Remember Me
forgot your password?

Times Tables - the Worst Way to Teach Multiplication

Learning the "multiplication tables" is one of the first traumas that children usually face when learning arithmetic.

Ask ten elementary-school kids to tell you what, say, eight times seven is. Watch as they look up and to their left (or right) and go into, "let's-see" mode. Often you'll hear them say, "Um, ah..." before give you the answer. Generally, there's a lot of hesitation. Only then, do they actually give you the answer. Sometimes it's even correct.

I know, I was one of them. Maybe you were, too. Most children are victimized by the thoughtless, authoritarian, wrong way to teach the "multiplication facts" (what a stupid term!)

Why are "the tables" the wrong way to learn? Maybe I can illustrate it best by analogy. Imagine that you wanted your children to learn the names of all their cousins, aunts and uncles. But you never actually let them meet or play with them. You just showed them pictures of them, and told them to memorize their names.

Each day you'd have them recite the names, over and over again. You'd say, "OK, this is a picture of your great-aunt Beatrice. Her husband was your great-uncle Earnie. They had three children, your uncles Harpo, Zeppo, and Gummo. Harpo married your aunt Leonie...yadda, yadda, yadda.

Boring!

But what if you had them all over for the weekend, and you found out Earnie did magic tricks, Beatrice had been a rodeo queen, Zeppo always wore mismatching socks, Harpo played the, well, you know, Gummo picked his nose and wiped it on his tie, and Leonie could sing like an angel?

Well, then you'd have some relationship with them, wouldn't you? The next time you saw Earnie, you'd ask him to show you a trick. You'd ask his daughter Leonie if she could teach you to sing, and you'd stay away from Gummo's tie.

It turns out that you can build relationships with multiplications, as well. And they have relationships with each other. You already know some of them. Like the relationship of nine to ten. Nine is one less than ten, so when you multiply something by nine, just stick a zero at the end of it, and subtract the original number.

Take the example 8*9. Just stick a zero behind the 8 to get 80. Next, subtract 8 from 80, and you've got 72, which is the correct answer to 8 multiplied by 9.

That is the intuitive way for many people to multiply by 9. So why do they make you stare at the nine-times-table in school? It's boring and fosters no sense of the relationship of nine to the other numbers. It turns multiplication into isolated "multiplication facts" (there's that stupid term again).

If you had children multiply by nine with the subtraction method often enough, they'd know the answers in their bones after awhile. It would take less time than it would to memorize the nine-times-tables by rote, and it would have them actively involved with using the numbers. Imagine that!

This may be hard to digest at first, because learning the "multiplication facts" by rote has been ingrained into the school system for decades. Maybe that is why our children are getting worse and worse at this easy, important skill.

If you're a teacher, you're probably fed up with the bad mojo from the policy-makers. You need to get your own mojo working. Find out how to get started at http://learn2multiply.com

Brian Foley

Brian Foley (a.k.a. "Professor Homunculus") is the creator and web manager of Math Mojo and The Math Mojo Chronicles. He's presented his Math and Magic programs at schools, corporations, and other facilities throughout the U.S. and Europe.

Please include the FULL Resource box at the end of the article if you intend to publish this. Thanks.

Rate this Article: 4.4 / 5 stars - 7 vote(s)
Print Email Re-Publish

Add new Comment



Captcha
-1
1. Chelly (20:52, 01.09.2008)
It is precisely people like yourself that have buggered up the teaching profession by the constant thinking up new ideas with no basis on fact apart from in your own head. To ask a child to have to do 2 calculations in their head when they can far more easily do one is complicating things up. Just like the new way of subtraction is confusing far more people than it helps. I know perfectly intelligent children who still cant subtract properly until they are shown the old way
+1
2. Brian (18:48, 08.10.2008)
Chelly,

Thanks for the "constructive" criticism.

I know thousands of children who couldn't multiply until they were taught this method. (By the way "showing " is not "teaching".)

And I don't know why you are arguing about subtraction, when this method has nothing to do with that. Your logic is erroneous.

If you are quite satisfied with the status quo of math education, by all means, keep teaching that way. People who have watched children from other countries, where they use other methods, consistently blow American and British students away in math, deserve better, though.
+2
3. eugenia francis (17:47, 18.09.2008)
Hi Brian,
Google my article, "Times Tables, the Key to Your Child's Sucess" on this subject. My method, based on patterns, is fast, fun & easy!
Eugenia Francis
www.TeaCHildMath.com
0
4. Ashley (00:41, 12.01.2009)
I teach 3rd grade, the year you really dig into learning multiplication. I agree that it is much more effective to teach children the concepts of multiplication and help them to understand the process of what they are doing whether than just memorize rote facts. It has to be meaningful! That is why in my class we begin hands-on, making arrays and groups of numbers with tiles. We also learn tricks, such as the 9s trick mentioned above (there are lots of things you can do with 9s, they are my favorite). Don't get me wrong; we are still working to memorize our facts. However, if they are asked only to memorize and they don't know a fact, they just don't know it. If they are taught tricks and concepts, then when they don't know or get stuck they have a way to figure it out. I find this much more effective!

