Is it true that Dr. William Glasser's Choice Theory doesn't believe in mental illness? Of course not! However, that is what many believe and some don't give his ideas credence because they think he is wrong about that. This article is my humble attempt to explain exactly what Dr. Glasser means when he says he believes in mental health, not mental illness. This article should be particularly helpful to those of you who work in the helping professions or those of you with family members who have been diagnosed with any type of mental disorder.
I'm asking you to take a journey with me into the realm of possibility. What if what we believe about mental illness is wrong in much the same way people in Columbus' day believed the world was flat? And if it's possible our conceptualization about mental illness is wrong, then it logically follows that perhaps we need to look at treatment differently.
My goal in this issue is not to change your mind about what you think and believe, but merely to present another possibility. Take a journey with me into an alternative explanation and see where it takes us . . .
Choice theory has two concepts that are central to this discussion. One is the concept of total behavior and the other is our creative system. I'll start with total behavior. Glasser says all behavior is total, meaning it consists of four inseparable components-your actions, your thinking, your feelings and your body's physiology. All of these components occur simultaneously, even when you are more aware of one of them.
You only have direct control over two of these components. No matter how hard you try, you will not be able to change your feelings or your body's physiology without first changing your actions or your thinking. You may not believe you have control over your thinking because sometimes certain thoughts enter our minds unbidden. However, once you learn how, you can direct your thoughts from unwanted topics to healthier ones.
When we want something we don't have, we are driven to create a behavior designed to get us what we want. Sometimes, we rely on behaviors we've used in the past that were effective. Other times we create a new behavior. Whatever our choice, we are choosing the best behavior available to us at the time to get what we want.
When it comes to mental health symptoms, many believe that an imbalance in our body's chemistry causes the unusual behavior or thinking. But what if the "crazy" behavior and thinking over an extended period of time actually causes the chemical imbalance instead? Isn't it at least possible? Isn't it exercising that releases endorphins into our blood? It's not the endorphins that make us exercise. Isn't it thoughts of bodily harm that releases the chemical adrenaline into our blood stream when we are scared? It's not the adrenaline that makes us scared, is it?
And what about those diagnoses that don't have a known chemical imbalance? What about Post Traumatic Stress Disorder or Dissociative Identity Disorder. These are groups of symptoms that develop during a serious crisis that serve us in that moment. In Choice Theory, Glasser would say they become organized behavior. In neurology, it might be said that neurons that fire together wire together. This means that once we produce a behavior and repeat it over time, it basically becomes the path of least resistance and when confronted with similar circumstances, we will default to our typical way of handling it.
So, if someone has developed a behavior that works for them to get something they want, then they are more likely to choose that behavior in the future. It is difficult to think of mental health symptoms as having any positive benefit to them. Why would someone choose such thoughts and behaviors?
Currently, there is a concept I hear more and more in psychology called secondary gain. Mental health professionals are recognizing that there often is some pay off for mental health clients in their symptomotology. It might get the client attention. It may abdicate them of daily responsibility. It might get them SSI benefits. They may be able to avoid unpleasant situations and keep undesirables at arm's length. The list goes on and on. Couldn't it at least be possible that these are not actually secondary gains, but rather the reason the symptoms developed in the first place?
Couldn't it be that a person learned that being sad got them attention so they developed the behavior of depression? Couldn't it be that a person learns anxiety gets them out of doing certain undesirable things? Once we experience a benefit, the behavior is more likely to become hard wired and therefore repeated, even long after it stops being effective.
Once of the criticisms of Glasser's theory is that no one would actively choose to be neurotic or psychotic or personality disordered. Glasser never said it was a conscious choice. Most people suffering with mental health disorders are truly suffering, unaware there is any choice in the matter. Our current approach to treatment basically reinforces this image of mental health clients as victims.
I don't know about you, but I want my clients to know there is a choice. They didn't know it before. But if they understand now how symptoms can develop out of satisfying some need the had, then treatment becomes a matter of teaching them more responsible ways of getting those needs met.
- Related Articles
- Related Q&A
- Three Myths About Mental Illness
- Sociology of Mental Illness: the Study of the Un-institutionalized Mentally Challenged in Abeokuta, Ogun State. Nigeria
- Taking Care Of Mentally Ill Seniors - Best Activities For Mental Stimulation
- Being Able To Detect Mental Illnesses
- Do you Hide in the Closet and Then Wonder Why Mental Illness Has you in a Tizzy?
- Do you Care About Someone With Mental Illness?
- Policy Changes and Disease Management: Keys to Halting Premature Death of the Mentally Ill
- Mental Illness: Disease or Choice?




