Author is a freelance copywriter. For more information on new jersey court reporters, visit http://huseby.com/newjersey.html.
New Jersey court reporters noted with interest a September 2008 decision regarding videotaping of depositions. A plaintiff wanted to compel the videotaping of her deposition over the objections of the defendant's attorney. The Honorable Rachelle Harz, Bergen County superior court judge, has ruled that the videotaping cannot be prevented.
The Value of the Written Transcript
Judge Harz made a point of saying that videotaped depositions did not remove the requirements for stenographic transcripts prepared by qualified New Jersey court reporters. The only addition to the transcript is the requirement that the name, address and firm of the video operator must be stated on record prior to the swearing in of the witnesses.
New Jersey court reporters were pleased by this decision. There have been unfortunate cases where decisions have been made that allow technology such as digital recordings to take the place of transcripts prepared by certified court reporters. These decisions are almost always reversed years later when the courts see the problems created by the absence of a professional and disinterested record keeper.
The Value of Videotape
The plaintiff's attorney asserted that the videotape was a necessary part of a complete deposition. The plaintiff had suffered debilitating injuries, allegedly as a result of improper treatment in the emergency room of the hospital who was the defendant. Her speech and movement difficulties were part of her situation, it was stated, and a complete picture of her condition wouldn't be adequately described by a reading of the transcript.
There is truth in this statement. Transcripts prepared by New Jersey court reporters are deliberately written to be impartial documentation of the proceedings. They are accurate records of the spoken word and often contain notes about the speaker's actions as well, but aren't designed to capture emotion or rhythms of speech.
To be fair, video is not a disinterested observer. It is human nature to change behavior when on camera. The defending attorney's objection was that the presence of video would interfere with her ability to take an accurate deposition. The judge noted that it would also prevent an overly forceful method of questioning.
Two Media Working Together
The true value of videotaped depositions is not to replace transcripts prepared by New Jersey court reporters but to supplement them. Each record of the proceeding brings different information and together they form a picture more complete than either would create alone.
This is a perfect of example of how changing technology doesn't threaten the court reporting profession but enhances it. Court reporters can use technology such as video, digital audio, and speech recognition to augment their abilities as a professional documenter of the spoken word. By embracing all new developments in record keeping methods, court reporters can serve better in their roles as guardian of the spoken word.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
How do I get my Thai Fiancee United States Citizenship?
By: Ben Hart | 08/11/2009A brief overview of the full process of getting a Thai Fiancee a US passport, from the initial K1 visa until the US naturalization process.
Personal injury lawyer Houston – finding the right one
By: Lewis Dylan | 08/11/2009The world in general is getting more and more dangerous by the day. Along with the world; work places are also in increasingly becoming dangerous. To be more specific the work hazards that workers are exposed to are also on the rise. In spite of all the protective gear however personal injuries are quite frequent.
How To Correctly Undertake Site Induction Training
By: Martin Sejas | 08/11/2009Site induction training is one of the most important yet under appreciated parts of any construction project. This article aims to briefly cover the major components of site induction training.
A Criminal Attorney For Murder Charges
By: Linda49818a | 08/11/2009Possession of explosives, aggravated assault, burglary, carjacking, drug crimes, drunk driving, and unlawful use of credit card are all criminal charges and filed in a criminal court.
Legal Document Drafting
By: Achal Madhavan | 08/11/2009We offer you the legal document drafting facility where you can convert your own content into template format for automated legal document drafting.
Why opt for document management software
By: Achal Madhavan | 08/11/2009With document management software system you can automate the scheduled events on documents. Brightleaf offers you document management system which is capable of storing & retrieving data at the blink of an eye.
Document assembly system helps you deliver quick and cost effective results
By: Achal Madhavan | 08/11/2009Brightleaf provides you the document assembly system that helps you consolidate all the legal information at one place & can also improve the quality of deliverables & broaden the scope of content available for reuse.
Legal document process automation service
By: Achal Madhavan | 08/11/2009Offering legal document process automation service where you can create, control, & collaborate on those documents of your clients that are more productive & more profitable.
New Jersey Plaintiffs Can Insist On Videotaped Depositions
By: Christine Harrell | 14/10/2008 | LawNew Jersey court reporters noted with interest a September 2008 decision regarding videotaping of depositions. A plaintiff wanted to compel the videotaping of her deposition over the objections of the defendant's attorney.
What Constitutes A Good Stretch Routine?
By: Christine Harrell | 14/10/2008 | Sports & FitnessPerforming a series of bad stretches before starting a home exercise program such as p90x is just as bad if not worse than doing none at all. These exercises are absolutely necessary to achieve your personal fitness goals in a healthy way.
How To Measure Improvement With A Home Fitness Routine
By: Christine Harrell | 14/10/2008 | Sports & FitnessOne of the biggest parts of a home fitness routine is being able to see the results. People want everything to work faster and select a ten minute trainer routine to get as much exercise as they can between schedule demands.
Looking For A Cheap Car? Consider Restoring A Willys
By: Christine Harrell | 14/10/2008 | CarsWe live in an automotive society and it's hard to get around without a car. Unfortunately even a used car can be out of some people's price range. Cars old enough to be cheap are also old enough to have crippling mechanical problems. So what is the budget-minded car buyer to do?
Preparing For Christian Home Schooling -- A Home Schooling Supplies Checklist
By: Christine Harrell | 14/10/2008 | HomeschoolingIn a traditional education system, the teacher, parents, and children need to prepare for the upcoming year. The same occurs with Christian home schooling except that the family does all of the preparations.
Cabinet Designs For The Den Or Living Room
By: Christine Harrell | 13/10/2008 | Home ImprovementCabinets for the den or living room are different from any other room in the house. Unlike a kitchen or bathroom where cabinet designs have a standard and specific purpose, these rooms serve a variety of functions and the storage needs to reflect that while still matching decor.
The Failing Economy -- Why It Is The Perfect Time To Buy New And Used Cars
By: Christine Harrell | 13/10/2008 | CarsWith the house market failing, higher gas prices, and the economy falling to dangerous levels, things have changed in the world of used cars. People are spending less in general and automakers and banks are changing the way they finance and provide vehicles to the public. Surprisingly enough, all of this makes it the perfect time to buy a used car.
UCC Filing Requires Perfection for the UCC Redemption Process - Tips For Filing A UCC1 Form
By: Christine Harrell | 02/10/2008 | Personal FinanceFiling a UCC1 form can be tricky business and requires nothing short of perfection or it can end up being filed wrong, thus ineffective, and that is the very last thing anyone would ever want go wrong! This doesn't mean it is impossible.