 |
The Acpa: Trademark Violations in Domains
Author: Enrico Schaefer  | Posted: 17-05-2007 | Comments: 0 | Views: 36 | Rating: (50)  (?) 
 Our law firm receives a lot of calls from people and companies who are being threatened with an Anti-Cyber Squatting Consumer Protection Act claim because they registered a domain name identical or similar to a trademark held by someone else. Inevitably, we hear the words “Network Solutions allowed me to register the domain, so there is no way someone can say that I did anything wrong.”
Of course, Network Solutions and the other registrars do little to ensure that a person registering a domain has legal right to do so. In reality, the responsibility of ensuring that you do have a legal right to the domain is in your own hands. About the only thing registrars do is make each person who purchases a domain affirm that they are not interfering with some else’s legitimate trademark rights. Simply having the ability to register the domain is no reflection of your legal right to it, and it doesn’t mean that you won’t get sued for having done so under federal law.
The ACPA is a federal law that took effect in November 1999, in order to preclude bad faith registration of domain names. This new domain name dispute law is intended to give trademark and service mark owners legal remedies against defendants who obtain domain names “in bad faith” that are identical or confusingly similar to a trademark or service mark.
When it comes to litigation under the ACPA (cases like these are commonly referred to as "cyber-squatting") plaintiff must prove that defendant has a bad faith intent to profit from the mark that is identical or confusingly similar or dilutes plaintiff’s mark. The key element in any case is the "bad faith" intent on the side of the defendant, who intended to profit from the mark.”
What this means for the "good faith" registrants, is that merely registering the domain, and keeping it non-commercial, will make it very difficult, if not impossible, for plaintiff to prove bad faith and have the domain transferred. Typically, intent to profit is shown by the use of the domain as a commercial site which sells goods or services. For an alleged domain violator who does not develop a website, bad faith intent to profit is often shown when the defendant tries to sell the domain name to the trademark holder. Any transfer of the domain for consideration will typically satisfy the profit test.
Another bad faith factor is if the registrant provides false contact information to the registrar or fails to maintain correct contact information moving forward. Because of this bad faith factor, it is important for all domain name owners to check their domain registrations regularly in the Who’s database to determine if their contact information is correct.
If you should decide to file an ACPA lawsuit, you have a variety of remedies which are available to you under the act. The most important one is potential forfeiture or cancellation of the domain name or transfer of the domain name to the plaintiff. In lieu of actual damages, the plaintiff may elect statutory damages and has discretion to award between $1,000 and $100,000 in damages for bad faith registration. Attorney’s fees are also available for a bad faith registration.
Sometimes, the domain owner cannot be found or served with a Summons and Complaint because they have provided false information or are not located within the United States. In these instances, a trademark owner may bring in “In Rem” action against the domain name in the judicial district in which the domain name registrar, domain name registry or other domain name authority that registered or assigned the domain name is located. Money damages are not available in an “In Rem” lawsuit. Typically, the trademark owner is more focused at having the domain name transferred to them than received damages.
One recent Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals case, Interactive Products, Corporation v. A2Z Mobile Office, No. 01-3590 (6th Cir., April 10, 2003), was not good news for trademark holders in our jurisdiction. The Court held that the “post-domain path of a URL (the sub-file directory). . . does not typically signify source (of goods or services). The post-domain path merely shows how the website’s data is organized within the host computer files.”
Accordingly, the Sixth Circuit held that the presence of plaintiff’s trademark in the path of the domain name of a competitor was unlikely to cause consumer confusion, and not a breach of their rights. Interestingly, the Court reached this result even though the defendant, A2Z, was selling competing products. While this is a step away from the rights of the trademark registrant, it should be noted that the Circuit Court did not exempt the use of another's trademark in the top-level domain, the website itself or the meta tags, from ACPA liability.
