 |
Reflections on a Pair of Novels, Losing Nelson and England, England, and a Couple of Trips to Chester
Author: Philip Spires  | Posted: 29-08-2007 | Comments: 0 | Views: 19 | Rating: (53)  (?) 
 This is not a review of Losing Nelson or England, England, or a record of visits to Chester. As the title claims, it’s a reflection, a few observations on culture and identity seen through Englishness. The trips to Chester are offered by the way, as a start and a finish.
I don’t recall the year when my dad’s Electricity Board Sports Club decided on Chester as its destination for the kids’ outing. I do remember many of those annual events vividly, however, perhaps because of the unearthly hour at which we had to set off. Britain had no motorways then and dual carriageways were rare. Roads went through town centres, the concept of the by-pass having just reached the drawing board – at least in the north – and adults could still smoke on the bus, despite the fact that potted meat sandwiches were probably being consumed in the next seat. The sandwich filling has a bearing on the tale, since the price of the trip included a packed lunch, usually passed around in bulk, the sandwiches cut in triangles, not the rectangles of home, and set in Toblerone ranges on a teacloth-draped tray. There was an apple or an orange, perhaps, to finish. I don’t know why I didn’t like potted meat, but I can remember persuading my mother to do me a round of bacon sandwiches as an adjunct to the standard fare. Perhaps I was just being greedy, but they did come in handy, if in a rather unexpected way.
I can remember visiting Chester’s historic town centre, all those half-timbered buildings provoking discussions about the Tudors, who they were, how they fit into history, who came before and who followed. The predecessors interested all of us on the trip, because we were from Yorkshire and we could never accept that the Lancastrians had won the war. At least we were in Cheshire! And then there were the city’s Roman origins to consider, leading to my learning my first Latin word when we were told that Chester was but a corruption of “castra”, Latin for camp (the military variety).
And so to the zoo. Yes, there were real zoos in those days. I was a fan of Zoo Time on TV, where Dr Desmond Morris, before his higher primate fame, did live experiments with chimpanzees and rewards, all encased in a Prokofiev theme tune. At Chester I remember I liked the sea lions, found the camels oppressively smelly and learnt that elephants really like cold bacon sandwiches.
When an infant, I used to wiggle the ridges off my candlewick bedspread. I don’t know whether it was a search for solace in the tactile, but it used to exasperate my mother, because I used to pick things into holes. Charles Cleasby, the Horatio Nelson worshipping main character of Barry Unsworth’s Losing Nelson, often sleeps under a holed and worn blanket of his mother’s whenever he needs reassurance. It’s a covering of peace for him, a way of shutting out the complications of the world and operates physically in the same way that his need to wrap himself in the myth of Nelson protects him mentally. Thus he is perhaps more a worshipper than a scholar. But the myth has become part of his psyche, part of his identity. Nelson’s greatness, Nelson’s genius, are parts of the nation’s greatness and genius and thus, by association, part of Cleasby’s own moral and personal identity. But, wanting to find out more, Cleasby researches Nelson’s history, expecting to confirm greatness and therefore bolster myth. To his increasing dismay and reluctantly admitted disbelief, what he uncovers are the complications of history, the messy realities of war and the personal limitations of the historical figure, who is often revealed as less than competent, certainly less than diplomatic, but also, and more importantly, as a self-seeking, ruthless individual, certainly not a team player. The myth dissolves little by little and so does Charles Cleasby’s hold on reality. As Nelson loses his mythical status, Cleasby’s world simply falls apart. He is no longer able to interpret experience nor relate to his surroundings. The blanket cocoon offered by myth generates an intellectual and mental solace that can both justify and reinforce identity and, once the protecting wrap has been holed for Charles, at least and perhaps for a nation, it is identity itself that is challenged. Losing Nelson is a serious and moving study of the essential role of myth in defining identity and creating psyche, citing its power and its limitations, these derived from its essence of simply being myth.
In England, England, Julian Barnes inhabits similar territory, but humorously. One character lists quintessences (there are more than five) of Englishness and many, perhaps most, are myth, by nature or association. And the purpose of identifying these icons of Englishness is to facilitate the construction, by Sir Jack Pitman on an eventually independent Isle of Wight, of an England Theme Park, packed with imitation and reproduction experience, collected together to take the strain out of tourism. Theme Park England becomes, itself, the quintessence (just one) of corporate identity and presence, with the products on offer being seen and marketed as “better” than the originals. It’s all a great success until, that is, the imitations begin to adopt their assigned identities. Smugglers become a problem when they start smuggling. Dr. Samuel Johnson changes his name to – guess what? – Dr. Samuel Johnson and begins emulating the behaviour of the historical figure, along with a few of his own improvisations for added effect. The King thinks he’s a king and Robin Hood and his Merrie Men yearn to be real outlaws. They are all in breach of contract. Through humour, the book asks questions about what is essential in national personal identity. The project identifies myths and reproduces them as second order experience which themselves become as capable of fulfilling the role of identity creation, definition and perpetuation as the real thing. So, by extension, the book questions how we create, assume and sustain cultures and their associated values.
