 |
Gay Marriages From Other States Recognized by NY Appeals Court
Author: Gary E Rosenberg  | Posted: 05-02-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 15 | Rating: (52)  (?) 
 New York must recognize same-sex marriages conducted in other states, until another appeals court rules otherwise. This was held by the New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Fourth Department, this past Friday, February 1, 2008.
The decision in Martinez v. County of Monroe arose out of Martinez's quest to obtain spousal health care benefits from Monroe Community College for Lisa Golden, whom she married in Ontario, Canada. Where the marriage was performed was legal, there was no question. And then they returned to New York.
In the absence of a New York statute forbidding same-sex marriage, the Court found no reason not to recognize the marriage. It held that the marriage "is entitled to recognition in New York State." Is this a silent invitation to the New York State legislature to pass a law deciding this issue one way or the other? Maybe.
After the lawsuit was started but before the court's decision, the college changed its health insurance policy to cover same-sex spouses. This gave rise to an interesting wrinkle in this case, for if Lisa Golden was getting health insurance anyway, what was there left to sue over? In legal terms we ask if there was any longer a "justiciable controversy." The Court said that there was, as the college would be liable for damages for the time period that it refused to give health insurance coverage to the plaintiff's spouse. We don't know if those damages are great or small. They might be the cost of Lisa Golden going to the doctor's office, or her out-of-pocket expense to purchase her own health insurance or whatever.
Thus, it seems that the court had a potential way out here if it wanted to duck the controversy entirely. It may have decided that since the college is now providing health benefits, there wasn't justiciable controversy so the lawsuit was "moot." Instead, the court waded in and addressed the gay marriage issue head-on, giving a favorable and enlightened reading to the facts before it. No cowards on this Appellate Division, Fourth Department panel.
Commentary: Gay advocates hail the decision as only a first step towards what they consider truly would be fair: permitting gay marriages in New York State. I and my lawyer friends look forward to the day when gay marriage is legal in New York; where there are gay marriages, there WILL be gay divorces.
Until another appeals court rules otherwise, New York must recognize same-sex marriages conducted in other states. So held the New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Fourth Department this past Friday, February 1, 2008.
The decision in Martinez v. County of Monroe arose out of Martinez's quest to obtain spousal health care benefits from Monroe Community College for Lisa Golden, whom she married in Ontario, Canada. Where the marriage was performed was legal, there was no question. And then they returned to New York.
In the absence of a New York statute forbidding same-sex marriage, the Court found no reason not to recognize the marriage. It held that the marriage "is entitled to recognition in New York State." Is this a silent invitation to the New York State legislature to pass a law deciding this issue one way or the other? Maybe.
After the lawsuit was started but before the court's decision, the college changed its health insurance policy to cover same-sex spouses. This gave rise to an interesting wrinkle in this case, for if Lisa Golden was getting health insurance anyway, what was there left to sue over? In legal terms we ask if there was any longer a "justiciable controversy." The Court said that there was, as the college would be liable for damages for the time period that it refused to give health insurance coverage to the plaintiff's spouse. We don't know if those damages are great or small. They might be the cost of Lisa Golden going to the doctor's office, or her out-of-pocket expense to purchase her own health insurance or whatever.
Thus, it seems that the court had a potential way out here if it wanted to duck the controversy entirely. It may have decided that since the college is now providing health benefits, there wasn't justiciable controversy so the lawsuit was "moot." Instead, the court waded in and addressed the gay marriage issue head-on, giving a favorable and enlightened reading to the facts before it. No cowards on this Appellate Division, Fourth Department panel.
