Electronic Discovery: Basic Framework

| Posted: 05-06-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 33 | Rating: (94)

(?)

Although the details of each E-Discovery effort will vary from case to case, there are certain similarities that exists between them. Basic data formats have evolved over the past few years into de facto standards used for the collection, review, and production of electronic documents. The steps taken to ensure quality are also generally applicable to most cases. Proper handling of ESI processing should begin with the following basic framework:

ANALYSIS & PRESERVATION:
Technology has created an incredibly mobile society. Aside from the normal desktop or notebook computers, data and evidence can now also be found on PDAs, iPods, Voice-mail, the Internet, flash thumb drives, and much. Keep in mind that data can spread around the globe and are not necessarily tied to business property.

COLLECTION:
Data should always be forensically duplicated wherever possible. Should the metadata, or deleted files of a potential witness ever come into question, a simple copy job would not stand up in court.

REVIEW & PRODUCTION PLATFORMS:
One of the main questions which should be decided prior to proceeding with the review, is the format in which the Review and Production should be made. The current "standard" is to provide TIFF files for production. Depending on the situations surrounding the case (amount of data, cost, and timing), various other formats may serve better for the review process. Below are some quick pros and cons:

TIFFs: These are the industry formats, and are generally the preferred format for all litigation related software and systems. TIFFs can easily be reviewed electronically, and bates schemes, along with redactions can be electronically applied with speed and accuracy. TIFFs' main drawback is the lack of visual appeal and color. All files are viewed in black and white or grayscaled format.

PDFs: Adobe's PDF format is fast becoming a popular favorite as images. Its key draw is its visual look. It comes in color and is a true representation of what the native document looks like. However,, it is still far from being a simple file to work with. PDF documents, unless used within specific hosting systems, lacks the ability to quickly apply bates numbers and redactions.

NATIVE: Document reviews done in native format can be a great time and cost saver. With no need to wait for processing or cost to convert the images, native format review presents a very attractive solution. And while the process is indeed perfect as an initial culling, it lacks many of the litigation review tools that are necessary for production. Native document reviews are at the mercy of the file type, meaning a lack of redaction and bates numbering tools. Generally, native formats are used for a first review to quickly remove irrelevant documents, prior to a conversion of the remaining documents for a more in-depth production review (though native productions are fast becoming favorites as new technology come into play.

CRITERIA/ISSUES:
Many review issues should be considered prior to the commencement of the review. Among them is clarity on unitization, legal issues, and folder paths:

UNITIZATION: Unitization refers to document break distinction - the start and end page which defines a document. For most electronic files, the document breaks are fairly straight forward - 1 MS Word file equals 1 Document. However, what if the Word document was attached to an e-mail? Would 1 Document = the email and Word document? or would that be considered 2 separate documents? And if one is privileged would both items automatically be privileged? Deciding on unitization ahead of time will give the reviewers and the processors a better understanding of the desired end result.

FOLDER PATHS: The world of paper litigation is familiar with the phrase "in the ordinary course of doing business". The equivalent of a review/production in the electronic world, is the file path. The directory and folder paths of each file should be maintained so that the review and eventual production can be conducted properly, where all documents can be identified as they would in the course of doing business.

LEGAL ISSUES: Another important part of a smooth review is a mutual team understanding of the issues involved in the case. Issues, folders, or tags, should be specified ahead of time and conveyed to all reviewers and data processors. Is the focus on fraud? related to a specific product? a specific date? a specific witness? By clarifying these issues, confusion and delay can be greatly avoided.

FILTERING & CONVERSION PROCESS:
Not all data collected need to be review. Most computer files contain generic system files which can be eliminated from the review process completely as it will have no relevance to the case at hand. Using specific key word or date filters prior to the conversion process will help to eliminate expense and time on the review of irrelevant material. System operation files, internet temp files, spam and personal e-mail can be cut from the review without fear of missing anything important.

