Randy Bisenz is the founder of http://www.BrightFuture.us , a non-partisan article hub and online community focused on solutions to worldwide problems.
Biofuels. What a great name! It just sounds green. Looking around I see a proliferation of Biodiesel bumper stickers everywhere I look. In my home state of Oregon all filling stations will be required to add at least 10 % ethanol to all gasoline by next year. Environmentalists are cheering as politicians and the media are jumping onto the Biofuel bandwagon. Sounds like a big win for the environment and society - think again, in reality Biofuels are much more brown than they are green.
Here are five reasons why Biofuels may actually be harmful for the environment:
- 1. Biofuels are so profitable that rain forest, the most efficient absorber of greenhouse gases, is being cut or burned to grow grains and sugarcane to make ethanol or Biodiesel.
- 2. Farmers growing highly profitable Biofuel crops are looking for the fastest growth and biggest yields and use heavy amounts of chemical fertilizer; which strips key micronutrients out of our increasingly scarce topsoil, and the nitrogen-rich runoff causes massive algae growth that destroys our streams, rivers and lakes.
- 3. Because Biofuels are more profitable than food crops large amounts of prime farmland is being devoted to Biofuel production creating grain shortages and increasing the price of grain products, especially in third world countries.
- 4. Although Biofuels emit less greenhouse gases per gallon than petroleum fuels they still emit significant amounts. Biofuels are also less fuel-efficient. In my vehicle mileage drops substantially when I use a fuel containing ethanol. So, overall Biofuels do not reduce greenhouse emissions nearly as much as claim.
- 5. This is perhaps the most important reason. To permanently solve both the energy crisis and eliminate greenhouse gas emissions we will have to move away from consumable fuels to toward energy sources that do not consume fuel, emit heat or produce pollutants. At the moment electricity is the cleanest energy source available and companies are beginning to develop and produce powerful electric cars that can go a few hundred miles on a charge. For these vehicles to be practical we will need to establish charging stations in every town and alongside every highway. This requires a massive transition from filling stations to charging stations. The use of Biofuels will perpetuate the existing infrastructure of filling stations and delay the transition to charging stations. The longer we delay this transition the more greenhouse gases will be released into our atmosphere.
At this point some of you might be wondering why our political leadership and big business is so supportive of Biofuels - yet they never even mention electric vehicles. It might be worth your time to see the movie "Who Killed the Electric Car", which is available on DVD. Click Here to go to their website.
To begin with most big grain producers are large corporate farms with a strong lobbying presence in Washington and a history of making campaign contributions to politicians that support their agendas. Biofuels are big business for these companies.
The auto industry also is heavily involved in politics, lobbying efforts, and campaign contributions. These companies have a big investment in continuing to make internal combustion engines that burn fuels. Moving to electric motors will require major retrofitting for these companies. Biofuels allow them to avoid making this investment.
The petroleum industry has perhaps the most to gain from the implementation of Biofuels. They know that the public will eventually demand a move away from petroleum. All the other solutions will take business away from them. However, they will be refining and distributing Biofuels just like they do with petroleum - and crude Biofuels are cheaper too. So, the petroleum industry stands to make a great deal of money from the distribution of Biofuels.
The petroleum industry makes huge campaign contributions to certain politicians. They have been successful at having many of their supporters and former executives elected and appointed to the highest levels of power in our current administration. It is not surprising that our political leaders are embracing Biofuels.
The solution to both the energy crisis and pollution is to transition to non-consumable fuels. This means solar, geothermal, wind and tidal energy production of electricity. Even nuclear energy could be a viable alternative if spent fuel can be safely transported out of the Earth's atmosphere using the low-cost rocket technologies recently developed. All of these kinds of energy production are already in use and are becoming cheaper and more efficient every day. We have not yet begun to see the economies of scale and innovation that will make this kind of energy production much cheaper the more that it is developed and used.
At this very moment several companies are planning massive solar energy installations in Arizona, which is beginning to be called the Silicon Valley or Middle East of Solar energy production. Huge wind farms are being planned for the Plains states. We could be only years away from a massive transition to electric vehicles. For this to be successful we need to get big business and our political leadership to focus on this transition. This will take a lot longer if we allow them to remain focused on Biofuels instead.
When comparing non-consumable energy sources to fuel based energy production remember that all fuels must be transported to where they are sold. The transportation of fuels burns more fuel - so these transportation costs must be figured into the numbers used for greenhouse gas emissions and energy efficiency. Distribution of electricity does involve some energy loss, but it is fractional compared to how much energy is used to transport fuel and does not emit greenhouse gases.
