Retired professor of philosophy and logic who blogs on social, political, and economic issues at http://johnkozy.mindsay.com and http://www.jkozy.com/. Tries to avoid mere opinion and propaganda and emphasizes logic, facts, and evidence. All or any part of his articles can be cited or distributed when properly attributed.
You have all seen the ads. Buy this and save 20 percent. Buy that and save 40 percent. The more you buy the more you save.
Marketers either must have flunked grammar school English or are abettors of thieves.
The word save means "to accumulate money." The word spend means "to pay out or expend money." These words are antonyms. The logical word is contradictories. No one saves anything by spending!
Suze Orman gives consumers a lot of good advice, but not about investing. She claims that investing in the market is a good way of saving for retirement. But it isn't; it isn't even saving.
When one invests in the market, s/he is buying shares of stock, and buying a stock certificate is just like buying anything else. What is paid for those certificates is money spent. Shares are what a buyer owns, and shares are not money.
Financial advisors like Suze make the claim that share prices increase, on average, over time. There are two things wrong with this claim. First, it is not true that share prices, on average, increase over all periods of time.
For instance, if one takes the time period from Oct. 9, 2007 to March 4, 2009, share prices, on average, have fallen 51.5%. Of course, one can select time periods over which share prices, on average, have risen, but the selection of time periods is completely arbitrary. Select one time period and one can claim that share prices rise on average; select another time period and one can claim that share prices fall on average. So the claim is nonsensical.
Second, averages are phantom numbers. No one ever earns an average return. A few people may earn a return that equals the average return, but not most people. Averages are calculated from a list of terms, and except for the single case in which the average equals the median, the number of terms below the average is always greater than the number of terms that exceed the average. So deluding investors by implying that by investing they can expect a return equal to the average is nothing but a bald faced lie. So even if a person's returns from selling his/her investments is greater than what he/she purchased them for, and that calculation is difficult to make since shares are bought at different times and are then subject to different inflation rates, chances are that the return will be far less than the phantom average which is also difficult to calculate for the same reasons as those stated above.
Owning a share of stock is just like owning a piece of furniture, and just as a piece of furniture is not money, neither is a share of stock. What the future value of a share of stock is can never be known. Just like a piece of furniture, its value cannot be determined until one tries to sell it. And as anyone who has tried to sell used furniture has learned, its value may be zero.
Investing in the market is no more saving than buying soup is.
© 2009 John Kozy
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
- Saving, Investing and Building a Business - Important Lessons Learned at Boys and Girls Club “money Matters” Program
- Universal Life Insurance | Save, Invest in the Universal Life Insurance Policy and be Relaxed
- Energy Saving Investments That Are Worth It
- Ways to Help you Invest
- Should I Invest?
- Joint Investing Important Financial Questions to Answer Before Marriage
- The Thrills Of Investing In The Stock Market
- Saving Money From Income - are You a Saver or Spender?
Mind Boggling Numbers
By: Ernie Fitzpatrick | 15/11/2009We're so far into the economic rabbit hole that we'll never be able to get out, but don't tell anyone!
The Beauty of Competition
By: Keith Brandon | 12/11/2009Competition is the only force to control costs and consequently prices. Corruption in government and giant corporations work together to interfere with fair competition for economic gain. The victims are the U.S. economy and our grandchildren.
Public Bank Energy Investment
By: Andrew Spark | 11/11/2009Investment and grants in clean energy from international development banks and organisations reached $8.3bn in 2007, rising from $6bn in 2006. This number looks set to continue increasing in the coming years.
Spanish Clean Energy Incentives
By: Andrew Spark | 11/11/2009Spain benefits from a Feed in Tariff system. There are also a number of other incentives and laws which are described below by sector:
Gold Sails Past $1,100
By: Ernie Fitzpatrick | 11/11/2009The US$ continues to sink into the Western sunset as gold continues to rise in the East!
