The Disadvantages of High School Rankings

Posted: Sep 10, 2007 | Comments: 0 | Views: 142 | Bookmark and Share

In a knowledge based global economy where your educational qualifications will invariably decide your social and economic status in life, it’s not surprising that such importance is attached to categorizing schools based on high school rankings. This is the reason why parents and students scan websites and pour through literature, searching for that dream educational institution that’s placed on the top rung of the ladder for high school rankings. In fact, better education is one of the reasons people choose to move every year, looking to build a better educational foundation for their kids. You might think that while looking for schools it’s best to base your selection on a predetermined listing for high school rankings. You might not always be right though. Here’s why.

Are High School Rankings the Only Factor?

Advocates of high school rankings argue that in a situation where the public education system in the country is in a sorry state of affairs at best, parents need tools to base their decisions on. High school rankings provide parents with that tool so they can make an informed decision. While this is true to a large extent, the fact is that these high school rankings don’t always take all factors into consideration while deciding a school’s place in the scheme of things.

For instance, schools might sometimes place lower on the high school rankings largely because of their location and student demographics. Unfortunately, schools with large minority student populations have a tougher time making it to the elite top positions in high school rankings. This is also true for schools that have large or majority African American populations. Education authorities will argue that the test scores in these schools are so dismal because the students aren’t motivated enough to succeed. Well, you wouldn’t be motivated either if you had parents who worked two jobs to support your family.

The uncomfortable truth is that in lower income communities, parents might not always have the time or resources to expend on monitoring their children’s education or motivating them. Managing to pay the bills and stay afloat takes enough energy. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure that schools with larger levels of such student populations will rank lower. The quality of education or the level of effort put in by teachers (who work diligently to goad their students to rise beyond any perceived limitations) is beyond reproach. One of the major reasons why such schools constantly place low on high school rankings is because of the low motivation levels of students.

And what about the success stories of disadvantaged children from such low ranked schools who go on to enjoy successful careers? They alone are enough proof that high school rankings need not always be taken as an open and shut categorization.

(ArticlesBase SC #212130)

Rate this Article
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1 vote(s)
    Feedback
    RSS
    Print
    Email
    Re-Publish

    Source:  http://www.articlesbase.com/education-articles/the-disadvantages-of-high-school-rankings-212130.html

    Article Tags:

    Patricia Hawke

    ,

    High School Rankings

    How do I Choose a School on Ranking

    Find out weather a school ranking is better than a school that suits you. (01:35)

    The Importance of Top Ranked MBA Schools

    In this video, David Petersam discusses the various steps involved in applying to a top-ranked MBA program, such as if it's important to get into the top-ranked schools (00:42)

    The Importance of MBA Rankings

    In this video, David Petersam discusses the various steps involved in applying to a top-ranked MBA program, such as should you use rankings as your guide (00:59)

    How to Find the Best Law School for You

    Learn if the law school's ranking is more important than your personaly preferance. (00:52)

    Going to an MBA From Undergrad School

    In this video, David Petersam discusses the various steps involved in applying to a top-ranked MBA program, such as if you are at a disadvantage for going straight from undergrad to business school (00:48)

    Lists assessing high school rankings for K-12 are hugely popular right now because of the intense scrutiny of American education. These rankings are important because parents make moves to areas, or away form them, based on how schools rate.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l Aug 08, 2007 l Views: 22

    With all the emphasis on mandatory testing and national standards it’s no big surprise that high school rankings have been getting a lot of attention. American high school students face a global economy, high technology demands, and the reality of living in a capitalistic society without the benefit of a solid financial education.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l Sep 04, 2007 l Views: 72

    What data is considered for High School Rankings for K-12 general interest? Newsweek Magazine is the most popular publication that ranks public high schools, and most high schools strive for inclusion. Newsweek journalist Jay Mathews devised the formula used by the magazine to determine which schools make the list.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l Jul 31, 2007 l Views: 12

    Who cares about comparing schools? After all, the experts are constantly advising parents NOT to compare their children to each other, their cousins, friends, and neighbors. It can damage their self-esteem, causing the little darlings to feel like they don’t measure up to their parents’ expectations.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l Aug 15, 2007 l Views: 78

    With the advent of school choice and the ever increasing ability of a family to move from one state or one neighborhood to the next, there is an increasing desire for parents to seek high school rankings. When doing so, there are so many factors to consider.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l Aug 30, 2007 l Views: 65

    Teachers and Their Place and High school rankings The No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) specifically determines the quality of teachers in a school as one of the basis for high school rankings. According to the provisions of NCLB, teachers are required to be highly qualified to teach core...

