Water Smokers – The Argument For And Against

Posted: Mar 15, 2011 |Comments: 0 |

For some reason, most of the research I do into the origins of cooking always leads me back to China. Don't get me wrong, Chinese food is great but why always China? Or is it to do with the fact that most of my research is into the barbecue smoker?

I started researching kamados and now it would appear that the humble water smoker also originated in China.

The principle of the water smoker is that that a bath of water is placed between the heat sources and the food to effectively steam the food. By cooking this way, you can ensure that the results of your cooking are always supremely moist.

The perceived negative of water cooking is that the temperature you cook at is lower (otherwise the water would boil away in no time) and therefore the cooking process takes about twice as long. Fair enough but it also means that your cooking time doesn't have to be quite as accurate.

If you are cooking at 350 Fahrenheit and you happen to leave something in the oven for an extra hour, you're sure to know about it by the texture and flavor but if you do the same with water cooking then the difference is less marked. This must have been a tremendous advantage in ancient times when you could just heat up the water over and let you food cook all day long, certainly it works for me today too.

The water cooker eventually found it's way over the Pacific to North America and it was particularly in the South of the country where devotees to this style of cooking started to appear. Some of these folks started the habit of putting wood chips on the fire and so we have the birth of water smoking.

Many modern day water smokers look somewhat like a torpedo or bullet. An upright elongated oval cylinder with a heat source in the bottom, two racks in the top for the food and in the middle is the water tray.

Fuel wise, you can get charcoal burners, propane and electric units so the options are there for you to try. Charcoal units will have the wood chips placed directly on the heat source whereas gas and electric units normally have a "hotplate" arrangement. The choice of fuel is yours, some will argue that charcoal is the traditional way to go but it is messy and takes more time to get the fire under control. Just like a gas grill, the propane units are a little more immediate to get the oven up to temperature and under control.

The advantages of these units are that they are compact in design and lightweight making them quite portable so if this is an issue for you then a water smoker maybe the way to go.

There are however a number of downsides:-

  • Take care that the water bath doesn't run dry. If it does you'll get some pretty nasty burnt smells that are going to taint the flavor of your food.
  • When you open the door to replenish fuel and water, you'll see a dramatic drop in oven temperature and it's take 10 or 15 minute to recover – all of this will add to the cooking time
  • These smokers aren't well insulated so every time you set up your smoker the settings are going to be different dependent on ambient temperature.

Having said all of the above, you can achieve great results from one of these little bullet smokers and they don't cost the Earth to buy either.

Questions and Answers

200 Characters left
Ask
Rate this Article
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 0 vote(s)
    Feedback
    Print
    Re-Publish
    Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/cooking-tips-articles/water-smokers-the-argument-for-and-against-4412356.html

    Article Tags:

    water smokers

    ,

    kamados

    ,

    smoker cooking

    If you're not familiar with a kamado it's a derivation of an ancient Chinese clay cooking pot that was later adapted by the Japanese (who named it Mushikamado) and it finally made it to the western world in the middle of the last century. Nowadays the clay has been replaced...

    By: Paul Yatesl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl Jun 09, 2008 lViews: 2,431

    The technique of indirect cooking is essentially a slow roasting process which guarantees a tender result. When you think about it it's pretty logical. The definition of indirect cooking is where the heat is not directly applied to the turkey as opposed to a grill where the turkey is seared...

    By: Barbecue Smoker Recipe Manl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl Feb 17, 2008 lViews: 1,731 lComments: 1
    Lewis Theakson

    Cooking great baby-back ribs is considered by many rib afficionados to be a science, though with some TLC, near competition-quality baby-back ribs can be achieved by using your own backyard BBQ smoker, but only, if you have good quality ribs and a tried and tested recipe.

    By: Lewis Theaksonl Food and Beverage> Recipesl Mar 26, 2010 lViews: 925

    Why not transform your backyard into a vacation getaway? Provide a setting in which your landscaping can be admired and enjoyed whether spending a tranquil evening or a summer meal with friends on the deck.

    By: Catherine Pyel Home Improvement> Gardeningl Mar 12, 2012

    Shift around burgers, step aside chicken; if you would like grilling anything which is really quick foods, contemplate one particular fish filet on the filet mignon. Several at home cooks forget fish as soon as they will retrieve the portable bbq grill, favoring that standard beef along with pork. However , barbecuing fish generates fillets that are certainly flaky and flavorful, a person won't think about losing the very beer batter or maybe that profound baking. Grilled fish is undoubtedly h

    By: otakuevel Food and Beverage> Home Brewingl Jul 28, 2010

    For centuries, seafood has been the top ingredient of eastern and western civilization. People across the world enjoy the delicious seafood and take advantage of its immense health benefits

    By: Xu Lixingl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl May 29, 2012

    After you are done with serving the guest for the dinner, and he is quite pleased with the type of the treatment he is dished out, one can easily win over his heart by serving him with the possible delicacy of the night: dessert.

    By: Nikita Vermal Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl May 28, 2012

    If you're thinking about picking up cooking, but aren't sure what to do and where to start, then you've come to the right place. When it comes to cooking the more knowledge you gain, the more you have to apply towards making a great meal. Knowledge such as contained in this article can help you to become a better cook.

    By: Beau Lesterl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl May 28, 2012

    Smells coming from the kitchen can many times evoke childhood memories of grandmas famous apple pie or thanksgiving dinner. Creating lasting memories like these for your little ones today is important. The following cooking tips will help you to savor those old memories as well as cook up some new ones for generations to come.

    By: Beau Lesterl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl May 28, 2012

    Is cooking a scary frontier for you? Are you nervous about entering your kitchen, remembering a previous disaster? If this is you, never fear! Plenty of people have trouble with cooking, and all it takes is a little practice and proper education to cook like a pro! Read on to find out how.

    By: Beau Lesterl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl May 28, 2012

    Are you building your business social networking strategy and finding that it is an significant drain on your time? I was the same until I started to use a suite of free tools that has improved the productivity of my social networking activities.

    By: Paul Yatesl Marketing> Social Marketingl Apr 12, 2011

    Some smokers use a water bath whilst others do not. Why would you want to use a water smoker and how do you get the best out of it. Here are the answers.

    By: Paul Yatesl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl Apr 12, 2011

    Ever wondered why you start to follow someone based on their bio and then find that they are firing out tweets every ten minutes about things that are frankly irrelevant to you? Here's why it's happening and ultimately who is making the money out of this strategy of Twitter marketing.

    By: Paul Yatesl Marketing> Social Marketingl Apr 12, 2011

    Many folks extol the merits of vinegar as a cleaning product but let's get back to what it really is, a food ingredient. As a barbecue griller I use vinegar all the time and here are my handy hints when to use it.

    By: Paul Yatesl Food and Beverage> Cooking Tipsl Apr 11, 2011

    Barbecue sauce has been taken in so many directions recently by recipe writers and manufacturers more about trying to create an angle rather than just giving us great barbecue sauce. I believe that the best barbecue sauce is one close to the original tradition and here's my recipe.

    By: Paul Yatesl Food and Beverage> Recipesl Apr 11, 2011

    Discuss this Article

    Author Box
    Articles Categories
    All Categories
    Quantcast