 |
A Student Government Election Made For TV - The Sequel
Author: Stuart Nachbar  | Posted: 16-05-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 3 | Rating: (162)  (?) 
This day, May 6, 2008, I spot a front page headline in my local New Jersey paper, The Trenton Times that reads: Ewing H.S vote is void a second time. I had previously commented on my hometown high school's senior class elections in a prior post, so I read on.
Seven students, one black and Hispanic, five black and one white, were barred from running in their senior class elections on April 23. The reason given was that the students had missed too many meetings for school activities and had not sufficiently participated in school fundraisers.
In my previous post on this election, I commented that such requirements were unreasonable for a student election; we do not require adults to show prior experience in politics to run for public office. I added that a school should have the right to deny students a right to vote if there are serious blots on their records: academic probation, repeat suspensions and criminal activity being examples. But neither faculty nor administrators in Ewing stated that any of the candidates who were denied the right to run was in any academic or behavioral difficulty.
I stepped back after writing that post and asked myself: was it possible that some of those students were in any difficulty, but the faculty and administrators said nothing, in order to protect the privacy of the students? It would have been inappropriate, not to mention embarrassing to the students' families to mention academic or behavioral difficulties to the media.
However, if this had been the case, then a responsible teacher or principal would have sent a personal letter to the student and their parents. But, based on reading the Times coverage, I have to believe the students were good standing or that the school didn't bother to inform them that they were not. All we have from the school system is a string of "no comments," which is nothing to go on.
At the end of last week, with the support of their superintendent, Ewing High School's principal and faculty advisors declared their senior class election a Mulligan. They called for a do-over; a new election where candidates who were denied an opportunity to run the first time were allowed to run for office, although they had little time to campaign. Those placed on the ballot for the first time might have achieved some recognition from the local news coverage that would have helped, but I do not know enough to say that students who could vote in this school election read the paper.
Then today's Times reports that the do-over was botched; the vote was disallowed after the principal and the faculty advisors realized that approximately 60 students were not eligible to vote because they owed fines. I'd guess these were fines for overdue books, failure to return school property, or to pay for damages to school property. I can not imagine other reasons for a high school to fine students.
But if this was a serious concern, why didn't the principal and faculty advisors stop these students from voting in the first election? If they were serious about assessing fines, they should have been equally serious about collecting them. It's not an unusual practice for a school to hold your diploma until you pay back unpaid fines and parking tickets, though I've never heard of a case where students in arrears were denied a right to vote in a student government election. I must add that had no one protested the first election, the votes of voters with outstanding fines would have counted.
I apologize to you, readers, if you believe that I might be beating this story to death, but it's too amusing to ignore. This is the first time, I'm aware of an election where people who owed fines were not eligible to vote. As adults we have the opportunity to vote in all sorts of elections: local, state and presidential, and we retain the right to vote if we owe back taxes, parking tickets, and of course, library fines.
Now there will be a third senior class election this week. I wonder if that should be put on hold a little longer to allow the principal and faculty advisors time to consider the meaning of free elections before they set the rules for a new contest.
(Originally published at Educated Quest blog and reprinted with permission of the author, Stuart Nachbar).
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/education-articles/a-student-government-election-made-for-tv-the-sequel-416795.html
About the Author:Contact Stuart Nachbar at Educated Quest, a blog on education politics, policy and technology or read about his first book, The Sex Ed Chronicle, a novel on education and politics in 1980 New Jersey, at Sex Ed Chronicles.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
A New Jersey Student Government Election Made For The Screen
By: Stuart Nachbar | 10/05/2008 | Education
This day, April 29, 2008, I spot a front page headline in my local New Jersey paper, The Trenton Times that reads: Students kept off ballot: District to explore race factor while rescheduling vote. Our local races for school board took place last week, so I thought this was an...
Romantic Trips and Destinations In New Jersey
By: Frank Dalotto | 02/03/2007 | Travel
The Best Romantic Trips and Getaways in New Jersey; Tips and Ideas for planning that memorable event
New Jersey Real Estate Market
By: Tom Beaty | 27/12/2007 | Real Estate
The New Jersey real estate market has just about everything and anything in any price range. Take a look at the New Jersey real estate market in Rumson. The nearest metro area is central New Jersey. It is an equal buyer to seller market with homes sitting between sixty and...
Joaquin Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon Make "walk the Line" Better Than the Film
By: Ed Bagley | 29/04/2008 | Art and Entertainment
"Walk the Line" is the story of Johnny Cash (Joaquin Phoenix) and June Carter Cash (Reese Witherspoon). Born poor in Arkansas, Cash rises to fame in the country music world and destroys a lot of relationships along the way with drinking, drugs and pandering. Phoenix and Witherspoon are outstanding in this film, even though the movie production could have been better.
Breakfast Pays Big Dividends in Boston Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/06/2006 | Education
For many years, scholars have recognized the link between a good breakfast and improved student behavior and academic performance. Boston schools see breakfast as their first tool of success.
Ohio Schools Closing the Gap for Students with Disabilities
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/06/2006 | Education
The Ohio Schools are redefining their Special Education program and closing the gap in the achievement of students with disabilities. The Ohio schools believe that achievement gaps are not the same as ability gaps, and the education system is responsible for ensuring that high achievement is an attainable goal for all students.
Overcrowding and Legislation Are Obstacles to Orlando Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/06/2006 | Education
The city of Orlando has a fast growing population and rapid development, creating a situation of overcrowding in the Orlando schools. The facilities are so overcrowded that, by the end of 2006, an estimated 40 percent of Orlando schools students will be taught in portable buildings — and the need is much greater than previously anticipated.
