Amy Danise is an editor for Insure.com. Visit Insure.com for a comprehensive array of comparative auto, life and health quotes, including a vast library of originally authored insurance articles and decision-making tools that are not available from any other single source. Insure.com is dedicated to providing impartial insurance information to consumers. Visitors can obtain instant insurance quotes from more than 200 leading insurers, achieve maximum savings and have the freedom to buy from any company shown.
If all of our neighbors would just drive even less, we'd get lower auto insurance rates.
And that could be in the process of happening. When Americans spend less time on the road, the frequency of auto accidents declines. And when auto accidents go down, so do claims on auto insurance. That gets the ball rolling: When auto insurance companies see their costs on claims declining steadily, they typically respond to market conditions by lowering their auto insurance quotes and, ultimately auto insurance rates in a bid to stay competitive. And voila!, we write smaller checks for our auto insurance premiums.
With run-away gas prices, Americans are already driving less. The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) reported in May 2008 that Americans are driving at "historic lows." The estimated "vehicle miles traveled," or VMT, for March 2008 fell 4.3 percent compared to March 2007, making it the sharpest dip for any month since the FHWA began tracking traffic-volume trends in 1942. Want to follow driving trends? The FHWA publishes monthly "Traffic Volume Trends."
When auto accident claims go down, auto insurance companies can usually respond fairly quickly. To adjust premiums, they must file new auto insurance rates with every state in which they operate. They can file new auto insurance rates any time they want to respond to market conditions, and many states offer a "file and use" system, where auto insurance companies can file new auto insurance rates and begin using them immediately without prior approval from the state insurance department. Some states even have a "use and file" system, so insurers can implement new auto insurance rates and then officially file them shortly thereafter. This way auto insurance companies can begin passing on savings (or increases) right away.
The nation's largest auto insurance companies are the first to see trends in accidents and claims payments due to the sheer volume of their claims data. For example, State Farm, the nation's largest auto insurance company, handles about 19 million auto insurance claims a year (that's a little over 17 claims per minute, all day, every day).
Robert Passmore, Director of Personal Lines for Property Casualty Insurers Association of America (PCIAA), an industry trade group, says, "This is where you see competition kick in." He notes that if you live in a state that requires "prior approval," it would take a longer time to see rate reductions. That means Californians and New Yorkers could be tapping their toes waiting for auto insurance rate reductions while everyone else pockets savings.
Auto insurance companies also note that auto insurance rates have been holding steady or declining over the past few years anyway. For example, State Farm customers in all states have seen rate reductions between Jan. 1, 2004, and Dec. 31, 2007, and customers in 39 of those states saw double-digit percentage rate decreases. (State Farm policyholders in New Jersey got the biggest drop of 29.19 percent.)
Passmore cautions that other factors could offset the trend in reduced driving specifically, medical costs from bodily injury claims, legal costs relating to claims disputes and repair costs that are, for now, rising faster than the rate at which auto accident claims are going down.
Darn those repair, medical and legal costs! If it weren't for those, drivers could already be seeing lower auto insurance rates (as we sit at home). However, auto insurance companies generally agree that if we see significant auto accident reductions, lower auto insurance rates won't be too far behind.
Perhaps at the $6-a-gallon mark?
Will reduced driving mean lower auto insurance rates?
Insure.com asked the nation's top auto insurance companies whether high gas prices and reduced driving are translating to lower auto insurance rates yet. Here are their answers.
State Farm spokesperson Dick Luedke notes that State Farm auto insurance rates have been on the decline nationwide since 2004, but reduced auto accident claims are not yet leading directly to further auto insurance rate reductions: "Our actuaries look at claims data not just to see the recent past, but also to see what might change the future, like gas prices."
Luedke says there's no hard and fast rule as to what level of auto accident reduction would spark lower auto insurance rates, but says, "If we saw a reduction as big as 10 percent in accident frequency, we would have reacted long before that."
Allstate spokesperson Kate Hollcraft says, "We have just recently seen a decline in automobile claim frequency and if this continues through the summer months, we would probably be able to attribute it to a rise in fuel costs."
Progressive spokesperson Leah Knapp says, "We don't speculate about future rate changes, but it would be accurate to say that we continuously review market and business conditions, including monitoring losses, so that we can ensure our policies are accurately priced everywhere we do business. When our analysis suggests our rates require adjustment, we may seek to either raise or lower rates accordingly."
Nationwide Vice President & Policyholder, Standard Auto Product & Pricing, Larry Thursby, observes that "customers are having fewer accidents." But he notes it's been that way for a couple of years due to a variety of factors, like an aging population that becomes safer drivers, graduated licensing laws for teens and crackdowns in drunk driving. In addition, potential auto insurance rate reductions due to accident frequency are being offset by inflation in the usual suspects: medical and hospital costs, repair costs and legal costs.
