 |
3 Games Managers Play – That Result in Hiring Losers
Author: Michael Mercer, Ph.d.  | Posted: 28-04-2008 | Views: 65 | Rating: (101)  (?) 
 DID YOU EVER HIRE A “SQUARE PEG FOR A ROUND HOLE?”
You can use pre-employment tests, certain astute insights, less laziness plus a shocking realization about betting to help you avoid a huge hiring mistake – avoid hiring ‘a square peg for a round hole.’
I’VE RECEIVED A “DEJA VU” PHONE CALL HUNDREDS OF TIMES
You will benefit from hearing a phone call I received hundreds of times from managers at a big variety of companies. I call it a deja vu phone call, because I have gotten the same phone call so many times that, as Yogi Berra quipped, “It’s like déjà vu all over again.”
In this phone call I receive, a manager who uses my pre-employment tests calls me, and says, “I want to hire an applicant, but the applicant got horrible scores on your pre-employment tests. But, I loved the applicant in the interview. What should I do?”
I always respond, “Well, that’s up to you.”
To which the manager always asks me, “O.K. but, Dr. Mercer, what should I do?”
Invariably, the problem boils down to this: A company using the pre-employment tests has customized “Benchmark Scores.” Those are scores its superstars or best employees typically earn on the tests. To help hire the best, the company obviously should prefer applicants who get pre-employment test scores similar to its best employees’ “Benchmark” test scores.
However, the manager making the “Deja Vu” phone call has an applicant who scored very different than the company’s superstars’ “Benchmark” test scores.
So, I explain, “The pre-employment test and its benchmark scores are the only customized and accurate prediction method you use. In contrast, interviews and reference checks are subjective, and typically rather inaccurate. The benchmark scores on the pre-employment tests are customized to tell you if an applicant has key qualities similar to your company’s best employees in each job.”
Then, I continue, “So, you want to hire applicants who get test scores similar to your superstar employees, plus also do well in all other prediction methods, such as interviews, reference and background checks, and realistic job observations.”
Suddenly, the truth comes out. The manager played hiring ‘games’ could have resulted in a whopper mistake: Hiring a ‘square peg for a round hole,’ specifically, hiring a lousy applicant.
Here are three games managers play – that can result is the blunder of ‘hiring a square peg for a round hole.”
GAME #1 = SEMI-PSEUDO-RELEVANT WORK EXPERIENCE
The manager hopes – or hallucinates – the applicant’s seemingly relevant work experience is transferable to success in the manager’s company. This often is an incorrect assumption. Just because an applicant did similar work does not mean the applicant will be productive in the new job.
GAME #2 = FALLING IN LOVE – WITH THE APPLICANT
This is a shockingly common mistake managers make. Why? First, research proves most managers do not know how to interview applicants nor make correct judgments based on interviews. Second, job hunters know interviewing tricks that knock-your-socks-off.
Here are three actions a well-rehearsed applicant uses to make a manager ‘fall in love’ with him or her. The applicant uses charm tricks of
1. entering room with big smile, looks manager in eye, and gives nice handshake
2. complimenting the manager’s office or a photo or momento in the manager’s office
3. making the manager laugh or smile in the first 120 seconds
After ‘falling in love’ with and hiring the super-charmer, a manager frequently feels foolish, like lyrics of Dierk Smedley’s song: “I knew what I was feeling. But, what was I thinking?”
GAME #3 = TOO LAZY – TO FIND A BETTER APPLICANT
After a manager admits to being seduced by semi-pseudo-relevant work experience and ‘falling in love’ with a charming applicant, then the truth comes out: The manager feels too lazy to find more applicants.
But here is the bottom line: A manager will spend less time finding a superb applicant than the manager wastes while managing an average or below-average applicant – and applicant who never should have been hired. Plus, a productive employee proves vastly more profitable.
So, I always assure the manager by saying, “I know it’s a hassle to find more applicants, but I’m sure you can find applicants who will turn into top-notch employees.”
SHOCKING REALIZATION = EACH TIME YOU HIRE SOMEONE, YOU ARE BETTING YOUR JOB & COMPANY
After discussing Games 1, 2 and 3, I say this to the hiring manager to convince them it is worthwhile to find better applicants: “Hiring is like betting. Every time you hire a person you are betting your job, career, and company. Do you feel confident betting on an applicant whose pre-employment test scores were different than benchmark test scores of your best employees?”
There always is silence on the phone. Then, the manager slowly speaks up and says, “You’re right – I am betting my career and the company each time I hire someone. Now, I realize I need to find a better applicant. It’s worth my time and energy.”