Washington D.C. School District Takes Aim at Language and Cultural Education
By: Stacy Andell | 28/06/2006 | Education
In 2004, the Washington D.C. enacted the Language Access Act. The Act was created in order to grant greater access to and participation in public schools and other public services for those residents that have limited or no English proficiency. The Act is designed to address four crucial areas of language use and access to public services.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Start of school
By: concerened | 23-07-2008
what are the best high schools and what day is the first day of school for the year?
Find a NYC DOE vendors to carry my books
By: Mike | 22-07-2008
I'm a new educational publisher seeking sales representatives who are DOE vendors to carry my titles. Who can help me find one?
Moving to CT.
By: Brana | 21-07-2008
Please tell me the all the differences between Niantic Ct. and Old Saybrook.
I am looking to relocate with my wife and two young children.
Thanks for your replys.
Phlebotomy school
By: ssmalluck | 21-07-2008
Hello,
Does anyone know of a full-time phlebotomy school in either San jose CA, Watsonville or anywhere close to Santa Cruz???
Education in laser technology
By: D. Hendy | 21-07-2008
I need a list of schools that offer education in laser technolgy . I would like to learn both the medical and industrial use of lasers.
Is a 2 day course for Baby Nanny beneficial in ...
By: mrgrmnt | 20-07-2008
Is a 2 day course for Baby Nanny beneficial in getting started as a Nanny
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Education Articles
Homeland Security: The New Age of Counterterrorism
By: Henley-Putnam University | 23/07/2008
After the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States, it became clear that much more needed to be done to protect America's freedoms and interests - both at home and abroad. The US Government, in response, created the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) over five years ago and...
Hypnotherapy Training Course
By: Khurram Zeb | 23/07/2008
Some things to keep in mind if you want to become a hypnotherapist.
The Hitler Pact: a Blood Oath
By: Brian Cuban | 23/07/2008
The Hitler newphews are alive and well in Long Island, NY. What can they tell us about their infamous uncle?
Maximize Your Speed Reading
By: Francis Hesse | 22/07/2008
Maximum Speed Reading is an incredible new program that will help you to read and comprehend massive amounts of written information - in any subject area - with unbelievable speed and remarkable retention and recall.
The Orginis of Plastering
By: Matt Morgan | 22/07/2008
An overview of the history of plastering buildings.
The Cherokee Language
By: Jacob Lumbroso | 21/07/2008
Like many other languages, the Cherokee tongue is named after its people, the Cherokee. It is classified under the Iroquoian language family, and it is the only Southern one from the group that is still used.
How to Select the Perfect Cell Phone for You
By: Richard Adams | 19/07/2008
Discusses 4 elements to consider when buying a new cell phone.
Biodiesel and the Kyoto Protocol
By: Mervyn Rees | 19/07/2008
I thought I would chat about some aspects affecting the production of biodiesel. The Kyoto Protocol goes by a number of aliases: The Kyoto Treaty, The Kyoto Accord, or The Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
More from Stuart Nachbar
Unintended Consequences of True School Choice
By: Stuart Nachbar | 07/07/2008 | Education
I always try to make it a point to see both sides of an education issue, and as Project Runway host Tim Gunn always tells his fashion designer cast, try to make it work.
The concept of true school choice fits that challenge.
The thought behind true school choice is that "dollars...
Comics For Extra Credit - Part 3
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Art and Entertainment
I've got Ironman to blame for catching the comic bug over the past few weeks. This weekend I went to see another Marvel character, The Incredible Hulk, be re-introduced to the public. This is the second Hulk movie in five years; the previous Hulk, directed by Ang Lee, more famous...
Citizens Owe Our Soldiers a New G.I. Bill
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Education
I have a novel in editing, a story of a college administration in the aftermath of the murder of a U.S. Army recruiting officer. I chose as my venue a privately supported engineering school, historically friendly to the military that had relied on receiving a considerable amount of tuition revenues...
Bi-Party Tickets Totally Senseless
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Politics
I receive a daily news feed from Salon, and for the past two days I have received articles about Obama-Hagel and McCain-Lieberman unity tickets. I have just three words for those who believe such events will happen: it ain't happening.
Abraham Lincoln was the last president to choose a vice president...
It Pays to Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Cowboys or Giants or Eagles or Redskins
By: Stuart Nachbar | 22/06/2008 | Sports and Fitness
NFL Draft Season is now upon us and if you're a pro football fan you already know about the widespread speculation about where your favorite players are going to plying their trade on Sundays, Mondays, and Thursdays and, if they're lucky, the weekends in January and February after their college...
A Bill to Protect Military Recruiters
By: Stuart Nachbar | 21/06/2008 | Education
I am completing Defending College Heights, a novel about an Irish Catholic family and a college administration in the aftermath of the murder of a U.S. Army recruiter. I started work on Defending because I had connections in the higher education community who were quite knowledgeable on the issues, or...
Do Graduation Reporting Standards Mean Anything?
By: Stuart Nachbar | 16/06/2008 | Education
Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings introduced new proposed regulations to help clarify how schools, districts and states implement policies and business practices under No Child Left Behind.
Among these proposals, Secretary Spellings has asked that high schools be required to use graduation rates that track cohorts of students as they progress...
Endowment Tax is Unsound Public Policy
By: Stuart Nachbar | 16/06/2008 | Education
I just read in the May 19 Christian Science Monitor that a Massachusetts legislator proposes a 2.5 percent tax on college endowments over $1 billion. The Commonwealth State has nine such institutions including Harvard, MIT, Williams, Boston College, Amherst, Wellesley, Tufts, Smith and Boston University; all of them are among...
|
|
Education 
