When dealing with decisions using Cost Benefit techniques it is very important to follow the proven principles. The health of your company and your reputation depend on it. If these rules are not followed then your decisions could be flawed.
Let's start, shall we?
Question #1. Is this technique suitable for the small business owner?
Yes. The theory works equally as well for small business as it does for big business and government.
Cost Benefit Analysis is a decision-making technique that assesses the positive outcomes (benefits) as well as the negative outcomes (costs) of different decision alternatives. The trick is to make its implementation easy for the small businessperson.
Once you have basic knowledge of the theory and can enter data into a spreadsheet then the rest is not too difficult.
Question #2. Is this all I need to make better decisions?
No. Cost Benefit Analysis is a tool to assist in making better financial decisions. It is not an end in itself. However, part of the Cost Benefit process requires that you think widely on all options before making a final decision. This is often where most people fail in their decision-making attempts.
Cost Benefit Analysis is also very skilful at providing a single viability output for each competing option, making comparisons objective and easy.
Question #3. What do I include as the Costs and the Benefits?
Costs. All costs attributable to the project are to be included. Some of these are listed below:
- Asset Costs (both Capital and ongoing)
- Supply costs for purchased items
- Extra administrative effort required to manage project
- Delivery costs if to your account
- Replacement of assets in future years
- Tender preparation costs
- Any specialised tooling associated with the project
Revenue. Revenue can only be attributed to a project if it were not received were the project not to go ahead.
Asset Disposal and Residual Values. Some assets may be retired prior to the end of their useful lives or may be salvaged at the end of the project. This value is to be included in the cash flows (less the costs associated with their sale or disposal).
Cost Savings. All cost savings attributable to the project are to be included. Wage and salary cost savings must include their overheads and on-costs.
Question #4. How do I treat non-financial costs and benefits?
Since only cash transactions (both costs and benefits) are included in Cost Benefit models, non-financial costs and benefits are usually described by way of notes.
If the Benefit Cost Ratio is = to 1 or > 1 then the use of non-financial costs and benefits would not be required since the project is already VIABLE. Normally these non-financial costs and benefits would be included when comparing competing options whose Benefit Cost Ratio is close to each other.
Question #5. How can I test my assumptions?
You are best placed to make assumptions based on your own experience and judgement. However, you can use a technique to show others how robust your assumptions really are. This technique is called Sensitivity Analysis.
This technique is important to understand because you have made many assumptions in your analysis. These could have been, for instance, the level of new income generated, the savings generated or the residual value of the asset at the end of the project life. These assumptions are at the heart of your analysis and have contributed to your final Benefit Cost Ratio outcome.
Since the future cannot be accurately predicted there is a high probability that some of your assumptions may prove incorrect.
Using this technique will add conviction and weight to your proposal by showing how changes to costs and benefits affect the Benefit Cost Ratio. Do small changes move the project from VIABLE to UNVIABLE?
Question #6. How can I be sure that the project is VIABLE?
You have made your assumptions based on your project knowledge and experience. You have constructed the model that shows the project to be VIABLE. If you have followed the proven principles it should work out OK. Once the project has been authorised it is important to ensure that the assumptions are correct and in fact are deliverable.
To ensure this happens follow up on these items:
- Any labour savings must be delivered - re-assign affected resources
- Cost savings due to process changes must be acted upon swiftly
- Increased revenue from price rises must be implemented urgently
A Post Completion Review undertaken a year from the project's implementation will show you if all or some of your assumptions proved correct. It will also teach lessons on how this could done more successfully next time rather than making the same mistakes again.
Question #7. How can I implement this technique in my company?
There are a number of ways as follows:
- Use Cost Benefit Analysis yourself in a pilot project
- Convince the CEO of its benefits to the company and use that authority
- Use Cost Benefit Analysis in a specific business unit
All of these ways require a thorough understanding of the theory, the reasons for its implementation and the expected payoffs.
A training program would need to be undertaken so that all those involved understood the technique.
Question #8. Why does it have to include NPV to account for the time value of money?
Typically the life of the assets, or the decision being made, will have a financial impact over more than 1 year. This is usually 3 - 5 years (computers, software, factory machinery), 20 years for some large electrical equipment and even up to 100 years for underground pipes as used in water and sewer reticulation.
Inflation, year by year, reduces the buying power of the dollar causing us to spend more each year in dollar terms to purchase the same item. So it is with projects whose life span is more than one year.
Costs and benefits that occur in year 3 or 4 of the project would not have the same impact as if they occurred in year one.