5 LESSONS from DEJA VU PHONE CALLS
1. Pre-employment tests – customized for jobs in your company – are most accurate way to
predict if an applicant may succeed in your company. Don’t bet against test results.
2. Don’t hallucinate past work experience translates into productivity at your company.
3. Never ‘fall in love’ with a charming, well-rehearsed job applicant.
4. Laziness in hiring squanders money and time when you fail to hire the best.
5. Hiring is betting. Is an applicant worth betting your job, career, and company?
RECOMMENDATION
Bet on job applicants who (a) get scores like your best employees’ scores on pre-employment tests, and also (b) rate well on all other prediction methods you use. That makes a good bet for your job, career, and company.
COPYRIGHT 2008 MICHAEL MERCER, PH.D. All rights reserved.
Rate this Article:
Current: 5 / 5 stars - 1 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/management-articles/3-games-managers-play-that-result-in-hiring-losers-398745.html
About the Author:Michael Mercer, Ph.D., is America's Hire the Best Expert™. Many companies use pre-employment tests he created -- "Abilities & Behavior Forecaster™" Tests - and his "7-Step Method to Hire the Best"™. Dr. Mercer authored 5 books, including "Hire the Best -- & Avoid the Rest™" and also "Turning Your Human Resources Department into a Profit Center™." You can (a) get a free subscription to his e-Newsletter at http://www.Pre-EmploymentTests.com or (b) call to talk with Dr. Mercer at (847) 382-0690
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
7 Steps That Help Managers Hire the Best
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 17/01/2008 | Management
Managers who use my pre-employment tests, interview training, or attend my speeches often ask me, “What is a comprehensive step-by-step method to hire the best?” Here are seven (7) steps that help managers hire the best.
Grow Your Company by Hiring “obsessive-compulsive” Employees
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 09/07/2008 | Management
You can use pre-employment tests and other methods to help you hire obsessive-compulsive employees – when the job requires an organized perfectionist. This article shows you how to assess job applicants.
Hiring Happy Employees
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 14/05/2007 | Human Resources
Hiring happy, optimistic job applicants can increase your company’s productivity and lower turnover. Plus, optimistic, confident employees are vastly more delightful to have on-board.
Methods to help companies have optimistic, positive employees include pre-employment tests, job interviews of applicants, managing being role-models, and reinforcing smiles. This article teaches you how to hire happy and productive employees.
5 Ways to Avoid Hiring Psychopaths
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 17/03/2008 | Human Resources
Avoid hiring psychopaths using pre-employment tests, key job interview questions, background and reference checks, and even their aura.
7 Horrible Hiring Mistakes
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 22/09/2006 | Home Business
Learn 7 hiring mistakes people make when looking to hire the best job applicant.
Employee Selection - are you Gambling at Work???
By: Chris Young | 31/01/2007 | Online Gambling
An examination of the growing use of personality assessments as a key part of the employee selection and hiring process. These tools can dramatically increase the chance of a successful job hire while offering invaluable insights into what motivates employees as well as how to communicate more effectively and improve retention
Google's Hiring Method Missing Key Steps
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 07/11/2006 | Human Resources
Google is revamping its hiring methods. Google is on the right track, but is sorely missing crucial pre-employment tests plus other prediction methods.
Avoid Hiring Deficient Employees
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 17/04/2007 | Human Resources
All managers want to hire applicants who are ready-to-work and are productive on-the-job. Unfortunately, a large research study uncovered six job skill deficiencies in huge numbers of job applicants. Fortunately, managers can assess job applicants on these common deficiencies using four hiring prediction methods. Correctly using these four hiring prediction methods help managers hire ready-to-work, productive employees.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Management Articles
Improve Telephone Communication by Linking Better Performance to Results for Employees
By: Barbara Brown, PhD | 21/08/2008
When you talk to employees about better telephone communication, you want to keep the focus on performance improvement and away from complaints about customers, processes, or procedures. You can do that if you link improvements to results for employees. This article describes this approach. It also contains examples of telephone behaviors and results.
Roles And Responsibilities Of Six Sigma Trained Champions & Master Black Belts
By: Tony Jacowski | 21/08/2008
Each organization will have its own structure and approach to Six Sigma. A successful Six Sigma deployment is the result of the teamwork of the members of the Six Sigma team. The deployment is successful if the approach is a top down one. Typically, a Six Sigma team has various members with varied roles and capabilities.
A Six Sigma Training Primer
By: Tony Jacowski | 21/08/2008
The training or education of employees is vital to the success of Six Sigma projects in any organization. Six Sigma training includes imparting knowledge about the various core concepts and techniques of Six Sigma.
