The author of the article argues the effectiveness of a future network-centric warfare system. She presents a number of valid points of view that lead the reader to a deeper understanding of possible problems that might occur as the result of such implementation. The new age of information technology and creative personnel has brought great changes into the business world; Scarborough however provides evidence that questions the effectiveness of such a system in the future Navy.
According to the author the Navy is a unique environment in which a strict wire-like hierarchy is a main way of communication and information flow. Network on the other hand is a new and widely adopted way of interaction in many businesses nowadays. Scarborough uses e-commerce as an example to compare it and network-centric warfare. She says that today’s business world is not a game that people play using technology it is a way of building relationships and partnership. Navy however is far from accepting partnership as a way of communication with their staff across the border. People in charge are used to being in control rather than being questioned as to whether some things can be done in a more efficient manner. Wire structure will simply fail to recognize the opportunity for the change and will stick with the old ways for it has proved to work in the past.
The Navy is a clearly structured and categorized system of order and command and it has been perceived as such by generations. Sheila Scarborough says that fulfilling organizational roles and being a disciplined problem solver was a major characteristic of a military official in the past. These days a trend that Navy is looking to adopt in the future will require a completely different perception of the tasks and command system. The author claims that thinking differently is a great thing, but only when it is taken into consideration by people able to make a positive change out of it. Higher ranked officials taking advice from a lower positioned personnel is a drastic change in the military world that might takes years to be fully adapted in the minds of those who are now in charge. The striking truth can be retrieved from this argument: the system will not change unless changes are intentionally implemented. People are never ready for it thus it should be maid a priority to seek for new opportunities and making progress without being forced by a critical situation.
Thinking outside the box and bringing in creativity in everyday routine is a key to success of managing time and people better. For decades the Navy only accepted those with a technical degree and Scarborough correctly points out that it was a definite flaw of the system. The mindset of the newly recruited was already predetermined to follow instructions, do what they were told and be like others. Nonlinear analysis and perceiving reality differently was not in the picture until recently. The author visibly depicts the importance of differently educated people in the modern Navy, as the world is evolving from the traditional base into a creative on. While technical education is undoubtedly a critical skill there are numerous instances in which other professions would serve better. Thus the changing organization should focus in pulling people of different backgrounds into the same environment and creating an effective way of information exchange. In the perfect world it would benefit everyone but in real life as the author points out there are traditions and values hard to break.
Scarbourough notes that there is a drifting notion toward new values such as "people first", still there remains a huge gap between the actual implementation of those vales and the reality today. As was observed earlier the Navy is a complex mechanism that was built on the idea of obedience and conscription. Therefore it will take longer than a few bright thoughts by the new generation to destroy this castle of order and discipline. Moreover the majority of those in charge will not be able to just tune into a completely new mode of thinking. They might not be able to simply recognize someone who is more creative and intelligent than they are. This leads us to another significant aspect of the new organizational structure in today’s business world: identifying opportunity at all times, whether is comes from a newcomer or a senior officer. Such attitude sounds great and could bring a positive change to the Navy, although we realize that Scarborough is completely right when claiming that senior officers might not be willing to give up their power by letting others make decisions.
Admitting that the old system is becoming inefficient means that we have been investing in the wrong things for many generations and now it is time to move on to a new value system. Change is never easily accepted and quickly implemented especially if it associated with letting go of the power and employing free thinking as a major weapon against the enemy. According to the author once a network-centric warfare is accepted, ships, aircraft and submarines will not play an essential role in winning wars anymore. The bad news however is that the Navy does not yet possess a different platform other than ships and submarines for fighting wars. It has not transitioned to a new level and the need to hold on to the metal carcass and buying more of it is essential for the system, as Scarborough points out it has worked for so long that there is no apparent need to change it.
Military culture and technological change in the world, authoritative manner of command and free-thinkers are the notions that somehow need to mingle and work together under the common base of the Navy system. Looking back at Scarborough’s facts and suggestions it becomes obvious that all of those things would create a perfectly balanced organization where creative ideas are being implemented in orderly manner. In reality, the transformative change is only going to happen in the face of urgent need or disaster unless deliberately instigated. Overcoming difficulties associated with the change in the chain of command and educational preferences will bring the Navy closer to a flexible network structure. The logical organization of the article demonstrated that the present Navy is not ready for a drastic change. The need for the transformation is evident however as the rest of the world is already living it and now it is a matter of time and a consequent action.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Co C, 143rd Regt, 36th Inf Div roster, WWII
By: abel Vidaurri | 28-08-2008
Sgt Benjamin F Ortega, C Co, 143rd Regt, 36th Inf Div. Would like to know what Battalion he was in and how a roster of C Companies men could be obtained. Sgt Ortega served till the end of WWII. Sgt Oretga had a dairy and kept a list of some of the men in his platoon listed in it.
abel.vidaurri@us.army.mil
What if the non custoidal parent moves and doesn't ...
By: adria | 27-08-2008
what if the non custoidal parent moves and doesn't notify the courts?
When I left the Navy in WWII I got a letter from ...
By: George H Horton | 26-08-2008
When I left the Navy in WWII I got a letter from Sec Navy Frank Knox can you help me with this all Navy men got the same thank you letter GHorton424@aol.com
We need rolls of blank embroidery name tape for ...
By: C&J ALT | 25-08-2008
We need rolls of blank embroidery name tape for all us military uniforms
Which navy league councils in florida are in ...
