ArticlesBase.com - Free Articles Directory
Free Online Articles Directory
24.07.2008 Sign In Register Hello Guest
Email:
Password:
Remember Me 
forgot your password?


Which is Better for Burning Fat, Weight Training Or Cardio?

Author: Dan Swanson Author Ranking Blue | Posted: 29-08-2006 | Comments: 0 | Views: 340 | Rating:  (58) Article Popularity - Blue (?) Got a Question? Ask.

I recently received a letter from one of my readers:

Dear Jon, You've written in Fit Over 40 (which I LOVE, btw), that you believe cardio is "overrated" and that training with weights is better for fat loss. This seems to run contrary to what Tom Venuto says in his book, Burn The Fat, Feed The Muscle, and what a lot of other experts in the field say, but I cannot help but listen, especially given your results and the results of everyone else in this book. Thanks — Joseph Surelli; New York, NY P.S. I should mention that I've already "discarded" (I'm using your terms and they work) over 40 pounds of fat in six months, however I do more cardio than you do. Joseph

My man, you are rockin! Great results...and they are very similar to a lot of emails I receive on a daily basis. Okay, on to your question.

Yes, I did say that, or rather something ‘close' to that. Here is my official, "take this to the courts" stance on how best to shed body fat for good, and this does not require you to be 21, belong to a fancy gym, or heaven forbid do hours of spin classes.

Your meals come before exercise, it's "Mind, Meals, Muscle, then Motion...in that order." So, unless you have your nutrition on the mark, forget shedding fat. It wont' happen.

What meal plan? My advice is to start with a balanced meal plan, or "isocaloric", in which you obtain roughly 1/3 of your calories from protein, 1/3 from carbs (low-glycemic and non- sugar-based carbs) and 1/3 from fats (both mono and saturated fats....yes, saturated.)

Divide your calories by 6 (a good start would be 12x your body weight for discarding fat) and prep each meal around this figure and these macro ratios.

Muscle is next...not cardio, but muscle. Why? Muscle burns calories 24/7. Nothing else can come close. Train with weights, or train with "any" form of progressive resistance (in-home training is fine. The bottom line is to train, and do so in a progressive fashion. Build muscle, even a few pounds, and it will help serve your metabolic needs in the long run...plus it will make your body curvy, sexy and "toned" (although I don't care for that term.)

You mentioned Tom Venuto. Interestingly enough, he and I did a recorded interview just last night on this subject, and even he (the StairMaster Master) agrees that weights are superior to cardio in post-exercise metabolic response. In short, your metabolism will stay elevated longer after weight training than any other form of exercise.

Finally, there's Motion...in this sense, I'm referring only to cardiovascular work. Yes, it is overrated, but certainly not useless. In fact, it's critical at times. What I meant by that statement is that most people ONLY do cardio while trying to burn body fat, and that's just a plan for disaster. Without meals and muscle, cardio is a wash for shedding fat, but can still be an excellent means of exercising the heart.

Weight training rules when it comes to overall health and fat shedding benefits if done correctly.

Rate this Article: Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/fitness-articles/which-is-better-for-burning-fat-weight-training-or-cardio-51477.html

Print this Article Print article   Email to a Friend Send to friend   Publish this Article on your Website Publish this Article   Send Author Feedback Author feedback  
About the Author:

Jon Benson is a nutrition and fitness counselor who specializes in weight loss and life coaching.
He is the creator of The Fit Over 40 Role Modeling System, and the author of "Fit Over 40".
More information on fitness is available at http://www.fitover40.com.

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Comment on this article Comment on this article
Your Name
Your Email:
Comment Body
Enter Validation Code: Captcha


Related Articles

Blood Sugar and Burning Fat – Part 1
By: Axis Labs | 24/07/2008 | Weight Loss
You have probably heard several variations of what the “goods” and “bads” about eating carbs. However do you really know why the anti-carb diet is such a debate? Learn valuable information about blood sugar levels and health by reading this article.

Blood Sugar and Burning Fat – Part 2
By: Axis Labs | 24/07/2008 | Weight Loss
In the modern day fitness industry there are some common misconceptions on the timing of food consumption to lose fat and/or gain muscle. Should you eat right before a workout? When is the best time to do cardio to burn fat? Learn valuable information by reading this article.

Blood Sugar and Cancer
By: Axis Labs | 24/07/2008 | Cancer
Having high blood sugar not only influences obesity and heart related ailments but may also increase the risk of falling ill to certain kinds of cancers. Learn why it is important to monitor your blood sugar if you hope to live long.

Fitness - The Key to the Fountain of Youth
By: Mike Hepburn | 25/02/2008 | Muscle Building
This article was written to give some great ideas on ways you can get your exercise routines on track. Working out releases endorphins and speeds up your metabolism, once you start to experience these feelings and see results you won't want to live without them.

Defeat Your Skinny Genetics
By: Vince Delmonte | 03/04/2008 | Muscle Building
It happens every year. The New Year comes and every scrawny twerp on the planet swears this is going to be the year that he slaps on an extra 20 pounds of muscle. But if you didn't pack it on successfully last year, what makes you think this year is going to be any different? Seriously?

Top 10 Tips to Successful Teen Bodybuilding Part 1
By: Vince Delmonte | 03/04/2008 | Muscle Building
Teen bodybuilding is growing at an alarming rate, as enthusiastic teens hit the gym every night of the week. I don't blame them. Teen bodybuilding is one of the most effective ways to boost a skinny guys self-confidence and self-image. Did I also mention lots of attention and admiration from the ladies and respect from the guys. Teen bodybuilding does not just help out with vanity but promotes a nutritious diet, disciplined lifestyle, and strong work ethic.