The Benefit Cost Ratio and the final decision regarding VIABILITY could be completely wrong if NPV is not used in the model.
Question #9. Are there any limits to its applicability?
Not really, as long as you are dealing with financial costs and benefits. It has application to large and small decisions, complex and simple, long lived and short lived assets, also profit based and government and charities.
There are some general limitations:
Subjectivity - It is quite unlikely that two analysts working separately will estimate exactly the same Cost Benefit Ratio number. There are many variables that can be treated slightly differently, some of which are listed below:
- Estimation of physical and/or economic life of the asset/project
- Estimates of costs/benefits of environmental protection
- The choice of discount rates (the rates illustrated above are indicative of a range which could be applicable)
- The value of benefits can be different for different groups in society (i.e. the value of a $ to the poor section of the community is different to that of the affluent class)
Political Decision Making - The necessity of making political judgements on the viability of the project (timing of elections, regional loyalties) can sway an outcome. Also decision-makers are not consistent over space and time.
First Round Effects - We would normally only include the effects that are directly attributable to the project going ahead. We would not, for instance, include the increased community agricultural output generally due to a project going ahead. This would only be justified if the sector was originally under-employed.
Question #10. How can this technique actually help me?
There are many ways - some are listed below:
- Increases your confidence knowing you have used a proven reliable method.
- Having thought of all the options for solving the problem you can present your proposal knowing you have the answers.
- Using this technique will ensure you gain recognition and more opportunities for advancement
- Once the company sees the benefits of this technique it may wish you to be the trainer of other staff or the implementation champion - more opportunities for you.
- This technique will you save time in project assessment and ranking of competing proposals.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Tennis court rental in Wimbledon?
By: Candonga | 13-07-2008
Can you rent a tennis court in the "All England Tennis Club" (Wimbledon)? and if so, how much does it cost?
Kinko's tuition reinbursement
By: Mig | 12-07-2008
What is the maximum amount FedEx Kinko's pay for tuition reinbursement for a part-time employee?
Currently I am interseted in buying a nonpoint red ragdoll cat in....
By: Sarah | 10-07-2008
currently I am interseted in buying a nonpoint red ragdoll cat in 2-3 years.I would like to know how much they would cost me,also I would like to know more information on them and see more pictures, if you know a great site or have your own red or non red raggdoll please send me pictures. I am very inertested! Thank you
Single mom needing financial help with bills, rent, car payment due to caring for my son that has mentally disabilites and has just started treatment
By: Sherry | 10-07-2008
income eligibility for financial aid for bills from the red cross help in Utah Need help paying bills, car payments and rent for single mom with soon with mental disabilities
Best contemporaneous playwright
By: ally | 10-07-2008
what is the best contemporaneous play and who is the best contemporaneous playwright (playwriter) in your country?please put the link of the play
Secret Lover/Friend
By: MiamiTemp | 08-07-2008
I'm a 25 y/o female from Miami. I've been involved with a man romantically for a year and a half but nobody knows about our relationship. I can't go into detail about why we have to keep this a secret. He's not married or anything but if people found out then it could hurt his career, etc. I had known for a few years before we started anything sexual but had fallen for him way before that. When the opportunity presented itself I took it and things have been very hot with him since then. However, he has no idea how much I care about him. We were always friends, so I know he gets that much but I'm scared that if he found out that I was in love with him our relationship would change. It kills me not to be able to tell this guy that he's everything to me. I've had my share of relationships, whether it has been boyfriends, friends with benefits or whatever but this is completely throwing me off track in my life. I know he recently started seeing another woman, but the terms of our current relationship are strictly "friends with benefits" so I can't really say anything. The other woman has no idea that me and him have the type of sexual relationship that we do. She thinks we are just friends. I love having this secret, but at times it gets difficult. I get sad at times when I think that he is waking up next to her and not me. He'll swing by my house, we'll hook up and then he'll go over to her house for a movie. It sucks and I'm not quite sure how to handle it. I don't want it to end, I want him to know how I feel but I can't bring myself to tell him. Anyone got any words of wisdom?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Corporate Articles
A Power Hire…lyons & Wolivar, Inc. (l&w Investigations) Retains Jerome Wallace for Northern California Territory
By: Steve Dubin | 25/07/2008
Richardson Bradshaw Unz, principal and general manager of L&W Investigations Northern California office, recently announced the hiring of Jerome Wallace as director of business development.
