 |
Colleges Make Web-Based Response To College Rankings
Author: Stuart Nachbar  | Posted: 16-11-2007 | Comments: 0 | Views: 18 | Rating: (53)  (?) 
Americans love rankings; educated consumers want to know what's the best on the market for autos, electronics, airline services, and hotels among other things. Educated businesspeople take high rankings seriously, loudly shouting independent praises through their advertising.
But college administrators dislike rankings. I understand some of the reasons why; it's almost impossible to compare dissimilar schools and the formulas and methodologies are considered non-scholarly by academics. College presidents have said that peer assessment means little when their peers base their judgments on the past perceptions of their schools.
This year, according to U.S. News and World Report, a record low 51 percent of college presidents completed their reputational survey in which they rank their peer institutions. Eight years ago, more than two-thirds completed it. This peer assessment represents 25 percent of a school's overall ranking. I could guess that the rankings would be less valid as more schools refuse to share information, as well as reliable statistics with the magazine.
However, you can't keep a good journalistic team down. U.S. News and World Report has been collecting and compiling this information for 24 years. Data collection and compilation for these rankings have been refined nine times, partly in response to institutional concerns. They have plenty of incentive; the America's Best Colleges issue and print guide are hot selling magazines. They would not be hot-sellers if they didn't try to be ahead of the curve and become more statistically valid.
Like it or not, these rankings are not going away. Not as long as colleges advertise high rankings as if they're a "good housekeeping seal" of approval. All educational institutions K-12, colleges and universities are operating in an era where parents and policy makers desire greater accountability and more statistical measures. Even if U.S. News quit publishing America's Best Colleges, another source would step up in its place. College and university presidents should consider themselves fortunate if Congress does not support that source.
One association, The National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities (NAICU) launched their own Web-based tool called U-CAN, which stands for University and College Accountability Network. U-CAN is a nationwide effort to provide consumer information to parents and students, including financial statistics, about privately supported institutions.
NAICU claims that U-CAN is not a reaction to published rankings; according to public content on their site, U-CAN was created in response to public demand for comparable, concise, relevant, and easily accessible information. But I scrolled down and noticed that NAICU acknowledges that if "consumers, Congress, and the administration decide that the information on U-CAN is self-serving and of little value, the likely alternative is new federal reporting mandates."
So, NAICU is behaving much like a business association of firms in the same industry; let's try to regulate ourselves before the government steps in. U-CAN is NAICU's attempt at self-regulation. As someone who has been in the education site business, I was curious to see how U-CAN worked. I played with U-CAN, much like a parent or student would.
Here's what I liked about U-CAN:
+ It's free and there's no need to register. If I were a student, I do not become part of a junk-mail database to schools that are of no interest to me.
+ Navigation is clear and simple-if your heart is already set on a very small number of private schools.
+ U-CAN has statistics that I cannot find in other published sources, specifically the tuition history, four-year and five-year graduation rates, diversity indices, student indebtedness, a price breakdown for tuition and fees, average net tuition charge (after grants in aid), residence life and direct access to campus safety information.
Some of this information is available on other sites, but not as easily searchable; in the case of U.S. News, you have to pay a fee for premium access to obtain more detail beyond the top schools on their lists.
U-CAN is comprehensive, and makes it an admirable effort; it is considerable work to secure cooperation from so many schools (approximately 450, as I write this piece), let alone organize the data in a user-friendly format.
U-CAN is useful, but less than perfect, for considering private colleges.
The first problem is unmemorable domain names. The host association uses a dot-edu in its web address instead of a dot-com, dot-net or dot-org; that's an unusual practice because the sponsor is a not-for-profit association, not an academic institution. The domain for the U-CAN site is http://ucan-network.org. This surprised me when I typed ucan dot-org and got nowhere. They cannot use ucan dot-org; that domain belongs to the Utility Consumer's Action Network.
So, my first suggestion to NAICU is to buy U-CAN dot-org, dot-com and dot-net before someone else does-or find a new name.
Two other problems come from searches. You cannot return to a list of search results if you want to look at more than one school in a state. For instance, I selected New Jersey and got a list of independent schools in the Garden State. After I finished viewing the complete profile of one school, I could not return to my list. I had to do the same search again. In addition, I could not do a search across schools in more than one state.
The search problems can make U-CAN quite cumbersome and, by comparison, they make the U.S. News print and online guides seem more user-friendly, if I want to compare schools.
That leads me to another suggestion: develop a print version of U-CAN that groups the schools by state and type of school using the available statistics. A print version of U-CAN confronts a major advantage of other guides-they're also books-parents and guidance counselors are more techno-phobic than high school students. The most difficult statistic to format in tables is probably tuition history. U-CAN lists tuition charges for each of the past five years; that can be converted into an average tuition increase.