Top 49 Things I Learned in 2006
By: Vince Delmonte | 03/04/2008 | Muscle Building
Pull ups are better than pull downs. Duh.

Top 10 Tips to Successful Teen Bodybuilding Part 2
By: Vince Delmonte | 03/04/2008 | Muscle Building
As discussed in part one, teen bodybuilding can start at a very young age allowing young fitness enthusiasts a whole new world to pursue.

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it true that if you want to burn fat you should ...
By: aperham78 | 21-07-2008
is it true that if you want to burn fat you should keep your heart rate lower like at 120 or 130 rather than to do high impact cardio?

I have severe Fibromyalgia which makes exercise ...
By: lilsooner | 21-07-2008
I have severe Fibromyalgia which makes exercise extremely painful. We do have a pool, to which I try to exercise in, but does anyone have any idea's about a less painful exercise I could do durning the winter months? Thank you & many Blessings, lilsooner53

Got a question about diet & fitness? Type your ...
By: italiandrlf | 21-07-2008
Got a question about diet & fitness? Type your question here...whats the best exercise to do to loose that flabby saggy back skin.. im 5 ft 3 130 lbs 57 yrs old / thanks for any help

Height? Weight?
By: Anilec08 | 21-07-2008
im 5'6 , how much am i suppose to weigh according to my height?

I have been struggling with losing about 8 lbs. I ...
By: WonderWomen | 21-07-2008
I have been struggling with losing about 8 lbs. I am 5'3 excersise regularly. I am toned everywhere but the middle. I need help with my stomach, some days it feels so bloated and I have a muffin top other days it seems smaller. I do eat well...yes I cheat here and there but not excessive. This is really depressing for me personally...I just want to lose this big belly I have to match the rest of my body. Please help

Rather there than on my head....
By: Karen Lunn | 21-07-2008
I have gone thru menopause & lost almost all pubic hair, therefore I am shaving what I have left off.  (very little)  Please advise if there is anything I can do to regrow hair in this place. thank you

Q&A Powered by:
Powered by Yedda 

Latest Fitness Articles

Meditation of Yoga
By: prabakar | 24/07/2008
Kundalini Yoga is the original and most powerful of the twenty-two schools of yoga, all of which are beneficial. As our society becomes increasingly technological, our world becomes more intimately connected and influenced by its numerous cultures. If you can practice at the same time each day, you will find that you will improve rapidly.

Meal Planning
By: Alien | 24/07/2008
Meal planning involves learning how to choose foods and eating the appropriate amounts. The so,called diabetic diet is no different from the diet that all people ought to be eating.

Proteins and Other Nutrients
By: Alien | 24/07/2008
Proteins have four calories per gram and are the most slowly absorbed foods. Until the early 1980s, fats were considered to be the slowest-absorbing of the three food groups. Research from a university on the East Coast determined otherwise.

Scientific Kundalini Yoga
By: prabakar | 24/07/2008
Kundalini Yoga combines breathing, movement, meditation, stretching, relaxation, the science of sequence, and rhythm and sound, to work on every aspect of your body, mind, and being. When you take this system to heart, your life becomes consecrated to the process of expansion and growth.

Stress Relief the Herbal Way
By: Paul Phillips | 24/07/2008
It seems like just about everyone is leading busy, hectic lives. Now, more than ever, people are looking for ways to deal with stress. And, for many, herbal stress relief is the answer they have been looking for.

Emergency Alert Services
By: Kevin Reilly | 24/07/2008
This article is for people like me- who have elderly parents or in-laws who live alone and are not in the greatest of health. My mother-in-law wants to live on her own but we worry about her. Having the Life Station medical alert in her home helps us sleep better at night knowing if she needs help, it's only a click away.

Burn Fat Quickly
By: Richard Adams | 24/07/2008
Revealed the proven techniques that will allow you to burn fat fast.

3 Tips to Getting Rid of Belly Fat Fast
By: Michael Jans | 24/07/2008
Getting rid of belly fat and getting a strong six pack abs is not as hard as many make it. Some simple dietary changes can put you well on the track to eliminating your belly fat.

More from Dan Swanson

How Are You Treating Your Company's Most Valuable Asset?
By: Dan Swanson | 20/10/2006 | Marketing
Most companies overlook an asset they worked very hard to create but fail to continue to nurture.

What Can you Do About Joint and Muscle Pain?
By: Dan Swanson | 29/08/2006 | Women's Issues
Diet related recommendations that will give you pain relief.

Ideal Illusion: Ending the Myth of the Balanced Life
By: Dan Swanson | 29/08/2006 | Fitness
Should we have a balanced life or focus with intensity on our primary goals?

Obesity Linked to Wasted Time and Early Death
By: Dan Swanson | 29/08/2006 | Fitness
Two recent studies show obesity is life-draining and can result in early death.

How to Overcome Social Anxiety and Perfectionism at Work
By: Dan Swanson | 29/08/2006 | Self Help
Do you find yourself nervous when interacting with colleagues or performing various tasks? Do you frequently worry about your work performance? Some simple steps you can take to help.

6 Steps to Speaking Without Social Anxiety
By: Dan Swanson | 29/08/2006 | Communication
Specific steps you can take to reduce your anxieties of public speaking. You can go from being anxious to being a confident speaker.

Article Categories






Give Feedback

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below