Wow did I get a real world demonstration of the saying, "Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder." If I could rephrase that to the business sale situation it could be, Strategic Value is in the eyes of the particular buyer." We are representing a small company that has a patented and somewhat unique product. They have gotten distribution in several hardware store chains, Lowes, and are going into Wal*Mart next spring.
The owners are at a cross-roads. To keep up with their growth in volume they recognize that they require a substantial capital investment. They understand that they have a window of opportunity to achieve a meaningful footprint before a much better capitalized competitor produces a similar product and undercuts their price. Finally they realize that a one product company at a big box retailer is quite vulnerable to the inevitable rotation of buyers or a change in policy that bumps them out of 25% of their sales volume.
The good news is that their product is unique and is protected for 15 more years with utility patents. It is not a commodity so it achieves healthy margins. The product is an eco friendly product so the retailers value that. Finally, the product can be used in retailer programs where it is combined with other same category products for the spring tune up and the fall tune up. It helps drive the sales of other products.
The ideal company buyer is a larger company that provides products in the same category and sells to the same retailers. They could plug this product into their existing distribution channel and immediately drive additional sales. They would strengthen their position within their accounts by offering an additional product, a unique product, an eco friendly product, and a product that would promote companion product sales. It would also provide a unique door opener to other major accounts that would want this unique product.
With the input from our clients we located a handful of companies that fit this profile. We were pretty excited at the prospects of our potential buyers recognizing all of these value drivers and making purchase offers that were not based on historical financial performance. The book, memorandum, confidential business review, executive summary, or whatever your business broker or merger and acquisition advisor calls it, will certainly point out all of the strategic value that this company can provide the company that is lucky enough to buy it.
As part of the buying process we usually distribute the book and then get a round of additional questions from the buyer. We submit those to our client and then provide the answers to the buyer with a request for a conference call. We had moved the process to this point with two buyers that we thought were similar companies. The two conference calls were totally different.
The first one included the Merger and Acquisition guy and the three top people responsible for the product category. Their questions really indicated that they were used to being leveraged as a commodity provider by the big box retailers. Why were co-op advertising costs so high? Were they required to do that again in order to stay on the shelves? Were they on the plan-o-gram? Was Wal*Mart demanding that they be at a lower price than Lowes? What about shipping expenses? Why were profits so low? We had a very bad vibe from these guys. They were refusing to recognize that this was a high gross margin product growing in sales by over 200% year over year and had a higher level of promotional expense than a mature commodity product line. We couldn't determine if they just didn't get it or were they being dumb like a fox to dampen our value expectations.
The second call from the other company included the Merger and Acquisition guy and the EVP. The whole tone of the questioning was different. The questions focused on growth in sales, pricing power, new client potential, growth strategy, their status at the major accounts, remaining life on the patent and what their strategy was for new categories and markets.
Well we got the initial offers and they could not have been more different. The first company could not get beyond evaluating the acquisition as if it were a mature, commodity type product with paper thin margins. Their offer was an EBITDA multiple bid without taking into consideration that the product sales had grown at over 200% year over year and the marketing and promotional expenses were heavily front end loaded.
The second company understood the strategic value and they reflected it in the offer. It was not an apples to apples comparison, because the second offer was cash at close plus a significant earn out component while the first offer was all cash at close. However, the conservative mid-point of the combined cash and earn out offer was 300% higher than the offer from the first buyer. This was the biggest disparity between offers I have ever experienced, but it was quite instructive of the necessity to get multiple opinions by the market of potential buyers.
There are some companies that no matter how hard we try will not be perceived as a strategic acquisition by any buyer and they are going to sell at a financial multiple. Those companies are often main street type companies like gas stations, convenience stores and dry cleaners that are acquired by individual buyers. If you are a B2B company, have a competitive niche, and are not selling into a commodity type pricing structure, it is important to get multiple buyers involved and to get at least one of those buyers to acknowledge the strategic value.
Related Articles
A Major Concern for Business Sellers - What Happens to My Employees
By: Dave Kauppi | 31/10/2007 | Finance
One of the biggest concerns of business sellers is what will happen to their loyal employees when the new owner takes over. There is a common misperception that the new owner will come in and slash and burn in order to hit their profit targets. The reality for the family business could not be farther from the truth.
Business Buyers Negotiating Tactics
By: Dave Kauppi | 05/11/2007 | Finance
When was the last time you walked into a car dealership and paid sticker price for that new car. How about never. As a business seller, do not expect an experienced buyer to over pay for your business. The negotiation process should not be taken as a personal attack. This article discusses the thrust and perry of negotiations to buy and sell a business.
Business Sellers - Beware of Potential Changes in the Capital Gains Tax
By: Dave Kauppi | 20/11/2007 | Taxes
If You are a business owner thinking of selling in the next few years, pay particular attention to the talk on capital hill about where they plan on getting the $800 Billion that will be lost by the repeal of the Alternative Minimum Tax. I think it will come right out of your pocket.
Capital Gains Deferral in a Business Sale
By: Dave Kauppi | 25/11/2007 | Taxes
The second most important consideration in the sale of the business is the tax situation. Even though capital gains taxes are comparatively low compared to ordinary income, a business sale usually invokes an eye popping tax bill. We have discovered a very effective to help reduce the effects of capital gains taxes in a business sale.
Selling Your Business - What Would Sam Zell Do?
By: Dave Kauppi | 12/02/2007 | Finance
Sam Zell, multibillionaire founder of Equity Residential (EQR) has approached the sale of his business the right way. Sellers of privately held businesses can learn a great deal from his approach. This article explores his process.
