 |
A Federal Match Makes College More Affordable For Scholarship Students
Author: Stuart Nachbar  | Posted: 03-02-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 7 | Rating: (50)  (?) 
As 2007 drew to a close, four of the nation's most selective colleges: Harvard, Duke, Swarthmore and Pomona, all announced plans to revamp their financial aid policies by replacing loans with grants. Other institutions, most notably Princeton and Columbia, had already implemented similar plans.
Harvard's policy is novel; according to the Chronicle of Higher Education, the university announced that families with incomes between $120,000 and $180,000 would be asked to contribute no more than 10 percent of their student's total expenses for college, while the neediest families would pay nothing. Harvard will raise its student financial aid budget by $22 million to implement this policy. With a $35 billion endowment, highest in the nation, Harvard can afford to do it; the added monies for aid are just a drop in the bucket.
This is good news for anyone wishing to apply to Harvard; cost is less of a detriment to well-qualified candidates in upper middle class families. A $180,000 family income gets spread awfully thin when there's more than one child in college and the family lives in a high-cost metro area. But if cost is less of a detriment to going to Harvard, than Harvard will become more selective, because the number of applications will surely rise.
This has a ripple effect, students apply to more colleges, so they're sure they will be admitted somewhere; other institutions become more selective too. Few can afford to do what Harvard has done. Imagine the resentment in a household where a Harvard reject must attend their safety school - and must pay more than they would have paid to go to Harvard, even if the safety school is their state university.
It's difficult to pity families in this predicament; the parents earn a good income and their child has not wanted for much, until this point. There are small tax credits; the Hope Tax Credit allows a deduction of $1,650 per student for the first two years of college, and the Life Long Learning Tax Credit may cover up to $2,000 of tuition for the remaining years. The cap on family income for these credits is $114,000.
The relief is paltry when I consider that Rutgers, my home state university, costs $20,000 for tuition, fees, room and board for an in-state student. It's reasonable to expect the entering freshmen and their parents to spend $100,000 for a bachelor's degree after four years, and certainly after five.
Government loans can't cover the total cost of a Rutgers degree; the maximum undergraduates may borrow ranges from $7,500 to $10,500 - and that's for a combination of interest-subsidized and unsubsidized loans. The maximum they may borrow for four years is $37,000; this principal is unlikely to rise as fast as Rutgers' tuition.
The federal government allows borrowers to consolidate those loans and repay them over 20 years; our $37,000 borrower repays $295 a month.
Assuming they qualified; there are needs tests associated with these loans.
Assuming they have no other loans at higher interest rates; the interest on interest - subsidized loans is 6.8 percent, and 7.9 percent for unsubsidized loans. Lord help any college student or parent who pays more principal and interest on student loans; it's not worth it.
So what's a family to do, if federal loans can't cover the difference between their resources and the total cost of college?
I guess they could hope their child gets into Harvard, or its kin.
Or they could hope that colleges loosen their purse strings; according to the National Association of College and University Business Administrators, the average institution spends only 4.6 percent of their endowment. The approach of Congress and the Bush Administration has been to slap colleges on the wrist and tell them to or loosen purse strings so that financial aid spending can be cut. The finger pointing is useless; the colleges have little to no incentive to cooperate.
The way I see it, we need an incentive to encourage schools to make more scholarship aid available, to encourage students and parents to become more financially prudent, and encourage students to do their best in the classroom. Grades are still important interview selection criteria; recruiters ask career centers to filter resumes by GPA before they see them.
Therefore, I propose a new incentive that I call the Federal Scholarship Match.
It works like this: for every dollar, up to $7,500, earned through an academic or service scholarship, the federal government would match it, up to the total cost of tuition, fees, room and board. This would not preclude a student from receiving other assistance; if the match doesn't meet the total financial need, the student can receive loans or other aid.
Thus, for example, a bright student who receives a $3,000 scholarship to Rutgers (from any source other than the federal government: private, state, the school) would receive an additional $3,000. If he received a full-tuition ($8,500 today) scholarship, he'd receive an additional $7,500 in federal match, so he and his family would be responsible for the balance, or $4,000.
The family with the six-figure income could pay the $4,000 out of their pocket - or the student could earn it through employment.
I can just see the head spins and eye rolls in some quarters of the higher education community; this proposal redefines the idea of need-based aid. This is what I'd hear: The match puts the needs of the brightest, regardless of income, over the truly needy. It would also reduce the number of full-ride scholarships offered out of college coffers because the government would chip in.
