 |
Unintended Consequences of True School Choice
Author: Stuart Nachbar  | Posted: 07-07-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 24 | Rating: (66)  (?) 
I always try to make it a point to see both sides of an education issue, and as Project Runway host Tim Gunn always tells his fashion designer cast, try to make it work.
The concept of true school choice fits that challenge.
The thought behind true school choice is that "dollars follow the child." Parents receive a government-estimated amount of money which represents the cost of educating each of their children, with adjustments for special needs such as special education, English language skills and physical disabilities. Parents may apply those monies it towards any school they choose: public, private, parochial or even home schooling. The state takes charge of informing parents of their options; public school superintendents and local school boards would have little incentive to do it.
True-choice advocates say this puts the decisions on quality schools in the hands of the parents, in effect creating a marketplace for education. It also, in theory, would provide "seed capital" for parents who could home-school their children or join with other parents to form a school of their own. It could also help parents create a more personalized educational experience for their child; for instance, they could elect to send him or her to college a year early. True choice assumes all parents also have equal access to perfect information to make an informed decision.
I understand why school boards and public school teacher's unions would be opposed to true choice; average and poor-performing schools could be the losers in the market place, as their students would be likely to seek alternatives. I do, however, agree with true choice advocates that competition would make these schools adjust and perform to new circumstances or deservedly close their doors.
True choice empowers parents, and therefore takes power away from local school boards. School boards are thrust into the role of marketers to try to identify and fill local needs, as well as teach the state's standard curriculum. That's good and bad; they could, for example, offer high school courses directed at post-graduation jobs with local employers, or college-prep SAT tutoring, but be forced to send their constituents elsewhere for needs that can't be filled. Elsewhere can mean a school further from home, where parents must provide transportation. Three words to those school boards: disgruntled parents remember.
But proponents of true choice also ask for less government intervention in the schools; they prefer that parents and teachers choose the academic program with little to no involvement from state government. I don't believe that's possible; in fact, government may need to be involved where it has not been involved before.
For one thing, public money would be sent to schools where it has never been sent before. The private and parochial institutions would have to be help accountable for that money, as would those who home school. At the very least, state governments would be likely to set standards for teacher-student contact hours or days as well as the submission of attendance records. They could also, and rightly, impose standardized testing by grade level across the board. If public money is distilled down to more schools, those schools must prove to state government that students are ready to advance to the next grade level. Parents might also need to provide proof of proficiency and attendance, especially if they home school children.
Another concern is preference-based admissions in public schools; this is already business practice in the private and parochial schools. While in theory there would be public school options, public school systems are likely to discriminate in favor of their residents. Out-of-towners would receive consideration if there is still room, but taxpayers are likely to be extremely concerned about assuming the costs of educating children who live someplace else. There are other municipal services that support the public schools such as police, fire, water and sewer; so in effect, one town will be subsidizing the costs of students from other towns. Is it possible that public schools might charge a premium to non-residents?
On the other hand, there are superintendents who might become public entrepreneurs who will find out-of-towners to be their economic salvation. They can do identify the educational specialties underserved by neighboring municipalities and target students accordingly.
Public schools are also regulated by health and safety standards, including building codes. I don't believe true-choice advocates mean for private, parochial and home schools to become similarly regulated. The same would be true for teaching practices; they would want government out of the classroom. But there will always be extremes: schools based on controversial political or religious philosophies or corporal punishment being two examples from the past. I don't know how these issues would be resolved in a true-choice environment.
Advocates of true choice have usually been considered conservatives, because true choice offers a market-based alternative to the traditional public school bureaucracy. However, in the 1960's there were liberal activists who felt the same way; they developed their own alternative educational options as a challenge to authority. That's one reason communes started; they were living and learning communities.
There would be plenty of challenges to making a true-choice concept succeed. I'd be curious to see if parents, educators and politicians of all persuasions could actually make it work.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/education-articles/unintended-consequences-of-true-school-choice-475126.html
About the Author:Contact Stuart Nachbar at Educated Quest, a blog on education politics, policy and technology or read about his first book, The Sex Ed Chronicle, a novel on education and politics in 1980 New Jersey, at Sex Ed Chronicles.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
What happened to:
By: KayLee | 27-08-2008
Why don't we see more of Kenadie, the toddler who is a primordial dwarf?
What happened to the little Russian girls who are conjoined twins waiting to be separated?
Different type of printer and defintion
By: sankar | 21-08-2008
different type of printer and defintion
What are the best private K-12 schools for ...
By: Proud Father | 20-08-2008
What are the best private K-12 schools for children diagnosed with asperger's in Tennessee?
Can SOL test results be interpreted by percentage ...
By: sekzam | 18-08-2008
Can SOL test results be interpreted by percentage. For example, If your child receives 500 in Math, can you find out how that score ranks?
My daughter was dignosed with weak visual-motor ...
By: Confused mom | 16-08-2008
My daughter was dignosed with weak visual-motor intergration skills, suggesting she would better benefit in a concrete, multi-sensory approach to learning.
Help, i'm at a loss!
Help
By: Poohbear4avon | 15-08-2008
i am about the register my son at Swann Road Early Learning Center, and I would like to know from other is this the best place for my son who has special needs.