Thursby says that Nationwide has been passing along cost savings by offering guaranteed renewability, lower surcharges and broader "forgiveness" for accidents, fender-benders and minor violations.
And that could be in the process of happening. When Americans spend less time on the road, the frequency of auto accidents declines. And when auto accidents go down, so do claims on auto insurance. That gets the ball rolling: When auto insurance companies see their costs on claims declining steadily, they typically respond to market conditions by lowering their auto insurance quotes and, ultimately auto insurance rates in a bid to stay competitive. And voila!, we write smaller checks for our auto insurance premiums.
With run-away gas prices, Americans are already driving less. The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) reported in May 2008 that Americans are driving at "historic lows." The estimated "vehicle miles traveled," or VMT, for March 2008 fell 4.3 percent compared to March 2007, making it the sharpest dip for any month since the FHWA began tracking traffic-volume trends in 1942. Want to follow driving trends? The FHWA publishes monthly "Traffic Volume Trends."
When auto accident claims go down, auto insurance companies can usually respond fairly quickly. To adjust premiums, they must file new auto insurance rates with every state in which they operate. They can file new auto insurance rates any time they want to respond to market conditions, and many states offer a "file and use" system, where auto insurance companies can file new auto insurance rates and begin using them immediately without prior approval from the state insurance department. Some states even have a "use and file" system, so insurers can implement new auto insurance rates and then officially file them shortly thereafter. This way auto insurance companies can begin passing on savings (or increases) right away.
The nation's largest auto insurance companies are the first to see trends in accidents and claims payments due to the sheer volume of their claims data. For example, State Farm, the nation's largest auto insurance company, handles about 19 million auto insurance claims a year (that's a little over 17 claims per minute, all day, every day).
Robert Passmore, Director of Personal Lines for Property Casualty Insurers Association of America (PCIAA), an industry trade group, says, "This is where you see competition kick in." He notes that if you live in a state that requires "prior approval," it would take a longer time to see rate reductions. That means Californians and New Yorkers could be tapping their toes waiting for auto insurance rate reductions while everyone else pockets savings.
Auto insurance companies also note that auto insurance rates have been holding steady or declining over the past few years anyway. For example, State Farm customers in all states have seen rate reductions between Jan. 1, 2004, and Dec. 31, 2007, and customers in 39 of those states saw double-digit percentage rate decreases. (State Farm policyholders in New Jersey got the biggest drop of 29.19 percent.)
Passmore cautions that other factors could offset the trend in reduced driving specifically, medical costs from bodily injury claims, legal costs relating to claims disputes and repair costs that are, for now, rising faster than the rate at which auto accident claims are going down.
Darn those repair, medical and legal costs! If it weren't for those, drivers could already be seeing lower auto insurance rates (as we sit at home). However, auto insurance companies generally agree that if we see significant auto accident reductions, lower auto insurance rates won't be too far behind.
Perhaps at the $6-a-gallon mark?
Will reduced driving mean lower auto insurance rates?
Insure.com asked the nation's top auto insurance companies whether high gas prices and reduced driving are translating to lower auto insurance rates yet. Here are their answers.
State Farm spokesperson Dick Luedke notes that State Farm auto insurance rates have been on the decline nationwide since 2004, but reduced auto accident claims are not yet leading directly to further auto insurance rate reductions: "Our actuaries look at claims data not just to see the recent past, but also to see what might change the future, like gas prices."
Luedke says there's no hard and fast rule as to what level of auto accident reduction would spark lower auto insurance rates, but says, "If we saw a reduction as big as 10 percent in accident frequency, we would have reacted long before that."
Allstate spokesperson Kate Hollcraft says, "We have just recently seen a decline in automobile claim frequency and if this continues through the summer months, we would probably be able to attribute it to a rise in fuel costs."
Progressive spokesperson Leah Knapp says, "We don't speculate about future rate changes, but it would be accurate to say that we continuously review market and business conditions, including monitoring losses, so that we can ensure our policies are accurately priced everywhere we do business. When our analysis suggests our rates require adjustment, we may seek to either raise or lower rates accordingly."
Nationwide Vice President & Policyholder, Standard Auto Product & Pricing, Larry Thursby, observes that "customers are having fewer accidents." But he notes it's been that way for a couple of years due to a variety of factors, like an aging population that becomes safer drivers, graduated licensing laws for teens and crackdowns in drunk driving. In addition, potential auto insurance rate reductions due to accident frequency are being offset by inflation in the usual suspects: medical and hospital costs, repair costs and legal costs.
Thursby says that Nationwide has been passing along cost savings by offering guaranteed renewability, lower surcharges and broader "forgiveness" for accidents, fender-benders and minor violations.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
Cheap Auto Insurance Rates Come in Many Forms
By: Jim Bassett | 08/11/2009If you're looking for cheap auto insurance rates, you should know about a few things. First of all, if you're not looking in the right places, you may end up paying too much for your auto coverage. Ask about discounts that are available to lower your rates. You can find...