U-CAN is an excellent site, if you have already whittled down your choices to a small number of private schools. It's better designed to be your last stop for information gathering-after you've bought the U.S. News guide, read student school reviews and done your campus visits-instead of your first.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/education-articles/colleges-make-webbased-response-to-college-rankings-260918.html
About the Author:Stuart Nachbar has been involved with education politics, policy and technology as a student, urban planner, government affairs manager, software executive, and now as author of The Sex Ed Chronicles. Visit his blog, Educated Quest
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
SAT Optional Schools Not Always Easy Schools
By: Stuart Nachbar | 13/10/2007 | Education
It has been 30 years since I was a high school senior, but I had to take the SATs just as 11th and 12th graders do now. I did okay, but not good enough to get into my two first choice schools. Back then, I blamed the SATs and called...
Tales Of Two Harvards
By: Stuart Nachbar | 22/11/2007 | Education
Journalist Hanna Rosin has written God's Harvard, a wonderful book about Patrick Henry College, a Christian school that its chancellor calls "a Harvard for the home-schooled."
Rosin, who has covered religion and politics for the Washington Post, has crafted an insightful - some of more moderate or liberal political persuasions might...
An Honor Roll, Not A Watch List, For Colleges
By: Stuart Nachbar | 08/12/2007 | Education
Members of Congress on the House committee on education have come up with an absolute bonehead idea: to publish a "watch list" of schools that have increased tuition at rates higher than inflation.
I am surprised when members of the House speak of reigning in college costs with measures such as...
The Best Money-Saving Tips for College Students
By: Ben Welch | 14/06/2007 | Finance
With the cost of tuition on the rise, college students are seeking new ways to save a buck while going to school. Read these top ten money saving tips.
New Forum for India- Discussindia.in
By: Cdmohatta | 11/08/2006 | Press Releases
A new forum centered on India has been launched today.
The 10 Strangest College Mascots
By: Ben Welch | 14/06/2007 | Non-Fiction
Sure, you have bulldogs, panthers, knights, and hawks. But not every school chooses a conventional mascot. Here are ten of the strangest, in no particular order - except for the last one.
From "Open Doors" To "Engines Of Inequality"
By: Jacob Jaffe | 16/01/2007 | Education
Over a hundred and fifty years ago, after years of controversy and struggle, New Yorkers voted by a 6 to 1 margin to establish the Free Academy for the Poor Man's Children. That trailblazer college removed the barrier of tuition for its first class of 149 college students and over...
How to Find your Goal in Life
By: Steve Boulden | 18/01/2007 | College and University
Most of us have an idea of what we would like to do with our lives. However, sometimes it's not solid in our minds. And sometimes we may just need to hear what we already know. What is your true calling in life?
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Provide information regarding television approach ...
By: jatin | 16-11-2007
provide information regarding television approach towards teaching learning with its supporting media like video,vcd,dvd,TV Broadcasts,CCTV,Cable tv
Do you think the president of the US has his own computer? if so, what do you think he reads/looks at when he surfs the web?
By: computerwhiz | 16-11-2007
do you think the president of the US has his own computer? if so, what do you think he reads/looks at when he surfs the web?
Future nurse needs GED
By: musicismyhothotsex | 14-11-2007
I dropped out of high school to get a job when I was 14.I was supposed to home-school but found I didn't have time,and when I did school was the last thing on my mind.Plus,I'm not religious and my mom picked out Christian based curriculum so it was really boring to me.Anyway,I'm 20 now and decided to go to nursing school.I need to get my G.E.D and need a good study guide.I'm great with English and Reading...Math is very difficult.I have not been in school in almost 6 years so the simplest Math problems are hard for me.What is the best GED study guide and maybe some math skills material as well?Thanks!
Uses of Web 2.0 Applications in Education
By: dbenzvi | 13-11-2007
What are the meaningful uses of Web 2.0 applications in education? By meaningful, I mean empirically proved impact on teaching or learning.
Democratic elections
By: iyakuppur | 13-11-2007
when are the democratic elections?
Best MP3 Player for Voice Recording
By: mocdeg | 12-11-2007
I want to buy an MP3 player to be used exclusively for voice recording. I am looking for the best voice recorder in an MP3 player, all the other features are unimportant except that it should have a minimum of 4Gb of memory. Which is the best on?
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Education Articles
The Green Fireball Unidentified Flying Objects (ufos) in Mexico
By: Joy Healey | 06/09/2008
Reports of Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs), from extremely credible witnesses, have fascinated ufologists for years now. Some of the most exciting, and well-documented stories are those about the Green Fireballs sighted in Mexico. Here's an extract taken from the mysterious "Project Blue Book".
