Thomas Pyzdek wrote the Six Sigma Handbook, The Quality Engineering Handbook and The Handbook of Quality Management. His works are used by thousands of universities and organizations around the world to teach Quality, Lean, and Six Sigma. Get Six Sigma Training and Certification information.
The Obama administration has proposed, and the House of Representative has recently passed, sweeping legislation to deal with the problem of climate change or, more specifically, global warming. The problem is supposedly that human activity is releasing CO2 and this in turn is causing catastrophic increases in global temperatures. This hypothesis is supported in part by data from ground-based temperature recording stations situated around the world. The United States has 1,221 stations scattered across the continent and it is believed that the data obtained from these stations is among the most reliable and accurate available.
A recent report by the Surface Stations Project casts serious doubt on this assumption. Volunteers for the project have to date examined, photographed 819 of the stations and rated 807. Ratings are based on he Climate Reference Network Rating Guide - adopted from NCDC Climate Reference Network Handbook, 2002, specifications for siting (section 2.2.1) of NOAA's new Climate Reference Network:
Class 1 (CRN1)- Flat and horizontal ground surrounded by a clear surface with a slope below 1/3 (<19deg). Grass/low vegetation ground cover <10 centimeters high. Sensors located at least 100 meters from artificial heating or reflecting surfaces, such as buildings, concrete surfaces, and parking lots. Far from large bodies of water, except if it is representative of the area, and then located at least 100 meters away. No shading when the sun elevation >3 degrees.
Class 2 (CRN2) - Same as Class 1 with the following differences. Surrounding Vegetation <25 centimeters. No artificial heating sources within 30m. No shading for a sun elevation >5deg.
Class 3 (CRN3) (error >=1C) - Same as Class 2, except no artificial heating sources within 10 meters.
Class 4 (CRN4) (error >= 2C) - Artificial heating sources <10 meters. Class 5 (CRN5) (error >= 5C) - Temperature sensor located next to/above an artificial heating source, such a building, roof top, parking lot, or concrete surface."
The bottom line is that 89% of the sites examined to date are in categories 3, 4, or 5. In other words, they fail to meet established NOAA requirements.
A logical question would be, does it matter? Evidence indicates that it does. For example, here's a photograph of a site that meets the standard:

The chart shows that the temperatures recorded by this station have actually declined over time. Compare this to the results from this poorly sited recording station:
The chart clearly shows warming. However, the cause of the warming is most likely the changes in the quality of the site over time, not due to human-induced increases in CO2.
In the business world we use quality and Lean Six Sigma to help us make good decisions based on facts and data. The process used is called DMAIC, or Define-Measure-Analyze-Improve-Control. In the Measure phase we assure that we have valid, reliable data before moving on to analysis and improvement. This is a lesson that policy makers in Washington and elsewhere should learn before embarking on policies that will cost trillions of dollars.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
- Global Warming As A US Election Issue
- Bloomberg & Global Warming
- This is Global Warming?
- Bigger Than Earth- Bigger Tha Global Warming
- Surface Temperature Data Quality Suspect--Casts Doubt on "Global Warming" Hypothesis
- Public opinion turning against global warming almost as quickly as science
- A LETTER TO A FRIEND ON GLOBAL WARMING
- Global Starvation Not Global Warming




Composting Toilet Environmental Benefits
By: Ellen Bell | 30/12/2009Eco-friendly composting toilets have a huge number of benefits for the environment. In this article, we'll explore several ways that these unique fixtures make a positive impact on the world around us.
You Are the Problem, You Are the Solution
By: Adolphpaul | 30/12/2009It is time to rectify the mistakes of past unplanned development. Effective and quick solutions are required for the revival of the environment of the Earth. This is not going to succeed with the efforts of just one person. Everybody has to take conscious steps to ensure sustainable living conditions.
Climate Change Factoid – The Greenhouse Effect (# 1 of a series)
By: Rich Albertson | 30/12/2009Here's a simple, non-technical explanation of how the Greenhouse Effect works. The Greenhouse Effect is a cause of at least two important events on planet Earth; Us, because were it not for the greenhouse effect, we would not exist and also Climate Change. Understanding this natural process is probably an indispensable first step to understanding the rest of the climate change story. It's not terribly complicated, check it out.
Disaster Survival Do You Have A Survival Kit
By: Fred Hurty | 29/12/2009A disaster could strike from anywhere at any time it could be a hurricane, an earthquake, a terrorist attack, a snow or ice storm or a tornado. Survival kits are a must have item for you to be prepared for a disaster.
The Squashing of Free Energy Inventions
By: Alain Prud'homme | 29/12/2009One of the problems inventors face is the fact that their inventions are always evaluated for their war potential. This can bring about the unwanted interest by the Pentagon, the CIA or other less well known secret government organisations.
Global Warming Or Climate Change? Learn What is Really Happening
By: Mike Wood | 28/12/2009For many years millions of Americans and indeed others around the world have worried themselves about the immanent dangers of global warming. An entire industry has mushroomed around the idea.
Who owns the water in Montana?
By: Agribusiness Blogger | 28/12/2009Montana farmland once used for agricultural purposes is now being developed and is taxing an already limited underground water supply. New development could spell disaster for agribusinesses should water supplies become depleted.
When Relief Operations Overwhelmed
By: M.E.Reza | 28/12/2009Inordinate delays in providing immediate humanitarian assistance will exacerbate the crisis arising from natural disasters, propelling such situations into another full grown disaster. Recent experience with the barrage of natural disasters that hit the Asian Pacific region posed a grim reminder that emergency preparedness cannot withstand intense wide-ranging devastation without efforts involving full collaboration, cooperation and coordination of regional stakeholders.
Why Healthcare Quality Stinks in America
By: Thomas Pyzdek | 29/11/2009 | MedicineLet's be honest, America's healthcare non-system has its problems. What are the root causes? Do any of the proposed solutions address them?
How to Deliver a Great Presentation
By: Thomas Pyzdek | 14/08/2009 | Self ImprovementMost professionals will at some point during their career find themselves standing in front of an audience. These guidelines and tips will help you make the most of that opportunity.
How to Calculate Process Yields
By: Thomas Pyzdek | 29/06/2009 | Ask an ExpertIf you calculate yields incorrectly, the results can be very misleading. This article explains the right way to do it.
Project Planning in a Nutshell
By: Thomas Pyzdek | 29/05/2009 | Project ManagementWhether it is Six Sigma, Lean, Quality improvement, or some other initiative, the simple fact is that progress is made project by project. This article provides an overview of why planning is important and what a project plan should include.