The DMAIC Model And Business Success
By: Tony Jacowski | 21/08/2008
The major success factor of any organization is the competitive edge it has over others. This is dependent upon the quality of products offered by the business according to the expectations of the customer. For this, the major aspect is the reduction of defects to zero.
The Quickest Way to Generate Targeted Traffic Through Affiliate Marketing
By: Ravii Kumarr | 21/08/2008
The quickest way to generate targeted traffic and start earning commissions with an affiliate marketing business is to use Google adwords. One doesn't even need a website of their own to make money online using adwords. Traffic can be sent directly to an affiliate link.
The Audit's Results and Report - the True Story, According to the Iso 9001 Standard Requirements
By: Itay Abuhav | 21/08/2008
The internal audit chapter is included under chapter 8.2 - Monitoring and measurement (it's been said before on our web site already). When performing an audit you are monitoring processes. You sample a process and validate that it is done according to prior requirements. Once you stumble upon nonconformity, a process that was performed not according to a requirement, you must mention it in the audit report. But this is not the end of your story.
Internal Audit - the Iso 9001 Standard Requirements for Internal Audits and the Audits Program
By: Itay Abuhav | 21/08/2008
Internal Audit. "What a headache" - that's surely what every employee think to himself when they receives the massage of an internal audit approaching. There is a reason why. They know that someone is coming to poke their deeds...
How Scheduled Overtime Can be Better Managed
By: SteveHyans | 21/08/2008
HourDoc offers superior solutions for scheduled overtime. HourDoc’s scheduled overtime solution takes into account PTO, electronic timesheets and other valuable time and attendance hardware features. Many clients using the HourDoc scheduled overtime solution comment that better managing scheduled overtime helps them save time and money.
More from Michael Mercer, Ph.d.
Grow Your Company by Hiring “obsessive-compulsive” Employees
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 09/07/2008 | Management
You can use pre-employment tests and other methods to help you hire obsessive-compulsive employees – when the job requires an organized perfectionist. This article shows you how to assess job applicants.
9 Unique & Amazingly Useful Ways to Evaluate Job Applicants
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 20/05/2008 | Human Resources
Research proves pre-employment tests are the most accurate method to predict or forecast how an applicant may perform on-the-job. Plus, this is borne out in my 20+ years of research in developing and helping companies hire the best using pre-employment tests. I also research and helping managers evaluate job applicants using customize-designed interviews, bio-data, and other prediction methods.
From this extensive experience I also created nine unique ways to evaluate job applicants.
5 Ways to Avoid Hiring Psychopaths
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 17/03/2008 | Human Resources
Avoid hiring psychopaths using pre-employment tests, key job interview questions, background and reference checks, and even their aura.
7 Steps That Help Managers Hire the Best
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 17/01/2008 | Management
Managers who use my pre-employment tests, interview training, or attend my speeches often ask me, “What is a comprehensive step-by-step method to hire the best?” Here are seven (7) steps that help managers hire the best.
Tips for Much Less Stress in your Workplace
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 02/11/2007 | Leadership
Stress is a hot topic in the workplace. Some employees get bent out of shape by almost anything. Other people calmly take almost any sort of situation in stride.Here are immediately useful tips for leaders and all employees.
Leaders & Hiring Managers Profit From ‘birds of a Feather Flock Together’
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 25/09/2007 | Leadership
Hiring managers and leaders use pre-employment tests, job interviews, role modeling and strategic de-employment to increase profits based on the saying, “Birds of a feather flock together.” In business and daily life, this is called “social networks.” What is the premise and useful research on social networks? This article provide practical business solutions.
Hiring Happy Employees
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 14/05/2007 | Human Resources
Hiring happy, optimistic job applicants can increase your company’s productivity and lower turnover. Plus, optimistic, confident employees are vastly more delightful to have on-board.
Methods to help companies have optimistic, positive employees include pre-employment tests, job interviews of applicants, managing being role-models, and reinforcing smiles. This article teaches you how to hire happy and productive employees.
Avoid Hiring Deficient Employees
By: Michael Mercer, Ph.d. | 17/04/2007 | Human Resources
All managers want to hire applicants who are ready-to-work and are productive on-the-job. Unfortunately, a large research study uncovered six job skill deficiencies in huge numbers of job applicants. Fortunately, managers can assess job applicants on these common deficiencies using four hiring prediction methods. Correctly using these four hiring prediction methods help managers hire ready-to-work, productive employees.
|
|
Business 