I disagree with the first point; if a student was motivated enough to earn a scholarship, they deserve the opportunity to go to college. They also deserve to stay, if they were motivated enough to maintain the grades to keep it.
The second point is true, but colleges could offer an affordable education to more students. The matching program needs a catch: colleges must loosen their purse strings to qualify for the match and agree to aid more students.
In effect, the federal government would give every college the incentive to follow Harvard's lead.
Who knows: a success match program could encourage Congress to offer young taxpayers a tax credit to help sustain it; thankful recipients could apply some of the money that they might be applying to student loan debt.
And they'd help future generations, including their children, pay for college.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/education-articles/a-federal-match-makes-college-more-affordable-for-scholarship-students-323173.html
About the Author:Stuart Nachbar has been involved with education politics, policy and technology as a student, urban planner, government affairs manager, software executive, and now as author of The Sex Ed Chronicles. Visit his blog, Educated Quest
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
Merit Scholarships Should Be Earned Not Handed Out
By: Stuart Nachbar | 03/06/2008 | Education
I've read about the decisions of flagship state universities to increase merit-based, not need-based scholarships to the best-of-best students, the ones who might have chosen an Ivy League school, or other highly selective private college.
This is not an academic strategy as much as it is an economic development strategy; state...
The Basics Of The Student Loan Mess
By: Stuart Nachbar | 26/05/2008 | Education
These past weeks there has been talk in the higher education press about private lenders and state guarantee agencies either withdrawing from the government-subsidized student loan market or refusing to underwrite new loans. These financial institutions cite either a cash crunch or a credit crunch, or reductions in the federal...
Good Student Credit Should Be A Corporate Social Responsibility
By: Stuart Nachbar | 26/05/2008 | Finance
The March 18 USA Today had an interesting cover story in education politics: Colleges' debit card deals draw scrutiny.
The purpose of these deals is to foster computerized cashless transactions on-campus, for example purchasing books, meals or tickets to athletic events through a debit card that doubles as a student ID....
Consolidating During your Grace Period
By: Matthew Kelly | 26/01/2007 | College and University
Why is it important to consolidate your federal student loans before your grace period is up? Because it will save you money!
All Scholarship Applications are Alike, Right?
By: Dale Clifton, The Scholarship Doctor | 03/03/2006 | Education
Learning how to "personalize" will be the extra ingredient that causes scholarship committees to notice your application.
Scholarships: The Top 10 Strangest Ways to Pay for College
By: Ben Welch | 13/07/2007 | Finance
Scholarships are a great way to pay for college education. The problem is that scholarships are typically merit-based, which means they are usually reserved for students with 4.0 GPAs or star athletes. Thankfully, there are scholarships that rely on other kinds of distinction.
Find Out the Truth About College Scholarships
By: Jon Arnold | 06/04/2007 | Finance
There is a dirty little secret about college scholarships, and that is that many go unawarded each year simply because nobody applied for them! Understand what scholarships are available and get those applications in, since the cost of a college education is going through the roof, and you can get a scholarship.
New College Grants for the 2006-2007 School Year
By: Brian Harbinson | 21/04/2007 | Education
College Grants and money for college from Government Grants. College Grants or College Funding to help grow your career. Matthew Lesko wants to show you how you can do it!
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
I wanted to tell me if national college was a good ...
By: bigmand32 | 22-07-2008
i wanted to tell me if national college was a good place intend school.
Looking for the soils report/boring logs for The ...
By: Jeff Pease | 22-07-2008
looking for the soils report/boring logs for The Grossmont College Health Physical Sciences District
Pacing calendar
By: dleeodahl | 22-07-2008
Is there a month pacing calendar for Literacy and Writing that can be found online or purchaed? I have the writing and reading curriculum, but I have new teachers that don't know and have never used curriculum. I need something that I can give to them that will guide them weekly.
DC
Gender Identity Help
By: daniellemtfts | 22-07-2008
Am I going to have to live the rest of my life, in the wrong body, because of financial distress, or will someone with a heart and some extra money, come to my rescue?
Really nice young man looking for room/board for Wharton College in Texas, Can you help?
By: room and board needed | 21-07-2008
A young man, age 18, is looking for room and board for area close to Wharton College in Texas. Parents can not pay. He works small part time job. Would pay cheap rent for a single room, just needs to be able to shower, and prepare for classes. May even be able to help with chores around the home. He's a good, honest kid that wants to succeed in life. Can anyone help him?
Northwest Ordinance of 1787
By: Larry Weaver | 21-07-2008
Robert M. Sutton of the University of Illinois wrote an article about the Northwest Ordinance of 1787 to help recognize the bicentennial of the document. How do I get a copy of his article?
