Do Modern Day Radar Detectors Really Work?

Posted: Jun 10, 2010 |Comments: 0 | Views: 179 |

The question we should ask ourselves is, does that warning from the Radar Detector prevent a driver from getting a speeding ticket, this remains to be seen. The problem isn't directly with the Radar Detector or how it works, but with the technology the law enforcement officers use to determine if a driver has committed a speeding violation.

The early versions of police radar guns used one of two radio bandwidths. There were the X and K bands. For the radar guns to be effective, they would have to transmit a constant signal in either the X or K bandwidth. Radar detectors had powerful antennas built into them which could receive a signal from an active police radar gun a long time before the car came into the range of the police officer. The X band could always be picked up from a distance, but the K band was much harder to detect. Only the best and most expensive Radar Detector units on the market could warn against K band police radar guns.

The whole point of Radar Detectors, is for someone speeding to receive an early warning before driving into an area where a police officer is operating a radar gun with the sole intention, of catching speeding drivers. This information is pointless unless the driver has plenty of time to slow his car down to the defined speed limit for that road. If the police officer is using a different radar technology than the radar detector located in the drivers car, there is no guarantee the driver will get the warning in time, if at all.


The Radar Guns used by police officers these days, use either a Ka bandwidth or a laser system, of which both of them allows police officers to use an "instant on" technique. This means a police officer can point and shoot at a speeding car and obtain an official speed reading within a matter of seconds. The current radar detectors sold on the market today can detect the presence of Ka band or laser police radar guns, but the driver doesn't usually receive the information quick enough to make any significant reductions in speed. This generally results in the driver getting an unwanted speeding ticket.

This doesn't mean to say that radar detectors are ultimately useless against modern "instant on" radar guns, But for example, if a motorway is busy and has a pack of speeding cars slowing down bacause of the traffic, police officers may target the first few cars. If the driver of the vehicle at the rear of the pack has a modern radar detector, he might just about have a few seconds warning to reduce his speed. Where a speeding driver is on a motorway that's not too busy which has a dedicated traffic police officer, the situation would be completely different, he may not get the warning from the radar detector quick enough to reduce his speed.

Radar Detector are not obsolete yet and are still being used, but how effective they are against modern day radar units is a different story. Some police departments still use the older X and K band radar units to catch speeding drivers, which ultimately means a good modern day radar detector could provide enough early warning to a speeding driver.

When dealing with modern Ka and laser "instant on" radar units, a speedy driver should seriously consider whether it's worth speeding and taking the risk of getting a speeding fine, it's better to save the speeding for track days, where you have an instructor who can ensure you drive fast, have fun but also stay safe.

Questions and Answers

Ask
200 Characters left
Rate this Article
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 0 vote(s)
    Feedback
    Print
    Re-Publish
    Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/cars-articles/do-modern-day-radar-detectors-really-work-2603269.html

    Article Tags:

    radar detector

    ,

    speed camera detector

    ,

    radar gun detector

    Graham Walker

    You will find speed cameras all over Scotland. They are not invincible. We win speed camera cases everyday. There is no easy formula to follow. Each case needs to be tackled head on and every angle checked. That is what we will do if you want us to deal with a speed camera case for you.

    By: Graham Walkerl Automotive> Carsl Feb 05, 2009 lViews: 1,012

    Are you shopping for speed camera detectors? Learn the fundamental differences between the different kinds that are available.

    By: Ben Buckleyl Automotive> Carsl Sep 18, 2010

    Are you shopping for speed camera detectors? Learn the fundamental differences between the different kinds that are available.

    By: Ben Buckleyl Automotive> Carsl Sep 18, 2010

    Speed Camera Detectors

    By: guccihandbagl Advertising> Prepressl Sep 29, 2009
    Radar Detectors

    For the very best in radar laser detectors, choose one that comes equipped with GPS. Though it won’t help you find your way to a restaurant or somewhere out of town, it will help you know when a speed trap is approaching while you’re out on any road; in town or away from home.

    By: Radar Detectorsl Automotivel Sep 23, 2009
    Radar Detectors

    he sound of the wind breaking as the car screams down the roadway and the feeling of going fast is what many drivers live for. However, those plans can be derailed if the car isn’t equipped with a top-of-the-line speed detector. Speed detectors, especially those that are GPS enabled, make for a better driving experience on the road.

    By: Radar Detectorsl Automotivel Sep 23, 2009

    Bentley has proven to be the extravagant vehicle for giving the classy touch. And these cars are used for family day out or for business purpose also, means multipurpose.

    By: kudoscarsl Automotive> Carsl May 31, 2012

    Many people in San Diego, California are very particular when it comes to their vehicles. They fuss about the way these look, what kind of model and type, or how fast these are.

    By: Rita McCalll Automotive> Carsl May 30, 2012

    Windshield wiper blades are essential parts of safety. They give the driver a clear and unobstructed view of the street especially during winter and rainy season. Whenever small droplets of water or snow get on accumulated on the windshield, the wiper blades wipe the windshield and keep it clean. Different kinds of windshield wipers are available in places like Riverside windshield replacement.

    By: Melisa Sosinskil Automotive> Carsl May 30, 2012

    Windshield wiper blades are very important since they ensure safety of the vehicle, the driver and the people inside the vehicle. They protect you from rid of snow, rain, dirt and dust from the windshield of your vehicle. They are made of flexible and thin rubber material. It is always essential to get the best type of wiper for your windshield from windshield repair Sacramento firms.

    By: Melisa Sosinskil Automotive> Carsl May 30, 2012
    Kyle Busch

    This article reviews the new (returning) Dodge Dart - An impressive joint American (Chrysler) and European (Fiat) effort that has resulted in a car that really hits the automotive bull's-eye.

    By: Kyle Buschl Automotive> Carsl May 28, 2012

    One way backlinks are links that point to your page with no returning link. These are the links you are going to need to rank high in the serps. Building oneway backlinks can be troublesome or it can be straightforward. The difference between difficult and very simple is whether or not you buy help or you attempt to create backlinks on your own.

    By: Trevor Vernonl Internet> Link Popularityl May 09, 2011

    Colon Cancer Introduction Colon cancer is one of the most common types of cancer, with more than 104 thousand new cases reported each year. Is a common type of malignancy (cancer) in which there is uncontrolled growth of cells that line the inside of the colon or rectum. It is also a disease that causes malignant (cancer) cells to form in the tissues of the colon.

    By: Trevor Vernonl Health> Cancerl May 04, 2011

    Cosmetic dentistry can be described as a specialised field of dentistry. It uses specialised dental procedures make you teeth look perfect, which generally also improves the overall appearance of someones face. Cosmetic dentistry is a common and very popular dental procedure nowadays which many people, young and old are deciding to do to improve their appearance.

    By: Trevor Vernonl Health> Dental Carel Apr 18, 2011

    What Exactly is Forex Trading - Forex Trading Explained I hear people talking about Forex Trading all the time, when online and surfing the web I see adverts, articles, banner and even receive spam emails related to Forex Trading. So what exactly is Forex Trading, what's it all about?

    By: Trevor Vernonl Finance> Currency Tradingl Apr 06, 2011

    As some point in your life, you will get into debt, that's a fact, and you will probably try to find a debt management solution to help get your finances under control. People get into debt for a number of reasons, generally because people live beyond their means. People resort to debt management because they are spending more money than they are earning.

    By: Trevor Vernonl Finance> Debt Consolidationl Apr 05, 2011

    Discuss this Article

    Author Box
    Articles Categories
    All Categories
    Quantcast