ORGANIZATION & REVIEW:
The review process is the bulk of the work during electronic discovery. Make sure your reviewers have been sufficiently trained, have a thorough understanding of the issues at hand, and have a steady stream of documents for them to look at. When organizing documents for review, keep in mind that it is more efficient to assign reviewers similar groups of documents or documents from a single individual. Conversation threads should be kept together if possible, and document groups should be based on subject. This will ensure maximum understanding of the issues, as well as a smooth judgment process. Depending on the skill level of the reviewers, generally a second level privilege review should be in place to do a quick quality check of all reviewed documents.

PRIVILEGE & REDACTION LOGS:
The review databases are not only for flipping through relevant documents. Most systems also help track redaction and privilege information. Consult with your service provider on how to make use of the system information to quickly export a redaction
or privilege log. With a large database of documents, this simple feature can be a real time and money saver.

PRODUCTION & ARCHIVAL:
Keep in mind that production with electronic documents is not a simple process. Lead time and quality checks should be built into the production process. This is especially true if the production is being done by a service provider offsite, processing and mailing time should be factored into all productions.

Rate this Article:

Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).

Article Tags: Electronic Discovery, Litigation Support, Dcoument Management, Document Production

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/cyber-law-articles/electronic-discovery-basic-framework-439788.html

Print article

Send to friend

Publish this Article

Author feedback

About the Author:

Article by Andrew P. Li

Mr. Li is a Litigation Support and E-Discovery trainer and consultant with over a decade of experience. He is the owner of APLCS, LLC (http://www.aplcs.com) and can be reached at requests@aplcs.com

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Add new Comment

Electronic Discovery 2.0
By: datatriage | 26/06/2007 | Data Recovery
Electronic Discovery 2.0, or “e-discovery 2.0” refers to the next generation of processes, technologies, and services that streamline and modernize the traditional e-discovery process as well as allows businesses to manage huge volumes of data, lower costs, and meet tight deadlines. In this Electronic Discovery process civil litigants seek to acquire information from both parties and from third parties.

A Peek Into the World of Hi-tech Litigation Support
By: Karen Unger | 31/07/2007 | Customer Service
At the heart of any legal undertaking is the mass of data that legal professionals need to perform their jobs. The demanding task of acquiring and organizing the documents that comprise this data is known as litigation support. It's a task that requires a high level or organizational ability and a painstaking attention to detail. And with these documents increasingly in electronic form, litigation support professionals need IT skills as well as legal and organisational expertise.

10 Critical Decisions for Successful E-discovery Part 1
By: Karen Unger | 17/11/2007 | Customer Service
The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure’s recent emphasis on producing electronically stored information requires that the e-discovery team understands the collection and processing choices to be made and their ramifications.

10 Critical Decisions for Successful E-discovery Part 2
By: Karen Unger | 18/11/2007 | Customer Service
The Federal Rules of Civil Procedureีs recent emphasis on producing electronically stored information requires that the e-discovery team understands the collection and processing choices to be made and their ramifications.

Computer Forensics Vs. Electronic Discovery
By: Karen Unger | 18/11/2007 | Customer Service
The field of computer forensics was developed primarily by law enforcement personnel for investigating drug and financial crimes. Electronic discovery has its roots in the field of civil litigation support and deals with organizing electronic files.

E-forensics: Critical Steps in Capturing Legally Defensible E-data
By: Karen | 31/03/2008 | Law
e-Forensics is the application of electronic investigation to uncover information that is not readily available or viewable to the average user. These deleted or hidden files can often contain vital electronic information that is important to your case, but identifying it is like searching for the proverbial needle in a haystack.

The Human Factor of Electronic Discovery
By: Andrew P. Li | 05/06/2008 | Cyber Law
The rapid invasion of technology within the corporate world has forced a steady (and speedy) change to the legal landscape. That E-Discovery is now a part of an attorney’s life and requires focus is no longer resisted (and certainly, can no longer be ignored). E-Discovery is here to stay, that will not change – what has to change (and should change) over the years is our approach.

The Ratio of Electronic Files to Paper in E-discovery
By: Andrew P. Li | 05/06/2008 | Cyber Law
Attorneys and paralegals (and really any professional working in the legal field) have always worked in the realm of paper and file folders. Their work-habits and thought processes have been tuned with the tangible, and therefore have a strong need to convert the ethereal bits & bytes of technology into sheets of clean paper.