The existence of myth and its potential to influence identity and culture are highly relevant to my second day out in Chester. This time as an adult I revisited the half timbering and Roman roots, the zoo having been transformed by changed notions of the animal. And a new reality asserted itself, redrafting the assumed permanence of my childhood memories. Unbeknown to the child, the half-timbering is largely nineteenth century reproduction and imitation. If it prompts discussion on Tudor England, it does so only by assumed association learned elsewhere. And the extant Roman elements of Chester are miniscule, reduced to a few piles of stone. The town’s official guide book, which I bought to help interpret the visit, pictured a Roman Centurion on its cover. He carried a shield with the words “Tetley Bitterman” emblazoned where one might have expected “SPQR”. At the end of the visit a myth I hade grown up with had been largely exploded. The history, itself, is not the myth. It’s the evidence that’s claimed on its behalf that is the problem. No wonder Sir Jack’s Theme Park attractions were as good as the real thing when the original was originally a theme park. The myth may survive the reality, I suppose, if the individual still wants to believe it. And, by the way, I have never managed to ask elephants if they really do like cold bacon sandwiches.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/fiction-articles/reflections-on-a-pair-of-novels-losing-nelson-and-england-england-and-a-couple-of-trips-to-chester-205569.html
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
Mission - Some Extracts From the Novel
By: Philip Spires | 29/08/2007 | Fiction
Mission is an African novel set in Kenya. It relates the lives of five main characters, priest, politician, teacher, church worker and retired army officer. Against a backdrop of a dry and dusty small town, the book evokes a strong feeling for the place where the people interact, love one another, drift apart, reunite and, unfortunately, hurt one another. Each has a mission, it seems.
Something of a Disappointment - Half of a Yellow Sun by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
By: Philip Spires | 29/08/2007 | Fiction
Half of a Yellow Sun by Chimanada Ngozi Adichie is a beautiful book, set around the the tragedy of the war in Biafra and its consequences for Nigeria. Philip Spires reviews the book, but finds it lacking in some key areas.
An Orchestral Concert 14 July 2007, La Nucia, Costa Blanca, Spain
By: Philip Spires | 06/09/2007 | Music
The closing concert of La Nucia's Festival – Nits de la Mediterrania featured twentieth century ballets, with music by Falla, Stavinsky, Piazzolla and Ginastera.
A Review of Arthur and George by Julian Barnes
By: Philip Spires | 06/09/2007 | Fiction
In Arthur and George, Julian Barnes explores that age old aspect of British life, social class.
Advice to Aspiring Writers. a Speech at the Awards Ceremony for the Libros International Children’s Writing Competition. 20 July 2007
By: Philip Spires | 06/09/2007 | Writing
Philip Spires advises young writers to live in the real world, communcate shred experiences in a public place and, importantly, to keep a journal to record experiences and reflections on them.
A Reflection on Saville by David Storey and a Bit of Rugby League
By: Philip Spires | 06/09/2007 | Fiction
Philip Spires reflects on a prize-winning novel of the 1970s, recalls its setting, and notes how the area has been transformed by economic change.
A Culture of Benidorm
By: Philip Spires | 29/08/2007 | Travel
Benidorm has been known for mass package tourism. In this article philip Spires argues that it, and the Costa Blanca, now deserve to be recognised as a destination for the cultural tourist.
Restless by William Boyd
By: Philip Spires | 06/09/2007 | Fiction
William Boyd's Restless is a novel about World War Two espionage. But it touches deeper themes, relating to identity and trust. The central character has multiple identities. How many of the other are doing the same?
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the 8th richest country in the world
By: Kim | 11-07-2008
what is the 8th richest country in the world
Henry The Eighth
By: Shelly | 11-07-2008
I am wondering about the final resting place of Henry the Eighth, I thought he was in St George Chapel Windsor alongside of Queen Jane and an infant son of Anne Boleyn. I was wondering why tour books do not mention this is it closed to the public? I am planning a trip and am fasinated by this period of history. Thanks Shelly RomeosJuliet7258@aol.com
5 & 10's Biddeford Maine
By: Dick Thibodeau | 10-07-2008
Trying to remember name and location of three 5 & 10's on Biddeford Main St. in the 40's and 50's Woolworth, Kressge and ? Used to buy model airplane kits in basement of one of them.
Why was Spring Valley, NY once called POT CHEESE ...
By: carol | 10-07-2008
Why was Spring Valley, NY once called POT CHEESE HOLLOW??
Civil War Hero
By: Gary | 09-07-2008
I am looking for information about a Civil War veteran from New Garden, Ohio. His name is Robert B. Wood, he received the Congressional Medal Of Honor for his actions during the war. After the war, he returned to his home town. He was commited to the Columbus Insane Hospital in 1878 where he died on July 1 of that year.
What to do if someone is trying to steal your ...
By: TINA | 09-07-2008
what to do if someone is trying to steal your identity.
