We provide the latest developments of Compliance Law in health care and offers advanced Learning Opportunities about Stark rules for healthcare executives, hospitals and physicians.
There’s a lot that your hospital can learn from the mistakes of others, especially those relating to slippery Stark rules.
Mid 2009 (June 26, 2009) saw OIG announcing a settlement with Memorial Hospital of Union County (MHUC) in Ohio for $31,202 for allegedly violating the Civil Monetary Penalties Law provisions on kickbacks and physician self-referrals.
The facility itself disclosed a situation that according to OIG involved the provision of excess non-monetary compensation to physicians and the immediate family member of a physician who referred patients to MHUC.
One report read that the hospital found out that it had given ten physicians $3,100 in excess Stark-violating gifts between 2007 and 2008. As per the reports, the gifts included weather clocks and seminars.
But for non-monetary compensation, that allows you to give up to $355 worth of stuff to a doctor yearly, Stark has an exception. In MHUC’s case, the value of the gifts offered to the docs that surpassed the $355/ each annual limit totaled over $3,000, and it ended up with a penalty that was ten times over the amount of that excess.
Wayne J. Miller, an attorney with the Compliance Law Group in Thousand Oaks, CA points out that the government could have required MHUC to pay back the whole reimbursement for the doctors for the period of violation. Nevertheless, it’s still an expensive hit for a minor violation, more precisely taking into account the staff and attorney time involved in resolving the matter. Miller says, “The hospital decided to take this path in order to duck a possible qui tam claim that could have ultimately cost your pocket much more.”
According to miller, the gift exception needs to be taken seriously. And the good tiding is that it’s relatively easy to know if you are walking on thin ice.
- Related Articles
- Related Q&A
- Slippery Stark rules? Learn from the mistakes of others
- New Stark Rules – Yet More Arrangements to be Restructured
- CMS Finalizes Major Stark Changes
- Stark II Phase III
- Does Your Practice Qualify as a Group Practice Under Federal Stark Law
- Recovery Audit Contractors and Medicare Audits: Successful Strategies for Defending Audits
- Recovery Audit Contractors and Medicare Audits: Successful Strategies for Defending Audits
- Privilege: Its Role in Oppression




Certain Forms And Habits Can Protect You From Being Sued
By: james kahn | 29/11/2009Accidents, mistakes and misunderstandings can happen in any business or transaction. People involved would try to settle it outside the court, that is amicably, through negotiations and compromise. However, others will grow into full-blown disputes maybe because of the complexity of the issues or the differences are just plainly irreconcilable. As a result of which, you may end up facing a legal claim…you are already being sued!
Health Insurance Forms Are Important Legal Forms That Must Be Reviewed Before Signing
By: james kahn | 29/11/2009Some might choose to stay uninsured because they do not perceive themselves to be at a great risk of illness. However, life is full of unforeseen events. Illness and diseases are unavoidable.
Medical Experts Qualified For Witness Can Make Or Break a Case
By: A.Noton | 29/11/2009In many cases where there is a question of medical liability whether that is medical malpractice or personal injury, Medical Experts Qualified for Witness will be called upon to testify. If there is an issue of medical malpractice and there is a court trial there will be an issue of...
Pinellas County Court Records | Pinellas County Criminal Records
By: Jason Donald | 29/11/2009Pinellas County Court and Criminal Records are now available. If you want to find Pinellas County Court Records or Pinellas County Criminal Records, you need to read this article. Pinellas County Court Records | Pinellas County Criminal Records:
Will County Court Records | Will County Criminal Records
By: Jason Donald | 29/11/2009Will County Court and Criminal Records are now available. If you want to find Will County Court Records or Will County Criminal Records, you need to read this article. Will County Court Records | Will County Criminal Records:
Carroll County Court Records | Carroll County Criminal Records
By: Jason Donald | 29/11/2009Carroll County Court and Criminal Records are now available. If you want to find Carroll County Court Records or Carroll County Criminal Records, you need to read this article. Carroll County Court Records | Carroll County Criminal Records:
Rock County Court Records | Rock County Criminal Records
By: Jason Donald | 29/11/2009Rock County Court and Criminal Records are now available. If you want to find Rock County Court Records or Rock County Criminal Records, you need to read this article. Rock County Court Records | Rock County Criminal Records:
Jefferson County Court Records | Jefferson County Criminal Records
By: Jason Donald | 29/11/2009Jefferson County Court and Criminal Records are now available. If you want to find Jefferson County Court Records or Jefferson County Criminal Records, you need to read this article. Jefferson County Court Records | Jefferson County Criminal Records:
Keep three on-call billing questions in mind
By: Jaun Paul | 25/11/2009 | HealthDon’t fall into the trap of letting the other physician bill for the services if your physician is on call and handling patient services for another physician. When your physician renders a service, even while on call for another doctor, it’s you who should bill the services.
New Interim Rule on HIPAA penalties gets going
By: Jaun Paul | 13/11/2009 | HealthIf the old HIPAA penalty rules confused you, don’t expect too much from the new one; it’s just a little better than the old one.
Slippery Stark rules? Learn from the mistakes of others
By: Jaun Paul | 11/11/2009 | LawThere’s a lot that your hospital can learn from the mistakes of others, especially those relating to slippery Stark rules.
Stark’s take on gifts to referring physicians
By: Jaun Paul | 10/11/2009 | HealthGifts to physicians who can potentially refer Medicare or Medicaid patients to your practice or health care body can run afoul of Stark and anti-kickback laws.
Oncology coding: Know the right CPT codes for simulation claims
By: Jaun Paul | 05/11/2009 | CancerTo get more insight on CPT codes for oncology, you can register yourself for one-stop medical coding websites, where you’ll get the entire CPT code list
FERA widens FCA’s reach in subcontracting
By: Jaun Paul | 04/11/2009 | EducationAs part of the follow-on to the 2009 stimulus package, Congress passed the Fraud Enforcement and Recovery Act (FERA), which widens the FCA’s reach in three critical aspects - subcontracting, Medicaid, and over payments - that providers need to train eyes on.
Medicare Administrative Contractors
By: Jaun Paul | 04/11/2009 | HealthMACs may repeal your billing rights if it catches you with the wrong address.