Each ACPA case turns on the particular facts presented. It should also be noted that the Interactive Products plaintiff did not present any evidence that the presence of its trademark in the post-domain path caused actual confusion or was likely to cause consumer confusion. If such evidence existed and was presented, the outcome could have been different. The ACPA in an important weapon for trademark holders in protecting their intellectual property in the online world. If you do not protect your trademarks, you may lose rights in those marks altogether. Besides, if you don’t protect your marks, who will?
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/intellectual-property-articles/the-acpa-trademark-violations-in-domains-149148.html
About the Author:Enrico Schaefer is the founding attorney of Traverse Legal, PLC, a law firm specializing in web law. You can find out more about protecting your domain name, UDRP arbitrations and anti-cybersquatting laws at Traverse Legal’s domain name theft and trademark blogs.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
Why Do We Hurt Those We Love Most and How to Stop This
By: Ineke Van Lint | 01/04/2006 | Advice
We all need energy to live and to survive. As long as you think this energy has to come from other human beings, you will get caught up in struggle. Because human energy is limited. You have to fight for it. It's the responsibility of each and every pers
How to Grab a Good Top Level Domain
By: Ian Williamson | 26/04/2006 | Domain Names
With the recent explosion in the availability of website domain name suffixes (such as .eu, .ws, .cc and so on) it's never been easier to grab a domain name that is directly related to the subject matter of your site.
Top 10 Tips For Free Domain Traffic
By: Colin Hartness | 24/03/2007 | Internet
The perfect domain name is one which has a natural ability to rank high in the major search engines. The domain itself accounts for over 20% of the total ranking factors which a search engine considers important.
Here are my top ten tips for choosing effective domain names:
1. Choose a dot...
Website Promotion - The Easy Way
By: Dominic Dat | 08/11/2007 | Internet
Most website owners will tell you the hardest part of setting up a website is the website promotion. Without that you will find it hard to attract visitors and make a success of your website. There are millions of websites out there competing for visitors, so website promotion is a...
How to Benefit From Expiring Domains
By: Piter Gurski | 30/04/2008 | Domain Names
To be successful on the internet you must have a web site with a good amount of traffic. These days everybody knows that traffic is a king. So all search engines are queens. So who are you then? A princes or prince? Or you are someone forgotten on the side of the big money road? Just don’t get lost among the road signs and look for some right exit. And here I want to tell you about one of these exits which is about domains which are about to expire.
Make Your Logo Simple
By: Jonathan Munk | 17/11/2005 | Business
Simple logos are infinitely more effective than complex ones. The most memorable logos in the world are always the most simple.
Costs, Likelihood of Success, and Timing for a Trademark’s International Branding
By: Bruce Margulies | 19/07/2007 | Trademarks
A benefit of the international treaties and laws regulating trademark registrations is the flexibility they provide. In the same vein, it may be hard for a non expert to determine which of the filing alternatives are best suited for their business objectives in terms of timing, likelihood of obtaining trademark registrations, and cost. I provide below an example of the decisional parameters and process based upon some hypothetical trademarks for a hypothetical product.
Trade Marks & Service Marks on the Internet
By: Peter Arkwright | 20/05/2006 | Law
An overview of the use of trade marks and service marks on the Internet
Latest Intellectual Property Articles
Management is the Key to a Successful Start-up Business
By: Dee Power | 23/07/2008
A key element to entrepreneurial success is choosing the right people to be part of your management team.
Strategizing Your Trademark Filings in Israel
By: Assaf Joseph Naim, Adv. | 11/07/2008
During the course of their brands portfolio management strategy, companies planning to expand their businesses outside of their native country, and is marketing or is planning on marketing its goods or services in Israel, will eventually wish to have its trademark protected in Israel.
Things to Consider When Planning a Retirement
By: Manuel Salvacion | 11/07/2008
One’s retirement plan is determined by his future needs. To identify possible needs, you must be able to pinpoint potential retirement expenses in relation to the sources of your income. Investing early for your retirement and knowing the value of your assets may help you prepare for a good retirement life.
