Remember Me
forgot your password?

History — ‘art or Science'?

There is a raging debate over the fact that whether history is an art or science.
History as an Art:
Those who believe that history is an art advocate the following opinion :—
1) According to Rickman, “History deals with sequence of events, each of them unique while science is concerned with the routine appearance of things and aims at generation and the establishment of regularities, governed by laws.”
2) Colingwood says, “Events of history are the things which the historian looks, not at, but through, to discern the thought within.”
3) Some scholars are of the view that history is neither pure science nor pure art. In other words, a blending of the two. When it discovers facts it is a science and when it settles truths, it becomes an art.
4) Some of the people went to the view that history is a part of literature.
5) Historical data are not available for scientific observation and experiment.
6) History is an art only. It cannot be called science. It is not based upon certain concepts and ideologies.
7) Of course, history is a social science, which contacts with human life and actions.
8) In history, we have a set of the data. It is fully analysed and classified.
History is a science:—
From the following points we can define history as a science.
1) History aims at discovering facts of the past events and interprets them objectively.
2) History uses various traits of enquiry such as observation, classification, formulation of hypothesis and explanation of evidence before reconstructing the past.
3) History follows the trends of enquiry to find out.
4) History seeks to tell the fact by giving a scientific method, hence, it is a science.
5) Is history a science as physics or chemistry or biology are? It is of course a negative question. History is a social science. It deals only with the experiences of human beings and human civilizations.
6) Historical facts cannot be observed.
Then, what is history?
1) History is a unique subject possessing the potentials of both an art and a science.
2) Secondly, history is neither pure science nor art, hence, it is two sides of the same coin.
3) Thirdly, history of course is a social science and an art. In that condition history shows its flexibility and variety.
4) Fourthly, history is a subject of study is less or more completely at the mercy of sources.
5) Fifthly, history is a natural science.

Guptajit Pathak

Present Address:
Guptajit Pathak
Head, Faculty of Social Sciences
Donyi Polo Vidya Bhawan
Itanagar - 791111
Arunachal Pradesh (India)
Mobile No. 09856274617
Email : guptajitpathak@yahoo.com

Permanent Address:
Guptajit Pathak
Village & P.O. Bezera
District : Kamrup
State : Assam
Pin : 781121
Phone : (03621) 280119
Mobile : 09864443099

Rate this Article: 3.2 / 5 stars - 5 vote(s)
Print Email Re-Publish

Add new Comment



Captcha

  • Latest College and University Articles
  • More from Guptajit Pathak

INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY BANARAS HINDU UNIVERSITY VARANASI INDIA - Those Glorious Days at ITBHU - Memories of my Alma Mater

By: Vikram Karve | 30/12/2009
ITBHU was amalgamated by integrating three of the country’s oldest and best engineering colleges: BENCO (Banaras Engineering College) – the first in the Orient, and certainly in India, to introduce the disciplines of Electrical and Mechanical Engineering, MINMET – the pioneer in Mining and Metallurgy in India, and College of Technology – the first to start Chemical and Ceramic Engineering in India;institutions who pioneered engineering education and were harbingers of modern industry in India.

Moms Going to College - A Growing Trend in America

By: Walter Sigmore | 30/12/2009
Nowadays, there are several moms going to college. This is all thanks to the program being spearheaded by US President Obama. Even though he has already provided an increased fund for the Pell Grant, the current US President has also allocated billions of dollars solely for the single moms.

College Girls Make Money By Selling From Catalogs Or By Peddling Pepper Sprays To Your Fellow Students!

By: Father Time | 30/12/2009
It is an easy way for a college girl to earn extra money while at school!

Pivot Table Review - Has The World Become Pivot Table Crazy?

By: Gen Wright | 30/12/2009
Pivot Tables allow you to slice and dice your flat tables like a kid's game. In just a moment, I will show you how this not-so-known Excel reporting command can boost your productivity...

Back To School Mothers Need Help Through Grants And Scholarships - They Are Available Now

By: Lindsy Emery | 30/12/2009
Many mothers find it necessary to go back to school in hopes of bettering their education now days, but they have special responsibilities when they have small children. They must find someone whom they can rely on to care for their kids while they work and attend school. Especially in the case of single moms, when there is no one else in the household who can help out, moms find the added expense of child care to be too much in many instances.

Are You A Single Mom And Wanting To Go Back To School? Try Government Scholarships

By: Lindsy Emery | 30/12/2009
Today there are many mothers, whether married or single, who find there is quite a large amount of responsibility involved with raising kids in this sagging economy. They find they definitely need to be better educated. Moms who wish to better themselves by improving their education can now take advantage of a program from our new president, Barack Obama.

Medical Billing and Coding

By: Career Step | 29/12/2009
To start working in the medical billing and coding, you need to receive proper coding training from an accredited college. Most billing training programs will provide you the education you need to work as a professional medical billing clerk or specialist.

Best Online Teaching Degree Programs

By: Ricky Lim | 29/12/2009
By doing an online teaching degree programs, you are able to jump start your teaching career in a very advanced and unique ways compared to other programs.

Festival Fiesta -‘nongkrem Dance’ of the Khasis of Mevhalaya

By: Guptajit Pathak | 18/04/2008 | Education
The Nongkrem Dance is the most important festival of the Khyrim state and is associated with goat sacrifice It is held at Smit, which is 15 kilometres (9 miles),

Tourism in Meghalaya - a Special Feature

By: Guptajit Pathak | 18/04/2008 | Education
Tourism is an attraction of the Government of Meghalaya: Tourism has been able to draw the attention of Government of Meghalaya, a lot of progressive features are marked in this sector. A few places were developed as the places of tourist interest.

The Khasis of Meghalaya - an Emphatic Study

By: Guptajit Pathak | 18/04/2008 | Education
The Khasis who live in ‘Meghalaya’ is one of the important ethnic groups of people of the North Eastern region of India. But nothing definite can be said about the particulars of this hill tribe. Generally, it is believed that the Khasis came to present Meghalay from a different place.

The Khasi Women of Meghalaya - 'the Mistress of the Household'

By: Guptajit Pathak | 18/04/2008 | Education
The Khasi women is considered as the ‘mistress of the household’ and the sole custodian of wealth and not just a proprietress. The father on the other hand is provider, master and guide of the family with the uncle as the undisputed director of the ancestral property.

A Change in Khasi Matrilineal Society of Meghalaya

By: Guptajit Pathak | 18/04/2008 | Education
MATRILINEAL SOCIETY

History and Historiography of the Khasis of Meghalaya

By: Guptajit Pathak | 18/04/2008 | Education
Prof J. B. Bhattacharjee has analyzed how the India's North- Eastern region is the homeland of a number of ethnic and cultural groups with different languages, religions, faiths and beliefs and traditions.

What is the Nature of History?

By: Guptajit Pathak | 16/10/2007 | College & University
Yes, history is the study of man, because it provides variety in the study of human experience. It deals with knowledge, when, it is related with people’s improvements. Of course, it can’t spare people’s struggle through the ages. History studies the past incidents and activities of the humans. No doubt, it acquaints us with the past experiences.

History — What is Its New Concept

By: Guptajit Pathak | 16/10/2007 | College & University
The new concept of history is more scientific and comprehensive. Though, history is one of the oldest subjects of knowledge, but, history and men are interlinked. Hence, it is not possible to differentiate the two.

Submit Your Articles Free: Signup
Article Categories




Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (0.05, 1, w3)