Breaching a contract is bad, bad, bad...isn't it? Well, not always, at least not in the eyes of the law. The purpose of contract law is not to spank naughty promise-breakers, but to increase economic efficiency.
Suppose, for example, that you own some real estate. Buyer 1 wants to live in your house and offers you what you consider to be a good price for it, and you enter into a contract with Buyer 1 to sell it to him. Then Buyer 2 calls you. He wants to buy your real estate to build a shopping center on it, and he is willing to pay you twice as much as Buyer 1. You contact a lawyer and he tells you that even if you pay full damages to Buyer 1, with what Buyer 2 is paying you you'll still come out way ahead. You respond by breaching the contract with Buyer 1, paying him the amount he lost on account of your breach (known as "expectation damages"), and selling the house to Buyer 2. Should you contact a priest to confess your sin?
Not necessary. By paying Buyer 1 full expectation damages, you put him in as good a position as he would have been in had you performed your contract with him. Therefore he has no legitimate complaint. Furthermore, by selling your real estate to a developer whose development will increase the economic value of your real estate far more than Buyer 1 would have, you have done your part to increase economic efficiency. So pat yourself on the back, take a trip to Maui, whatever. You have just committed what is known as efficient breach, and Uncle Sam is happy with you because the property taxes on your former real estate will undoubtedly increase, and so will your income taxes.
The point is that when it comes to civil law (as opposed to criminal law), morality takes second place to economic efficiency. That is why someone who robs a house is guilty, but someone who breaches a contract to sell a house is merely liable (of course, you can be guilty and liable at the same time!).
Real Estate Law in Plain English explains real estate law without the legalese.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
- Remedies for Breach of Contract in the UK
- Breach of Contract Discussion, in Its Laws, Remedy and Lawsuits
- What Defines a Breach of Contract - Contracts 101
- Efficient Breach - When You Should Breach Your Contract, And Why The Law Is Designed To Encourage Certain Kinds Of Breach
- Quick Lesson in Breach of Contract
- Common Defenses to Florida Breach of Contract Lawsuits
- California Contract Lawyer On How A California Contract Attorney Determines If There Is A Breach Of Contract And What Damages Are Recoverable
- Procurement Law – When is a contract not a contract?
Adoption Laws In Islam: Some Issues
By: Zahidul Islam Biswas | 08/12/2009This article illustrates why adoption of child is not permitted in Islamic law, and it also discusses some relevant issues.
FBAR:Foreign Bank Account Reporting is Sought By IRS
By: KevinThorn | 08/12/2009In the wake of the UBS AG fallout and IRS Offshore Settlement Initiative, the IRS continues its pursuit of tax evaders with undisclosed offshore accounts with their requests of FBAR (Foreign Bank Account Reporting) of suspected violators.
Consular Processing Issues: 221g, 214b, Administrative Processing, and the Fraud Prevention Unit
By: Ben Hart | 07/12/2009A brief overview of ways that US visa applications can be delayed overseas.
Legal Forms-Their Importance
By: james kahn | 07/12/2009The importance of legal forms and when you need one
Warrants and their implications:
By: Mark Zelman | 07/12/2009Information on warrants and what can result from them
Notes on warrant types:
By: Mark Zelman | 07/12/2009Different types of warrants
Using Fee Based Websites to Find Criminal Records
By: Mark Zelman | 07/12/2009How to search for criminal records using fee based websites
Understanding the Procedure for an Arrest Report and How to Get It Online
By: Mark Zelman | 07/12/2009How arrest reports are made and how to access them online.
Yew Git Off My Property! The Law Of Trespassing
By: Bob Miles | 29/05/2007 | LawCYA Disclaimer: The following is intended for reference purposes only and not as legal advice. What is "trespassing", anyway? Most of us think we know. But the more you think about it, the more complex it can get. For example, could you be sued for trespassing on property that you are...
Real Property Law: Fixtures
By: Bob Miles | 29/05/2007 | LawCYA Disclaimer: The following is intended for reference purposes only and not as legal advice. What is a fixture, anyway? Odds are you own one. The formal definition is "a tangible object that was once personal property but has become so connected with real property that it has become a part...
Real Estate Law: Underground Water
By: Bob Miles | 29/05/2007 | LawCYA Disclaimer: The following is intended for reference purposes only and not as legal advice. Do you own the water running under your property? If you're not the kind of person who would care one way or another, then read no further (although it is beyond me how anyone could fail...
Real Property Law: Nuisances
By: Bob Miles | 29/05/2007 | LawCYA Disclaimer: The following is intended for reference purposes only and not as legal advice. "He's such a nuisance, constantly drumming his fingers on the table like that!" Just what is a "nuisance", anyway? Well, it has one meaning in common parlance and another more specific meaning in law, although the...
Airspace Over Your Property - How Much Of It Do You Own?
By: Bob Miles | 29/05/2007 | LawCYA Disclaimer: The following is intended for reference purposes only and not as legal advice. The short answer is, "as much of it as you can use". No, you cannot float a "No Trespassing" blimp and shoot down passing airliners for trespassing. But believe it or not, you can build a...
How Mortgages Work
By: Bob Miles | 28/05/2007 | Real EstateA mortgage is created when someone uses real estate to secure a promise to repay a debt. For example, if you borrow money from a bank and give the bank permission to sell your house to pay off the debt if you don't pay it back yourself, then you have...
Registering The Purchase Of Your Real Estate
By: Bob Miles | 27/05/2007 | Real EstateAs soon as you buy real estate, it's a must to register it at the recording office or wherever real estate transactions are registered in your particular jurisdiction. If you don't, you could end up losing title to your real estate due to the misconduct of the previous owner or...
Real Estate Law: Damages For Breach Of Warranty Covenants By A Seller
By: Bob Miles | 27/05/2007 | Real EstateIf you own real estate and sell it to a buyer under a general warranty deed, you can be liable to the buyer years later for some defect in the title that you didn't even know about at the time you sold him the real estate, and you could end...