Nursing Care Facilities: Reasons Why They May Be Your Best Choice
By: Brent McNutt | 12/11/2009A nursing home can be a good option particularly for children whose jobs and own family life hinder them from giving full-time care to their parents. However, a few still hesitate to go for this route because they do not want to make it seem like they are abandoning their parents.
Circumcision: Facts and Figures
By: Brent McNutt | 12/11/2009The foreskin, also called the prepuce, is a natural and retractile protective covering of the glans of the penis. This is the most erotogenic area of the penis that contains specialized nerve receptors and stretch receptors. It has over 240 feet of nerves and over 1,000 nerve endings.
Finding the Right Pediatrician for your Baby
By: Brent McNutt | 12/11/2009The joy of having an adorable sweet baby is one of the best perks about being a parent. However, you also have to remember that this is not all about fun. Being a parent is a serious endeavor that comes with a wide variety of responsibilities.
The Right Nutrition after a Major Surgery
By: Brent McNutt | 12/11/2009Healthy foods can provide the necessary nutrients, vitamins, and minerals that can speed up healing of wounds and scars. Here are some tips on how to have a healthy diet to help you on your way to the road of recovery.
The Right Nutrition after a Major Surgery
By: Brent McNutt | 12/11/2009Healthy foods can provide the necessary nutrients, vitamins, and minerals that can speed up healing of wounds and scars. Here are some tips on how to have a healthy diet to help you on your way to the road of recovery.
The Right Nutrition after a Major Surgery
By: Brent McNutt | 12/11/2009Healthy foods can provide the necessary nutrients, vitamins, and minerals that can speed up healing of wounds and scars. Here are some tips on how to have a healthy diet to help you on your way to the road of recovery.
Special Care for Premature Infants
By: Brent McNutt | 12/11/2009Your premature baby has different requirements and needs but just like most kids, he also needs the same kind of love, support, and guidance that any child needs.
Easy Weight Loss Tips You Already Know
By: Steven Magill | 12/11/2009The process of losing weight today is made more complicated by various weight loss products sprouting everyday like mushrooms. The fact that there seems to be a thousand different ways of losing weight available makes it more confusing rather than helpful.
Parenting: How to Discipline Teenagers
By: Kim Olver | 29/07/2009 | ParentingI have received a lot of inquires lately about how to discipline teenagers. It's an interesting topic and one that bears consideration. I believe most of the issue lies in how one identifies the problem. There are three major considerations. When children enter the teen years, their developmental stage is of...
Creating an Effective Online Presence: Social Media
By: Kim Olver | 29/07/2009 | MarketingAbout three years ago, I wrote a three-part series on Creating an Effective Online Presence but that was before I understood anything about social media. Now if you are going to have an effective online presence, social media is one aspect that can help put you on the cyber map. I...
Ten Steps to Building Instant Rapport
By: Kim Olver | 29/07/2009 | ManagementWhether you are a teacher, counselor, therapist, doctor, receptionist, sales person or friend, you know the power of instant rapport. I was recently asked to give a talk about it and it challenged my thinking. I thought to myself, "I know how to build rapport. I do it quite naturally,...
Mental Illness: Disease or Choice?
By: Kim Olver | 29/04/2009 | HealthIs it true that Dr. William Glasser's Choice Theory doesn't believe in mental illness? Of course not! However, that is what many believe and some don't give his ideas credence because they think he is wrong about that. This article is my humble attempt to explain exactly what Dr. Glasser...
Relationships: Physical Compatibility
By: Kim Olver | 29/04/2009 | RelationshipsHow important is physical compatibility in relationships? Well, it depends on the couple. For some people their physicality is of utmost importance to them. When it is, they often want their partner to engage in many of their activities with them. For some couples the physical nature of their relationship...
Losing Weight: Understanding Why You Eat
By: Kim Olver | 29/04/2009 | HealthOne of the first things in learning to change a behavior is to bring into conscious awareness why you do the thing you are attempting to stop doing. Losing weight is a theme common to many who have enough in their lives that their own starvation is not something that...
Can Your Relationship Survive This Affair?
By: Kim Olver | 13/03/2009 | RelationshipsI have received enough questions from people over the years asking about how to get past an affair that I wanted to write about it. There are so many intricate details of your personal relationship that factor into this decision that it is challenging to make generalizations but I will...
Relationships of Possession
By: Kim Olver | 13/03/2009 | RelationshipsHow many times in a day do you use the word "my" to describe a particular relationship you have with someone in your life? For example, you might say "my husband," "my child," "my friend," or "my parents." While the possessive pronoun "my" helps to explain certain relationships, it can...