By: ndnormdalyliz | 24-08-2008
which navy league councils in florida are in compliance with fl solicitaion of contributions act?
I am a military wife whose husband is active duty ...
By: Brandy | 24-08-2008
I am a military wife whose husband is active duty Air Force. We are in Utah and we have orders to go to another country therefore i have to quit my job that i have been at for 9 years, am I able to apply for unemployment benefits?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest College and University Articles
Role of Teachers in the World of Online Education
By: Gen Wright | 10/10/2008
How is internet changing the dynamics of learning? And what does a teacher have to do in this fast changing world of online education? Read on.
Juggling Work and School Can Pay Off
By: Cynthia Atoji | 09/10/2008
OntarioHealthCareSchools.com has advice to help people with the trials of going to a local career college or a nursing school while they are working to make money, and how they can get the most advantages from their current employment and education.
A New Occupation Can be the Reward for Balancing a Job and School at the Same Time
By: Cynthia Atoji | 09/10/2008
Healthcare is the fastest-growing industry in the country. Trained nurses with their BSN and RN are in demand. By getting your BS in Nursing or AS in Nursing you can improve your job opportunities and advance your career.
An Exciting New Career Can be the Motivation for Juggling Work and School
By: Cynthia Atoji | 09/10/2008
LAMedicalTraining.com offers the following tips to help students handle the strains of attending a local career college or nursing school while working, and to help students take full advantage of their work and school experience.
Balancing Work and School Can Pay Off in a New Career
By: Cynthia Atoji | 09/10/2008
You can increase your earning potential when you train as a massage therapist.
New Horizons Hosts Charity Golf Tournament to Benefit Dana Farber Foundation
By: Dotty Zukoff | 09/10/2008
Microsoft and New Horizons of Boston, along with Altico Advisors, B2B Contact, Insight, Magenic and Presidio, have teamed up for their Fourth Annual Customer Appreciation Charity Golf Tournament on October 7, 2008.
Career Education Corporation – What is It?
By: Lester Lee | 08/10/2008
The Career Education Corporation is one of the leading providers of education. They have many different programs that you can take. They were founded in 1994 and have a wide selection of schools, colleges and universities that you can choose from. You need to do some research into the CEC Career Education Corporation.
Career Education Services – What Does This Mean for You?
By: Lester Lee | 08/10/2008
College is a lot to deal with and get through. However, there is one powerful tool that you need to take advantage of before you get out of college. That is the career education services. The career services office can help you get your future figured out. This is very important for every student in college.
More from Jeff Stats
Print Media & Its Future
By: Jeff Stats | 05/10/2008 | College and University
Ever since John Gutenberg invented the Printing Press, the printed word has been shaping the civilization of the world. All print media share one common characteristic i.e. they are composed of words inscribed on paper by ink. Their form is strikingly different from the flowing signs and images of televisions and films. For much of their history books have been controversial because of their content rather than their form. In an age when new electronic channels of communication are taking hold,
Brunhild and Kriemhild
By: Jeff Stats | 05/10/2008 | Article Writing
Traditionally, “The Song of the Nibelungs” is perceived as a great gift inebriated by European literature from the past. Basically, this literary work incorporated myths and legends which perfectly illustrated beliefs and traditions of the people that created them. At the same time, the book provides not only important cultural and artistic information but it is also of a great value as a literary work depicting a variety of characters. Brunhild and Kriemhild may be actually named among the most
Social Diversity
By: Jeff Stats | 05/10/2008 | Article Writing
Sociology as a science is concerned with the study of people as a group. It examines human activities in all of its aspects, from political inclinations to religious believes. There are a number of groups that society is divided into according to interests, earnings, age, sex and other numerous factors. In general, one can split modern society into two groups: minority and dominant. A minority group is a so called subordinate group members of which possess less control and power over their own l
My Prized Objects
By: Jeff Stats | 04/07/2007 | College and University
In our material age almost everything can be bought and sold. Thus, it is very important to not get overwhelmed with a great variety of choices we are offered. It is essential to find joy in ordinary things that surround us.
Major Environmental Factors That Impact International Project Selection
By: Jeff Stats | 04/07/2007 | College and University
A company that chooses to implement an international project is obligated to conduct a thorough research in order to understand if such project is viable and can be brought to life in a certain country.
Major Environmental Factors That Impact International Project Selection & Implementation
By: Jeff Stats | 04/07/2007 | College and University
A company that chooses to implement an international project is obligated to conduct a thorough research in order to understand if such project is viable and can be brought to life in a certain country. Numerous factors have to be taken into consideration and investigated; it has to be done objectively from the point of view of the host country in which business will be performed.
Alzheimer’s Disease
By: Jeff Stats | 04/07/2007 | College and University
Along with the development of modern technologies, going to the moon and other exciting developments humans face the threat of diseases that affect the process of life and can be lethal in some cases. One of the illnesses that have a great affect on people’s behavior is Alzheimer’s disease (AD).
: James Joyce and His View of the Irish People Through His Writing in the "dubliners"
By: Jeff Stats | 03/07/2007 | College and University
"Dubliners" of James Joyce is a unique work of literature in many senses. The primary outstanding feature of this book lies in the very structure of it. It consists of four major elements, that in turn consist of few stories that are not connected with each other but the reader somehow realizes that they all talk about common things that were present in Irish society at that time.
Education 