You Can Find Cheap Car Insurance For Young Drivers
By: Jim Bassett | 08/11/2009If you've been dreading the day that you have to get car insurance for your young driver, you'll be happy to hear that cheap car insurance for young drivers really does exist. If you get online and do a little research, it won't take you long to realize that you...
Looking For Affordable Car Insurance Locally
By: Jim Bassett | 08/11/2009Looking for affordable car insurance? Who isn't these days, right? Well, as expensive as it is to own and operate an automobile, you probably wish more than anything that you didn't have to buy insurance. Most states have very strict insurance requirements that can land you in trouble with the...
Auto Insurance Comparisons in Florida
By: Jim Bassett | 08/11/2009Have you taken time to get auto insurance comparisons in Florida? You may be paying a higher price than you have to unless you get comparison quotes you will not know. Florida and the No-Fault system have worked to provide coverage to those even if they are not at fault...
How to Get Low Cost Car Insurance
By: Jim Bassett | 08/11/2009Everybody that drives on the highway needs car insurance. It can be costly depending upon your circumstances. But there are numerous ways you can try to acquire low cost car insurance. Why pay an extortionate amount when you don't have to! Now it is possible to quickly compare quotes through...
Debt Settlements Vs Bankruptcy - Which Financial Decision is Better?
By: Matt Couch | 08/11/2009When looking to get rid of debt, there are two mainline ways of doing so- debt settlements and bankruptcy. But which financial decision is better? Bankruptcy can have near-fatal effects on your credit rating for years to come, making it hard to recover from. Debt settlement appears to be the solution because creditors work with you, and sometimes you only have to pay back a fraction of the unsecured debt.
Debt Settlement Programs - How to Locate the Most Respected Debt Relief Programs
By: Matt Couch | 08/11/2009Debt settlement programs vary widely in both their structure and their overall effectiveness in eliminating your debt. Consumers generally need to be at least $10,000 in unsecured debt to qualify for debt settlement programs but the most important thing to know is how to locate the best programs on the market.
Debt Solutions - How Obama is Making Debt Solutions Financially Popular
By: Matt Couch | 08/11/2009In this financially stressful time, everyone seems to be hurting a little bit. Even families, who were not struggling before this, seem to be struggling now. Job loss is still high. Qualified and educated candidates do not quite find jobs as nice as the ones they lost.
Downsizing: Switching to a Smaller Car Can Increase Your Insurance Bill
By: Amy Danise | 02/09/2008 | FinanceAmericans are looking to smaller cars for savings on spiraling gas prices and for lower emissions, but will car insurance savings follow, too?
State Farm Car Insurance Claims Lead to Better Vehicle Design
By: Amy Danise | 01/09/2008 | FinanceImagine that the company you work for started getting 17 calls per minute from customers with problems, and that the phone rang off the hook 24 hours a day, every day. You'd think something had gone terribly wrong.
"return of Premium" Term Life Insurance Comes of Age
By: Amy Danise | 20/06/2008 | FinanceIf you'd like to have term life insurance in place to provide for beneficiaries yet you're confident you'll outlive the life insurance policy, you now have many options for "return of premium" (ROP) term life insurance. Under this type of life insurance policy, if no death benefit has been paid by the end of your life insurance term, you receive all your premiums back.
Car Insurance Coverage for Pets in Car Accidents
By: Amy Danise | 19/06/2008 | FinancePets ride in cars all the time, but what if they're injured in a car accident? Whose car insurance company pays to treat their injuries? The answer depends on the cause of the accident.
Car Insurance Faqs: How to Buy Car Insurance
By: Amy Danise | 12/06/2008 | FinanceFrom lowering your insurance premiums to adding a teen driver to your policy, buying car insurance can be a confusing, overwhelming, and expensive process. However, it is a necessary part of life, and can save you a lot of stress and money in the future. It may seem like a daunting task, but there is an easier way to shop for car insurance quotes and rates.
Auto Insurance Faqs: Accidents Happen
By: Amy Danise | 12/06/2008 | FinanceWith over 6 million auto accidents per year in the United States alone, there's a good chance that you or someone close to you will be involved in an auto accident at some point. Having auto insurance is a great way to be prepared for an auto accident. When shopping for auto insurance, it's important to look at auto insurance rates and quotes and do some comparing.
The Lowdown on Life Insurance Medical Exams
By: Amy Danise | 23/05/2008 | FinanceThere are three main ways a new life insurance policy is priced: Underwritten policies are those where you answer questions on your personal and family medical history and undergo a medical exam arranged by the insurance company; a simplified issue life insurance policy application asks you some medical questions but does not require a medical exam; and a guaranteed issue life insurance policy requires no questions and no medical exam.