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Education Articles
How to Find Someone With Just an Address
By: Chad Kiser | 25/07/2008
Let's start with how to find people by address. That is the solution to this problem. Some sites that allow you to do this are listed in this article.
The Vedic System Of Education
By: Victor Epand | 25/07/2008
A Gurukul provides a type of education that ranges from how to live a life, to cooking and to running a business, among other things.
What Are Student Loans and Where to Find Them
By: Daniel Millions | 24/07/2008
There are basically two places where you want to actively look for student loans. The first would be the federal government and the second would be private lenders. In order to be considered for any of the loans given out by the federal government, you are first going to fill...
The Chickasaw Language
By: Jacob Lumbroso | 24/07/2008
The Chickasaw language is derived from the Muskogean family and is spoken by Chickasaw inhabitants of Southeastern Oklahoma. It is one of the less common Native American languages, as only about 1,000 individuals speak it today.
Disadvantages of Public Schooling
By: Uchenna Ani-Okoye | 24/07/2008
When we consign our children to public schools, we feel satisfied that they are receiving 'quality education'. But, are we really getting our money are worth?
Nazi Jews:a Historical Paradox
By: Brian Cuban | 24/07/2008
Would it surprise anyone to learn that there were upwards of 150, 000 soldiers of partial Jewish descent serving in the Nazi army during World War II?
Homeland Security: The New Age of Counterterrorism
By: Henley-Putnam University | 23/07/2008
After the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States, it became clear that much more needed to be done to protect America's freedoms and interests - both at home and abroad. The US Government, in response, created the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) over five years ago and...
Hypnotherapy Training Course
By: Khurram Zeb | 23/07/2008
Some things to keep in mind if you want to become a hypnotherapist.
More from Stuart Nachbar
Unintended Consequences of True School Choice
By: Stuart Nachbar | 07/07/2008 | Education
I always try to make it a point to see both sides of an education issue, and as Project Runway host Tim Gunn always tells his fashion designer cast, try to make it work.
The concept of true school choice fits that challenge.
The thought behind true school choice is that "dollars...
Comics For Extra Credit - Part 3
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Art and Entertainment
I've got Ironman to blame for catching the comic bug over the past few weeks. This weekend I went to see another Marvel character, The Incredible Hulk, be re-introduced to the public. This is the second Hulk movie in five years; the previous Hulk, directed by Ang Lee, more famous...
Citizens Owe Our Soldiers a New G.I. Bill
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Education
I have a novel in editing, a story of a college administration in the aftermath of the murder of a U.S. Army recruiting officer. I chose as my venue a privately supported engineering school, historically friendly to the military that had relied on receiving a considerable amount of tuition revenues...
Bi-Party Tickets Totally Senseless
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Politics
I receive a daily news feed from Salon, and for the past two days I have received articles about Obama-Hagel and McCain-Lieberman unity tickets. I have just three words for those who believe such events will happen: it ain't happening.
Abraham Lincoln was the last president to choose a vice president...
It Pays to Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Cowboys or Giants or Eagles or Redskins
By: Stuart Nachbar | 22/06/2008 | Sports and Fitness
NFL Draft Season is now upon us and if you're a pro football fan you already know about the widespread speculation about where your favorite players are going to plying their trade on Sundays, Mondays, and Thursdays and, if they're lucky, the weekends in January and February after their college...
A Bill to Protect Military Recruiters
By: Stuart Nachbar | 21/06/2008 | Education
I am completing Defending College Heights, a novel about an Irish Catholic family and a college administration in the aftermath of the murder of a U.S. Army recruiter. I started work on Defending because I had connections in the higher education community who were quite knowledgeable on the issues, or...
Do Graduation Reporting Standards Mean Anything?
By: Stuart Nachbar | 16/06/2008 | Education
Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings introduced new proposed regulations to help clarify how schools, districts and states implement policies and business practices under No Child Left Behind.
Among these proposals, Secretary Spellings has asked that high schools be required to use graduation rates that track cohorts of students as they progress...
Endowment Tax is Unsound Public Policy
By: Stuart Nachbar | 16/06/2008 | Education
I just read in the May 19 Christian Science Monitor that a Massachusetts legislator proposes a 2.5 percent tax on college endowments over $1 billion. The Commonwealth State has nine such institutions including Harvard, MIT, Williams, Boston College, Amherst, Wellesley, Tufts, Smith and Boston University; all of them are among...
|
|
Education 