Commentary: Gay advocates hail the decision as only a first step towards what they consider truly would be fair: permitting gay marriages in New York State. I and my lawyer friends look forward to the day when gay marriage is legal in New York; where there are gay marriages, there WILL be gay divorces.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/law-articles/gay-marriages-from-other-states-recognized-by-ny-appeals-court-324948.html
About the Author:FREE books and reports! For more information about New York car accidents and personal injury request my FREE book: Warning! Things That Can Destroy Your CarAccident Case (And the Insurance Companies Already Know These Things) at http://www.GreatlegalBooks.com. For more information and FREE reports, visit my website, http://www.InjuryAtty.net.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
Auto Accidents - When to Get a Lawyer for Personal Injury
By: Luke Sabucco | 28/01/2007 | Law
A brief overview of when to find a Personal Injury Lawyer for Automobile Accidents, When it comes to auto accidents, people often wonder if they should contact a injury lawyer right away. It depends on the situation.
The Battle Against Trial Lawyers
By: Jason Crawford | 23/06/2008 | Law
A commentary on the recent trend to limit the amounts that attorneys can charge clients in injury cases and a recent New York times article on this trend.
Pursuing a Motorcycle Accident Claim
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 26/02/2008 | Law
All about motorcycle accidents and injuries, including some safety tips and what to expect when pursuing an accident claim for injuries.
The Wrong-way Driving Accident Epidemic in Washington State
By: Christopher Davis | 03/03/2008 | Law
There seems to be a sudden increase in wrong-way driving accidents occurring in the metro Seattle area. Not only have we have noticed more of these types of accidents being reported in the news, but lately we've received several inquires from wrong-way accident victims. So we decided to look into the matter to find out just how big of a problem wrong-way driving is in Washington State. What we discovered was somewhat surprising.
Dangers of Drunk and Reckless Driving
By: Peter Kent | 23/05/2008 | Automotive
As more individuals continue to become licensed drivers in America, the number of automobile accidents also continues to be on the rise as well. One of the most common automobile accidents occurs while an individual is under the influence of alcohol, which often result in deadly and severe accidents.
Machine Guarding Safety
By: Alan Haburchak | 17/03/2008 | Law
Hazardous working conditions where machines do not have adequate guards in place can increase the risk of personal injury to workers. For at least a century technology has existed to protect workers in situations where machine guarding should be in place, but often management is reluctant to spend money that they deem unnecessary, although it could save a life.
Emotional Damages? How to Choose a Psychiatrist to Examine Your Client-from Chicago
By: Dr Michael Shery | 04/08/2008 | Law
Are you a personal injury lawyer who suspects that a client may be mentally or psychologically impaired as the result of an accident? Have him examined to assess the quantity and severity of any resulting psychological symptoms. After all, there may be a need for significant compensation to make your client whole again. Read this article to discover everything you need to know!
Construction Site Accidents and Injuries
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 08/04/2008 | Law
Get legal advice immediately if you or a loved one have a construction site accident. Because these accidents involve complex issues and an assortment of possible defendants, there must be a thorough investigation of the construction site, interviews of co-workers and witnesses, and, possibly, taking of photographs. This must be done fast, fast, fast - sometimes even while the injured worker is still in the hospital.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Law Articles
Protect yourself From Identity Theft
By: Ed Opperman | 21/08/2008
Wouldn't is be wiser and safer to know how vulnerable you are to identity theft before the theft occurs? Too many ID theft programs only help you after you are a victim.
10 Things to Know About the Miami, Florida Court Reporter
By: Mark Etinger | 21/08/2008
The legal community in Dade County is one of the busiest in the country. As we speak, there are millions of criminal and civil cases being held in Miami area courthouses, as well as thousands of depositions being taken every day within the law offices found in the area.
When the Rising Cost of Car Insurance Becomes a Pain in the Neck
By: Nick Jervis | 21/08/2008
When the latest quotes for your car insurance hit the doormat you may need to sit down before you open them: motor insurance premiums have more than doubled since 1994 and, over the last year alone, fully comprehensive and third party insurance premiums have gone up 5.9%. Yet according to...
An Ill Wind of Change?
By: Nick Jervis | 21/08/2008
The winds of change are blowing through the UK's employment legislation and it could well be an ill wind that blows nobody any good because the Government wants to scrap laws that require employers to retain insurance policy records for at least 40 years.