  • Latest K-12 Education Articles
  • More from Brian Foley

Tackling CBSE Question Paper

By: Ashutosh Sharma | 26/11/2009
While attempting CBSE Question Paper, students sometimes miss attending to certain important points that can often make them lose valuable marks. However, these mistakes and omissions can be easily corrected by paying a little attention. It is imperative for students to identify these mistakes and rectify them so as to secure a comparatively better result.

Science Fair Projects to Make Everybody Happy

By: Kayla Fay | 25/11/2009
Science fair projects - Kids think they should be fun. Teachers think they should be educational. Parents just want them to be fast and easy. Since students, teacher and parents are all involved in the process of getting ready for the science fair, most of the time, science projects have to be all of the above!

Kids Science Project Boards That Aren't Boring

By: Kayla Fay | 25/11/2009
Kids' science projects aren't finished until the last letter is glued onto the science board. After the science project is finished, you want it to look its very best for the science fair! You really want the project to reflect how hard your kids have worked.

Could Leslies Jacobs be the cure for New Orleans Failing Schools?

By: Tyronne Jacques | 25/11/2009
New Orleans Public Schools System is still in need of real leadership and support in the Mayor's office. Leslie Jacobs could be the only choice in the upcoming New Orleans Mayor's race who will put Education first.

My Experience of Coaching Mathcounts Math Contest Preparation

By: Frank Ho | 23/11/2009
This article is about comparing the MATHCOUNTS results of students whom I coached in 1999 and 2000, with different methods in a private learning centre - Ho Math and Chess. I feel the main reason of improvements was due to different coaching methods used in these two years. Students want to participate BC MATHCOUNTS as individuals may find this paper resourceful since individual participation is allowed in 2002/2003 in BC, Canada .

How to Use Chess to Improve Math

By: Frank Ho | 23/11/2009
Some math educators seem to feel math problems can be divided into 2 parts, one is pure computation and the other is problem solving - this claim is evident by examining the textbooks used in schools. When looking at the worksheets offered for elementary students, this seems to be very logic since there is “nothing” could be related to numbers used in the computational problems to enhance thinking ability.

How to find a good math learning center?

By: Frank Ho | 23/11/2009
The most two important ingredients are the teaching material and the instructor. There are many math learning centers who have not developed materials in a systematic and consistent way, they simply collect each tutor's lecture notes and bind them together and call them "the most valuable material developed by a group of outstanding scholars''.

Using Chess to Teach Math in Elementary Schools

By: Frank Ho | 23/11/2009
Chess has been heralded as a miracle to help children develop their math skills. How true is it? After my over 10 years of research and teaching of math, I think the answer is not a simple yes or no, rather it depends on how chess instruction is delivered. If chess is delivered as a pure game and taught in a way that it has nothing to do with math then the impact on math learning is minimum. On the other hand, if chess is integrated into math worksheets then the effect is more significant.

How KenKen Puzzles can Help You Learn Math

By: Brian Foley | 29/04/2009 | K-12 Education
KenKen puzzles are a new and exciting way to learn and teach basic math. KenKen is addictive, inexpensive and easy to learn. And it really does teach math skills in a very effective way.

Learning the Multiplication Tables - Skip Counting by Two and Three

By: Brian Foley | 19/04/2009 | K-12 Education
Skip counting is a great way to start familiarizing a child with multiplication. There a lots of ways to do it, but using normal playing cards has advantages that no other way has. Here's a link to a free video you can view to learn a good way to teach skip counting with playing cards.

Multiplication - Do you I have to show the work?

By: Brian Foley | 17/04/2009 | K-12 Education
The dogma of, "you have to show your work," is generally more harmful than good. Why do schools insist on it?

Multiplication by Two - How to Practice Multiplying With Playing Cards

By: Brian Foley | 11/02/2009 | K-12 Education
A very easy, effective way to learn or teach multiplication by two, using playing cards.

Multiplying by Nine With the Finger Method

By: Brian Foley | 24/11/2008 | K-12 Education
Here's a clear description of an easy way to master the "nine-times-table" immediately, so you'll never have trouble with it again. And there's no memorization!

Multiplication Tables - Better Ways

By: Brian Foley | 19/11/2008 | K-12 Education
Why do so many teachers and parents forbid kids from learning on their fingers? If you use them often enough to learn the simple arithmetical skills, you will automatically memorize those "facts." You will do it by muscle/mind memory. You will make the skills part of you, rather than getting them inculcated from some external "tables."

Memorizing the Multiplication Tables to 20 - That's Just Crazy!

By: Brian Foley | 19/11/2008 | K-12 Education
Learning the multiplication tables to twenty is pretty impressive - but there is a better way than memorizing them. There is a simple way to do it that you can learn in a minute or two.

Submit Your Articles Free: Signup
Article Categories




Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (1.17, 6, w1)