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education > Tutoring l Sep 26, 2007 l Views: 101

    Remember the Army slogan, “I Want YOU for the U.S. Army!”? The poster showed a very stern Uncle Sam jabbing his finger nearly out of the picture. What about the one by Smokey the Bear? “Even YOU can prevent forest fires!” Well, let’s add another one, shall we? “It’s important for YOU to consider Public School Rankings !” when considering a move to a new city or state.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l Aug 15, 2007 l Views: 373

    In putting together an outdoor survival kit for urban use, you can pretty much use many of the same items you would use for any outdoor survival gear bag. You need water and a means to purify it and you must have some sort of food in your bag, even if it’s just a couple days worth of something.

    By: Josh Stevens l Education l Feb 09, 2010

    If you live in an urban setting, what kind of outdoor survival gear can you put together that will help you in an emergency situation? When you start to put a kit together, the first things you should consider are safety items.

    By: Josh Stevens l Education l Feb 09, 2010

    Having to take care of their families on their own, working single mothers have probably the toughest job of all. Having to take care of their families on their own, working single mothers have probably the toughest job of all.

    By: Marlon Jackson l Education l Feb 09, 2010 l Views: 1

    We know about global warming. We know about climate change. But often, we tend to view these as quite abstract concepts that don't affect us yet. Those people who are professionals in environmental research know that this is not something that has crept up on us.

    By: Wolf Krammel l Education l Feb 09, 2010 l Views: 1

    This article is about college grant application

    By: Sergey l Education l Feb 09, 2010

    This article is about alternative loans.

    By: Sergey l Education l Feb 09, 2010

    Unfortunately, I found prohibited the demanding way with the purpose of scholarships are not for eternity as pronounced as family believe. Certainly, I am a promoter of scholarships, on behalf of they packed in my "unmet need," and suffer provided money on behalf of me to take summer classes and study Spanish in Argentina.

    By: Margaret Atwood l Education l Feb 09, 2010 l Views: 3

    Description: Here you will find soemthing about student loan consolidation.

    By: Aptem l Education l Feb 09, 2010

    Does ‘free market’ work in education? The Los Angeles Unified School District is testing the idea that competition among a group of people for running schools will yield better ones. It's a radically different approach than the traditional civil service model and probably the boldest experiment taking place in public education in America.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education > K-12 Education l Jan 31, 2010 l Views: 8

    Students at Detroit schools are leaving before graduation at a disturbing rate. Depending on which estimate you believe, the number ranges from 34 to 68%. Whichever number you decide is the right one, these levels are still far too high.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l May 17, 2008 l Views: 375

    There is a problem with the system being used to rate the performance of teachers at Dallas schools. Due to errors in coding or otherwise, some teachers are being rated based on classes they didn't teach or students who weren't assigned to them. This issue at Dallas schools needs to be dealt with immediately.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l May 17, 2008 l Views: 82

    The latest statistics on violence in Cleveland schools indicate that incidents are on the rise. Recent incidents involved an assault on a teacher and a principal getting injured while trying to break up a fight. It really shouldn't be all that surprising that violence acts are being committed in Cleveland schools when violence is so prevalent in our society as a whole.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l May 17, 2008 l Views: 61

    Officials at Charlotte schools recently sent their 18,000 workers a form asking that each employee consent to a rigorous background check or be fired.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l May 17, 2008 l Views: 29

    A new initiative at Baltimore schools provides yet another glimpse into the possibilities that a public school system can throw up for its students, if it only makes the effort. Baltimore schools have tied up with MedStar the Columbia based health care system, to offer students an opportunity to intern at health facilities.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l May 17, 2008 l Views: 16

    In Arizona schools, it is estimated that 130,000 students have a language other than English as their first language. These youngsters are not fluent in English. Unless their English-language skills are brought up, how can they be expected to get a good education?

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l May 17, 2008 l Views: 32

    Middle school students attending two Virginia Schools have had the opportunity to meet an award-winning author. Sharon Flake has written a work of fiction about a 13-year-old African American girl who struggles to fit in with her peers.

    By: Patricia Hawke l Education l Sep 10, 2007 l Views: 15

    Add new Comment

     
    * Required fields
    Author Box
    Articles Categories
    All Categories
    0