The Importance Of A University Education
By: Paul Hata | 06/09/2008
Having a university degree gives you a competitive edge over those who do not. In many cases you will find that education is beginning to trump experience as employers are seeking workers with more rounded skills rather than those with very specific skills.
Making Your Way To College With Freshman Scholarships
By: Paul Hata | 06/09/2008
There is a Freshman Honor Scholarship, this is funded by organizations which grant scholarship to those students who are by far excelling in the class and were able to gain honors. The requirements may come in separate application form, while there are others that do not.
Get The College Soccer Scholarships
By: Paul Hata | 06/09/2008
It is a fact that it may seem too good to believe that soccer can take your child to college. However, there are good colleges out there that offer college soccer scholarship. They send out scouts to different schools to evaluate different soccer players and offer the best soccer player a college scholarship. This is one of the best and the most common ways that your child can earn a scholarship.
The Need For Education In The Developing Countries
By: Paul Hata | 06/09/2008
Education is the only weapon with which one can kill ignorance and fight with unawareness. An educated person can perceive things in a better way because he has a broad mind with which he can see the things differently. He has a broadened mind with which he is able to understand all the faces of any problem and then he will be able to handle the situation in a better way.
What Are The True Value Of A Two-Year College
By: Paul Hata | 06/09/2008
Community colleges offer an excellent start for many people who are seeking higher education whether to further their careers or just to find fulfillment on a personal level in life. There are many wonderful programs in vocational fields as well as academic fields that can be explored and studies on the community college level.
Financial Assistance For Educational Expenses
By: Paul Hata | 06/09/2008
A college education in many cases is a significant investment. The good news is that there are many options for the average family when it comes to paying the high costs involved in higher education.
The Financial Aid For College Students
By: Paul Hata | 06/09/2008
Most people find that the expenses of college are much too great to afford without assistance of some sort. If you are a parent chances are that you will some day face the need to pay college tuition along with the worry of how on earth you will manage to accomplish that goal.
More from Stuart Nachbar
Juno And The Restless Virgins
By: Stuart Nachbar | 20/01/2008 | Art and Entertainment
Since I wrote a novel based around sex education, I've tried to pay attention to other books and movies that do the same. I reviewed Tom Perrotta's The Abstinence Teacher, which I thoroughly enjoyed. This time, I'm reviewing Juno, a movie I enjoyed so much I saw it twice, the...
Should TV Bring Back Room 222?
By: Stuart Nachbar | 11/01/2008 | Education
Every profession could use a good TV show to help it flourish in tough times. With No Child Left Behind, maybe teachers need one more than ever.
I've heard most of the arguments on why this happens: pay, working conditions, job satisfaction, bureaucracy, lost tenure, ad infinitum. If you're reading this...
The Rutgers 1000 Is Baaaack!
By: Stuart Nachbar | 29/12/2007 | Education
I have lived in New Jersey practically all of my life.
The Garden State has been in fiscal crisis practically all of my academic life and my working life. I realized this almost thirty years ago, as a student taxpayer; the tuition at Rutgers tripled between from my freshman year to...
Rutgers To Reorganize Alumni Association For The Better
By: Stuart Nachbar | 14/12/2007 | Education
From time to time, I write about Rutgers, the state university I know best. Rutgers is a very good school; U.S. News ranks my alma mater as one of the nation's top 20 state universities - and quirky enough to be interesting to an education writer.
Rutgers is the state university...
An Honor Roll, Not A Watch List, For Colleges
By: Stuart Nachbar | 08/12/2007 | Education
Members of Congress on the House committee on education have come up with an absolute bonehead idea: to publish a "watch list" of schools that have increased tuition at rates higher than inflation.
I am surprised when members of the House speak of reigning in college costs with measures such as...
Back To Back: Two Good Reads On Entry Level Leadership And Culture
By: Stuart Nachbar | 01/12/2007 | Writing
This month, I read two books back to back: Soldier's Heart by Elizabeth Samet and Punching In by Alex Frankel. Both of these works are an excellent introduction into entry-level corporate culture and leadership development.
Soldier's Heart is a civilian English professor's take on the leadership culture of West Point, based...
Tales Of Two Harvards
By: Stuart Nachbar | 22/11/2007 | Education
Journalist Hanna Rosin has written God's Harvard, a wonderful book about Patrick Henry College, a Christian school that its chancellor calls "a Harvard for the home-schooled."
Rosin, who has covered religion and politics for the Washington Post, has crafted an insightful - some of more moderate or liberal political persuasions might...
College Or Pros, What Pays For Young Baseball Players?
By: Stuart Nachbar | 05/11/2007 | Baseball
If your son is a professional baseball prospect, you might want to know what makes more sense for him: continue playing at the collegiate level, or turn pro right away. The price where it pays to go pro might surprise you.
Of the four major U.S. sports, only baseball and basketball...
|
|
Education 
