Remember Me
forgot your password?

Push to Ban Smoking Goes Too Far

[This was published June 9, 2007 in the Springfield, IL State Journal-Register]

Both the Springfield, IL anti-smoking ordinance and the Smoke Free Illinois Act have a well-intentioned public purpose - to safeguard public health. But when the Springfield City Council and the Illinois General Assembly included private clubs in their prohibitions, they overreached.

Our fundamental law, the United States Constitution, enumerates many of our individual rights that government is obligated to protect, such as the freedom of speech and the right to a fair trial, but there are also individual rights which, although not specifically mentioned in the Constitution, have been judged to be constitutionally protected by the ultimate interpreter of the Constitution - the United States Supreme Court.

In 1964, the court held that although freedom of association is not expressly mentioned in the Constitution, it is a peripheral First Amendment right because "its existence is necessary in making the express guarantees fully meaningful." And delivering the opinion of the court in a 1965 case Justice William Douglas wrote, " ... the First Amendment has a penumbra where privacy is protected from governmental intrusion."

Of course, this does not mean that all private behavior is constitutionally protected any more than it means that all speech is protected - a person does not have a constitutional right to yell "Fire!" in a crowded theater. But it does mean that the government must have a well-defined interest that passes a standard of strict scrutiny when regulating constitutionally protected private behavior like the freedom of association.

Both city and state actions demonstrate that their lawmakers are completely oblivious to the difference between "public" and "private."

Smoke Free Illinois "prohibits smoking in public places, places of employment, and governmental vehicles ..." In order to make their intentions clear, legislators often include definitions of key words within the text of the law itself. In the Smoke Free Illinois Act a "public place" is defined as "that portion of any building or vehicle used by and open to the public ..." And to further enlighten their constituents, legislators have provided an "includes, but not limited" list of no less than 50 examples of public places ranging from libraries, museums and concert halls to retail stores, restaurants and bars.

The Springfield City Council provided the same kind of "public place" examples in its anti-smoking ordinance. Unfortunately, there is one entry in both lists, which according to the law writers' own definitions does not belong - private clubs. Illinois legislators define "private club" to mean, "a not-for-profit association ... used exclusively for club purposes at all times" while, at the same time, they declare that "public places" are places "used by and open to the public."

Whether or not a private club chooses to open its doors to the public is the choice of its members. That choice is what makes it private.

The Springfield daily paper, the State Journal-Register, recently editorialized that private clubs may not opt out of fire safety codes, but neither can private homes. Does this make them public places as well?

Suppose a bunch of guys belong to a duck-hunting club located on several acres of property on which a clubhouse rests, which can be found only if you know where to look.

After a long, cold day sitting in a blind, these guys like to gather in front of a warm fire, down a few beers and smoke cigars. How is public health being harmed, and where does the government interest lie in making this an illegal activity?

Enforcement of such laws on private club members will not make the public safer and will likely require the same kind of approach federal "revenuers" employed when they hunted "moonshiners" during Prohibition. The results would probably be similar as well - few arrests, and a decrease in respect for the rule of law.

Gary Watts
Retired teacher -- math, political studies B.A. math, M.A. political studies
Rate this Article: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s)
Print Email Re-Publish


Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/health-and-safety-articles/push-to-ban-smoking-goes-too-far-181996.html
Add new Comment



Captcha

  • Latest Health and Safety Articles
  • More from Gary Watts

California Product Liability Issues Are A Concern

By: Joel Mclaughlin | 07/07/2009
There are various types of product recalls that take place every year in the United States. Food is recalled when it is discovered to be contaminated with viral pathogens like salmonella and e coli. Car seats are recalled when they’re found to be unsafe to use for children. Prescription drugs are recalled when they cause unexpected, hazardous side effects in patients.

Young Workers Have Rights Too

By: catherine | 07/07/2009
A young man who took up a summer job to earn extra money was severely injured in his workplace. He went on to speak to other young workers about making sure they are aware of their rights in the workplace.

California Product Liability Issues Are A Concern

By: Joel Mclaughlin | 07/07/2009
There are various types of product recalls that take place every year in the United States. Food is recalled when it is discovered to be contaminated with viral pathogens like salmonella and e coli. Car seats are recalled when they’re found to be unsafe to use for children. Prescription drugs are recalled when they cause unexpected, hazardous side effects in patients.

Construction Accident Attorney - Did Your Employer Take Care of You?

By: Jack Hurst | 03/07/2009
No one plans to get injured while doing construction. When you get injured you may be able to set compensation from the owner of the construction company, the agents and contractors. Do not let anyone tell you that if you are receiving workers compensation that is all you are entitled to because this is not workers compensation. Finding a construction accident attorney is an essential fir...

On the Brink of Generic Biotech Drugs, What's the Cost to Innovation?

By: Jeff Fox | 03/07/2009
With the advent of biotech generic, an impact on the economy is guaranteed, albeit unquantifiable. Industry insiders highlight that the biotech sector also stands to undergo some immeasurable changes itself.

Get the Experienced Pennsylvania Medical Malpractice Lawyer

By: Jeff Lowenthal | 02/07/2009
Find the experienced Pennsylvania medical malpractice attorney to solve either your medical malpractice or dental malpractice case.

Asbestos Claims: Help With Real Estate Lawyers

By: Lilly Jovita Jones | 01/07/2009
Brief explanation of facts about asbestos and the cancer it causes.

Evacuation Chairs – Full Range of Evacuation Chairs From Health and Care

By: Toby Hargreaves | 28/06/2009
Evacuation chairs are a vital part of building and office evacuation planning, enabling colleagues to evacuate a disabled or injured person quickly and safely. Emergency evacuation of a disabled colleague from a building with stairs may prove difficult without access to an evacuation chair. Where lifts may be out of action, evacuation chairs are vital in ensuring safety for all members of staff.

Here, Freedom Works

By: Gary Watts | 24/12/2007 | Philosophy
Our social contract binds us in union for the purpose of enjoying the individual freedom to pursue happiness. . . Many bumps along the way,yet, what set of rules anytime, anywhere have worked as well for so many as ours?

Climate Odds Look a Little Long

By: Gary Watts | 15/05/2007 | Environment
In the view of many, if not most, of former Vice President and his followers any argument regarding global climate change is over. The scientific questions have been asked, answered and verified. Probability theory suggests that the odds of the many "sky is falling" predictions are a little long.

Negotiations not Always a Silver Bullet

By: Gary Watts | 28/01/2007 | Politics
In my view, those who think that negotiations are silver bullets for every possible situation either haven't had much experience negotiating or are terribly naive. Iran is the perfect case in point. . .There is only one incentive that would, in the short term, keep Iran's hands off of Iraq. Let them have the bomb. The president will not allow this.

Advanced Algebra not for Every Kid

By: Gary Watts | 09/01/2007 | Education
Most people can, do and will continue to lead very productive lives without having mastered algebra's algorithms. Not all students who enter high school have the intellectual capacity to be successful in second-year algebra. The solution is to "dummy down" the course, but this negates the reason most students take Algebra II -- most colleges require it. Colleges won't use Algebra II as a filter if it is no longer an advanced course. Advanced Algebra requirement does not help society either.

Submit Your Articles Free: Signup


Article Categories




Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (0.09, 1)