ArticlesBase.com - Free Articles Directory
Free Online Articles Directory
21.08.2008 Sign In Register Hello Guest
Email:
Password:
Remember Me 
forgot your password?


Florida School Grades Confusing Issue for New Residents

Author: Calum MacKenzie Author Ranking Bronze | Posted: 20-07-2007 | Comments: 0 | Views: 15 | Rating:  (53) Article Popularity - Blue (?) Got a Question? Ask.
Sign Up Now!

School quality is always a concern for relocating parents. In a world where a good education is increasingly important, many parents even base their final decision about home choice on the reported quality of the schools in various neighborhoods.

Here in Florida, the state’s A+ school reporting plan is supposed to give parents an easy way to compare schools with one another at a glance, but many question whether the system really reflects the situation accurately. When the Florida Department of Education released the school grades for 2007 a couple of weeks ago, there seemed to be more confusion and controversy than information in the published reports.

If you were a parent trying to decide where to relocate, you’d be understandably confused by the newspaper reports announcing the gains and losses over the preceding year. In Orlando, the papers announced that school grades had taken a nose dive. In Palm Beach, they reported that there were dramatic improvements – and crushing drops. In Tampa, the papers admitted to confusion over exactly what the school grades were measuring, but reported a general dissatisfaction with the entire system. When the professionals are confused about what school grades mean, how can parents be expected to make an informed choice?

How School Grades are Determined
Under the Florida education system, school grades are based on three major areas:

  • the performance of the school as a whole on the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test in Reading, Math and Science at specific grade levels
  • the improvement in grades of students in the school in Reading, Math and Science on the FCAT over the previous year
  • the improvement of the lowest performing 25% of students in Reading, Math and Science in the FCAT over the previous year


In addition, in order to receive any grade above an F, 90% of the school’s students must take the FCAT. In order to receive an A, 95% of the students must take the FCAT. Schools receive points on a scale of 0-800 based on those factors, and are assigned a letter grade based on those points.

The system was originally instituted in 1999. In that year, 78 schools received a failing grade and another 600 received a D. Only 13% of the schools received an A rating. The state’s school grades overall have trended upward each year, with a couple of exceptions.

In the intervening years, the standards for receiving a passing grade have been changed three times, each time tightening the requirements to “raise the bar”. Each time that the standards have been tightened, the results were predictable – more schools failed than in the previous year and a percentage of schools found that their school grade had dropped from the year before. In nearly every case, those grades were recovered over the next year as teachers and students adjusted to the new material they were required to know.

The most recent adjustment to the grading system took place this year. For the first time in the 2006-2007 school year, the performance of students on the Science portion of the FCAT was taken into account in grading schools. Predictably, as has happened both other times that students had to meet higher standards, there are more schools than last year with F ratings, and a number of schools received lower grades than they did last year. If you take the comparative numbers against last year’s figures without adjusting for changes to the grading system, it certainly appears that the schools are losing ground in the fight to educate our children.

If you take a longer view, though, the picture is far different. In 1999, only 13% of all Florida schools received an A rating. In 2007, that figure increased to 52% - despite the fact that the standards are much higher than they were just eight years ago. In 1999, nearly 50% of all Florida schools received a C rating. This year, that figure is 17%. The percentage of D rated schools went from 24.5% to 8%. The only figure that has remained unchanged is the F rating – with approximately 3% of Florida schools receiving an F rating.

Even so, both parents and educators – and in many cases students – have serious concerns about the way that schools are graded, especially in light of the consequences of lower grades for schools. Many parents who have children in the lower graded schools are bewildered – they see that their children are being taught by teachers who care enough to work with them after school and push them to learn more. Teachers express concerns that they are forced to “teach the test instead of the children” – and in many cases to do so without the equipment and supplies necessary to teach effectively. These concerns aren’t unique to Florida. They mirror controversies and conversations that are being held in nearly every state across the nation.

Through all of this, though, two facts stand out. The first is that accountability is a vital part of the public education process. There must be some method of measuring whether the schools are doing their jobs of educating children. The system that we’re using now may be flawed, but it does provide an overview of a school’s progress toward improvement, and it allows for adjustment and improvement of the system itself to measure more accurately. It allows the state to pinpoint schools and regions that need assistance in meeting standards so that resources can be focused there.