On the face of it that may...
Beating the Super Bugs
By: Nick Jervis | 21/08/2008
Our medical expertise is quite extraordinary these days with access to phenomenal hi-tech wizardry that can look inside our bodies, microsurgery that can save limbs and increasingly effective drugs, and yet the biggest battle we have is against the so called 'super bugs' such as MRSA and Clostridium difficile, commonly...
Deadly Dust Victims
By: Nick Jervis | 21/08/2008
Government plans to relax rules that require employers to keep Employers Liability Insurance records for up to 40 years could be very bad news indeed for former employees whose work-related illness didn't manifest until many decades later such as mesothelioma and Vibration White Finger.
Victims need access to Employers Liability Insurance...
Not Such Good Vibrations
By: Nick Jervis | 21/08/2008
Have you worked in the construction industry or forestry? Are you a grounds man, a green keeper or professional gardener? Then your profession could triggered Vibration White Finger (VWF) or Hand-Arm Vibration Syndrome (HAVS). Anyone working with vibrating hand-held tools over a prolonged period, whether it's a lawnmower or a...
Things You Must Do After an Auto Accident - Part II
By: John Harris | 20/08/2008
Part II of Things You Must Do After an Accident. It contains information and tips to help you protect yourself is you are in an car accident. It outlines information your attorney will need if you decide you need an attorney.
More from Gary E Rosenberg
I Had an Accident Two Months Ago - Why Do My Neck & Back Still Hurt?
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 18/08/2008 | Personal Injury
So, you had an accident. You slipped and fell, or maybe you were involved in a car collision. You thought you were okay, a little sore maybe, bumps and bruises – nothing serious. No broken bones. You noticed your back and neck started feeling tight, stiff and you couldn’t move as freely as you could before the accident. You used a heating pad, took some pain relievers, and maybe saw your family doctor, just in case. But weeks have gone by, and you still hurt.
Your Children Must Always be in Car Seats
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 17/06/2008 | Law
Too often I see children standing up in cars, looking out the back window or just sitting on laps. Don't parents know that in an accident the body of an unrestrained child becomes a projectile, bouncing around the interior of the car?
What is Arbitration and Mediation?
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 23/04/2008 | Law
Arbitration and mediation are two types of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), which is a way to resolve conflicts outside of traditional lawsuits and courtrooms. Sometimes attorneys are involved and sometimes not.
What is an "infant Compromise"?
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 20/04/2008 | Law
Legally, an "infant" is a person under age eighteen. In New York State, an infant's case can not be settled without the approval of a judge, not even if the parent wants to accept the settlement. This situation typically arises when the infant has a claim or lawsuit for personal injury arising out of an accident. The reason is simple: to protect the infant and tie up his or her money at least until the age of eighteen.
A Conflict of Interest - What is It?
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 15/04/2008 | Law
Attorneys are supposed to represent their clients competently and diligently and to the utmost of their abilities. Attorneys are not allowed to accept employment where their loyalties may be divided because it's a conflict of interest.
What is a Deposition?
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 12/04/2008 | Law
To remove the mystery about a deposition: it is a question and answer session which takes place under oath, with a stenographic reporter present to take down all that is said. A deposition may also be tape recorded or videotaped. It is sometimes also called an "examination before trial."
What is an Independent Medical Examination?
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 11/04/2008 | Law
Independent medical examination (IME) is a fancy term for being examined by a doctor when you are involved in some kind of claim or lawsuit where your physical or mental condition or an injury is in dispute.
Construction Site Accidents and Injuries
By: Gary E Rosenberg | 08/04/2008 | Law
Get legal advice immediately if you or a loved one have a construction site accident. Because these accidents involve complex issues and an assortment of possible defendants, there must be a thorough investigation of the construction site, interviews of co-workers and witnesses, and, possibly, taking of photographs. This must be done fast, fast, fast - sometimes even while the injured worker is still in the hospital.
|
|
Law 
