoid subtypes found in the study.

Because it is an open procedure, thoracotomy makes it easier for surgeons to collect a larger sample of malignant mesothelioma cells for testing. However, because it involves a large incision into the chest, it also carries a greater risk of potential complications than other diagnostic methods.

Summarizing their findings in the latest issue of the Journal of Thoracic Oncology, the research team writes, "The determination of histological subtype from a diagnostic biopsy is difficult due to sampling error, but an adequate specimen obtained from surgical biopsy increases the accuracy of subtype classification compared with radiological-guided biopsies."

Questions and Answers

Ask
200 Characters left
Rate this Article
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 0 vote(s)
    Feedback
    Print
    Re-Publish
    Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/cancer-articles/open-biopsy-better-for-diagnosing-mesothelioma-subtype-5413795.html

    Article Tags:

    staging mesothelioma

    Mesothelioma stages are categorized in the medical community for evaluative benefit for the physician, the medical institution, participation in clinical trials, and advancements in mesothelioma treatment options. Staging systems are used to define mesothelioma stages; however, mesothelioma stages are far more descriptive for pleural mesothelioma than for peritoneal mesothelioma or pericardial mesothelioma.

    By: Lina Smithl Healthl Feb 12, 2009 lViews: 270

    Mesothelioma staging systems define mesothelioma stages; however, they are far more descriptive for pleural mesothelioma than for peritoneal mesothelioma. These systems have changed over time. Mesothelioma stages are important considerations in treatment and prognosis. By sectioning a progressive disease into stages, doctors can evaluate mesothelioma treatment options.

    By: Sarah Adamsl Health> Cancerl Feb 24, 2009

    Brighan staging system, on the other hand, determines whether the Mesothelioma can be surgically removed or not and whether the lymph nodes are affected or not. In stage I Mesothelioma, the lymph nodes are not yet affected and the patient can still recover through surgery.

    By: Smith & Chenl Health> Diseases and Conditionsl Aug 21, 2007 lViews: 434

    The staging process is very critical to determine the prognosis of mesothelioma. For a proper prognosis it is very important to have an early diagnosis as well as proper treatment. As mesothelioma is commonly diagnosed only at an advanced stage, the survival rate is quite less as in the Stage 4; the disease is spread to many parts of the body and has distant organ metastasis.

    By: Agatha Simonal Health> Cancerl Nov 18, 2011

    Mesothelioma is a rare and deadly disease that is the result of long periods of exposure to asbestos. The symptoms of mesothelioma cancer can take decades to be revealed, which is why LegalView.com provides a resource of information for victims with the cancer to better understand the different types and treatments available

    By: Alan Haburchakl Healthl Nov 18, 2007

    Malignant mesothelioma will be a cancer of organ linings. Two types of mesothelioma are peritoneal mesothelioma as well as pleural mesothelioma. Peritoneal mesothelioma affects the lining of the abdominal cavity as well as pleural mesothelioma affects the lining of the chest wall and lining of the lungs. Asbestos cancer mesothelioma

    By: mrazuanl Health> Cancerl Mar 17, 2011

    Cancer translational research brings together scientists' and clinicians' suggestions to develop solutions to biomedical complications. This kind of applied research strives to offer strategies to questions surrounding the etiology, pathology, diagnosis, prevention and treating cancer.

    By: Terry Dancerl Health> Cancerl May 30, 2012

    Orbs are actually a lumpectomy or quadrantectomy combined with rotating the breast tissue or mobilize the flap into the cavity of the surgery time fill is removed. It also includes the comparative change in shape and size is doing in relation to breast and moved if necessary, does not affect the conversion of the breast. The deferred plan the reconstruction is not part of endoplasmic techniques. Both procedures are performed by specific thoracic surgeons.

    By: Omer Faroohl Health> Cancerl May 28, 2012

    What every woman fears for is losing her self confidence , losing hope and losing her personality. The term "Breast Cancer" is a very negative word and that it creates negative vibrations in her heart. So, to make her comfortable with the basics of breast cancer and to make her means any woman understand that this type of cancer is the least dangerous than all cancers and that if it is detected early then you will fight with it successfully. Causes, Symptoms, treatment, discussed in detail.

    By: Medha Srikanthl Health> Cancerl May 27, 2012
    Myra Foreman

    Mesothelioma is a rare cancer that originates in the mesothelium. The mesothelium is the protective lining that covers the body's internal organs. Mesothelioma occurs when the mesothelium cells start to divide uncontrollably.

    By: Myra Foremanl Health> Cancerl May 27, 2012

    Chemotherapy is a treatment for killing cancerous cells which is given intravenous or extra-venous to the cancer patient. Even breast cancer patients have to go through the treatment. This treatment mainly focuses on the cancerous cells that are spread in the blood stream in the whole body . If any cancerous cells are there then they are killed by the chemotherapy medicine. The medicine is very costly and it has to be taken for one or two days continuously for every 21 days .

    By: Medha Srikanthl Health> Cancerl May 25, 2012

    Asbestos fibers are microscopic, though they are also quite durable. For this reason, asbestos was used in a number of different industrial compounds to enhance strength and resistance to temperature extremes- two properties at which the mineral is highly adept.

    By: Agatha Simonal Health> Cancerl Dec 11, 2011

    It has long been known that smoking is hazardous to one's health, causing a marked increase in instances of mesothelioma lung cancer among those who smoke regularly.

    By: Agatha Simonal Health> Cancerl Dec 11, 2011

    Exposure to asbestos particles is one of the principal causes of mesothelioma cancer, also known as asbestos cancer. As a naturally occurring mineral with useful commercial applications, asbestos is found in plumbing, insulation and other building materials and products.

    By: Agatha Simonal Health> Cancerl Dec 11, 2011

    There are several risk factors that increase the likelihood that a person will develop mesothelioma.

    By: Agatha Simonal Health> Cancerl Dec 11, 2011

    Mesothelioma Information – Basics Mesothelioma is a type of cancer that is usually caused by previous exposure to asbestos.

    By: Agatha Simonal Health> Cancerl Dec 11, 2011
    Author Box
    Articles Categories
    All Categories
    Quantcast