Aaron Lovaas is a lawyer practicing in the areas of business litigation, business formation and planning, and real estate matters through his law firm, Shimon & Lovaas, P.C., in Las Vegas, NV. aaron@shimon-lovaas.com; website: http://www.shimon-lovaas.com.
The recent national surge in home foreclosures coming on the heels of the collapse of the sub-prime lending industry and decline in home values likely means additional bad news for those former homeowners who feel like they just lost everything: additional income tax liability.
Income tax liability? From losing your home? Such is the nature of the United States Internal Revenue Code.
Given the foreclosure epidemic and the huge losses to which lenders of all sizes are now exposed, many lenders are willing to enter into a variety of work-out programs with their borrowers to avoid foreclosure. Avoiding foreclosure does not necessarily mean keeping the home, however.
The foreclosure process is time-consuming for the lenders and often subjects them to the additional time and expense of physically evicting the former home owner from the home after the foreclosure sale. From the borrower's perspective, a foreclosure is a huge blow to credit worthiness and will impact the borrower's ability to finance major purchases for years to come.
Considering many lenders' goals of reducing their losses on foreclosures, borrowers have met with success recently in negotiating "short sales" with their lenders. A short sale is the borrower's reconveyance of the home to the lender for less than the amount owed on the mortgage.
For example: Joe obtained a creative home loan and purchased a home at the height of home values and during the most liberal period in sub-prime lending.
Eventually, the appraised value of Joe's home began to drop and the "creative" part of his home loan kicked-in. Perhaps his interest rate adjusted or his interest-only payments ceased and he was required to commence paying both principal and interest.
In any event, Joe finds that he cannot afford to continue making the mortgage payments and, due to market circumstances, he now owes more on the mortgage than the home is worth. In other words, he is upside down in the home.
Joe defaults on the mortgage payments and is now subject to the foreclosure process.
Applied to the example above, the borrower might successfully negotiate a short sale with his lender. Many lenders are now accepting a reconveyance of the home and forgiving the remaining debt exceeding the value of the home.
In the example, Joe may have purchased the home for $300,000. He has made interest-only payments on the loan for a year, but due to the recent slump in the market, the home is now worth only $250,000. He still owes $300,000 on the mortgage. The lender, therefore, may accept a reconveyance of the home - in essence a $250,000 payment - against the $300,000 debt.
The sale is "short" because the value of the home does not cover the amount of the mortgage. The lender may forgive the additional $50,000 owed by the borrower in order to avoid the foreclosure process, or to avoid litigation expenses in pursuing the borrower for the deficiency balance, and essentially cut its losses.
For the borrower, he avoids foreclosure and its ramifications to his credit, as well as facing a likely judgment for the amount still owed on the debt.
The hidden drawback here, though, is that the tax code treats Joe's debt relief as income. By being relieved of the obligation to pay $50,000, the IRS considers that Joe has in effect put $50,000 in his pocket.
The debt relief is subject to ordinary income tax. Joe may not even know of his additional tax liability until he receives an envelope in the mail from the lender containing a 1099 form reporting the debt relief income to the IRS.
The same result may follow if Joe simply walks away from the home, allows foreclosure to proceed, and then the lender elects not to pursue Joe for collection of the deficiency balance on the loan.
The ripple effect of the sub-prime lending market over the past couple of years has yet to reach its full effect. Individual homeowners must be wary of all consequences of divesting themselves of the homes they purchased in that market.
While financial planning might be the last thing on a borrower's mind when he or she faces the harsh reality that the home will be lost in some way, the unforeseen consequences of a foreclosure or short sale can only be addressed through the sound advice of a tax professional, CPA, or, at the very least, the IRS website.
Of interest to us lawyers, however, is the approach the IRS will take to the likely spate of litigation that will proceed, alleging that these borrowers, now facing additional income tax liability through the loss of their homes, should not be responsible for the 1099 income tax burden, by virtue of alleged fraud or misrepresentation on the part of the sub-prime lenders.
As they say, "the Wheels of Justice grind slowly." We will all have to wait to see how this shakes out.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
- Las Vegas Foreclosure - Get the Best Real Estate Deals
- No New Building in Las Vegas Great for Investors
- Las Vegas Foreclosures for Sale – Why to Buy and How to Find the Best Las Vegas Foreclosures?
- Las Vegas Foreclosures – Your Best Investment Option Today
- Steps to follow to make best use of Las Vegas Foreclosure Listings
- Know more about Las Vegas Foreclosures
- Las Vegas Foreclosure What To Do
- How to Handle a Las Vegas Foreclosure




http://HomeEquityTheft.blogspot.com/search?q=short+sales+income+tax
Wrongful Death – Criminal or Civil Action?
By: Thomas Ajava | 16/11/2009The legal system in the United States is divided up into a number of channels. Civil and criminal law are the two most common forms that people experience. A wrongful death action is one where a person is killed because of the alleged wrongful conduct of another party or parties. So, does this make it a criminal action or a civil one?
How To Check Arrest Records Free Of Charge To See A Persons Arrest History
By: James Nash | 16/11/2009Arrest records and arrest history isn't thing of the private detectives anymore. Did you know that you can check all that information free of charge? Yes you heard me, and here is how.
Immigration - Factors, Rules and Barriers
By: Sundeep | 16/11/2009Immigration means migration into place especially to a country for the purpose of permanent resident. It is a biological and modern phenomena. Immigration concept is related to development of citizenship law.
Have auto accident - don’t vacillate! Employ an auto accident lawyers!
By: Brain Stone | 16/11/2009You know car casualities can influence not just on your health and induce several harms or woundings. They may pull you as well in some additional charges. Furthermore any casuality may affect on your psychic also. Sometimes many firms, which promise you to pay funds in a occurrence of any accident which may take place with you and your auto, act not so legally. They may repay you a tiny sum of money not everything you have right to. So your first step you must realize at once after ...
Legal Research and Writing
By: Web Spiders | 16/11/2009Outsourcing legal process has gained a great importance during this global financial crisis. The LPO companies that are based in the developing countries are helping the international firms by proving them an opportunity to cut down their legal costs.
Problems with your attorney – what are they and in what way to avoid them?
By: Ned Moon | 16/11/2009There are cases when you start to treat your lawyer with distrust or feel that he isn't so able in your occasion and chances to win the process lessen, then you should act without any hold-ups. You mustn't axpect until you will receive a term and will be sent to goal. Wrong attorney's actions can impact badly on your case condition. You shouldn't be furious in the following situation just call your attorney, appoint the meeting with him and discuss once more your position and all his ...
How Can I Check Criminal Records On The Internet To View Peoples Past
By: James Nash | 16/11/2009Well you don't want to marry a thief or leave your kids to a nanny with criminal history. You can avoid all this unpleasant situations by getting a criminal report on someone, and there are few way you can do that.
What Happens If I Don’t Make My Chapter 13 Payment?
By: Bass.Franklin | 16/11/2009If you're filing for bankruptcy in Los Angeles, California and have decided that you no longer want to make payments on your Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you do have several options. Contact the law office of Borowitz & Clark, experienced bankruptcy attorneys who take your case from start to finish.