New Supreme Court Ruling: Laboratory analysts must now appear in court

<h1>New Supreme Court Ruling: Laboratory analysts must now appear in court</h1>Author: <a title="Rick Mueller" href="http://www.articlesbase.com/authors/rick-mueller/87507.htm">Rick Mueller</a> Laboratory analysts must now appear in court and submit themselves to cross-examination if their reports are admitted into evidence, according to a brand new ruling by the United States Supreme Court. Last week's 5-4 ruling in Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts mandates forensic analysts must appear in court under the Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause which gives criminal defendants the right to confront witnesses. Crime lab analysts previously were rarely subpoenaed to testify about their reports. Justice Scalia questioned the reliability of forensic science as a whole, mentioning a recent National Academy of Science report which raised a number of issues. Rejecting the Prosecutor's position that forensic reports, as scientific findings, are neutral facts rather than accusatory testimony, he opined: "Forensic evidence is not uniquely immune from the risk of manipulation. According to a recent study conducted under the auspices of the National Academy of Sciences. & Confrontation is designed to weed out not only the fraudulent analyst, but the incompetent one as well. Serious deficiencies have been found in the forensic evidence used in criminal trials." "Like expert witnesses generally, an analyst's lack of proper training or deficiency in judgment may be disclosed in cross-examination." Each state is left to establish a procedure for contesting lab reports and calling analysts to court, so it is too soon to tell what the ruling's full consequences are. This decision means a significant, future financial impact on crime labs by requiring analysts also to appear.  It usually takes twelve to twenty-four months to hire and train a new analyst, even if one's budget supports new hirings. Even considering that approximately 9 & 1/2 out of 10 cases end in a plea bargain, rights must be protected in that 5% that go to trial! "The Confrontation Clause may make the prosecution of criminals more burdensome, but that is equally true of the right to trial by jury and the privilege against self-incrimination. The Confrontation Clause--like those other constitutional provisions-- is binding, and we may not disregard it at our convenience."About the Author: DUI Specialist Rick Mueller is the only <a href="http://www.sandiegoduilawyer.com">San Diego DUI attorney</a> who was the featured Speaker at 7 DUI seminars in San Diego County in the last several years. Rick Mueller is known as the "DMV Guru".Article Source: <a href="http://www.articlesbase.com/">ArticlesBase.com</a> - <a href="http://www.articlesbase.com/criminal-articles/new-supreme-court-ruling-laboratory-analysts-must-now-appear-in-court-1007057.html" title="New Supreme Court Ruling: Laboratory analysts must now appear in court">New Supreme Court Ruling: Laboratory analysts must now appear in court</a>

Laboratory analysts must now appear in court and submit themselves to cross-examination if their reports are admitted into evidence, according to a brand new ruling by the United States Supreme Court.

Last week's 5-4 ruling in Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts mandates forensic analysts must appear in court under the Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause which gives criminal defendants the right to confront witnesses.

Crime lab analysts previously were rarely subpoenaed to testify about their reports.

Justice Scalia questioned the reliability of forensic science as a whole, mentioning a recent National Academy of Science report which raised a number of issues.

Rejecting the Prosecutor's position that forensic reports, as scientific findings, are neutral facts rather than accusatory testimony, he opined:

"Forensic evidence is not uniquely immune from the risk of manipulation. According to a recent study conducted under the auspices of the National Academy of Sciences. & Confrontation is designed to weed out not only the fraudulent analyst, but the incompetent one as well. Serious deficiencies have been found in the forensic evidence used in criminal trials."

"Like expert witnesses generally, an analyst's lack of proper training or deficiency in judgment may be disclosed in cross-examination."

Each state is left to establish a procedure for contesting lab reports and calling analysts to court, so it is too soon to tell what the ruling's full consequences are.

This decision means a significant, future financial impact on crime labs by requiring analysts also to appear. It usually takes twelve to twenty-four months to hire and train a new analyst, even if one's budget supports new hirings.

Even considering that approximately 9 & 1/2 out of 10 cases end in a plea bargain, rights must be protected in that 5% that go to trial!

"The Confrontation Clause may make the prosecution of criminals more burdensome, but that is equally true of the right to trial by jury and the privilege against self-incrimination. The Confrontation Clause--like those other constitutional provisions-- is binding, and we may not disregard it at our convenience."