New Digital Asset Management Solutions and Xml Content Servers Help Companies Reach Out
By: 10x Marketing | 25/07/2008
Businesses are discovering that they cannot rely on the old ways of advertising and reaching out to new customers using the same old products and systems. In this digital era companies need new tools. With a digital asset management system, businesses and organizations save money and gain revenue in new and different ways.
Get Efficient Business Relocation From Professional Relocation Consultants
By: Aravind Ramesh | 25/07/2008
Business relocation consultants can help you in relocating your business so that money, time and effort spent over business relocation can be wisely used for the development of your business. Finding good professional relocation consultants has become easy with the introduction of search engines.
Finance Directors Demand Pay and Display
By: Gary Howes | 24/07/2008
40% of FDs call for greater transparency for domestic and international payments.
How Important is Reverse Phone Lookup for Your Business?
By: Jeru Wilson | 24/07/2008
Are you one of those who are losing out on potential clients because you do not know about reverse phone lookup?
Advertising and Promoting Your Own Site on a Small Budget
By: Ankur Bhardwaj | 22/07/2008
Promoting your website on the Internet used to be all about marketing by email. This was a very cost effective promotional medium and reigned supreme for many years. But as things and people progressed it was pushed beyond its useful boundaries and the result was spam.
Do You Need Someone to Watch Over Your Shoulder Before You Start Doing Things
By: Manojj Kumarr | 21/07/2008
There are more and more people working at home. Some of them prefer to work for others, so they do freelance work. However, there are a number of people who aspire to be their own boss; therefore, they started their own home based business. Before you start a home business, it is very important to ask yourself what you really want in your life.
Choose the Night Club You’d Like to Visit and Join the Guest List at Café De Paris
By: David J | 21/07/2008
For guest list places at some of most popular night Café De Paris London, London Party venue, sign up for free membership with londonparties.co.uk now.
More from Bruce Hokin
Are your Financial Decisions Becoming Stale? Here are 3 Fresh Tools to Help!
By: Bruce Hokin | 19/02/2007 | Entrepreneurship
Profitable financial decisions are the very life-blood of vibrant businesses. These decisions can cover asset replacement/repair options, investment choices, advertising options, business directions, new product development and introduction and innovative work practices. These decisions all have a positive or negative impact on the viability and health of the business. Would your business be more successful if your decisions were freshened up?
9 Secrets to Making Laser-accurate Financial Decisions
By: Bruce Hokin | 08/02/2007 | Entrepreneurship
Financial decisions are an integral part of any business. Good financial decisions will make the business grow and prosper; poor decisions can bring a business to its knees. There is a process that will yield the best financial decisions. If followed, it will offer the highest potential for success. These secrets for success are listed below.
Cost Benefit Analysis–how it Helps you Make Better Financial Decisions–9 Ways
By: Bruce Hokin | 30/01/2007 | Business
Financial decisions can make or break a business, and its owner(s). It would be prudent to use tested and proven methods that are guaranteed to improve the quality of financial decisions - especially capital purchase decisions. These ways listed below are but a few of the many benefits that will accrue to those who learn and implement them.
Cost Benefit Analysis - 10 Most Common Myths Debunked
By: Bruce Hokin | 25/01/2007 | Business
There are many reasons why executives, business owners and others put off learning and implementing Cost Benefit Analysis in their businesses. Some of the reasons are listed below. You can gain the advantage over these by understanding the real truths of this powerful, decision-making tool.
Do you Make These 10 Mistakes With Cost Benefit Analysis?
By: Bruce Hokin | 14/01/2007 | Business
Financial decisions are very important to the health of any company. So it is critical that decisions are made using the best techniques available. Cost Benefit Analysis is designed to help you make the best financial decisions possible.
Do you Make These 10 Mistakes When Making Financial Decisions?
By: Bruce Hokin | 04/01/2007 | Corporate
Making decisions is what managers are paid to do. However, the ramifications of these decisions can have a marked positive or negative outcome on the company. Not to mention the manager's prospects as well. The article covers just a few of the mistakes.
10 Critical Benefits you Receive by Using Cost Benefit Analysis
By: Bruce Hokin | 04/01/2007 | Corporate
If you are called upon to make financial decisions you may find it difficult sometimes to confidently choose the best proposal. Using Cost Benefit Analysis can help.
9 Profitable Ways Accountants Can Boost Their Business Using Cost Benefit Analysis
By: Bruce Hokin | 04/01/2007 | Corporate
Accountants are well suited to making extra income by using Cost Benefit Analysis. The 9 ways shown in the article will make it easy to add these elements to your business. Cost Benefit Analysis can assist your clients and boost your profit.
Business 