The Next Shoe To Drop
By: Ernie Fitzpatrick | 10/11/2009How will Christmas be this year? If the retailers don't get a good one, it may be their last one.
Clean Camera, Clear Capture
By: Felicia luo | 06/11/2009A clean digital camera not only looks better outside, it also work better inside, giving us superior enjoyment.
Clean Camera, Clear Capture
By: Felicia luo | 06/11/2009A clean digital camera not only looks better outside, it also work better inside, giving us superior enjoyment.
Balderdashing Education Bashing
By: John Kozy | 14/11/2009 | EducationWhen Calvin Coolidge said "The business of America is business," he and very few if any others knew just how deep this sentiment would sink into the American consciousness. Now it seems apparent that the way business thinks has muscled every other kind of thought process out of the American mind. The unfortunate result is that if no business solution exists to an American ailment, it festers into an incurable American disease.
Killer Country
By: John Kozy | 10/11/2009 | CultureAmerica is a killing field! It has been for a very long time. Historically, the oppressed have killed their oppressors. In America the oppressed kill each other. American politicians claim that America is the free-world's leader. But what other country would want to follow America down this road? It is noteworthy that since 1789, approximately 70 nations have become democratic, but not a single one has copied the American model. Whom are we leading where? Perhaps only ourselves to perdition.
Are Settled Class Action Suits Scams?
By: John Kozy | 05/11/2009 | LawThinking about filing a class action suit? First find a lawyer who understands that if s/he is unable to negotiate a substantial award for each member of the settlement class, you will insist that the suit be taken to trial; otherwise, you are merely involving yourself in a lawyerly boondoggle in which the lawyers will use your misery to enrich themselves. If your lawyer is not going to get you and your colleagues substantial awards, at least make sure that s/he does not get any either.
Dumb, Dumber, and Dumbest in Higher Education
By: John Kozy | 22/10/2009 | College & UniversityAs an elderly, former university professor, I am deeply anguished whenever I come across shameful academic writing. Such writing not only exposes the inability of the writer but it exhibits the extent of decline in American university teaching and is a symptom of a decadent civilization. Institutions that employ these writers have abandoned the classical educational ideals of truth, goodness, and beauty for belief, greed, and exploitation. And not only Americans but the whole world is paying a h
Nobel? That's No Prize
By: John Kozy | 22/10/2009 | News & SocietyExcellent journalism was never a priority of Joseph Pulitzer's, and the prizes reflect it. So does the mainstream press which is yellower than ever in both the conventional journalistic sense and the colloquial sense of cowardly. Even worse, however, are the Nobels. They are almost always given to those committed to Western civilization and Capitalism. So now Obama has gotten the prize. Why was it awarded to him? Because he is a protector of the economic status quo and a hegemonist—a true child
Mortgage Anyone?
By: John Kozy | 01/10/2009 | MortgageWhy are the standard terms for mortgages 15 and 30 years? Could it be because downturns in the American economy have occurred on an average of once every 14.5 years? When a buyer defaults on a loan after paying on it for 14 years, the lender gets the house for free, sells it again, and nets a small fortune or an investment of zero. Wouldn't you like to find a way of doing that?
20-20's John Fossil (sic)
By: John Kozy | 14/09/2009 | JournalismJohn Stossel has claimed that governmental attempts to ameliorate malevolent conditions should be curtailed if not entirely prohibited so that people could be left alone to solve their own problems. No government is not a solution to bad government; good government is. A propagandist is not an honest man. Although everyone (perhaps) is entitled to his own opinion, no one has a right to present it as fact. Not even John Stossel.
Everywhere Arms Races
By: John Kozy | 12/09/2009 | PoliticsSecretary of State, Hillary Clinton, and President Obama claim that both North Korea and Iran must be prevented from developing nuclear capabilities to prevent arms races in North East Asia and the Near East. But the United States of America began the international nuclear arms race more than sixty years ago and has never taken the task of eliminating nuclear weapons seriously. So yes, as ye sow, so shall ye reap! Why should anyone expect otherwise.