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Fiction Articles
How Do Pirates Dress for Halloween (and What Do They Do?)
By: Edward Chupack | 17/07/2008
How do pirates dress for Halloween? They can't strap on a peg leg, prop a plastic parrot on their shoulders, apply an eye patch and wrap a red bandana around their scurvy heads. That's no fun at all -- not for a pirate on Halloween. That would be like we landlubbers wearing a suit to a Halloween bash -- the same suit and "business casual" clothing that we wear to work each day.
The Man in the Starched White Shirt
By: Edward Chupack | 16/07/2008
So there I was, riding my usual train one day, in my starched white shirt, reading the newspaper and looking out the window, exceedingly happy, when I saw a book that another passenger was reading. The book was "Sliver", but I misread the title and believed that the book's title was "Silver", and immediately envied the author that had come up with the idea of writing the memoirs of Long John Silver. Where could I buy that book?
How to Write a Short Story
By: Curtis Foster | 15/07/2008
Have you ever read a magnificently written short story and said, “Wow, I wish I could write that way!” You can, and it may not be as difficult a challenge as you think.
A Fool's Knot
By: Philip Spires | 15/07/2008
A Fool's Knot is set in Kenya and features the same characters as Mission, published in 2007. The novel deals with how people, societies and cultures change as they develop, particularly focusing on the role played by education.
Book Review: My Life as a Fake by Peter Carey
By: Philip Spires | 15/07/2008
My Life As A Fake by Peter Carey pursues the nature of creativity and artistic identity. A bogus poet, an invention of an Australian who now repairs bicycles in Kuala Lumpur, writes blissfully. The problem is he does not exist.
The Mission Song by John Le Carré
By: Philip Spires | 15/07/2008
In The Mission Song John le Carre examines the establishment of a deal that will hopefully bring stability to an area of central Africa. It will also create profit for a selection of its sponsors, a situation not appreciated by everyone involved.
Science Fiction Books: Unlimited Thrill, Unlimited Fun
By: Alden Jerry | 14/07/2008
A plethora of science fiction books are flooding the modern day book market across the world.
Science Fiction Stories: the Time is Now
By: Mark Mason | 13/07/2008
The science fiction story field is far from saturated. In fact, there are few if any fantastic science fiction websites. It is true that you can find some free science fiction out there, but too many of them have bland commentary. Most sites simply expound on what is currently the rage from Hollywood. Unfortunately the media moguls in Hollywood have terrible judgment in this area. The time for science fiction is now.
More from Philip Spires
Stamboul Train by Graham Greene
By: Philip Spires | 18/07/2008 | Literature
Stamboul Train was the novel that made a name for Graham Greene. In is, several characters travel across pre-war Europe on the Orient Express. The character's indiviual plots intertwine and interact during the journey, a journey that for some of them is definitely one way.
After These Things by Jenny Diski
By: Philip Spires | 18/07/2008 | Literature
In After These Things Jenny Diski gives life and thoughts to Old testament characters. She creates a psychological drama out of myth, a drama that explres human realtionships, marriage and kinship. Her novel thus becomes much more than the story it sets out to interpret.
Fasting, Feasting by Anita Desai
By: Philip Spires | 18/07/2008 | Literature
Fasting, Feasting by Anita Desai is a surprising book. Set in India and the USA, the lives middle class families are unpicked, especially in relation to the status of women. Opposites are thus shown to be similar, and an apparently gentle domestic tale becomes tragic.
The Hired Hand by Melvyn Bragg
By: Philip Spires | 18/07/2008 | Literature
The Hired Man by Melvyn Bragg is a novel about working class life in England. It starts at the end of the Victorian era and finishes in the 1920s. It is a subtle, but powerful portrayal of the struggle which, by definition, characterises the lives of ordinary people.
Life at the Top by John Braine
By: Philip Spires | 18/07/2008 | Literature
It is over forty years since John Braine published Life At The Top, a novel that presents a stark, perhaps cynical view of the British class system. Its frank portrayal of relationships and sex caused a stir at the time. Fifty years later, it is still poignant, and it also reminds us that some things have changed a lot, though not the British class system.
Double Vision by Pat Barker
By: Philip Spires | 18/07/2008 | Literature
Double Vision by Pat Barker is a highly complex novel that examines the relationships, the psychology, the reactions of a group of people each of whom, in their own way, have suffered loss. It is a tender, surprising novel where strong emotions are traded.
Kingdom Come by J. G. Ballard
By: Philip Spires | 18/07/2008 | Literature
Kingdom Come by J. G. Ballard presents a stark view of a Britain driven by rampant consumerism tinged with boredom. It decribes a dystopia that the writer clearly believes is almost upon us.
The Inheritance of Loss by Kiran Desai
By: Philip Spires | 15/07/2008 | Literature
The Inheritance Of Loss promises much, delivers a lot, but eventually delivers little. Small town concerns trouble the inhabitants of a globalised world, but, though the book charms, it fails to comment.
|
|
Writing 