The second fact is also undeniable. Since 1999, Florida schools have shown marked overall progress toward meeting the standards of education set forth by the state. In New Tampa, every one of the elementary schools received an A rating this year, despite the higher standards, and not a single school was rated an F.

While the current system may be flawed, it does provide a starting point for parents looking for school information. Parents who want a deeper look can access the school’s full report card at the FDOE’s web site, and use the time-honored methods that parents have always used to decide on a school for their children. Schedule an interview with the school principal. Talk with neighbors in the neighborhoods you’re considering. Learn about the schools on a personal level. The more involved you are in the process, the easier it becomes to make an informed choice about your children’s education.

Rate this Article: Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/k-12-education-articles/florida-school-grades-confusing-issue-for-new-residents-185439.html

Print this Article Print article   Email to a Friend Send to friend   Publish this Article on your Website Publish this Article   Send Author Feedback Author feedback  
About the Author:

Calum MacKenzie is Broker/Owner of Real Living Southern Homes, a leading residential real estate brokerage serving the New Tampa real estate and Land O’ Lakes real estate markets.

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Comment on this article Comment on this article
Your Name
Your Email:
Comment Body
Enter Validation Code: Captcha


Related Articles

Improvement in Florida Schools Libraries Boosts FCAT Scores and Students Reading Abilities
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/06/2006 | Education
The purpose of any school library is to promote reading and improve reading and research skills. Educators have long agreed that good libraries are essential to academic success, since students must be able to read by third grade in order to learn other subjects, such as history and science.

Tampa Schools Require Change of Focus
By: Jason Thomas | 31/07/2007 | Education
Schools around the nation are looking for ways to improve student performance in light of stricter state and national standards. The Tampa Schools in Florida have been forced to make changes. But maybe that’s not such a bad thing.

Report Card on Florida Schools Policy to End Social Promotion
By: Patricia Hawke | 26/06/2006 | Education
Though it is the fourth largest public school system in the United States, Florida Schools have consistently ranked close to the bottom on academic indicators, including high school graduation rates and national assessment of education progress test scores. For the past few years, Florida schools have been implementing programs to improve student scholastic achievement. Most have been well received and implemented with little-to-no resistance.

Safety and Wellness Important Features of Tampa Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 04/09/2007 | Education
Every Monday morning, we send our children off to school. Not only do we expect for them to learn exciting new things which will broaden their horizons, we expect them to be safe and well while they are there.

Demand for Speech Therapists Versus Availability Causing Crisis for the Florida Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 22/08/2006 | Education
With the passing of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, schools across the nation are now required to offer services that were before considered a luxury for students with disabilities. One such service is for speech and language therapy.

Florida Schools Flying High On Last Year's Middle Schools Success
By: Patricia Hawke | 05/09/2006 | Education
The 2005-2006 school year was a tremendous success for the Florida schools, especially at the middle school level. The Florida schools' educators across the state worked hard to improve student academic achievement levels and were rewarded for their efforts.

Entrepreneurship Major Introduced for Secondary Florida Schools
By: Patricia Hawke | 08/02/2007 | K-12 Education
One of the things I appreciated, only after graduating college graduation, was that my school employed professors, who had “real world” experience. I cannot tell you how many times we heard a professor say, “Okay, that’s what the textbook tells you. Now, let me tell you how it works in the real world.”

Florida School Grading System
By: Calum MacKenzie | 23/02/2007 | Real Estate
To unify curriculum and learning benchmarks, Florida State created the Sunshine State Standards, or SSS. These regulations outline what each student should learn during their current school year before being promoted to the next grade level. By adopting these standards, schools are better equipped to assign realistic goals to each student and teachers can concentrate on how to teach, rather than what to teach.

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Q&A Powered by:
Powered by Yedda 

Latest K-12 Education Articles

Homework and School - Two Sides of the Same Coin
By: Angela Norton Tyler | 18/08/2008
Homework is sent directly from school, yet many parents don't understand the strong homework and school connection. We sit down, see what comes out of those messy backpacks and hope that between ourselves and our children we will figure it all out. But, in order to know if our children are doing the right homework the right way, parents must fully grasp what is going on at school.

Slavery and the Civil War
By: Steven Chabotte | 18/08/2008
A pivotal issue leading up to the American Civil War was slavery. While the sum total of the reasons for the Civil War is greater than slavery, this was certainly a driving issue for many Southerners to secede from the Union. Understanding the South's dependence on slavery for their economy gives insights into the fierceness of their response to the Northern position.