DUI Specialist Rick Mueller is the only San Diego DUI attorney who was the featured Speaker at 7 DUI seminars in San Diego County in the last several years. Rick Mueller is known as the "DMV Guru".

Rate this Article:

0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s)

Re-Publish

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/criminal-articles/new-supreme-court-ruling-laboratory-analysts-must-now-appear-in-court-1007057.html

Article Tags: Supreme Court Dui Lawyer San Diego

Related Videos
Related Articles
Ask / Related Q&A

Play

Leadership on the Supreme Court

Play

How does the Supreme court works Part 1

Play

How does the Supreme court works Part 2

Play

What are Miranda Rights

Play

The Legal Right to Picket

Latest Criminal Articles
More from Rick Mueller

DUI Lawyers Do Help

By: Maria Palma | 28/11/2009
I know that there are many people out there who think that DUI lawyers (or any lawyer, for that matter) are just after the money. There's this belief that lawyers don't care whether someone is guilty or not - as long as they can pay for the bill, well, that's all that matters. Many DUI lawyers in particular face criticism from people because they're defending people who have been drunk driving.

Minneapolis Criminal Lawyer : The Right Answer when Charged with a Crime

By: Naveen kumar sharma | 27/11/2009
Being accused or charged with a crime can be very embarrassing as well as frightening. If you or a loved one has been arrested or accused for a criminal charge, then it’s extremely important to retain the services of a Minneapolis Criminal Lawyer to protect your rights.

What Makes Spongebob Coloring Pages So Fun is the Fun of Coloring

By: Daren Moss | 26/11/2009
How many times have you simply sat there with a box of crayons or coloring pencils and a coloring book or coloring pages and just enjoyed yourself for a little while? It truly is not that surprising that there are as many adults that truly love coloring as there are youngsters that love this activity. Too many times adults sit there and hide the proven fact that they like or love to color as much as their youngsters, or the kids in their lives, do. Think about this and answer this q...

What Makes Spongebob Coloring Pages So Fun is the Fun of Coloring

By: Daren Moss | 26/11/2009
How many times have you simply sat there with a box of crayons or coloring pencils and a coloring book or coloring pages and just enjoyed yourself for a little while? It actually is not that surprising that there are as many adults that really love coloring as there are kids that love this activity. Too many times adults sit there and hide the indisputable fact that they still like or like to color as much as their youngsters, or the children in their lives, do. Think about this and...

Criminal Records Search Done On The Web

By: Ben Dave | 26/11/2009
The online fee-based method to search for Criminal records is commonly utilized by the people these days because it’s totally hassle-free.

How to avoid jail time

By: Robert Miller | 25/11/2009
A guide to alternative options to avoid having the jail cell lock behind you. Steps, and choices, towards making even a mandatory jail sentence a distant choice in any case.

How to get a restricted license in a California DUI case

By: Robert Miller | 25/11/2009
Information on obtaining a restricted license through the DMV. A restricted license allows persons to drive ONLY for the following purposes: • to work; • from work • during the "course and scope" of employment; and • to and from any required alcohol classes.

Public Criminal Background Check - How To Get The Most From Public Background Checks

By: Tanner Hemingway | 24/11/2009
Doing a public criminal background check today has become part of the landscape that is society.

Unlawful or Lawful Arrest DMV finding after California DUI?

By: Rick Mueller | 15/07/2009 | Criminal
Though not expressly stated in VC §§13353(c)(2) or 13557(b)(2)(B), other statutes and case authority establish that what is actually required in a DMV administrative per se hearing as a result of a California DUI arrest is proof that the person was “lawfully” arrested.

New Supreme Court Ruling: Laboratory analysts must now appear in court

By: Rick Mueller | 01/07/2009 | Criminal
Laboratory analysts must now appear in court and submit themselves to cross-examination if their reports are admitted into evidence, according to a brand new ruling by the United States Supreme Court.

Did You Just Find Out You Have A San Diego Dui Bench Warrant For Your Arrest?

By: Rick Mueller | 02/03/2009 | Criminal
If you live in San Diego, California, you might be arrested by police and sent to San Diego county jail. You could be stopped for a driving infraction and taken to jail. They could also come to your home or office.

Background Checks & Expungement of a San Diego California Dui / Drunk Driving Conviction

By: Rick Mueller | 10/10/2008 | Criminal
Tips to removing a California DUI from your record, and the benefits of consulting a specialist to assist.