Coin Collection - Overgrading and Undergrading Coins

Posted: Jul 01, 2011 |

Overgrading:Prior to the advent of the independent grading services, unscrupulous or uneducated dealers made a nice living off new collectors by deliberately overgrading coins or not knowing how to grade themselves. Fortunately, grading services eliminate just about all of this problem by providing an independent grade that is recognized and accepted by virtually every dealer and collector in numismatics. If you don't personally know how to grade coins, don't buy coins that haven't yet been independently certified or graded.

Undergrading: We would all like to buy a coin for a fraction of its true value. But would you do it by deliberately knocking the grade of someone else's coin to undermine its value? A lot of people would, it seems, because this is a common practice in numismatics.  

Say you bought a coin for $500 in Extremely Fine condition. You've owned the coin for five years and you decide to sell it and use the money to buy other coins. The market value has gone up slightly since you purchased the coin, so you expect to get offers in the $475 to $525 range. A dealer looks at your coin, comments on what a lovely piece it is, and offers $250. "What?" you exclaim, "How can you offer $250 for an Extremely Fine coin worth more than $500?" The dealer replies calmly, "But your coin is only Very Fine. The catalog price is $200, so I'm being more than fair in offering you $50 over catalog." Welcome to the world of undergrading, which also happens when the buyer still doesn't know how to grade coins.  

The problem of undergrading is one of the best reasons we can think of to certify your valuable coins. After you've settled the grading question, you can argue over the price, which is a whole other issue.  

When is a profit too much? If a 5 percent markup is fair, what about 10 percent? Is a 25 percent markup unfair? Would a 100 percent profit be unconscionable? Should the profit margin be tied to the cost of a coin, or should it be related to the market price? These questions are ones every dealer struggles with as he attempts to strike a balance between fairness and profitability. We're firm believers that any profit earned in a fair and equitable manner is well-deserved, no matter how large or small. On the other hand, we consider any profit earned by deliberate manipulation of any part of a transaction to be unconscionable — again, no matter how large or small.  

Questions and Answers

Ask
200 Characters left
Rate this Article
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 0 vote(s)
    Feedback
    Print
    Re-Publish
    Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/collecting-articles/coin-collection-overgrading-and-undergrading-coins-4977063.html

    Article Tags:

    undergrading coins

    ,

    overgrading coin

    Are you contemplating about flying in an air craft and are worried about what the experience might be? The experience can be an enthralling one. You need not be apprehensive because the technology of air journeys has greatly been improved. These days there are a number of modes through which you can travel through air against the rule of the gravity.

    By: Christinel Hobbies> Collectingl May 25, 2012

    Australian high relief silver proof strikes are rapidly becoming a popular collecting genre.

    By: Perth Mintl Hobbies> Collectingl May 24, 2012
    Javed Khan

    An remote control helicopter can be used indoors or outdoors and is a great activity for the family to enjoy together. It can be used in your backyard, carried along for a picnic or at your local Remote Control Club

    By: Javed Khanl Hobbies> Collectingl May 24, 2012
    Javed Khan

    Anyone with a love of remote control apparatus combined with a love of flying can pick up an RC helicopter and enjoy it.

    By: Javed Khanl Hobbies> Collectingl May 24, 2012
    Javed Khan

    Flying an RC helicopter is a great hobby to indulge in. Not only is it a great outdoor activity to indulge in by yourself or with your child, it will also get you learning about aerodynamics. Gone are the days when this was only available to the select few. There is an remote control helicopter to fit almost every budget and need.

    By: Javed Khanl Hobbies> Collectingl May 24, 2012

    This is a hands-on tour, with none of that, "On your right, you'll see the historic Go menu" for you! I will show you around the most important elements of the Finder.

    By: woodwindl Computers> Operating Systemsl May 09, 2012

    If you're upgrading from an older Mac running Mac OS X to your new iMac, I have great news for you: Apple includes the Migration Assistant utility application that can help you copy (whoops, I mean, migrate) all sorts of data from your old Mac to your new machine. The list of stuff that gets copied over includes

    By: woodwindl Computers> Softwarel Apr 21, 2012

    Currently, all iMac computers ship with these major software applications installed and ready to use:

    By: woodwindl Computers> Hardwarel Apr 21, 2012

    What can roses do for you? Just about anything (well, anything becoming to a plant). They're long-lived plants, they deliver plentiful and gorgeous color, and you get to pick your own bouquets to enjoy indoors (or give away to your dazzled friends!).

    By: woodwindl Home Improvement> Gardeningl Apr 18, 2012

    With HD Radio, a digital signal piggybacks onto regular analog radio broadcasts. Because the HD Radio signal is digital, FM can potentially sound as good as a CD and AM as good as FM. Plus, there's virtually no static, drop-offs, hiss, or the other noises or reception problems associated with analog radio broadcast.

    By: woodwindl Home Improvement> DIYl Mar 28, 2012
    Author Box
    Articles Categories
    All Categories
    Quantcast