Quantrill's Raiders
By: Steven Chabotte | 18/08/2008
Quantrill's Raiders were a fierce band of guerrilla warriors led by William Clark Quantrill. Fighting on the side of the Confederacy, they terrorized Union sympathizers along the Missouri-Kansas border for the duration of the Civil War.

Jefferson Davis - Forgotten President of the Confederacy
By: Steven Chabotte | 18/08/2008
Of all the notable people in the Civil War, Jefferson Davis is perhaps the most overlooked. His legacy overshadowed by Lincoln and the most influential generals - Lee, Jackson, Grant, etc. So who was this enigmatic man who for a few short years presided over half of these United States?

A House Divided - the Winter of Secession
By: Steven Chabotte | 18/08/2008
Abraham Lincoln's Speech about a house divided marked the beginning of the Civil War. This speech and the later election of Lincoln to the Presidency of the Untied States gave the Sothern states the final reason for Seceding from the Union.

How to Succeed on the Sat
By: John | 18/08/2008
The SAT is the most important test many students will take in their lives. These are the steps I used to score well on the SAT.

Introduction to Uefa Champions League
By: Robert | 15/08/2008
The UEFA Champions League is the most popular club competition in Europe. In addition, it is a competition where only the champions of each league in Europe can participate.

Introduction to Spanish La Liga
By: Robert | 15/08/2008
For those of you who are familiar with English Premier League, the Spanish La Liga starts a few weeks later and ends later for each season. Some popular clubs of La Liga includes Real Madrid, Barcelona and Valencia.

More from Calum MacKenzie

Practical Tips to Make Moving Easier
By: Calum MacKenzie | 26/07/2008 | Moving and Relocating
If you’re planning to move house in the near future, chances are you’re already groaning at the thought of organizing a move. But don’t worry—moving doesn’t have to be a complete nightmare. Check out these practical tips and make your next move smooth and trouble-free.

Salt and Chlorine Pools: Which is Best?
By: Calum MacKenzie | 22/07/2008 | DIY
For those of us who don’t enjoy swimming in chlorinated water, it’s good to know that there’s an alternative available. Salt water swimming pools are increasingly popular, but how safe are they? Salt or chlorine—which does a better job at keeping your pool clean?

Choosing the Right Pool Heater for the Job
By: Calum MacKenzie | 17/07/2008 | Remodeling
Which heating system is best for your swimming pool? In most cases you’ll be able to choose between electric, gas, and solar heating systems, but the best system for your situation will vary depending on where you live and what your specific needs are. So which is best? The answer to that question depends on a fairly long list of factors, including your budget, location, the size of your pool, and how and when you normally use it: check out the full article to find out more.

Understanding Florida Real Estate Taxes With Florida’s Amendment 1
By: Calum MacKenzie | 30/06/2008 | Real Estate
Trying to determine your Florida real estate taxes is like trying to determine if you qualify for an IRS tax break, near impossible. If you're trying to understand Florida property taxes this article explains everything you want to know, but were afraid to ask, including information on Florida's New Amendment 1 passed by voters on January 9, 2008.

Get Ready for Florida Hurricane Season
By: Calum MacKenzie | 29/05/2008 | DIY
With the Florida hurricane season almost upon us, it’s important to make sure you’re ready. A family disaster plan and a disaster supply kit are two important actions you can take to make sure you’re not caught out if a hurricane cuts off your electricity, isolates you in your home, or forces you to evacuate.

Florida Home Inspections: Common Issues
By: Calum MacKenzie | 20/05/2008 | Real Estate
The warm, moist Florida climate means that we often have our own special set of common issues that crop up during home inspections. Why is it important to learn about these? It not only gives you some forewarning when you’re buying a new home, but it also means you’ll know where to concentrate your maintenance efforts on the home that you buy.

Florida Property Insurance Changes Will Affect Most Homeowners
By: Calum MacKenzie | 16/04/2008 | Insurance
The last week of March saw the Florida Senate approve some changes to property insurance that might end up increasing property insurance rates by around 3%.

The Emergence of Spring Brings Termite Trouble
By: Calum MacKenzie | 03/03/2008 | Real Estate
What does the month of March mean to you? For most people it means Easter, or the promise of nice weather. For anyone who has suffered a termite infestation, they know that between the months of March and May, termites begin to congregate and search for homes to start new colonies.

Article Categories






Give Feedback

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below