Some of you might be wondering why I have not mentioned hydrogen fuel cells. There are three reasons why: 1. Hydrogen combustion still produces heat, 2. Our engineers still have not figured out how to produce hydrogen without using large amounts of energy to do it, and 3. The other renewal energy sources mentioned earlier have already moved beyond the experimental stage and are in real-world use.
On the Bright Future website we offer a comprehensive discussion about energy and climate. Check out our radio show: Click Understanding Climate Change on the Listen page. On our panel for this discussion is Greg Jones, a distinguished climate scientist from Southern Oregon University. This discussion reveals some of the complexities of properly addressing Climate Change.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
- The Great Biofuel Hoax of 2008 - Energy Policy and Climate Change
- Climate Change to Reduce European Holidays to the Mediterranean
- Climate Change and Your Retirement - a Changing Future
- Climate Change Psychosis and Lily Pad Cities
- Coping With Climate Change
- The Vilification Of Climate Change Sceptics
- Preparing For Climate Change- Why It Is Important To Act Today!
- Climate Change




Bhalessa legends
By: Sadaket Malik | 31/12/2009Now, Bhalessa has grown up and the only passion in lives of the masses is to look for a sea change in their lifestyle in hitherto heritage.
Recycle Old Digital Cameras and other Electronic Devices Online for Cash Payments
By: Stephen Roper | 31/12/2009With the electronic waste problem gradually getting worse in the UK day by day, now is a great time to do something positive and recycle your old digital camera and other electronic goods.
Composting Toilet Environmental Benefits
By: Ellen Bell | 30/12/2009Eco-friendly composting toilets have a huge number of benefits for the environment. In this article, we'll explore several ways that these unique fixtures make a positive impact on the world around us.
You Are the Problem, You Are the Solution
By: Adolphpaul | 30/12/2009It is time to rectify the mistakes of past unplanned development. Effective and quick solutions are required for the revival of the environment of the Earth. This is not going to succeed with the efforts of just one person. Everybody has to take conscious steps to ensure sustainable living conditions.
Climate Change Factoid – The Greenhouse Effect (# 1 of a series)
By: Rich Albertson | 30/12/2009Here's a simple, non-technical explanation of how the Greenhouse Effect works. The Greenhouse Effect is a cause of at least two important events on planet Earth; Us, because were it not for the greenhouse effect, we would not exist and also Climate Change. Understanding this natural process is probably an indispensable first step to understanding the rest of the climate change story. It's not terribly complicated, check it out.
Disaster Survival Do You Have A Survival Kit
By: Fred Hurty | 29/12/2009A disaster could strike from anywhere at any time it could be a hurricane, an earthquake, a terrorist attack, a snow or ice storm or a tornado. Survival kits are a must have item for you to be prepared for a disaster.
The Squashing of Free Energy Inventions
By: Alain Prud'homme | 29/12/2009One of the problems inventors face is the fact that their inventions are always evaluated for their war potential. This can bring about the unwanted interest by the Pentagon, the CIA or other less well known secret government organisations.
Global Warming Or Climate Change? Learn What is Really Happening
By: Mike Wood | 28/12/2009For many years millions of Americans and indeed others around the world have worried themselves about the immanent dangers of global warming. An entire industry has mushroomed around the idea.
Numbers Lie – Statistics, Politics and the Media, Part 2
By: Randy Bisenz | 12/08/2008 | PoliticsPart 2 of an article discussing how politicians and economists use spin to distort information and use statistics selectively to forward their own agendas.
Numbers Lie – Statistics, Politics and the Media, Part 1
By: Randy Bisenz | 12/08/2008 | PoliticsPart 1 of an article discussing how politicians and economists use spin to distort information and use statistics selectively to forward their own agendas.
The Politics of Hope
By: Randy Bisenz | 12/08/2008 | PoliticsOur society faces some of the greatest challenges in the history of humankind. We need great leaders to inspire us to do whatever is necessary to move through these challenges as efficiently as possible so we can create and maintain a high quality of life on planet Earth.
Simple Fuel Efficiency
By: Randy Bisenz | 12/08/2008 | CarsHow to get superior fuel efficiency.
Politicians Need not Apply
By: Randy Bisenz | 12/08/2008 | PoliticsA discussion of the traits desirable in a leader.
Effective Activism - Politics & Change
By: Randy Bisenz | 11/08/2008 | EnvironmentEffective Vs Ineffective activism is discussed with suggestions on how to win over the public trust. Examples are given from the Environmental Moveme
Young People to the Rescue!
By: Randy Bisenz | 23/07/2008 | EnvironmentYoung people: the world needs your help now.
What is Sustainability?
By: Randy Bisenz | 23/07/2008 | EnvironmentA discussion of sustainability and the importance of long-term planning.