So is this difference in style just a perception or is it based on any evidence?
We are aware of the animal studies than show the differences in behaviour between males and females that have characterised females as being more nurturing and of males classically exhibiting aggressive, dominant “A” type behaviour – but how far do these results transfer across to management roles in organisations?
We also know that there are differences in some physical performance aspects of men and women which have to be taken account – especially in occupations where physical strength and stamina is important e g The Army, The Fire Brigade
When we look at some of the more sophisticated Psychometric tests measuring personality characteristics such as 16pf, we do know that there are some gender differences which are significant enough for us to use different norm tables for men or women in order to normalise any comparative results.
So if we accept that there are some gender based differences in managerial style and approach should we then provide different forms of management development training for man and women?
I think that the answer is probably no – because there are other factors that are even more important to consider when we look at the role of a manager, their styles, approaches and when we consider the people that they are managing or dealing with as customers and clients.
The sorts of factors that are more important to consider are these:-
• What are the gender types and likely responses of the customer set for your product or service?
• How good at your managers at understanding personality differences and gender styles in this customer set? Can they deal effectively with diverse types?
• What makes a successful manager in your business from a competency point of view?
• What are the different learning styles of your participants on any training programme and how well are you delivering your programme to reach and appeal to these different styles of activist, pragmatist, reflector etc?
• What is the culture and style of your organisation that you are looking to reinforce and encourage – whether it is adopted my male or female managers is less relevant.
In conclusion whilst accepting that differences do exist in the styles of individual managers, there is a broad spectrum of styles and approaches produced by individual differences rather than by simple gender stereotyping and that there are other factors outlined above which are more significant.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Why am i such a loner. is perfring to be alone bad ...
By: Lenniebens | 15-07-2008
why am i such a loner. is perfring to be alone bad? i love being around people. but im shy so i barely say anything. which is weird because im usually really hyper and goofy. at least with my family. but i care too much about wat people think of me. so i get nervous and have like a social anxiety attack, so i like to be by myself. plus when ever my friends text or call me, i never answer, unless its my boyfreind. im in clubs and stuff but its hard to participate. im used to not getting my voice heard so i jus like to listen to others opinions. ive never really been much of a talker i guess. im not sure what im asking. lol. umm maybe jus some feed back/
HEALTHY GUY: My somewhat of a friend of 1 1/2 yrs ...
By: doitright | 15-07-2008
HEALTHY GUY: My somewhat of a friend of 1 1/2 yrs became my boyfriend 6 months ago. We are exclusive, committed, both have kids. He is younger than I am (BY TEN YEARS!), but very smart and mature. He doesn't "court" me so-to-speak. I've missed a lot of that 'you are special enticements from the guy'!!! Over the years, I've had a ton of fakes with flowers and gestures. I think this man is exactly what I want. We have both expressed wanting to be married again, that we are loyal to each other. SO WHY.............do I look for things to be wrong that he may not even be aware he is doing or not doing. (MOSTLY...I don't let him know I feel these things... and try to let it pass. My past is full of abusive men; and I'm trying not to let that carry over and deal with it.) If I am always available, and all things are good in his mind.....why should he do anything different? If I become a little more unavailable, and maybe even go away (give myself time to think too) maybe this will be a tell-tale sign for both of us. Does he care? Is he serious about me...or flippant? In between though...... I need an exercise to calm myself down when the anxiety comes around. Thanks
Ovarian cyst
By: daisyd220 | 14-07-2008
I have been diagnosed with a 4cmx3cm cyst on my right ovary...I'm having pelvic, abdominal and leg pain as well. Has anyone had a cyst like this? What will the dr do? I am not having any more children.
Teenage Boy Sexually Curious
By: Mom | 14-07-2008
My son has been caught several times now watching porn movies. He is very sexually curious and I think would have sex with anyone who would let him. How do I handle this? I do not want him to think the movies are really how things are. I also do not want him to picture women they way the a portrayed in these movies.
