Defining The Parameters Of Limitation Periods In Personal Injury Actions

Posted: Mar 18, 2010 |Comments: 0 | Views: 115 |

A limitation period is a stated period of time, the expiry of which extinguishes a party's legal remedy and forbids the commencement of a legal action. Each province in Canada has general statutes of limitations and many provincial and federal statutes contain limitation periods applicable to a variety of causes of actions. Traditionally, limitation periods have been strictly enforced. More recently, the subject of when time begins to run has received greater attention from our courts.

The discoverability rule has evolved fairly recently in our civil jurisprudence.1 It gives relief in certain factual situations by extending a limitation period. According to the discoverability rule, a limitation period begins to run when the material facts upon which an action is based have been discovered, or ought to have been discovered by the plaintiff through the exercise of due diligence. The effect of the rule is to postpone the running of time until a reasonable person, in the exercise of reasonable diligence, would discover the facts necessary to maintain the action.2 It is a general rule applied to avoid injustice.


It is now over two years since the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the Ontario Court of Appeal's decision in Peixeiro v. Haberman. Justice Major in Peixeiro adopted Taddle's J. A.'s statement in Fehr v. Jacob (1993), 14 C.C.L.T. (2d) 200 (Man. C.A.) at 206, which is as follows:

In my opinion, the judge-made discoverability rule is nothing more than a rule of construction. Whenever a statute requires an action to be commenced within a specified time from the happening of a specific event, the statutory language must be construed. When time runs from "the accrual of the cause of action" or from some other event which can be construed as occurring only when the injured party has knowledge of the injury sustained, the judge-made discoverability rule applies. But, when time runs from an event which clearly occurs without regard to the injured party's knowledge, the judge-made discoverability rule may not extend the period the legislature has prescribed.

In Peixeiro the court concluded that the limitation period under the Ontario Highway Traffic Act did not start to run in a personal injury action arising out of an automobile accident until the plaintiff discovered facts that could sustain a claim that his or her injuries met the threshold under the Insurance Act.

Since Peixeiro, the discoverability rule has enjoyed broad application in Ontario in motor vehicle actions and actions against municipalities and the provincial crown. As such there is now a body of jurisprudence on the scope and application of Peixeiro. The purpose of this paper is to review the way Ontario courts have applied Peixeiro in the context of personal injury litigation so that the parameters of the present authorities in the area of motor vehicle actions and actions against municipalities and the provincial crown can be better understood and defined.

Questions and Answers

Ask
200 Characters left
Rate this Article
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 0 vote(s)
    Feedback
    Print
    Re-Publish
    Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/criminal-articles/defining-the-parameters-of-limitation-periods-in-personal-injury-actions-2006536.html

    Article Tags:

    insurance claim settlement

    ,

    insurance dispute lawyers

    ,

    lawyers for disability

    ,

    life insurance disputes

    The following Content tells you in detail about the Disability Insurance Claim and Settlements and also the various types of disability insurance claims which David Share Associates deals in such as: Short term or Long Term Disability Insurance, Life Insurance, Critical Illness Insurance Disputes, etc.

    By: Jacob Solomonl News and Societyl Dec 31, 2009 lViews: 120

    The following Content tells you in detail about the Disability Insurance Claim and Settlements and also the various types of disability insurance claims which David Share Associates deals in such as: Short term or Long Term Disability Insurance, Life Insurance, Critical Illness Insurance Disputes, etc.

    By: Jacob Solomonl Lawl Jun 23, 2009 lViews: 365

    Personal Injury Lawyers in Toronto

    By: Tony Kovacsl Law> Personal Injuryl Dec 26, 2009

    A personal injury or catastrophic injury case occurs when a person has suffered some form of severe physical or psychological injury as a result of another person or company’s wrongful conduct. The wrongful conduct may be simple negligence or intentional, willful, wanton or reckless conduct. In some instances, a party may be strictly liable for injury to another without the injured person having to show any wrongdoing by the other party.

    By: Mitch Jacksonl Lawl Feb 02, 2011 lViews: 229

    If you are suffering from a serious injury caused by another person, motor vehicle accident injury or have lost a loved one in wrongful death, you likely need guidance from someone who will stand behind you and protect your rights.

    By: abnerbarbl Law> Personal Injuryl Dec 27, 2011
    Mark Langschied

    Before we can answer the question of the role of Alcoholics Anonymous in restoring drivers licenses, it's helpful first to briefly review the Michigan drivers license restoration process and what you must prove.

    By: Mark Langschiedl Law> Criminall May 29, 2012

    In many cases, especially when the crime is publicly scorned (i.e. DUI, domestic violence, animal cruelty, sex offenses) yet a bona-fide defense exists, one should consider waiving a jury trial. The case is then tried to only the judge. This can make it easier to focus the case on evidence and argument that matters most toward a not guilty verdict, rather than spending a lot of time and effort persuading twelve jurors to put aside their biases.

    By: Greg Hilll Law> Criminall May 29, 2012

    When someone moves into an assisted living center, that person is likely not doing so with much in the way of excitement or happiness.

    By: carsonl Law> Criminall May 29, 2012

    The Criminal lawyers Ottawa have special skills to fight out both simple and complicated cases and help you the best legal justice ever.

    By: samvegal Law> Criminall May 29, 2012

    A professional criminal attorney in Los Angeles can surely get your name off the list of criminals in the city if you really are innocent. It does not actually matter if you go for a professional Los Angeles criminal attorney that charges lower or higher compared to others.

    By: jorlatl Law> Criminall May 29, 2012

    If your claim has been denied, a long term disability claim lawyer at David Share Associates can help you sort through the details of your contract to figure out how much protection you are entitled to.

    By: Jacob Solomonl Law> Cyber Lawl Oct 11, 2010

    The following Content tells you in detail about the Disability Insurance Claim and Settlements and also the various types of disability insurance claims which David Share Associates deals in such as: Short term or Long Term Disability Insurance, Life Insurance, Critical Illness Insurance Disputes, etc.

    By: Jacob Solomonl News and Societyl Dec 31, 2009 lViews: 120

    Depression or any other psychiatric disorder which hampers the working ability of an individual is a long term disability and is covered under the long term disability insurance. However, problems arise when the insurance company refuses to give due credit to the contract and refuses to pay the claim on various grounds.

    By: Jacob Solomonl News and Societyl Dec 31, 2009 lViews: 135

    The article is about how to manage and litigate Depression Disability Claims Treatment Rehabilitation and Retraining. The prediction by the World Health Organization is that in less than twenty years, depression will be the second leading cause of disability in the world. To find more about this read further..

    By: Jacob Solomonl Lawl Jun 23, 2009 lViews: 441

    Discuss this Article

    Author Box
    Articles Categories
    All Categories
    Quantcast