Use of Competitors’ Trade Marks and Comparative Advertising in the United Kingdom and Europe
By: Leigh Ellis | 06/07/2008
Ordinarily use of competitors’ trade marks amounts to a trade mark infringement and/or passing off. However the Trade Marks Act 1994 (‘TMA’) and European legislations legitimise use of competitors’ trade marks provided that the use takes place in a particular way, and certain tests are satisfied.
UK Government in Trouble for Climate Change Loans
By: Catherine Moody | 15/06/2008
The UK government is under attack by debt campaigners as well as developing countries, for their plan to give £800 million to poorer countries in preparation for climate change, as a great bulk of the money would be in the form of loans, not grants, and would be sent via the World Bank instead of the UN.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Invention Process
By: Victor Martel | 05/06/2008
How does an inventor get started with their invention idea? A brief overview describes what to do and what not to do to help inventors move forward.
Bomb Blast in Islamabad
By: Dalip Singh Wasan | 03/06/2008
When we prepare terrorists, we shall have to provide them work and when they are vacant and idle, they shall not sit idle, but shall attack the master itself and shall finish him.
Invention Company Scams And How To Avoid Them
By: Victor Martel | 29/05/2008
Inventors are getting ripped off by invention marketing and patent companies every day. It is estimated that over $300,000,000 is lost annually. Inventor Be Wear!
More from Enrico Schaefer
Domain Name Dispute Resolution: Choosing your Forum
By: Enrico Schaefer | 15/05/2007 | Internet Law
Whereas a civil or ciminal case must be arbitrated in a specified court, domain name dispute cases are resolved through service providers such as WIPO and NAF, providers which serve the same purpose but should not be selected at random.
Udrp Panels: What you Should Know
By: Enrico Schaefer | 10/05/2007 | Intellectual Property
Just as a trial attorney never enters a courtroom without researching his judge, those who arbitrate before a UDRP Panel need to be aware of the views of the panelists, and the rights granted in the UDRP that can be used to shield hostile panelists.
Preventing Domain Name Theft: Beyond the Udrp
By: Enrico Schaefer | 07/05/2007 | Domain Names
While the UDRP is an efficient method for achieving the transfer of domain names that violate trademarks, it has no method for preventing their violation in the first place. Luckily, with some help and active prevention, it is possible to prevent any run-ins with the UDRP.
Pornosquatting: a Domain Name Theft Nightmare
By: Enrico Schaefer | 07/05/2007 | Domain Names
When facing a stolen domain name, or having intended visitors sent over to sites filled with obscene material rather than your own, it is often the most important time to get legal advice and fight to have your trademark restored.
Non-compete Contracts as a Tool for Protecting Competitive Edge
By: Enrico Schaefer | 03/05/2007 | National, State, Local
Todays economy is filled with industries who face unprecedented competition as they struggle to gain an edge upon their competitors. As never before, non-compete and non-solicitation agreements are becoming effective avenues through which businesses can protect investments and information that help them in the competitive market.
Non-compete Contracts: the Employer Perspective
By: Enrico Schaefer | 02/05/2007 | Strategic Planning
Non-compete and non-solicitation contracts, along with the legal basis upon which they rest, are complex issues that face both employees and their employers and should be totally understood in order to ensure the rights of both parties are protected in the case of a dispute.
The Michigan Sales Represetatives Commission Act: Protecting yourself
By: Enrico Schaefer | 30/04/2007 | National, State, Local
With the Michigan Supreme Court yet to make a decision following the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals one, the specifics of the enforcement of the SRCA has grown more unclear. However, there are things that a producer can do before they face the severe penalties for what the SRCA deems "improper" withholding of sales representative commissions.
Stolen Domain Names: How to Know if you are a Victim
By: Enrico Schaefer | 27/04/2007 | Domain Names
Are you losing visitors to your domain? Are your search engine rankings still yours?
|
|
Law 