Baby Boomer Business Sellers - The Rush to the Exits Could Erode Company Valuations
By: Dave Kauppi | 01/12/2007 | Finance
The Baby Boomers are retiring in large numbers over the next ten years and the impact on the economic landscape of America will be dramatic. This article will examine those trends and the likely impact on business valuations over the next several years.
Business Brokers - Bad Practices from the Big Boys
By: Dave Kauppi | 03/04/2007 | Finance
The business broker profession has earned a poor reputation with attorneys and accountants. This is largely the result of a few national firms that use questionable marketing practices. This article analyzes a real case and exposes the practice.
Sell a Company - How is the Selling Price Determined?
By: Dave Kauppi | 17/01/2008 | Finance
Business valuations are a valuable tool to set a range of prices when you sell a business. The only true way to determine value, however, is to present the business to the universe of buyers in a true open market bidding process.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Finance Articles
Why Finding the Right Coin Price Guide is Important
By: Gareth Bray | 29/08/2008
If you're new at coin collecting, you might find yourself overly excited at the prospect of finding or holding a coin that's priceless. Some coins are worth more than others, while other coins are not worth anything at all. To help you figure out if what you have is treasure...
The How and Why Behind Online Stock Investing
By: Jack Benson | 29/08/2008
Do you want to get involved in stock trading? The modern and easy way to do it is online.
Let's explore a bit of the history of stock trading. The first continuous stock exchange trading took place in Amsterdam during the 17th century. Before this stock exchange, during the 13th century...
Benefits To Refinancing Your Mortgage
By: Edwin Hezron | 29/08/2008
A lot of people don't really understands what it means to refinance your mortgage, Though it a popular term but it has been greatly misunderstood.Despite the several factors that may influence it, there are different benefits to refinancing your mortgage.
Refinancing your mortgage has a lot of advantages in this our...
Finding Finance Inside Your Business
By: Rakesh Gaikwad | 29/08/2008
Many businesses are finding it increasingly difficult to secure funding for expansion at the moment due to the credit crunch, but there are still ways to raise the money that you need for expansion.
The first thing to remember about borrowing money is that you will need to be able to...
Try An Asset Protection Trust In Mauritius To Pass Your Assets On To Your Family!
By: Ramapati Singhania | 29/08/2008
Asset protection trusts are time tested legal instruments to save your wealth and pass it on to whomever you choose.
Why You Need To Avoid Repeated Finance Applications
By: Peter Kenny | 29/08/2008
Over recent months lenders have had to really tighten up on their lending criteria, and this means that many of those that may have been eligible for a credit card, loan, mortgage, or car finance last summer may now find that they encounter real difficulties when it comes to getting the credit that they need
How To Use Debt Consolidation To Get Yourself Out Of Debt
By: Peter Kenny | 29/08/2008
With the increased costs of energy, fuel and food, more and more homeowners are finding themselves in financial difficulty having to cope with these rising prices as well as higher payments on their mortgages because of higher interest rates charged by lenders
Make Sure You Get A Fair Price For Your Home
By: Peter Kenny | 29/08/2008
Most people have heard that the property market has slowed down considerably over recent months, with a number of factors affecting the level of property sales that are being seen. Estate agents have reported very poor property sales, and many homeowners are struggling to try and sell their properties
More from Dave Kauppi
Tax Consequences of Selling a Business
By: Dave Kauppi | 09/07/2008 | Taxes
If you are thinking about selling your business, the first thing you should do is to consult your tax accountant to understand the tax consequences of various transaction structures and the resulting after tax proceeds from a stock sale versus an asset sale.
Reduce Capital Gains Tax in the Sale of a Business
By: Dave Kauppi | 01/07/2008 | Taxes
The sale of your business will be your largest financial transaction. As a business owner, you have benefited from the growth in the value of your business tax free. Unfortunately when you sell your business, it is time to pay up with capital gains taxes. This article discusses an approach that allows you to again defer your capital gains taxes, maximizing the returns from your business sale.
Sell a Software Company - The Valuation Dilema
By: Dave Kauppi | 16/06/2008 | Finance
One of the most challenging aspects of selling a software company is coming up with a business valuation. Sometimes the valuations provided by the market defy all logic. This article explores the key elements that drive software company valuation multiples.
Private Equity May Be Your Best Business Exit Strategy
By: Dave Kauppi | 16/05/2008 | Finance
This article discusses the dynamics of private equity investments into family owned businesses and under which circumstances they may be the best business exit strategy.
Ten Reasons to Sell Your Information Technology Company
By: Dave Kauppi | 15/04/2008 | Finance
Discression is the better part of valor was appropriate in the writings of William Shakespeare. It may also be appropriate in the rapidly changing environment of the information technology entrapreneur. This article discusses reasons an owner may consider selling his company.
The Number One Driver of Business Valuation in a Software Company Sale
By: Dave Kauppi | 02/04/2008 | Finance
Considering selling your software or information technology company? This article discusses the most important thing you can do to increase your selling price.
Not Invented Here is Not an Option for The Large Beverage Companies
By: Dave Kauppi | 29/03/2008 | Finance
The innovation in the beverage industry is coming from a group of entrepreneurs known as the new rule makers. This article discusses an approach to form equity partnerships between these start-ups and the beverage industry giants.
Healthcare Information Technology - Business Valuation
By: Dave Kauppi | 28/03/2008 | Finance
Business valuations for healthcare information technology companies is more of an art than a science. Ultimately a competitive market bid situation is the only true method. We attempt to quantify the important valuation elements in this article.
Finance 