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Education Articles
A Few Things to Remember Before Choosing Online Spanish Courses
By: Dinah Leabeau | 15/10/2008
Fluency in Spanish extends your horizon and opportunities. Being able to speak Spanish decently gives you the chance to take advantage of more travel, employment and business relationships.
But first, you need to learn Spanish even if it is the most rudimentary kind. The most recommended type is Spanish online lessons....
A Few Things to Consider Before Choosing Online Spanish Lessons
By: Dinah Leabeau | 15/10/2008
Fluency in Spanish extends your horizon and opportunities. Being able to speak Spanish decently gives you the chance to take advantage of more travel, employment and business relationships.
But first, you need to learn Spanish even if it's the most rudimentary way. The most recommended kind is Spanish online lessons. Here...
Questions to Ask Before Learning Spanish Online
By: Dinah Leabeau | 15/10/2008
Several opportunities are opened if you're able to speak Spanish fluently. Travel, employment, friendships and professional relationships with Spanish-speaking places and peoples are within your reach; just imagine the various countries and the hundreds of millions of individuals you can visit and converse with!
Of course, fluency in Spanish needs you...
Carhartt Pants - 4 Lessons Learned From Company History
By: Mike Girolami | 14/10/2008
Carhartt pants have been around since they were first produced in the mid 1800s as part of a line of clothing designed to outfit railway workers. Since that time, the clothing line--until recently produced in the United States--has continued to expand and improve in an effort to produce long wearing...
What is an Amber Stone?
By: Mithun Rao | 14/10/2008
Amber - a gemstone formed in the early days of planet earth - which fascinated millions of people throughout time. Amber derives its name from the Middle English word 'ambre', from the Medieval Latin word 'ambra', and from the Arabic word 'anbar ambergris'. Read on to know more about amber, its history and its properties...
Why There is a Necessity to Learn Spanish
By: Dinah Leabeau | 14/10/2008
We reside in a world where learning to speak a language other than your native tongue can unlock windows of opportunities. Of course, speaking the said language in a pidgin manner can also put your foot in your mouth and inspire laughter in others. But hey, that's called learning and...
An Overview of Written and Spoken Chinese
By: Julie Landry | 14/10/2008
Written Chinese is mainly composed of ideographs. They express a meaning. Written Chinese, however, tends to be uniform in vocabulary and structure, regardless of the dialect of the speaker. On the other hand, when compared to actual spoken dialects, Chinese characters have seen far less changes than the spoken language.
When...
How to Have Fun in College Without Partying
By: Tom Tessin | 14/10/2008
When college students go away to college they have a lot of their parent's rules. They are not allowed to do whatever they want and be home whenever they want. Although there are rules, most college students have a lot more freedom than they did at home. Since not everyone...
More from Stuart Nachbar
Comics For Extra Credit - Part 3
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Art and Entertainment
I've got Ironman to blame for catching the comic bug over the past few weeks. This weekend I went to see another Marvel character, The Incredible Hulk, be re-introduced to the public. This is the second Hulk movie in five years; the previous Hulk, directed by Ang Lee, more famous...
Citizens Owe Our Soldiers a New G.I. Bill
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Education
I have a novel in editing, a story of a college administration in the aftermath of the murder of a U.S. Army recruiting officer. I chose as my venue a privately supported engineering school, historically friendly to the military that had relied on receiving a considerable amount of tuition revenues...
Bi-Party Tickets Totally Senseless
By: Stuart Nachbar | 04/07/2008 | Politics
I receive a daily news feed from Salon, and for the past two days I have received articles about Obama-Hagel and McCain-Lieberman unity tickets. I have just three words for those who believe such events will happen: it ain't happening.
Abraham Lincoln was the last president to choose a vice president...
It Pays to Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Cowboys or Giants or Eagles or Redskins
By: Stuart Nachbar | 22/06/2008 | Sports and Fitness
NFL Draft Season is now upon us and if you're a pro football fan you already know about the widespread speculation about where your favorite players are going to plying their trade on Sundays, Mondays, and Thursdays and, if they're lucky, the weekends in January and February after their college...
A Bill to Protect Military Recruiters
By: Stuart Nachbar | 21/06/2008 | Education
I am completing Defending College Heights, a novel about an Irish Catholic family and a college administration in the aftermath of the murder of a U.S. Army recruiter. I started work on Defending because I had connections in the higher education community who were quite knowledgeable on the issues, or...
Do Graduation Reporting Standards Mean Anything?
By: Stuart Nachbar | 16/06/2008 | Education
Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings introduced new proposed regulations to help clarify how schools, districts and states implement policies and business practices under No Child Left Behind.
Among these proposals, Secretary Spellings has asked that high schools be required to use graduation rates that track cohorts of students as they progress...
Endowment Tax is Unsound Public Policy
By: Stuart Nachbar | 16/06/2008 | Education
I just read in the May 19 Christian Science Monitor that a Massachusetts legislator proposes a 2.5 percent tax on college endowments over $1 billion. The Commonwealth State has nine such institutions including Harvard, MIT, Williams, Boston College, Amherst, Wellesley, Tufts, Smith and Boston University; all of them are among...
Comics For Extra Credit - Part 2
By: Stuart Nachbar | 16/06/2008 | Education
My first post about comics as an educational aid generated an interesting response - from the managing director of Classical Comics, a comic book company in the United Kingdom. Not to be confused with Classic Comics, often teasingly referred to as a study guide for college literature classes here in...
|
|
Education 
