 |
Hiring Managers: Did you Make an Exception?
Author: Joseph Skursky  | Posted: 13-02-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 16 | Rating: (53)  (?) 
Hiring new employees can be a risky business, though it doesn’t have to be. One of the more fundamental mistakes I see in the hiring process is screening in candidates to the pool of finalists.
What exactly is screening in? It’s the hope that you’ll end up with a nice selection of final candidates to find that diamond in the rough. Making exceptions, creating shortcuts, or whatever means you use, but the result of the problem is that you intend to compare candidates to one another.
Here’s how it works. Along the way, standards for what makes a good candidate are gradually lowered. An exception today results in a shortcut tomorrow, and sooner than you may think you’ve lost sight of your original standards. What you may not realize is that you’ll end up with what I call the ‘best of the mediocre.’
I hear this too often, “But there’s something about this candidate that I really like. I know they don’t meet all the critical criteria that we discussed, but I think they’re talented enough to change.”
Of course they are. How many divorced couples thought the same thing *before* the wedding? Let’s face it, people don’t change just because you’d really like them to.
How can you better prepare for these tough issues so your company becomes stronger, not weaker, from the hiring process? Many times the criteria for what makes the best candidate aren’t fully established before the hiring process begins. So let’s cover that first.
Some obvious questions from hiring managers are:
Can they deliver what I expect?
If so, will they stay as long as I want them to stay?
So how do you reach those conclusions effectively? By determining the core attributes required for success in the position. Here are some examples which may vary depending on your company and the specific position:
- Integrity/Loyalty
- Team Player
- Motivated/Self-starter
- Organized/Detail-oriented
But you also must consider a fit with the team and especially the hiring manager:
- Are the values naturally aligned with the company and the manager?
- Does the natural behavioral style fit well with the daily activities?
For my clients I strongly encourage a rating system with multiple checkpoints to clearly answer these questions and more. Examples of the checkpoints are: Resume screening, Phone screening, and Personal interviews.
Each checkpoint has its purpose, and each one builds on the previous checkpoint to provide greater clarity and verification. Each candidate, as they progress through the process, is rated against the original criteria. Those who don’t meet the criteria are quickly eliminated without exception.
In this case, it’s better to pass on a questionable candidate who *may* be able to do the job effectively than to hire someone who could cost you tens or hundreds of thousands. While there are never any assurances in business, you can stack the odds in your favor by following this simple philosophy.
Let’s be clear about one final thing, no candidate is ever going to meet every standard you determine. However, you need to know in advance what the most essential attributes are. Then stick to the original standard without wavering.
In conclusion, screening out candidates rated against clear and high core standards, maintaining integrity throughout the process, and intentionally creating a selective hiring system will help you feel better about screening out those candidates who simply don’t match the peak level of success required for the position.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/human-resources-articles/hiring-managers-did-you-make-an-exception-332601.html
About the Author:Joseph Skursky has redefined recruiting guarantees with performance measurements that assure his clients will hire the very best talent. Based on substantial research, the Market Leader Solutions guarantee exceeds the most stringent demands of hiring managers. His whitepaper, “The Recruiting Enigma: Mediocrity, Top Performers, and Imposters” covers the ‘Screening Out’ topic in much more detail, plus many other issues to improve hiring performance. To download this complimentary whitepaper go to http://www.marketleadersolutions.com.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Human Resources Articles
The Many Different Types of Storage Boxes
By: Doug Nourse | 04/09/2008
When you actually look, you can see that storage boxes come in a huge range of sizes from tiny to massive. Also, they are used in almost every setting. They are used in schools, offices, libraries, shops, supermarkets and even on cargo ships. Storage boxes are a great way of storing things cheaply and easily. People in the office and at home seem to prefer storage boxes over any other kind of storage system.
You Can Find a Person Through People Directory Online
By: lhenzie U. dayap | 04/09/2008
In order for you to locate and identify a person, you can conduct free people search online. People search online can provide you with an access to the information about a person or people from USA. Actually, search services can aid you in locating person or people and gain lots of information about them; they offer different services such as phone number lookup, email search and address search. You can obtain the address and telephone number of people with it.
Getting in Touch With People Through People Search
By: John Walter Adams | 03/09/2008
If you have ever tried to regain contact with a person you have lost contact with these past years, then we’re sure that you couldn’t say that it was an easy activity – that is, unless you use online people search resources.
Regain Peace of Mind by Using a Fast Online Phone Number Lookup
By: Francisella Griffin | 03/09/2008
Phone numbers that keep on appearing on your landline caller ID or your cell phone’s missed call list that are not familiar to you can be another thing that will keep you thinking all day. Sometimes, you will not have peace of mind until you discover who made that mysterious phone call. You might ask yourself—would that be a former friend, a business associate, a threat, or a call for help? Whatever it might be, you really need to know who is behind that call to regain your peace of mind.
Where to Look for Public Marriage Records
By: lhenzie U. dayap | 02/09/2008
If you want to search for marriage records without the hassles of manual labor, don't fret. Technology has made easy access to this information possible. Online registries over the Internet can give anyone access to marriage records and other documents (divorce records, court records, criminal and military records, adoption records, etc) that used to be restricted to the public.
Creatine - Every Teenager Must Need to Know?
By: Brayan Peter | 02/09/2008
Creatine is naturally found in vertebras. It is a nitrogenous organic acid. The supplements of creatine are used by athletes and other body builders to improve their energy levels. The nerve cells are also benefited.
How to Locate Broward County Public Records
By: Antonius Brigpenship | 01/09/2008
Tracing Broward County public records has never been easier. Whereas before you always had to go down to the county courthouse and sift through mountains of paperwork. Now all it takes is a few strokes on your computer.
Investigate Prank Callers by Using Online Phone Number Lookup
By: Francisella Griffin | 01/09/2008
Almost everyone who has a phone number experienced the scenario when their phone rings and then after answering it, no one answers on the other line. It can become more annoying when after a few minutes, that same call happens again and again throughout the day. Prank calls will never stop until you catch who is behind the abusive phone calls. It can be very frustrating receiving calls from someone you have no idea who.
More from Joseph Skursky
What if you Could Hire Like the Navy Seals Recruit?
By: Joseph Skursky | 02/10/2007 | Human Resources
Why are the Navy SEALS such an Elite group of soldiers? Could it be that they only recruit the best people so it’s easier to create the ultimate warrior?
That would just be too easy an answer, right? In fact it’s the rigorous recruiting process from application to graduation that allows only the best to become Navy SEALS.
|
|
Business 