Utility Conversion Program
By: Zunguze | 09-07-2008
What are the typical guidelines to follow when implementing a utility conversion (undergrounding electrical overhead lines) program?
Secret Lover/Friend
By: MiamiTemp | 08-07-2008
I'm a 25 y/o female from Miami. I've been involved with a man romantically for a year and a half but nobody knows about our relationship. I can't go into detail about why we have to keep this a secret. He's not married or anything but if people found out then it could hurt his career, etc. I had known for a few years before we started anything sexual but had fallen for him way before that. When the opportunity presented itself I took it and things have been very hot with him since then. However, he has no idea how much I care about him. We were always friends, so I know he gets that much but I'm scared that if he found out that I was in love with him our relationship would change. It kills me not to be able to tell this guy that he's everything to me. I've had my share of relationships, whether it has been boyfriends, friends with benefits or whatever but this is completely throwing me off track in my life. I know he recently started seeing another woman, but the terms of our current relationship are strictly "friends with benefits" so I can't really say anything. The other woman has no idea that me and him have the type of sexual relationship that we do. She thinks we are just friends. I love having this secret, but at times it gets difficult. I get sad at times when I think that he is waking up next to her and not me. He'll swing by my house, we'll hook up and then he'll go over to her house for a movie. It sucks and I'm not quite sure how to handle it. I don't want it to end, I want him to know how I feel but I can't bring myself to tell him. Anyone got any words of wisdom?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Human Resources Articles
Outsourcing Payroll Brings Peace of Mind
By: 10x Marketing | 25/07/2008
Is your business growing? Consider the time you could save by outsourcing payroll management…
Performance Technologies Schedules Second Quarter 2008 Earnings Release and Conf
By: atomxiao | 25/07/2008
A conference call will be held on Friday, July 25 at 10:00 a.m., New York time, to discuss the results. All institutional investors can participate in the conference by dialing (866) 250-5144 or (416) 849-6163. The call will be available simultaneously for all other investors at (866) 494-3387 or (416) 915-1198. A digital recording of this conference call may be accessed immediately after its completion from July 25 through July 29, 2008. To access the recording, participants should dial (866) 2
Develop Skills to Beat Recession
By: Gary Howes | 24/07/2008
Business leaders offer start-ups advice on how to ride through the slowdown.
Preparing for Disclosures Under New Form 990 - are You Ready?
By: Paul R. Dorf, Ph.D., APD | 24/07/2008
Many not-for-profit organizations will be utilizing the new Form 990 for filing tax information this year. The recent issuance of these "final" regulations on financial reporting for tax-exempt organizations is a long-awaited reaction to misfilings that have occurred over the years, whether intentional or not. Reporting under the new Form 990 is an outcome to actions caused by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the Securities and Exchange Commission relative to good governance and disclosure of execut
Workers Compensation Insurance as Employee Benefit
By: PeterSam | 24/07/2008
Employers have a legal and a moral responsibility to provide their employees safety at their workplaces. But despite the best of safety measures in place, accidents cannot be totally eliminated and they can, at best, be minimized. It is the responsibility of an employer to maintain a safe workplace, have workers compensation insurance covering his employees and protect the workers from financial hardship in the event of a workplace injury. Workers compensation insurance covers workers injured no
Building Your Credit From No Credit or Bad Credit
By: Shyr Miles | 23/07/2008
For those who want to open a business but is apprehensive about their credit scores should not dismay. Fortunately, there are ways to break into building your credit score, even if you have no history or bad credit history. The secret is to start small and stay responsible.
Lyons & Wolivar, Inc. (l&w Investigations) Offers Tips on Workers Comp Claim Abuse
By: Steve Dubin | 22/07/2008
Lyons & Wolivar Inc. (L&W Investigations), the foremost private investigations firm specializing in insurance claims, offers tips or red flags on how to spot possible abuses of a workers comp claim.
Utilise Space With Office Plants
By: PaulZ | 22/07/2008
Specialist office plant suppliers will be able to help you make use of any awkward spaces by utilising planted office displays
Business 