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Q&A Powered by:

Latest Cyber Law Articles

What is Cybercrime?
By: Randy Vezina | 05/09/2008
It's complicated. Cybercrime cannot be described by any one word. Just like crime as we know it, cybercrime has many different applications and can occur anytime and anyplace. Identity thieves and other criminals use several different methods, depending on how much they know and what their objective is. Cybercrime is 'crime' involving some sort of a 'computer' or 'cyber' factor.

Bots and Cybercrime and Identity Theft
By: Randy Vezina | 05/09/2008
No one person can say for sure how large a role bots play in cybercrime today. Cybercrime will, at some point, make use of a botnet to do everything from spamming to hosting fraudulent Web sites. Internet security software giant Symantec has protected people from bots for a lot of years and has tracked the evolution of bots from basic threats to highly complicated crimeware.

Critical Analysis of Cyber Law
By: Ashutosh Kaushik | 28/08/2008
Information Technology Act, 2000 is the first and the only legislation of its kind in India. It is the only act in India which deals with cyber space and Information Technology laws. Though as compared to other areas of law it is still a new legislation but still, eight years have passed since the act was enacted and in these eight years technology has changed at a much faster pace. This article discusses some of the the major lacunas of the Information Technology Act, 2000.

Cyber Crimes
By: Sidhartha Roy | 28/08/2008
The article is about a new breed of crime which is promising to threaten human life and property in a completely hi-tech manner.In my article i have highlighted about cyber crime,its modes , how it is different from the conventional crime and also about its statutory provision.

Cyber Crimes - an Overview and the Measures
By: Harsh | 27/08/2008
This paper contributes an understanding of the effects of negative use of Information technology, and how far the present law in India is successful in dealing with the issue, and what way is the legal structure lagging to curb the crime. Possible changes needed in the system and the ways to combat cyber terrorism having safe and trustworthy transactions

Porn Can be Found on Hard Drive by Computer Forensics and Used to Imprison You!
By: Valeri Tkatchenko | 27/08/2008
Police Investigators are now cracking down on illegal porn and throwing hundreds of people in prison for having illegal images and videos on their computers... Illegal porn can be found by Computer Forensics in minutes... no matter how hard you try to get rid of porn and try to delete it they will still find it. It can cost you your job, family and even imprisonment!

The Various Types of Lawyers Available in Pennsylvania Help You Settle Your Legal Disputes Soon
By: Daniel Kaffee | 22/08/2008
Specialized lawyers in Pennsylvania include Family Law Lawyers, Litigation Lawyers, Personal Injury Lawyers, Real Estate Lawyers, and Criminal Lawyers etc. They help solve your legal tangles with expertise.

Introduction to Promissory Letter by Find a Solicitor
By: Rebecca Lim | 20/08/2008
A promissory letter is a paper which contains the signature and name by 2 parties or more, who’re in a trade and negotiations circumstances. In general, this file presents when an individual intends to get a sum of funds from the other individual, given that the individual has stated he/she will give back the whole-sum of funds to the lender, at the précised time and date, in addition to any percentage of the principal amount and further conditions assured in the agreement.

More from Andrew P. Li

Electronic Evidence & Information Gluttony
By: Andrew P. Li | 05/06/2008 | Cyber Law
In this current age of the "Information Superhighway," companies literally "do not know what they know." And for attorneys who must review this avalanche of information (often from multiple sources) to ferret out "smoking guns" for a trial, this problem of information overload is much more compounded.

Article Categories

Article Marketing

Article Notepad

Stop Duplicate Content

Term Papers

Follow ArticlesBase at http://twitter.com

Need Help?

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (0.34, 17)

Electronic Discovery: Basic Framework

Article Comments

Related Articles

Got a Question? Ask.

Latest Cyber Law Articles

More from Andrew P. Li

Need Help?

Site Links

Webmasters

Business Info

Sign up for our email newsletter